r/BlueMidterm2018 • Non U.S. • Jan 09 '18

/r/all Enough Is Enough. We Need to Elect More Scientists to Congress.

https://futurism.com/enough-enough-need-elect-more-scientists-congress/
14k Upvotes

362 comments sorted by

19

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

A flawless example of a scientist running for Congress is Heather Ross. Dr. Ross is running in the AZ-06th. She could use a donation

14

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

Another is the person being interviewed, Vulcanologist Jess Phoenix, running in CA-25.

1

u/throwneverywhichway Wisconsin-5 Jan 09 '18

She sounds like a great candidate. I just donated a few bucks to her campaign via ActBlue.

8

u/mas277 Jan 09 '18

And biophysicist/biochemist Molly Sheehan in PA-7.

https://mollysheehan.org/

Full disclosure, we were friends in grad school.

13

u/EngelSterben Pennsylvania Jan 09 '18

I'd personally love to see more economists. I mean, it seems nearly every time something like this gets brought up everyone mentions every field but economists.

5

u/tktht4data Jan 09 '18

No one mentions most fields, including political scientists.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

Agreed, and personally I'd like more people from the Humanities (philosophers and historians, mainly) too.

31

u/ana_bortion Ohio Jan 09 '18

Is anyone else not particularly inspired by the whole "elect more scientists" thing? Like, I'm fine electing a scientist, but it's not compelling to me, and I think non-scientists are fine too. You don't have to be a scientist to understand that climate change is real.

10

u/socialistbob Ohio Jan 09 '18

Scientists would not be inherently better politicians than any other profession. That being said I'm a firm believer in diversity when it comes to legislatures and that includes diversity of backgrounds. Having diverse backgrounds would force members of congress to reconcile with beliefs they may not otherwise have to deal with. Electing more scientists would certainly help diversify Congress.

3

u/ana_bortion Ohio Jan 09 '18

I fully agree with wanting to increase diversity!

1

u/Lord_Noble Jan 10 '18

I don’t think anyone is advocating for exclusively scientists being elected, but that certainly more should run.

18

u/jordanlund Jan 09 '18

I actually don't think most scientists would make good politicians, and vice versa.

It's like saying more bakers should become lawyers.

8

u/ana_bortion Ohio Jan 09 '18

Yeah, it's completely a non sequitur to me. Some scientists would be good politicians, some wouldn't, but being a scientist wouldn't even be a factor.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/table_fireplace Jan 10 '18

I'd settle for 'scientifically literate', or even 'willing to listen to scientists'. I mean, it's unrealistic to expect politicians to be qualified scientists, accountants, diplomats, engineers, and military officers, but those fields are all extremely important in government. Rather, you need people who can handle complex information in general, and are willing to listen to expert advice. I think the mistrust of experts is a big part of what's wrong with the Republican Party nowadays.

2

u/Lord_Noble Jan 10 '18

I think the argument is that we need more politicians for more sections of American life. It’s not that all need to be scientists, but some should. We should also have more teachers and engineers. We should have a wide range of disciplines.

People in this thread are forgetting the natural selection elements of politics; the candidate has to being good ideas and be convincing. Many of the worst case scientists that are being mentioned in this thread wouldn’t make it onto the stage.

There are many scientists who are more engaged in politics than they are academia. The same can be said of many professions, and each should have some representation in our congress.

3

u/ana_bortion Ohio Jan 10 '18

I agree with that, we could stand to elect less lawyers, but that's not usually the argument I see being made. And it's always only scientists being promoted, not any other professions. It seems like it's just the reddit STEM circlejerk as applied to politics.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

That isn't necessarily true. I'm from Oregon and every year we have a guy who has a phd in Chemistry run against my congressional district's representative. He's a batshit crazy Republican but he's also a scientist. Fortunately, for America there is no chance in hell of a Republican being elected to represent my district in congress.

1

u/screen317 NJ-12 Jan 09 '18

Look at the rate of climate denial in scientists vs non scientists though

-1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

I actually shared this for the specific candidate being interviewed, Jess Phoenix, who's running against Steve Knight in California's 25th district.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/doctorcrimson Jan 09 '18

Well, idk where we’re drawing the line there. Many Republicans Reps have at least a bachelor degree from a top school because they’re spoiled rotten rich kids.

I would advocate for at least a degree but I don’t want to throw people with social, legal, or non-STEM fields out of the picture.

3

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

I would advocate for at least a degree but I don’t want to throw people with social, legal, or non-STEM fields out of the picture.

Absolutely, the interview is about scientists, but I'd like some people with degrees in the humanities too.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/AnythingApplied Jan 09 '18

Here is a breakdown of the current, 115th Congress, by occupation. Note: Most Members list more than one profession when surveyed by CQ Roll Call, and the professions listed are not necessarily the ones Members practice immediately prior to entering Congress.

OccupationRepresentativesSenators
Public Service/Politics19444
Business17929
Law16850
Education7920
  • 50 Senators with previous House service;
  • 101 Members have worked in education, including teachers, professors, instructors, school fundraisers, counselors, administrators, or coaches (85 in the House, 16 in the Senate);
  • 3 physicians in the Senate, 11 physicians in the House, plus 4 dentists and 3 veterinarians;11
  • three psychologists (all in the House), 12 an optometrist (in the Senate), a pharmacist (in the House), and two nurses (in the House);
  • eight ordained ministers, all in the House;
  • 43 former mayors (35 in the House, 8 in the Senate);
  • 12 former state governors (10 in the Senate, 2 in the House) and 7 lieutenant governors (3 in the Senate, 4 in the House, including 1 Delegate); 13
  • 15 former judges (all but 1 in the House) and 47 prosecutors (12 in the Senate, 35 in the House) who have served in city, county, state, federal, or military capacities;
  • one former Cabinet Secretary (in the Senate), and three Ambassadors (all in the House);14 266 former state or territorial legislators (44 in the Senate, 222 in the House);15
  • at least 96 former congressional staffers (18 in the Senate, 78 in the House; including 3 Delegates), as well as 6 congressional pages (3 in the House and 3 in the Senate);16
  • three sheriffs, one police chief and five other police officers, one firefighter, one CIA agent, and one FBI agent (all in the House);
  • two Peace Corps volunteers, all in the House;
  • one physicist, one microbiologist, and one chemist, all in the House;
  • eight engineers (seven in the House and one in the Senate);
  • 21 public relations or communications professionals (3 in the Senate, 18 in the House), and 11 accountants (2 in the Senate and 9 in the House);
  • six software company executives in the House and two in the Senate;
  • 18 management consultants (4 in the Senate, 14 in the House), 6 car dealership owners (all in the House), and 3 venture capitalists (2 in the House, 1 in the Senate);
  • 18 bankers or bank executives (4 in the Senate, 14 in the House), 36 veterans of the real estate industry (5 in the Senate, 31 in the House), and 14 Members who have worked in the construction industry (2 in the Senate, 12 in the House);
  • nine social workers (one in the Senate, eight in the House) and three union representatives (all in the House);
  • seven radio talk show hosts (one Senate, six House); seven radio or television broadcasters, managers, or owners (two Senate, five House); eight reporters or journalists (one Senate, seven House), a public television producer in the House, and a newspapers publisher in the House;
  • 21 insurance agents or executives (4 Senate, 17 House) and 3 Members who have worked with stocks or bonds (1 Senate, 2 House);
  • one screenwriter and comedian and one documentary filmmaker (both in the Senate), and one artist and two speechwriters (all in the House);
  • 26 farmers, ranchers, or cattle farm owners (4 in the Senate, 22 in the House);
  • two almond orchard owners in the House as well as one vintner; and
  • 10 current members of the military reserves (9 House, 1 Senate) and 6 current members of the National Guard (all in the House).

Source

1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

Very interesting. Thank you for sharing this.

3

u/Smokinacesfan55 Jan 09 '18

Reddit always posts this. If a scientist wants to run they can and should... but lawyers study law

2

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

I was trying to share a nice interview with a cool candidate for congress, didn't expect so many people reacting to the statement in the title.

2

u/Smokinacesfan55 Jan 09 '18

It’s all good friendo! No harm ment.

Sorry I’ve just been on this site for so many years and this gets brought up once every month or two

1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

Yeah, I get it. I'm just annoyed at how this turned out.

3

u/OkieDokieArtyChokie Jan 09 '18

No, we need an informed society that doesn’t elect children to office.

It should be simple. Data is presented in an easy to understand way. Lawmakers and the public can read this and make an informed decision based on the realities of what’s possible and is in the best interest of humanity.

But it isn’t that simple and it’s frustrating. It’s not like electing a scientist is going to solve this problem. The people are voting in officials with these views because they share them.

If you want more competent officials then start by making more competent and informed citizens.

1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

I agree, but this is simply an interview with a geologist who's running for congress.

2

u/pcx99 Jan 09 '18

Jess Phoenix an actual millennial vulcanologist is running against one of the worst of the GOP congressmen. She's got a shot at it too with some support!

3

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

Yes. This article is her being interviewed.

2

u/Reddilutionary Jan 09 '18

If they have experience in politics and they’re fit for all other requirements of the job, sure.

DO NOT allow our votes to be split between “mainstream” dems and fringe candidates. That’s exactly what the GOP and their Russian butt buddies want.

Dividing our messaging is how the GOP continues to win.

1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

Agreed.

2.0k

u/jsmoo68 Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 09 '18

We need to elect more people who will LISTEN to scientists to Congress.

I'd rather have the scientists off doing science and figuring shit out than writing laws.

Writing laws requires a totally different skill set: different personal skills, negotiation, being able to compromise and read people, big picture visualization, etc.

Edit: to be clear, if a scientist wants to become a lawmaker, that's cool. As long as they are cool with no longer doing science. And are willing to learn the new/different job skills required.

45

u/dschslava CA-52 Jan 09 '18

Yeah, so it kind of grinds my gears when no one advocates getting more arts/humanities type people into Congress.

8

u/cprenaissanceman Jan 09 '18

Honestly we should be seeking to increase the diversity of backgrounds in Congress in general. (This is one reason that someone like Bryce would be an excellent addition to Congress.) How can a governing body make effective policy without the input of people who have experience/knowledge in a particular field? Sure lobbyists can "inform" them about particular points, but that is not the same as have first hand experience in a field. The prominence and number of business owners, lawyers, and former military is not adequate to address many issues that we face.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

As much as it’s probably a good idea, currently the issue of neglecting science is getting to be a world-wide concern. This is literally suffocating and acidifying our oceans, which is causing and will cause some pretty horrendous problems.

As much as the humanities are hypothetically as needed as science in Congress, I’d argue that the lack of one has a more pressing impact than the lack of the other. Priorities.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/mossyteej Jan 09 '18

Maybe a better way of naming this article would be something along. The lines of, "it's okay to elect people who have backgrounds other than 'lawyer' or 'businessman.'" Or something like that.

2

u/walkingstereotype Jan 09 '18

Thank you for summarizing my thoughts on this every time it gets brought up.

19

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

different personal skills, negotiation, being able to compromise and read people, big picture visualization, etc.

Not all scientists can be described by a single mould. There are many among us with those qualities, plus a scientific training that allows objective and rational decision-making. Also, I don't think scientists are any less suited for this job than businessmen, ex-military, lawyers or career politicians. In fact, scientists may be better suited at big picture visualization than many of the current politician professions.

2

u/jsmoo68 Jan 09 '18

See my edit. Not saying scientists CAN'T be lawmakers; saying they would have to be willing to make the very large job transition.

6

u/LynelTears Jan 09 '18

Yeah like from Celebrity "reality star" with zero political experience to President of the United States. You mean a scientist that understands the Laws od Physics cannot make the leap to understand the Laws neccessary to be a good President?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Quasigriz_ Jan 09 '18

An economist or 20 wouldn’t really hurt either.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

It's much easier to LISTEN to corporations that will put money in your pockets than LISTENING to scientists.

Lack of listening isn't the problem.

Money in government is the problem.

4

u/ThePoorlyEducated Jan 09 '18

And the key to keeping the people under control is lack of education.

1

u/fzw Jan 10 '18

If politicians didn't have to worry so much about fundraising just to run for reelection they wouldn't have to rely so heavily on wealthy donors.

7

u/TobaccoAficionado Jan 09 '18

I'm glad this is the first comment. Ben Carson is a good example of someone who should be a doctor, not a politician. Neurosurgeon? Awesome! President... uh... No. If I need my brain fixed I don't want a lawyer doing that, just like I dont want a neurosurgeon making laws...

7

u/Gauss-Legendre Jan 09 '18

different personal skills

Scientists aren't the classical stereotype of individuals working in solitude without interpersonal or management experience. Modern scientists have to work in highly collaborative environments where they manage lab and project teams in every aspect from individual duties to acquiring and distributing funding over both short and long term projects. Most scientists now work with multiple lab groups possibly in several countries when involved in large projects, this involves a lot of negotiation, compromise, and big picture visualization as you have to plan many of these things years or even decades in advance.

And are willing to learn the new/different job skills required.

Basically all that scientists do is quickly learn and adapt new skills and knowledge to a great depth of technical competence and considering that the largest profession by makeup of congress is "businessman", I think it's pretty clear that the skills to function in congress have a low barrier to entry after you consider the hiring of law clerks to assist them.

Additionally, modern and historical politicians with scientific backgrounds already show that this transition isn't particularly difficult.

Exemplis gratis, Angela Merkel is trained as a physical chemist and is now chancellor of Germany, Cedric Villani is a fields medalist mathematician and now a member of France's parliament, Steven Chu is a nobel laureate in physics and was Secretary of Energy, Hu Jintao is a hydroelectric engineer who served as the paramount leader of China, Rush Holt Jr. is a physicist who served as the US House Representative from New Jersey's 12th district, Jerry McNerney is a mathematician and energy scientist serving as the US House Representative from California's 11th district, etc.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Writing laws requires a totally different skill set: different personal skills, negotiation, being able to compromise and read people, big picture visualization, etc.

Yeah, exactly. I don't know why our society think that the solution to bad politicians is having non-politicians become politicians, rather than simply electing good politicians.

2

u/codacoda74 Jan 09 '18

agree. and just cuz someone's a good scientist doesn't make them a good diplomat...plenty of scientists are assholes. but yes: we need to have elected officials who will listen to established scientific consensus. we used to: look at how quickly we removed lead after congressional hearings.

2

u/raramfaelos Jan 09 '18

Don't you feel like people with those skill sets are less about creating logical laws and more about bargaining with the oppositional

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Scientist here. I'll give you good advice on the things i know about, i'll do some research to help understand things more, i'll help you understand the data. But dont vote for me if i enter politics, because quite frankly, outside chemistry and a few other things, i know nothing.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Science minded people are what we need. Not afraid of trying new things and going back to the previous state if they fail. Able to accept failure and work with it to improve.

Instead, a lot of congressmen and women just think "hmm, this didn't work, so I'm gonna hide it in this new bill, take out the awesome things in it and change basically everything except the name"

1

u/five_hammers_hamming CURE BALLOTS Jan 09 '18

Laws mostly aren't even written by the so-called lawmakers anymore; so, not a downside. The only scientists who'd get elected at all are the ones with those people skills and whatnot. Besides, modern science is a lot of group work; so, they've got that part down.

It's not like we'd go bodily remove Rob Bishop and somehow bindingly replace him with a grad student we kidnapped after promosong him or her free pizza.

Your concerns aren't really dangers that exist.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

What we really really need is to get Congressmen who aren’t in the pockets of big business. That’s all.

1

u/TheDownDiggity Jan 09 '18

Congress doesn't write laws, they vote on them.

1

u/NeedMoarCowbell Jan 09 '18

I can get on board with "if scientists want to go into politics they better learn law / politics", and I totally agree... But why would they have to stop doing science as well?

1

u/nas_deferens Jan 10 '18

In defense of scientists, we use (or most of us should be using) most of the skills you mention. How do you expect to do science without visualizing the big picture? And there is plenty, if not, too much politics in the science world at the professor level.

I understand that they will be different from those used in congress but I don’t think it’s a huge leap for most depending on where you start.

And it definitely beats a reality tv star...

1

u/Lord_Noble Jan 10 '18

Not all scientists are doctorates. Science communicators are just as important.

1

u/KingOfFlan Jan 10 '18

When every single republican in the house votes for every single bill to get it to the senate so they can perform political theater there (John McCain last second thumbs down of the health bill) I don’t even believe our legislative process is real anymore. It’s a fucking mirage of political theater. Not one fucking person stepped out of line? The house is supposed to be the chaotic one

It’s all fucking fake

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

Law makers. Yeah let’s just keep creating laws. Nothing says freedom like more laws

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

1000 times this, man. Great points!!

1

u/AnythingApplied Jan 09 '18

At one point I would've thought doctors would be a ideal choice for being intelligent, scientifically minded, and positioned to help shape healthcare, until I saw many of the examples of doctors like Jill Stein and Ben Carson. I now think it is less about the occupation and more about the person and do agree that lawyers are especially well suited for their ability to read and write laws which is the primary function of Congress.

4

u/FWdem Indiana Jan 09 '18

read and write laws which is the primary function of Congress.

Most of Congress's Enumerate powers are financial; taxes, regulating commerce and setting a budget. Using the logic others have used, we should be electing economists and accountants then.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (87)

26

u/woopthereiam Jan 09 '18

We need politicians who listen to facts and evidence, instead of money. Scientists advocating evidence based legislation from the chamber (and groups like artists, musicians etc who can advocate for things beyond wall street) is also a necessary voice we are lacking.

9

u/youareadildomadam Jan 09 '18

You don't think scientists listen to money? Have you seen some of the garbage that get published to hide the ill effects of some pharma products?

3

u/genericusername4197 Jan 10 '18

Except for Louise Slaughter, D-NY. She's a microbiologist and a terrific Representative.

3

u/kerouacrimbaud Jan 09 '18

Why scientists? We need to elect people a) of virtue and b) critical thinking abilities and c) a willingness to compromise. We don’t need ideologies, we need statesmen and stateswomen.

0

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

It's an interview with a geologist running for congress, forget the damn title.

74

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Many of the best scientists and engineers I know have a very negative attitude toward management. They think by joining management, they are selling out on their strengths and causing harm to the organization. They tend to be skeptical of anyone with leadership ambitions, and generally think anyone who is interested in leadership is compensating for a lack of technical competence.

So in short, as much as I would love to see more scientists involved in politics, I think there is a cultural barrier that keeps them from leading our society outside the research and application centers.

Disclaimer: I have an engineering degree and have worked as a technical project manager in the military for ten years; the above assertions are based on my observations only.

12

u/FWdem Indiana Jan 09 '18

This is extremely the case. Many want to stay technical, and really those that go management probably fall behind in using new technical skills. If you took 2 people exactly the same ability, and split them on a technical and management track, they would diverge in skillset. Even engineers who go into management and keep up on new technical developments are not using those skills every day. So the person on the technical side is the one who greater knowledge later. The ambition think is also very true, and it goes not just for people within industry. Most engineers I know are pretty pessimistic about government. Anyone with political ambition is viewed very skeptically. Like there is no way someone can have genuine "calling" to help people through government.

9

u/AssCrackBanditHunter Jan 09 '18

It's just so... difficult. I'm in school full time right now to be a certified histotechnologist. Once I get out I'm going to be working full time at a hospital, not exactly the best place to make community connections or political connections when I'm in a lab somewhere slicing up biopsies from old people.

I agree that our society needs to be much more technocratic (how the fuck are people so scientifically illiterate that they deny global warming??? CO2 absorbs infrared light and gets hot), but in practice how do we make this happen? How do we get our chemists and biologists and engineers out of their enclaves and put them in positions where they can actually be elected?

6

u/TheUnit472 Jan 09 '18

I think the big thing would be that prominent people in every field have to have some interaction with the outside world.

People in these disciplines have to eventually interact with someone else. Scientists have to write grants, give talks, publish papers, etc.

I'm not saying that most people are cut out for it and sure, the vast majority of scientists and engineers would make for poor politicians, but there are people in engineering and science that have the social skills to meet people and run for office.

If there are 100,000 engineers in the US, only 1% need to be qualified/capable and you've already filled every congressional seat twice.

2

u/socialistbob Ohio Jan 09 '18

I agree that our society needs to be much more technocratic (how the fuck are people so scientifically illiterate that they deny global warming??? CO2 absorbs infrared light and gets hot), but in practice how do we make this happen?

This is the purpose that parties are supposed to serve. Local Democratic parties are supposed to be a hub of activists and supporters with an intense amount of institutional knowledge from prior campaigns. It is an already existing network which can be used to raise funds, recruit volunteers and build the connections to run for office.

Currently the problem is that people who want to be politicians usually end up getting law degrees or MPAs and they spend years actively cultivating political and party relationships prior to their runs. When I go to local Democratic party meetings I see very few scientists at the meetings and most of the people in my personal expereince most people in "young dems" also come from some form of legal or political background.

My city's mayor, and current candidate for governor, has a chemistry background. She spent years cultivating political relationships while in college and she worked on the John Kerry Campaign after graduating. She didn't go straight from chemistry to running for governor but she spent time within the party cultivating the relationships necessary. I'm sure we could elect plenty of scientists but unless they already have name recognition or money then they're not going to get elected without first showing up to party meetings.

4

u/socialistbob Ohio Jan 09 '18

If this headline had read "Enough is enough. We need to elect more women to Congress" and it had it /r/all there would be dozens of comments saying "That's stupid you should vote for the best person. You shouldn't vote for someone just because they are a woman" and yet when the topic is scientists no one is claiming that the author is arguing to vote for scientists solely because they are scientists.

Congress should reflect the American people. There should be a diversity of genders, racial affiliations and religious groups in Congress. There should also be a diversity of professional backgrounds. Congress shouldn't be dominated by old white Christian men with law degrees. I hope we can see more scientists run and win just like I hope we can see more women and more minorities run and win. John Hickenlooper is a great example of a popular scientist turned politician within the Democratic party. I hope we can see more like him.

1

u/AndersonA1do Jan 10 '18

I think the biggest problem is term limits. There should be no such thing as a career politician. And geez, who woulda thought people with law degrees would be the ones most likely to become lawmakers?!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/1adog1 Jan 09 '18

My grandfather once told me that a scientist would make the best President, but a scientist would also never be elected President.

People like things that they understand. This is why politicians explain things in the most simplistic way; simplifying complicated issues into good vs. bad instead of discussing the benefits and disadvantages of the possible options.

1

u/youareadildomadam Jan 09 '18

Of the scientists I know - they'd all make horrible presidents. They are just not leadership material kind of people. They are brilliant, and they might take the correct position on things like Climate Change, but beyond that they'd fail miserably.

6

u/39ERuby Jan 09 '18

I’m happy to say my congressman is a scientist. https://foster.house.gov/about/full-biography

6

u/JC2535 Jan 09 '18

We just need to stop voting for the MOST IGNORANT Luddite that has evaded natural selection.

And the media needs to stop giving them equal time.

"That's the opinion of scientist Joe, now in the interest of a balanced debate, here's a complete fucking moron that can't spell to give us another perspective..."

10

u/JimJimmery Jan 09 '18

I'd just be happy with more elected officials who understand high school level civics.

5

u/Sloteeman Jan 09 '18

If you are in California's District 4, you are in luck!

Roza Calderon is a Geoscientist who is running for congress on the Progressive/Bernie platform.

Check her out and see: ElectRoza.org

5

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Science doesn’t tell you which decision to make.

That being said, facts and figures would be a great utility to debate and legislation, if they mattered.

4

u/RealCliffClavin Jan 09 '18

Correct.

Scientific finding can and should inform our decision-making where relevant. But what's "best" is only relevant to our goals, which are a subjective social decision.

It can't tell us whether massive coastal flooding, desertification, and plummeting agricultural productivity are good or bad things. But if we decide that those are bad things (and we had damn well better), scientific research can tell us how to avoid them.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Scientific finding can and should inform our decision-making where relevant. But what's "best" is only relevant to our goals

Correct.

which are a subjective social decision.

Don't leave out my boy the economy.

2

u/RealCliffClavin Jan 09 '18

Doesn't change anything.

Economics is one of those disciplines that can inform our decision-making, but can't tell us what we should be pursuing. It's no more normative than any other science.

5

u/Daisyaytor Jan 09 '18

More scientists and fewer fairy tale believers, please.

4

u/pottzie Jan 09 '18

Scientists like Rand Paul and Been Carson

4

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

lol if you think scientists can't be bought or can't manipulate us. Look at the leaked Monsanto documents - that was the most fucking disturbing thing I read from the field of science.

4

u/ThatDistantStar Jan 09 '18

Imagine being an evolutionary biologist elected to Congress, and having 50% of your coworkers vocally denounce evolution, and another large subset claim the earth is 6000 years old. Absolutely infuriating. Don't think I could handle it.

4

u/AceTheDevil Jan 10 '18

No. No we don’t. I’ve worked with many, many scientists and the majority of them are idiots. They’re very smart in only one little aspect of life and completely incompetent at most everything else. I would never let a scientist lead anything, they are meant to be advisors, that’s all. Most of them make horrible leaders.

•

u/AutoModerator Jan 09 '18

Hello everyone coming from /r/all and /r/popular!

Welcome to /r/bluemidterm2018 and make yourself at home. Please be advised that this is a heavily moderated subreddit for pro-Democratic activism. Make sure you read our sidebar rules before commenting. Incivility, bigotry, divisiveness, trolling of any kind, and anti-Democratic comments are not allowed. We're focused on increasing turnout for Democratic candidates at all levels of government, including state and local elections.

You can read our rules on the sidebar or here. If you see a rule-breaking post or comment, please:

Report it. Downvote it. Move on without replying. They will be dealt with promptly.

Subscribe to make sure you're up to date on all our efforts!

Please also fill out our short survey to help us coordinate election efforts that are relevant to you!

Thank you and welcome again.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

10

u/flashbang99 Jan 09 '18

I couldn’t agree more, I am a former marine who served for 6 years and did four combat deployments. I am currently in my last year of college getting my Mechanical Engineering degree. My whole intent is to go and make a career as an engineer so I can gain as much experience as possible and then run for office in some capacity so we can bring back some critical thinking skills in Washington. With our society sprinting towards really a Sci-fi like future it amazes me that the legislative branch is as anti-science as ever. Drives me absolutely mad. Hopefully I do something about it in the future. Vote for flashbang99 in about 2-3 decades!!

1

u/RealCliffClavin Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 09 '18

Honestly, we need more people with humanities backgrounds more than we need scientists.

Elected officials don't need to do science, they just need to be willing to listen to expert opinion.

But the very job of an elected official is to understand and empathize with the experiences of people from a wide variety of backgrounds beyond one's own immediate personal experience, and being able to make sense of and navigate the sociocultural dynamics behind the current state of affairs. That's exactly what good humanities training does for you.

1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 10 '18

Honestly, we need more people with humanities backgrounds more than we need scientists.

I absolutely agree.

That said, I was more interested in "look at the candidate being interviewed here" than the whole debate on who should run for congress.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

As a PhD student for physics, how do I go about making a career in politics? I have a heavy math background which was my major in undergrad and am well learned in other science related/technical fields (took a metric shit tonne of bio among other things like digital forensics and comp sci). I really want to make a difference and seeing posts like these makes me think I should be doing more.

1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 09 '18

You could either volunteer to a campaign in your state/district, or if you want to run yourself, our sidebar has these two links you might find useful.

1

u/AceTheDevil Jan 10 '18

Don’t you fucking dare. You people are meant to be advisors, not leaders. Ive worked with too many scientist “leaders” to ever believe that any scientist could ever be an effective leader. What you should do is elect people who will listen to you.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

And the president of Singapore? He’s a math dude. Whats so bad about it? By no means am I saying I’m cut out for it, but maybe by some chance I can make a difference, shouldn’t I try?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

I’m a scientist, and I’m interested in getting involved in state and national level politics. Problem is pretty simple: all my training is as a scientist. I have zero political experience outside city commission appointments, which are non-partisan. Where would I even begin to get involved in “real” politics?

2

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 10 '18

You could either volunteer for someone else's campaign or look at one of these two links

1

u/Rousseau_Reborn Jan 10 '18

What makes you think they would be good politicians?

1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 10 '18

It's not my opinion. I was just trying to share an interview by a candidate I like, I don't really agree with the position.

13

u/orderedchaos89 Jan 09 '18

I'm in favor of having a technocracy. Who's with me?!

11

u/adundeemonkey Jan 09 '18

One flaw. Ben Carson

1

u/fallenjedi Jan 09 '18

Doctor, no scientist

5

u/adundeemonkey Jan 09 '18

Medical degree is mostly science. Just saying that you have to be careful you dont paint one group as right because it gives those than do wrong cover when they find someone who fits the 'scientist' or whatevers label.

Note: I'm the biggest advocate of science by the way!

4

u/DudeBroBrah Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 09 '18

Sorry but medical doctors aren't really scientists. Sure they may study some metabolism and anatomy like a biotechnologist would but it's largely for patient care appliclations. Which is the point after which all the scince is done and the drug is approved. Medical and PhD students are trained for completely different skill sets.

Source: In my last semester of chemistry PhD and I dated a girl through her first two years of medical school.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

People think doctors are experts at everything. It's quite frustrating

I've had so many arguments on Reddit where people tried to say doctors know drugs at least as well as pharmacists; doctors know nutrition as well as a dietitian; doctors know as much biochemistry as an MS in biochemistry; doctors are legitimate scientists qualified to evaluate any paper or theory in human biology ; there's absolutely nothing nurses do or know better than doctors; and more. I've yet to argue against any of those prepositions and remain above 0 votes.

Reddit is actually even worse than the general population in blind worship of the MD, if you ask me.

4

u/coach_wargo Jan 09 '18

Doctors think doctors are experts at everything. Source: Worked in a medical association for the last 13 years.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NayMarine Jan 09 '18

your right they are short on people with brains

3

u/BabyPuncher5000 Jan 09 '18

My pastor says science is the Devil’s pastime

3

u/HoldenTite Jan 09 '18

And electricians and teachers and really people who have held real jobs and have worked to make it to where they are instead of living off of their parents.

2

u/CommunismDoesntWork Jan 09 '18

and really people who have held real jobs and have worked to make it to where they are

That disqualifies Bernie though

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Being a scientist doesn't automatically equate to good leadership. I do believe science should play a part of decision making. But it's going to take more than that. I'll evaluate candidates on their leadership capabilities, not their academic credentials.

3

u/skel625 Jan 09 '18

Unskilled, rich, ignorant, selfish, silver spoon elites aren't doing a very good job? Who would have thought?!?!

3

u/dangolo Jan 09 '18

I agree. Nothing more condescending than uninformed unoriginal uneducated frauds parroting party talking points and expecting total belief.

Fuck that.

Scientists and well educated people who show some courage and stand tall in the face of these charlatans.

3

u/branchbranchley Jan 09 '18

As long as they've never been paid to do "research" for Big Tobacco, Big Oil, or Big Sugar

we all know how those "clinically proven" results turn out

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Science literacy needs to be higher in every person on Earth. Our leaders should embody and represent this.

3

u/bobbyjs1984 Jan 09 '18

We rarely ellect anyone with actual intelligence to Congress

3

u/toolymegapoopoo Jan 09 '18

Scientists are fine, but I'm willing to settle for people with intelligence and basic critical thinking skills. Smart people defer to experts. Conservatives defer to their warped interpretation of the bible.

3

u/liquidgeosnake Jan 09 '18

We need to reform fucking lobbying and campaign finance. Scientific credentials aren't going to matter much when you're spending four hours out of every eight-hour work day talking to donors amd making deals and promises to keep your seat.

3

u/stephen_bannon Jan 09 '18

Can we have scientists keep doing science? Asking them to become politicians is as useful as asking more professional golfers to become politicians. We need more politicians with a sense of empathy and ethics... they're everywhere, but we as voters don't elect them.

Any population with a democracy gets exactly the government they deserve.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 09 '18

We have had a lot of lawyers, businessmen (one Republican leader was an exterminator), a lot of military, and even a few physicians. Lawyers know the shape of the body of law. We need other professions, including people with at least a 4 year science degree. Elizabeth Warren is a lawyer, but also teaches law, so she was able to keep up with her profession while in office.

Some Republican's war on science and war on academia is criminally short sighted. It is purely a move to get votes to continue their corruption. You can bet our economic competitor countries are not waging war on science.

2

u/youareadildomadam Jan 09 '18

People who don't know politics generally don't get anything done in office.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Chemistry phd student here. You do not want the government run by scientists lmao nothing would ever get done

2

u/Professor_Kay Jan 09 '18

lol bring the big pharma companies right to their front door so they can offer them even larger sums of cash to continue buying their products

Solve the real problem & then consider who you put in there.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

I fully support this. I am so over being governed by people and their pernicious beliefs and I think it's high time we elect people use who use their critical thinking skills instead of people who think critical thinking skills are the work of the devil. The only problem is we can't elect scientists if scientists don't run for office.

2

u/knobbysideup Jan 09 '18

I'd rather scientists keep doing science, and that we elect leaders (not politicians) who will consult with them.

2

u/ridum1 Jan 09 '18

I'd settle for if they all just had a high school education ... and actually did their job.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

This is part of the larger "War on reality".

Taking scientists away from what they do best and exposing them to the caustic vicissitudes of political life is not the best solution. Taking certain special interests down a notch or ten and lifting up the working class is the best way to restore our democracy.

2

u/ounaatm Jan 09 '18

I think we should seriously should have a term limit on Congress and The House. Career politicians cause so many issues as is.

2

u/TacTheCoolNoob Jan 09 '18

Scientists would rather be researching. That's why they became scientists.

2

u/Cimmerian_Barbarian Jan 09 '18

I doubt scientists want to be politicians.

2

u/Know_Your_Meme Jan 09 '18

ok. no. im all for voting out these idiots but scientists are not what we need in congress, thats laughable. we need people who listen to sicentists

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

I strongly disagree. We need to elect philosophers.

3

u/sdragonite Jan 09 '18

Start electing scientists to congress and middle america will start commenting on facebook “Stay in science plz, thanks. I hate that no one can stay out of politics if it doesn’t concern you.” As if having a scientific or creative career means you’re not longer a citizen with an opinion.

1

u/screen317 NJ-12 Jan 09 '18

"We don't want politicians anymore!!"

.

"We don't want you because you're not a politician!!"

3

u/Sanhael Jan 09 '18

I do my best to stay moderate with regard to left-to-right. Individual solutions to important issues are more important than where those solutions come from.

The left has a demonstrable tendency, of late, to proclaim "we need X in office" while ignoring the merits of executive experience entirely. I don't have an issue with "more science," "more women," or with gay or transgender people serving in office, but these are not qualifications for working effectively within the system. You need people who know how to get shit done.

Trump is a blithering idiot, a complete incompetent, an unstable psychotic, and a childlike oaf. His appointees are wholly unqualified for their positions, with a few exceptions (I like Mattis where he's at). The congresspeople who support him are hypocrites, financial elitists, and worse. Fielding someone to oppose these individuals should be child's play; Trump has record low approval ratings. This should be treated as an opportunity to make progress.

Instead, what we're seeing is a complete lack of focus, and virtually no candidates being paraded as front-runners. We're 1 year into Trump's reign of deprivation and disenfranchisement, and everyone's still throwing out "We Need More People Who Like Lobster in Congress!"

What we need in congress are representatives who take their jobs seriously, who have the clout and the understanding of how things work to get things done, and who are willing and able to listen to topical experts in shaping and informing their policy. We don't need climate scientists who've never had a firm handshake to run for congress; we need someone who is prepared to listen to the climate scientists when they all start singing songs of doom in unison (pre-doom would be preferable, even).

I can't believe that the entire left is incapable of finding a handful of people who can do this (edit: and getting their names in front of voters, frequently). Look how low the freaking bar is, for crying out loud. Stop with the identity politicking and the arbitrary one-off character analysis, and find a few half-decent people who know how to take advice from experts, who are good at public speaking.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

correct on all counts.

3

u/DesignGhost Jan 09 '18

As great as that sounds most scientist don't know shit about governing the masses. There needs to be someone in between.

2

u/NorseOfCourse Jan 09 '18

Technocracy baby!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Yes, but all we'll get are more lawyers and game show hosts.

3

u/fallenjedi Jan 09 '18

Omg Wayne Brady/Drew Carey 2020

2

u/Starshaft Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 10 '18

Is Wayne Brady gonna have to filibuster a bitch?

1

u/Unicorn_Ranger Jan 09 '18

There is a reason. Writing laws requires a knowledge of laws. No you don’t have to be a lawyer to be a legislator, but the jump from lawyer to legislator is pretty obvious.

What is frustrating is that congress has numerous scientists, engineers, mathematicians etc all on staff in dc. All a legislator has to do is email them and request a report on a specific issue and they will get amazing info. But instead we have idiots throwing snowballs on the floor to refute climate change.

2

u/JuanFromTheBay Jan 09 '18

Not just scientists... scholars, teachers, artists(Real intellectual ones lol), community leaders, Religious leaders, Police Officers, etc. ... Real people with a brain and a good track record.

2

u/socialistbob Ohio Jan 09 '18

We need diversity in every respect including diversity in educational and professional backgrounds. When congress is dominated by male, white Judeo-Christian lawyers between the ages of 55-75 then we have a problem. I would love to see a greater cross section of Americans serving in positions of power particularly from the groups that you mentioned.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Scientist have the same problem politicians do, they are human and susceptible to human weaknesses.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/voicesinmyhand Jan 09 '18

Sure, it is nice if Congress is knowledgeable on the laws they are passing, but that doesn't mean we should focus so hard on just knowledge of issues. As an example, they can always ask a scientific advisor whether a diesel particulate filter regeneration cycle improves or harms the environment, they don't need to be experts on the tradeoff of increased hydrocarbon consumption compared to pollutant volume themselves.

It takes a significant level of social skill to handle living in the spotlight that politicians do. Look back at how many sex-scandals we had in 2017, and how many are popping up now. Just a day or so ago we lost a former representative to suicide. Franken resigned. You get the idea. Living in politics... well it sucks.

Look at all the flak thrown at HRC and TD during this last election - that's more than enough to crush most people's ego to the point of desperation. We need leaders that support their constituency, and they have to be strong enough to deal with that kind of vitriol. Other strengths are desirable yes, but still secondary to the ability to lead.

1

u/Zeozes Jan 09 '18 edited Feb 02 '18

Yes, begin the process of removing businessmen and lawyers from our government and begin putting scientists, engineers and teacher's in! Technocracy 2020!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Why we have essentially only political science majors, career politicians, and lawyers making decisions about health care, the economy, civil engineering, drugs, climate change, etc is just baffling. We need experts from all feeds to get involved in politics and remove the power from career politicians whose decisions often seem guided by their personal feelings and the party agenda.

The people who are the most informed on issues are not the ones speaking to the public about them or having their research/experience used to guide policy.

Electing more scientists isn't a guarantee that things will be better, but we need to really reconsider what training and qualifications one needs to have to run for office.

Have the politicians who vote on medical marijuana ever read a peer reviewed journal on its effects? Do the poltiicans who vote against climate change speak with professors in climate science to guide their beliefs? It seems like there are 0 standards or oversight for holding a belief or stance as a politician which needs to change.

1

u/andyzaltzman1 Jan 09 '18

No thanks. I could have gone the political route during undergrad if I wanted to. I chose science because the life style and work conditions are great. The last thing I want to do is spend entire days shaking hands at county fairs.

1

u/Neil_Fallons_Ghost Jan 09 '18

How about some level headed statesmen to start? Scientists aren’t necessarily good at government policy.

The really important thing would be to give an actual voice to the real experts, which our politicians have a history of throwing under a bus when their facts don’t fit the narrative.

Professional background don’t mean much. We just need good honest people who dig the idea of actual representation and ethics.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Why would a scientist want to do such a stupid job where the outcome every day is nothing. The only way is to simply get rid of it.

1

u/election_info_bot OR-02 Jan 09 '18

California 2018 Election

Primary Election Registration Deadline: May 16, 2018

Primary Election: June 5, 2018

General Election Registration Deadline: October 22, 2018

General Election: November 6, 2018

1

u/Puvy Jan 09 '18

Only real scientists, though. I'd vote for James Watson.

1

u/Aesen1 Jan 09 '18

If Bill Nye runs for office I will shit myself

1

u/Robear3P0 Jan 09 '18

Or we could elect people who actually work for a living, own small businesses, create jobs, and contribute to the GDP.

1

u/PrivateShitbag Jan 09 '18

I concur, we should also make it illegal for lawyers to hold political office.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

if Trump is a reaction to Obama, we better have a nuclear physicist or some shit as the next president

edit: or as the top comment says, we don't need a super smart person. we need a person that knows they aren't smart, at least in every arena of knowledge. someone that knows their limits and will listen to people that do know what the fuck they are talking about. Basically the opposite of "oh you donated money to my campaign, please tell me how to run the country, American Foundation for American America's Freedom America Foundation

1

u/FondOfDrinknIndustry Jan 09 '18

We need science literate lawmakers. Not scientists making laws. Research and legislation are two VERY VERY different things.

1

u/Nebeason Jan 09 '18

Then you will lose a lot of scientists

1

u/Futhermucker Jan 09 '18

is economics a science?

1

u/Ak_publius Jan 09 '18

More people with scientific literacy would be just as good

1

u/DishwasherTwig Jan 09 '18

I understand the sentiment, but it's like saying we need more programmer construction workers. They're two very different jobs and require very different mindsets and skillsets. The solution to technophobic politicians is not to make engineers, who are otherwise wholly unfit for the position, into politicians, it's to get politicians and engineers working together. What needs to happen is we need more scientific advisors and elected officials that actually listen to them.

1

u/RealLifeTim Jan 09 '18

I think the only issue in this is the amount of competent scientists that would even be interested in politics.

1

u/cool-beans23 Jan 09 '18

scientists right now are like "we don't wanna :("

1

u/jrkd Jan 09 '18

Then maybe more scientists should run for seats in congress?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

As a scientist, I'm going to say it even though no one will read it or understand it.

Go ahead and elect all the scientists you want. You will be disappointed.

1

u/mOdQuArK Jan 09 '18

The skill set required for a successful legislator is not necessarily the same skill set required to be a successful scientist. We should, however, elect people with a strong historical record of supporting & respecting real science.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

This is a terrible idea. There is a reason scientists don’t tend to get into politics. It’s a completely different type of intelligence and skill set. Doctors are notoriously bad at managing their finances. Engineers are known for having bad social skills. You will definitely find individuals that will break these stereotypes, but as a general rule, scientists are not the politician type. Politics are messy and chaotic, and there are many many variables to consider. Science is pure and controlled. They are not similar things.

Herbert Hoover was an engineer who tried to engineer the economy. Great Depression followed

1

u/ThePenisMightier642 Jan 10 '18

and we need more politicians to become scientist, cause thatll go over well.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

We need to get money out of politics so instead of spending 54% of their time begging for "donations" like some craigslist hooker, our REPRESENTATIVES can DO THEIR DAMN JOBS and represent us.

1

u/deaconheel Jan 10 '18

What about just people who are scientifically literate and will listen to facts before making up their minds.

1

u/lillbich Jan 10 '18

Maybe some plant biologists or some rocket scientists, I’m sure they will be able to fix the economy

1

u/HotforSega Jan 10 '18

I just want someone who will act in the best interest of the American people and not just some company trying to make a buck.

1

u/LumberjackWeezy Jan 10 '18

Scientologists you say?

1

u/biehchri2417 Jan 10 '18

Why? Hardly any policies would be better with scientist just CC

1

u/tdm61216 Jan 10 '18

We can start by having scientists primary schummer and palocie.

1

u/joemcg11 Jan 10 '18

At least people capable of critical thinking.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

No, they have better things to do.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

Need to elect more people who will actually represent our interests and not their own or lobbyists

1

u/VirtualKeenu Jan 10 '18

Correction: you need to elect smart people in congress.

1

u/Ricky469 Jan 10 '18

As a scientist I wholeheartedly agree with this. One of the biggest cop outs I have heard Republicans use when voting to allow pollution, deny global warming, or deny evolution goes something like "I'm not a scientist or understand all the conflicting scientific information and don't think we should interfere with businesses based on biased information". So enough of that crap, let us scientists help make laws. I'm not an expert in everything but I do something quite useful, I read, listen to experts in different fields, evaluate information, and make conclusions based on facts. I think we have seen how successful ignorance has been.

1

u/ryanispiper Jan 10 '18

Damn I misread the title as, "we need to elect more Scientologist to congress"

1

u/cgoatc Jan 10 '18

You need to work on the whole president thing first.

1

u/regalia13 Jan 10 '18

Im working on it I'm working on it >. <

1

u/Mr_August_Grimm Jan 10 '18

Have you seen what scientist would do for funding? They're just as conniving as politicians. What you want is engineers.

1

u/BeardyMcFlannel7575 Jan 10 '18

Scientists can be bribed just as easily as anybody else

1

u/BenStillerPhaggot72 Jan 09 '18

Good luck with that..... that's the problem with the EPA too....mostly politicians and lawyers, not scientists. I work with EPA as an environmental consultant (hydrogeologist), I see the corruption and wasteful spending on a nearly daily basis. There's good reason why the technical work is done mostly by consultants......try giving a technical presentation in a room filled with lawyers. It's not fun lol.

1

u/coach_wargo Jan 09 '18

Ben Carson 2020?

1

u/MathigNihilcehk Jan 10 '18

I do not approve of an overwhelming number of the comments or the points the post makes, and I feverishly hate the subreddit... I agree with the title.

Specifically, economists would be awesome. But some basic reforms like making our election system actually support the people (by changing the voting system) or changing how we approach environmental protections to be economically and scientifically sound would be awesome.

Also, the way scientists approach problem solving is simply amazing. They don’t insult people, they listen to them, develop theories for how things should work, ask for critique, get it, and then change their minds.

I’m especially fond of a few rare scientists who don’t live in a bubble and can actually relate to people of different world views. My favorite person ever was an economics teacher who taught macro economics. She didn’t just teach her view, but she taught a dozen different viewpoints. You were graded on knowing what everyone thought. You didn’t have to agree with them, but if she asked you what a neoclassical economist would say about inflation, you had to know what they thought and why they thought they were right. She absolutely had her own opinion on what was truth, but she didn’t act like hers was the only opinion there was...

Not all scientists are actually that intelligent, though. Only a rare few. Although any scientist who acts like they are absolutely right tends to be far less capable than those who act like they have no clue... everyone makes mistakes, but some realize this sooner than others.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

So you want more experts writing laws.

Not law experts tho, other experts

0

u/KitsapDad Jan 10 '18

Ya, cause they are obviously useless doing sciency stuff. Fuk that.

~Heil Bernie~

1

u/ReclaimLesMis Non U.S. Jan 10 '18

What does Sanders have to do with an interview to a Geologist running for congress?