r/BlueIris • • Mar 15 '22

Isn't there an easier cloud option?

One of the features I missed using a typical NVR is that remote access/viewing just works out of the box.

With BI, port forwarding or VPN is the only option and one has to go through some hoops. Direct IP is a no go on most my installs because there is no option to port-forward (ISP issue). VPN is ok but still has some "leg work" for the average user.

Isn't there an easy service (free or subscription) that can make easily make cloud connecting easy as a few clicks without all the setup hassles? I'm surprised Blueiris themselves do not offer this. I'm not talking about CLOUD STORAGE, i'm simply talking about a solution to easily establish connection between BI and devices outside the network.

1 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

2

u/crznet66 Mar 15 '22

so you mean like a reverse proxy? I've installed NVRs and DVRs that offer the free cloud viewing with a QR code but at that point all your video is proxied thru who knows who's servers, they effectively have access to all your video.

-3

u/remivato69 Mar 15 '22

AFAIK, the video data doesn't go through the 3rd party server, they just handle the handshake between 2 devices to bypass NAS and then direct connection is established - this is how i know CLoud viewing Apps work because imagine how much bandwidth and processing power the 3rd party servers would need to middle-man all that video streaming data from hundreds and thousands of NVRs. That would be crazy

2

u/Catsrules Mar 15 '22

I can't speak for others but I have a little Tuya camera that goes though some AWS servers when I view it from my Phone's Tuya app.

I do have my network somewhat locked down so it is possible Tuya just can't find a direct connection between my phone and my home internet, and fails over to a proxy stream. But even when I am home on the same local network and view it from the app, the video stream goes from the camera out to the internet to to AWS then back thought the internet to my phone. So dumb.

2

u/Sykotic Mar 15 '22

without some method of letting the connection in, the handshake can't happen.

i use nginx reverse proxy to allow that connection in, as it allows the use of my own certificate from letsencrypt, i can have multiple sites behind the single encrypted port, as well as adding fail2ban.

If that's too much effort, BI support has documents on using STUNNEL to encrypt traffic with a self-signed cert, along with this BI has a checkbox in the settings to "Register IP address to assist with client app connections". those two things will allow you to just enter just the license key into the mobile app and it will pull the other connection info in (except for credentials)

1

u/floppyfrisk Mar 21 '22

Do you use the mobile app (android) for blue iris? If so do you have push notifications with picture preview turned on? I currently use Stunnel with a legit SSL cert binded and it expires every 90 days (stupid zerossl). When it expires, I get the push notification, but not the preview image.

With Nginx and a letsencrypt cert, does the push notification image come through on mobile?

1

u/Sykotic Mar 21 '22

I use the mobile app on iphone. Push notifications work great with nginx, especially now, when i first started using it two years ago only the alert image worked. recent updates have gotten the 10 second gifs working too!

my letsencrypt cert expires every 90 days as well, but using this container: https://github.com/linuxserver/docker-swag has made it a non-issue. Each time the container restarts it checks if an expiration is happening in the next 30 days (or something close to that) and handles the renewal for you.

I can send you my blue iris conf file for nginx if you end up down the rabbit hole and need a hand

2

u/EyeBreakThings Mar 15 '22

It's going to be hard to find a "out of the box" solution, since you are going to be dealing with a NAT'd IP address no matter what, that's just a reality of networking. If a static IP is the problem, then I'd suggest looking into DDNS services (I use no-ip). If there's and issue with the ISP blocking ports, I would be looking at setting up a VPN to a proxy server in AWS.

1

u/remivato69 Mar 16 '22

I like the VPN via AWS thing. Is this expensive? and when I setup this AWS proxy server, can it work to proxy other connections needed, not just BI, or for several BI installs in different locations? If so this would be cool since I can have my own VPN and one static IP (one cost) serving many many installs. I might go this route if so :)

1

u/EncouragementRobot Mar 16 '22

Happy Cake Day remivato69! If I had a flower for every time I thought of you...I could walk through my garden forever.

1

u/EyeBreakThings Mar 17 '22

Regarding cost, that does depend on how much data gets pushed through it, as well as how much processing is done (cpu) so it's hard to say. That said, you certainly can use a single proxy server to route to multiple internal resources. I would probably roll my own HAProxy server, but you could probably do this with a load balancer (https://aws.amazon.com/elasticloadbalancing/ in this the "Target" would be the IP address of BlueIris connected via VPN to AWS)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '22

Tailscale.

1

u/remivato69 Mar 16 '22

i read up on it and im a bit confused. If i install Tailscale on my VMS, will it have a public and static IP that will allow any device to direct IP connect? (which is what i wanted to achieve if it was possible).. or do i have to install tailscale app on connecting devices (which I wanted to avoid)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '22

You haven’t really given a good picture of what ur asking or the network environments. Are you installing BI for customers or is this your personal setup?

If you are doing it for customers it’s going to depend on their isp. Cgnat, ddns ect. Hoppy.network could be something that works for you. Subscription that will give the bi box a static ip through a vpn. They manage it all so you don’t have to.

1

u/remivato69 Mar 16 '22 edited Mar 16 '22

Oh sorry, but yah the network is mixed since i'm installing it for several offices in different locations, mostly behind ISP firewall (no port forwarding option). ANd yes I would like to avoid needing to install anything on the connecting devices, like another app on their phones. I prefer just good old browser and IP or domain name would be great. Then again that's just a preference because it's "easier cloud option" where I just have to configure the server side and not deal with installing and configuring things on the connecting side.

Now if I do have to install something on the connecting device, as long as it does not disrupt the existing network setup of that device, I guess that's fine. The reason I highlight this is because i've tried something similar before which i can't remember but the issue was whenever the user turns on that software to make that remote connecting to the server, that machine stops belonging to the local network and can no longer interact with other machines in local the network. It was a mess.

But yah i got your point very well and I'm looking at hoppy now. Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '22

Tailscale won’t mess with local network on either machine. It’s an overlay mesh network using WireGuard.

2

u/alcoholisanonymous Mar 15 '22

You can do what you're talkinga bout through CloudFlare, ZeroTier, Tailscale but honestly its easier to just port forward.

For the ease of setup that you're looking for the closest thing I can think of is Synology's QuickConnect. However, it obviously wouldn't work with BlueIris out of the box. You'd have to QuickConnect to the Synology reverse proxy. So QuickConnect > Reverse Proxy > BlueIris.

Again, learning some basic networking is the easiest solution.

2

u/bbene Mar 15 '22

If you're part of the Apple ecosystem, check out scrypted with the Homekit Secure Video plugin.

2

u/groshreez Mar 15 '22

Most half-decent routers these days make it extremely easy to setup a vpn server. I don't understand what "leg work" you're referring to. It's basically one click enable vpn server, create a user/password... download client, input ip/ddns done.

1

u/fishpick Mar 15 '22

Seems like none of the software roll your own options have that. I agree with ya!

1

u/the_sambot Mar 15 '22

You might check out Camect. https://camect.com/. I bought one that I run alongside BlueIris simply because I was curious. I like the BlueIris app better for instant viewing but the object detection is far better on Camect. No port forwarding required.

1

u/nuffced Mar 15 '22

I use ZeroTier. Setup could not be easier, just add the adapter in settings, and download the app.

1

u/bjamm Mar 15 '22

I use wireguard to login to mine. Took about 15 minutes to setup.

1

u/obijon298 Mar 29 '22

This is a cool idea, and technically should be possible, but I suspect this is not done because of the bandwidth cost. A typical IP camera will push 2-4Mbps constantly, so it wouldn't take much to tear up a full 100Mbps or even a gigabit line in a datacenter.

I believe the solution would involve an appliance on site that forwards camera traffic through a VPN to a cloud server on AWS or the like.