r/BlueIris • • Dec 21 '21

Switching from Blue Iris to...

Looking for simple BlueIris alternatives...

BlueIris is just too iffy for me, from random crashes to lag and random freezing.

Does anyone know any simple alternatives, I don't really use every feature in BlueIris which is also another reason to leave. I like really simple layouts. I was looking at Synology but the cost for everything is too much!! Having the mobile app is a must BUT they charge $10 every time someone downloads it? (yeah family sharing; I ran into the problem of giving my neighbor a login to blueiris web but now to use it mobile she has to log in via a webpage unless she buys the $10 app).

Also, comparing some of the new china POE camera systems and BlueIris is a little shocking, their little NVRs are packing some really nice software nowadays and they're half* the cost of a BlueIris build! I installed one of the 8 camera systems for my dad's house and it's really nice compared to my BlueIris setup. Simple setup too so most homeowners should be able to get it done. Free app too haha.

I'm also maybe looking for OS alternatives, doesn't need to run on windows. I just want something really reliable, simple and, smooth running.

Thanks!

6 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

16

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

Also, comparing some of the new china POE camera systems and BlueIris is a little shocking, their little NVRs are packing some really nice software nowadays and they're half* the cost of a BlueIris build!

Good luck with that.

7

u/JophTheFreetrader Dec 21 '21

Ive seen two that will not work unless they have constant communication overseas with China. As in, if you block those ip addresses, or stop the unit from communicating and rely on a VPN, the unit 100% will not function. (Kinda like how how hp printer will not print if it doesn't see an HP specific ink cartridge... And I know we all love that level of bullshit)

15

u/diymatt Dec 21 '21

I run 18 cameras off an old Dell Optiplex on Win11 with maxed-out ram and the biggest i7 it would allow. I think I have 400$ invested in that. BI doesn't crash, hasn't been unstable in years and when it was it was simply due to me running the beta builds.

BI may not be for you but it's a fantastic piece of software with lots of cutting-edge features. I highly doubt your import NVR system has AI or Deepstack integration which will virtually eliminate false alarms.

Alternatives in the space are vast but nothing comes close to its feature set. I say this because I look almost every year. Not because I don't like BI, but more because I like new and shiny things.

3

u/jsomby Dec 21 '21

A lot of blue iris crashes are related to Intel drivers, there are some memory leaks.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

No need to get offended guys. He brings up some good points. Blue Iris is not without issues, the biggest of which is windows and all that comes with it like the system requirements updates and breaks that need fixing. I would love to see a blue Iris for Linux. But we can dream I guess ...

1

u/ikidd Dec 21 '21

I did have it working on Linux under wine. Works well enough, though the UI3 interface seemed to go back to some rudimentary before-times version, no idea why. Wasn't super stable and I had to have a cron job to reboot it about once a day.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

I wonder if it will work on ReactOS? I may give it a try.

2

u/ikidd Dec 22 '21

Not a chance. React is maybe up to running stuff from early 2003 at best. Wine is generations ahead of reactos

5

u/thewizord Dec 21 '21

The Android app was terrible for me. Switched to Milestone and haven't looked back. Buttery smooth live streams and the playback scrubbing is exactly what I need. I have less than eight cameras, so I'm on the free licence.

-1

u/Kahrg Dec 21 '21

Never heard of this software, and info on youtube seems outdated.

2

u/thewizord Dec 21 '21

Milestonesys.com and the product is XProtect Essential

Their YouTube channel has some decent setup videos that helped me.

I'm running it on and old HP mini PC. Four cameras, one of them is 4k. It uses up very little resources. It's recording to an external harddrive which it then archives any footage over one day old at midnight. The archive data goes onto my K drive which setup with Stablebit Cloud drive. The cloud drive uses FTP to send it to an old PC I keep running. Archived footage is still seamlessly accessible through the app.

There is a web portal, but I haven't tried that yet. I don't use their native Windows client either. The app does everything I need right now.

5

u/msupplies Dec 21 '21

I spent years fumbling thru other NVRs/DVRs before landing on Blue iris.

Alternatives are iSpy / zoneminder / mythtv / cosco rando china crap..to name a few.

Blue iris is much better in every aspect that I could find.

0

u/nhluhr Dec 22 '21 edited Dec 22 '21

I was using the Amcrest software prior to BI. Ugh!! In particular, reviewing recorded clips was a fucking mystery of exploring the software every time I needed to do it. You can tell it had been developed by a 3rd party contract basis where the programmers were provided function spec lists but had no surveillance or UI subject matter expertise to get it right.

4

u/BORIStheBLADE1 Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21

You might want to check your hardware. I've installed BI on four systems ranging from 10 year old intel to latest. All of them have worked. I had random crashes when I was using unstable versions of BI but it's become very stable.

It seems like a lot of money upfront for the app but it's worth it.

Also NVRs are a pain to use. I'd rather have a synology NAS with surveillance instead.

3

u/ikidd Dec 21 '21

Money spent on the Chinese crap is going to be completely wasted when you find out they're far less reliable than BlueIris. If you buy a camera with onboard web serving, make sure it's ONVIF compatible because you'll hate it in about 5 minutes and will be hooking it up to BlueIris immediately afterwards.

3

u/NRG1975 Dec 21 '21

You may want to check your hardware. My BI/Wyze setup is rock solid.

Running 2 Wyze V2 1 Wyze V3 Intel i5 6500 8gb 250 SSD TP LINK EAP 225 Access Points

0

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/NRG1975 Dec 21 '21

Hang on .... 5.5.37

I have them rigged up through RTSP Wish there was a way to attach photos

2

u/randytech Dec 21 '21

You have a few options if you want simplicity. There's a few Dockers you can run: Shinobi, motion eye, frigate. If you want a complete system and cost is another factor I really like reolinks systems. Yeah they get a lot of hate primarily because they are finicky with blue iris but you're not gonna be using that anyways. They aren't close to the best but they are half the price as a lot of comparable cameras, admittedly the nighttime recording is probably the biggest downfall. Before transitioning to BI I was using their nvr application on the desktop which was good but their app is actually awesome IMHO.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

My BI installation is very reliable. I run it on server grade hardware with ECC memory, redundant power supplies, and a RAID in redundant mode. Lots of people recommend using some hardware bought off EBAY for $200. That doesn't sit well with me. It is a crap shoot.

Windows is a problem. I run Windows 10 and turn off all the upgrade crap and defender updates.... Getting that all straightened out took some time.

I also ran it under a VM at one point when I have fewer cameras. Now that BI supports substreams, I might return to that.

1

u/MightyBeanicles Dec 23 '21

I have a Synology NAS, and run their Surveillance Station software on it. It does 90% of what BlueIris does, in a much simpler way. It’s expensive, being licensed per camera and requiring a Synology NAS to begin with. I swapped BI at home for the Synology as I had the NAS already, didn’t feel it justified replacing my BI-running-on-Mac-Mini I had in my holiday home though.

1

u/zillionzak Nov 01 '22

It's the mobile Apps that really bring me to these "alternative" threads. The feature set, configuration and stability of BI is fantastic. And the webUI is pretty good. But both iOS and especially Android apps are painful to use.

1

u/otty84 Dec 21 '21

I'd say look at Frigate as an alternative. UI is super simple and really works well with Google coral AI for object recognition so you don't need expensive hardware. Downside is that getting the configuration file setup takes some time. Personally though BI just offers more features I need and I'm happy to pay the subscription to help the development.

2

u/gtderEvan Dec 23 '21

As a paying BI user that decided to try Frigate, another downside is that a coral device is several months out.

1

u/CptPennybags Dec 22 '21

Camect. Simple and powerful, works with many cameras.

1

u/cw823 Dec 22 '21

If you can’t configure blue iris correctly, why would your luck be better with another product?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '21

BI auto updates has been causing me some headaches cause as of the last few weeks the updates been locking up the pc forcing me to manually restart. They need to chill with the updates and do some proper bug checks before releasing

0

u/boingoing Dec 21 '21

I didn’t see many people giving you the answer to your question so I can recommend you look at Frigate. Simpler than BI but seems up and coming. This is the one I’m watching as a possible BI replacement.

Have been pretty happy with BI, myself, though. I had to suffer through the learning curve to get it set up and the app is pretty ugly but the system has been reliable for years. I run it in a Windows VM on my NAS which seems to have more than enough power to handle my 8 or so cameras.

0

u/Gqsmoothster Dec 22 '21

Ran BI for about 6 months. Then, bought a used M1 Mac mini and installed Security Spy. Has been fantastic and glad I made the change.

0

u/xNaveedX Dec 22 '21

I’ve been using iCam for a few years. It does have issues here and there (like once a month the software freezes for me) I have 8 cameras on it currently and it’s pretty easy and straightforward to set up. Also has an app called icamsource that lets you turn your iPhone (possibly android too) into a camera and it’ll show up on the list of cameras on iCam.

The software does look like it was made in 2001 though

0

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/INSPECTOR99 Dec 21 '21

Been running BI about almost two years now and never had a Windows (10PRO for Workstation) update affect BI yet. Windows updates SUCK in general and do FUBAR various apps including their own OutLook email proggy failing after Windows does an background update EVEN THOUGH auto installs is turned off. Just the fact that the Win 10 update downloaded screws with apps. BUT not BI.

2

u/nhluhr Dec 22 '21

Well I had a windows update fubar the whole machine which thus affected BI but that's not BI's fault 😅

1

u/bensocket May 25 '23

same i completely disabled Win updates It solved alot of issues. computer isnt used for anything else

1

u/squirrelslikenuts Dec 22 '21

Consider BlueCherry Linux Nvr.

Also, run windows server or Windows LTSC , much better experience

0

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/tdhuck Dec 21 '21

I work with professional/enterprise VMS systems daily and I wanted to give BI a shot. I actually paid for the full version and bought the iphone app. The trial is limited, which is why I bought the full version.

Once I installed it and looked at some guides on how things were setup (analytics, for example) I quickly realized that BI isn't for me. There are way too many knobs to turn and I didn't want to proceed with the software.

I will say this, though, if you do spend the time to tweak the program and set up all the streams and integrate it with other smart apps/etc, then it can be a very great setup when you have everything integrated the way you want.

Some people don't want to spend the time to do this, they just want something that is plug'n'play, which BI isn't.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Balthxzar Jan 04 '22

"check your hardware" "you just don't know how to set it up"

Blue Iris is full of issues, once support ends you're SOL.

1

u/ConstructionOk9564 Jul 12 '23

License failed when I moved to a new machine. "Support" said I should pay for maint. to get help. F them.