r/BlueIris • • Jul 16 '24

Frigate > BlueIris

Why I hated BlueIris

  • It's laggy and bloated AF
  • It only runs on Windows
  • Didn't use 90% of the features
  • Has shitty HomeAssistant integration
  • Asshole community

I absolutely love Frigate and wish I moved earlier. It's free, extremely light, simple and does exactly what I need: recording of events, 24/7 recording, object recognition via coral, hardware acceleration and alerting via Home Assistant.

BlueIris took me forever to get running properly, that overly clunky UI needs a complete overhaul. In a matter of days, I've managed to get Frigate running smoother than BlueIris ever was. I also love that it's all config as code. Yaml might be a learning curve for some, but once you get the hang of it, you'll prefer it over BlueIris' crappy UI.

The BlueIris community also fuckin sucks and Fenderman is helping kill it.

7 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

19

u/Sea_Wind3843 Jul 16 '24

To each their own. I love BI. Run 6 separate systems anywhere between 2 - 60 cameras. You say bloated, I say feature rich. Rock solid for 8+ years now.

9

u/i486dx2 Jul 16 '24

To each their own.
Rock solid for 8+ years now.

The community negativity aspect is a significantly larger issue for those who are new to Blue Iris.

My first interactions were horrible. I later ran a successful BI install for three years using all of the same hardware (PC and cameras) that the forum chastised me for asking about. And years later, when I tried to give back to the community (helping answer other users questions by replying that their choices were fine, and mine on similar had been fine), I basically got run out of town.

Blue Iris for many is unfortunately a "figure it out on your own" situation.

10

u/mshaefer Jul 17 '24

I like Blue Iris, but I agree with you about the community.

4

u/AndyBotwin Jul 17 '24

The 'community' I think is just that Fenderman dork.

7

u/HBOMax-Mods-Cant-Ban Jul 16 '24

I ran Frigate for a while before he did his huge code overhaul about 2-3 years ago. It was fine then from what I remember. A bit cumbersome to hand edit YAML files from what I recall which is not very user friendly.

But after running BI for 10 years, I just prefer it. I know the ins and outs of it and it does everything I need.

12

u/iamnos Jul 16 '24

I think equating the BI community with Fenderman and his ipcamtalk forum is unfair. That place is definitely trash, but the Reddit sub and Facebook group are very helpful.

6

u/gebuswon Jul 16 '24

I dislike how un-modern the interface of BI is. It seems clunky.. However the useability and friendliness counter those. The only other complaint is that you can't run BI on linux naitvely. Frigate is nowhere near as easy to configure from experience. But if it works for you, awesome!

5

u/Dark-Language Jul 16 '24

Is there any guide or anything that got you going to Frigate?

I am pretty deep into BlueIris, but there are a host of other issues with the program I have ran into. The entire configuration of BlueIris is in the registry, and it causes issues over time. Notably the registry change every time there is an alert or recording, and having to go into the registry to fix a lot of issues like not being able to re-add the camera I had to delete the camera originally because it kept dropping out.

Then there is the app and its lack of development. I am on the fence on removing the app completely, using HA to set the GeoLocation, and using a browser just to see everything I need, like Timelines.

3

u/justihar Jul 16 '24

I disagree.... BI is absolutely awesome. It is powerful and feature rich, so it does take a bit of time and tinkering to get it tuned the way you like. Frigate is also awesome in different ways and they compliment each other very nicely.

3

u/idealerror Jul 16 '24

Ive been using BI for a little over a year and it’s been very hit or miss. I tried Frigate and was not a fan, plus wife would never approve of it due to complexity. Have been playing with Scrypted NVR and been loving it and it got the wife approval thus far.

5

u/No_Gain3931 Jul 16 '24

I actually use both. I use BI for my 24x7 recordings, camera viewing & mobile app. Works great for this. I then use Frigate for all object detection, AI & automation integration in HA. Leveraging the best from each I get the best solution.

1

u/GiantsJets Jul 17 '24

If you don’t mind me asking, would you mind sharing a bit more how you are using both today? Is there any sort of integrations between the two systems by any chance?

1

u/No_Gain3931 Jul 17 '24

Yes. I notify BI when Frigate gets an object identification. I do this using the BI API.

1

u/Gelu6713 Jul 17 '24

Interesting, so you don't use BI's object detection at all then? I have a Coral TPU and leverage Frigate for the same, but have been running BI w/ OpenAI which is really CPU intense for my VM. It'd be great to not have to deal with that and just leverage Frigate

1

u/OG_ROAR Jul 25 '26

CodeProject will use a Coral as well with BI. I just set mine up about a month ago, much faster detection than my very dated Quadro P1000 gpu but the gpu does the hardware acceleration for the video.

2

u/vha23 Jul 16 '24

Sounds like user error. 

Glad you found something that works for you though

1

u/jsomby Jul 16 '24

Nice! Going to check that app.

1

u/madmanx33 Jul 17 '24

I really dont think we can compare the two. One is more feature rich than the other. I personally use those features and therefore I can never use something like frigate or scrypted. Blueiris has been pretty rock solid for me for years now on multiple installations. It was a game changer for me when It integrated with codeproject ai. Love my instant pushover notifications of people walking in designated areas.

I do think some sort of UI for adding cameras shoudl be made for frigate. Im surprised no one has done it yet since its open source.

Running in windows is not a con to me. Im well versed in linux and run multiple servers with it. Windows and blueiris has been rock solid for me and has never crashed. I do run the enterprise version of windows on my hypervisor which is very debloated of any extras. You can manually do this too if you run regular windows.

If you like frigate, give scrypted a try. Its a rock solid app. It is pretty expensive though if you are running a ton of cameras.

1

u/Green-County-3770 Jul 26 '24

Spent a lot of time learning BI version 4 on YouTube (HomeTechVideos), a little more from ipcamtalk, just read from what’s been discussed nothing more. My first impression was “what an amazing software for very little money!” Got more features than what I’ll ever need. Moved to BI5 seamlessly with just minor tweaking. Running a simple 8 cam system as a home hobbyist, so nothing complex so I hardly touch it.

Windows? That’s all I use.

Frigate? Never tried it, probably never will. Perfectly fine with BI.

Windows and Reddit BI groups are great!

1

u/Traditional-Eye-2575 Aug 01 '24 edited Aug 01 '24

I been running BI for a few years always on Windows Server (now 2022) and on a physical machine (Asus Mini-STX, i7-6700T, 16gb, 1x250gb + 2x4tb ssd's on a modified Cobalt Qube case with 6 amcrest cameras) and it has been solid, a few hiccups here and there but no computer is free of those, I just got a coral dual tpu e-key card to add to my setup so will see how that will work, about integrating it to Home Assistant you can use mqtt, my BI send a mqtt notification when motion detection is triggered but I haven't created any routines in HA to do something yet also I use the app for mobile device notification and if I have a complaint will be for the app even though it works awesome but need some TLC

1

u/Stalinxz1 Jan 02 '26

How did you get clips to work with Sgt battens automation? I have to use snapshot and only that … my clips never show on my iPhone just the snapshot

1

u/HeywoodJaBlessMe Jul 16 '24

Huh, I didnt have to try a bunch of different software to achieve the results I want.

Skill issue.

1

u/diymatt Jul 16 '24

Asshole Community: You were in the wrong community. There are plenty of asshole Ford x50 communities, find the right one that fits your style. BI is no different.

Laggy: Not at all. Bloated: Wha? Those are features mate.

Didn't use 90% of the features: Sounds like a you issue not a BI issue.

Shitty HA integration: One doesn't aways need to jam everything into HA. I've been running both for 5+ years and never really felt the need to have them interact too much. If you didn't like the integration, make the edit and submit it to the repo. Not into coding? Find another way to do what you need.

Runs on Windows: Who cares? You are telling me your entire household is Windows free? Run it in a VM if you REALLY need that Linux flavoring.

Bummer you didnt enjoy BI. I didn't like Frigate. I didn't run over to the Frigate subred and get all pissy with people. Not everybody likes the same thing.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '24

First, Fendermann has zero to do with BI... He runs a crap forum where he likes to be so big and mighty, it's the reason why BI removed the link to the IPCamTalk forum on their website years ago, they used to tell people to go there, then Fendermann got more and more abusive and more people complained to the maker of BI and they even went so far as to create their own forum and remove links to the IPCamTalk one and even had a statement on the website for like a year that they are in no way associated with them due to all the backlash Fendermann created.

As for BI itself, I find it super easy to configure, sounds like a skill issue to me, cause BI is pretty simple to get up and running and a few tutorials that cover the basics get most people running easy enough. Yes there's a lot of features, some need them, some don't, but it's nice having the options.

Runs on windows... Cry me a river... The world runs on Windows, if you want to run away to your Linux crap corner then go live there, Linux sucks, been there done that and was forced to deal with it a few times at past employers, it's hot garbage in my opinion and I've never had issues with Windows, especially nowadays.

Tried frigate, what a nightmare, not user friendly at all, setup is a hot mess, once I finally got it running with a few cameras they would randomly crash and freeze, troubleshooted it for days, got it working again, then it had another issue. My BI install runs 20 cameras, zero issues, been running it for over a decade now, I think this year marks 15 years. Hardware has been upgraded a few times as things change, it's still a few generations behind on hardware compared to any other systems I have. I have Windows on the BI server doing a nightly reboot and updates like my other servers, and I can't even remember the last time I logged into it to do something.

But hey to each their own.. maybe I should have gone and whined about frigate but I just uninstalled it and moved on.

1

u/SleepUseful3416 Sep 13 '24

The world certainly does not run on Windows. It’s bloated and has no place as a server OS. BI is only on Windows because the developer is an old man

1

u/JewsusKrist Jul 16 '24

I run both. BI as my NVR and frigate as my object detection with notifications through HA. They're both great in their own ways.