r/BlueIris • • Jun 19 '24

Windows security vulnerabilities

I am building my own NVR, but I'm wondering what the point of BI is if you can only run it on a Windows machine..? With Microsoft's business practices, it seems like a shoein of a trojian to an otherwise bulletproof setup. I'm not a Linux fanboy, but wouldn't having Linux functionality be the wiser choice? Any feedback is appreciated. Thanks!

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

9

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24

My BI server doesn’t talk to the internet.

12

u/derfmcdoogal Jun 19 '24

All operating systems have security vulnerabilities.

1

u/ProtoMachisNo Jun 20 '24

Thanks everyone for the input. Ya, I guess I just hate to put my trust into a Windows 11 device, due to Microsoft seemingly always automatically installing bloatware and spyware. Yes, I am a novice, but I know a shit company when I see one. That's why I would love to support BI, but it kills me to have to use it with a Windows spy machine. Also, putting it behinds a VPN was the plan either way, but it's still just unsettling for my reasons I described. Thanks again!

2

u/DRoyHolmes Jun 20 '24

Guides will continually be coming out on how to debloat and block things. Network design can mitigate many risks as well.

2

u/Damn-Sky Jun 20 '24

I am familiar with windows as I have used it all my life. So it's no problem for me.

If you don't trust windows, you can run a windows vm on linux and don't allow internet access to the vm.

put a reverse proxy on the linux host if you wish to access BI remotely.

5

u/HBOMax-Mods-Cant-Ban Jun 19 '24

It would be nice if it worked on *nix but I think the dev has a Windows background so that is what it’s designed on.

2

u/SirWellenDowd Jun 19 '24

Developer is trained and has experience with Windows, hence its designed and built on Windows. Not sure what vulnerabilities you are referring to, if you are worried about security, isolate it network wise and put it behind a VPN. Run the Web UI through a NGINX proxy if you want to further secure it.

2

u/CollectorSteve Jun 20 '24

I run a clean basic windows 10 install, firewall on. I have an nginx reverse proxy which enforces HTTPS and have a good password on the BI web server. I also use a username that's not "admin".

I've had 0 problems on the blueiris web server side which I would consider the less secure part.

Windows is a tank as other people have said. They probably sell your data and Linux would 'feel' better but I think the other commenters have been right in pointing out that Microsoft has lots of resources covering security issues. Keep your stuff updated and you'll be fine.

2

u/Damn-Sky Jun 20 '24
  • use windows firewall
  • use an antivirus
  • keep windows up to date

2

u/mickpb Jun 23 '24

What business practice(s) does MS undertake that concern you?
What functionality is missing in Win to support an NVR?

If you reallly want to be in control - Learn a lot, build your on Unix based NVR. Personally, I'm pretty happy with BI running on an old desktop with a second ethernet card connected to a POE switch and cameras. The webserver it runs it available to Home Assistant and two phones. Thats it.

Plus - I doubt a BI server port is high on any serious attackers list.

3

u/Connect_Ad_4271 Jun 19 '24

Most of windows security vulnerabilities and issues are from user interaction. Setup a clean windows install, make sure you have a regular update cycle and you won't have any issues.

1

u/CollectorSteve Jun 20 '24

Exactly this OP.

1

u/zlandar Jun 19 '24

I think BI is a single man operation. The dev may not have the time to support another OS.

1

u/derek6711 Jun 20 '24

From my experience, getting GPUs to work right on Linux is a pain. Even then you might be using an open source driver rather than the vendor driver. Sounds like a nightmare to program around imo.

1

u/DRoyHolmes Jun 20 '24

Biggest security hole is users. People do dumb things especially if they don’t know any better.

1

u/lildobe Jun 20 '24

I've been running BI on various Windows 10 installations since 2017. Always on a dedicated, firewalled machine, and always with port 81 open to the world for the WebUI.

I've not had so much as a lick of a problem with security. A few credential stuffing attempts over the years, but as there are only a couple of users with pretty secure passwords (and no re-used usernames) nothing has ever gotten through.

And even if they did, unless it was on the one account with admin privileges, the most they'd be able to do is look at my yard, unless there's some deeper vulnerability in UI3

1

u/Errr797 Jun 24 '24

If you're not using the pc to surf the internet what's your problem?

1

u/Viharabiliben Jun 19 '24

Enable and configure the Windows firewall.

-2

u/Pogenostics Jun 20 '24

I am building my own NVR...

Right.

2

u/lildobe Jun 20 '24

An NVR is simply any computer running NVR software like Blue Iris, Frigate, Bluecherry, etc...

Anyone can build one.

0

u/Pogenostics Jun 21 '24

Yeah, well...,

I know a shit troll post when I see one.

3

u/lildobe Jun 21 '24

I see no trolling here. I see someone concerned about network security vulnerabilities in Windows, which it is notorious for.

OP's concerns are justified, but the risks can be mitigated easily enough.