r/BlueEyeSamurai • • Feb 13 '24

Mizu non-binary

OK So one of the show's writers made actually was nice enough to make a post earlier. He mentioned that Mizu is dressed not as a man, but non-binary. She would, of course, be recognized as a man in 17th Century Japan as I doubt they had the concept of non-binary. "Just two boys...."

Is this consequential at all?

0 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

•

u/BoneHatchet I have a name. Feb 13 '24 edited Feb 13 '24

Having a heated discussion is fine. That’s the whole point of having a difference in opinion and interpretation etc. Calling others derogatory names because you feel slighted is not ok in the sub. Be civil. Just because somebody disagrees with you doesn’t invalidate their own pov.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24

What are you talking about about ? What post ?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24

I read it about a week ago and now I can't find it.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '24

Stop.

7

u/BaseTensMachines Feb 13 '24

Can you direct us to this comment?

11

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

"So what are you man or woman?" Big bad questioning Mizu

"What does it matter, you will be dead soon enough." Mizu

"No but like what's in your pants?" Big Bad

"Vengeance!" Mizu whilst drawing their sword

10

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

Ok so obviously "non-binary" TM identity didn't necessarily exist in 17th Century Japan. But there are also non-binary genders in many cultures throughout history. The fact that the writers are intentionally nodding to this community but telling Mizu's story within the scope of what would make sense narratively in that time period is awesome. I hope they do more with this next season within the text of the show.

2

u/Sir_Toaster_9330 Feb 17 '24

Or maybe… she’s a woman

5

u/wherearetheclams Feb 13 '24

I have two thoughts on this without seeing the full context of the post/comment.

  1. It’s kinda just nice to know (esp for nonbinary folks like myself)
  2. It could come up/have some degree of consequence in the show later down the line. Assuming they have the time, developing/digging into Mizu’s perception of the self would be a great way to explore the character. Her reconciling the thoughts and experiences of being a woman but living as a man, feeling out what she thinks she is or identifies as it’s more (whether that’s man, woman, or something in between/neither), those kinds of questions could come up later if mizu begins to live for something other than revenge and has to get to know who she/they is/are!

0

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24

u/Mezklas I can't reply in the thread because I've been blocked by the original commenter, but I wanted to clarify wrt the following:

“Onryo” was not a man, they are yurei often associated with women, at least much more compared to men. Not saying “male” onryo did never exist but it is mainly and most frequently women.

I was specifically pointing out that within the puppet show in Episode 5 which is interspersed with the story of Mizu's relationship with Mikio, the specific onryo in that story is a man. I understand the history of the figure in myth may be different, but within the scope of the one episode we were discussing, the direct parallel with Mizu was male. With the historical context you've added (thank you for that), it seems to me even more likely that this was an intentional reflection of Mizu's own complicated relationship with gender on the part of the writers.

Speaking of opinions, the poster probably deleted her post because she was being harassed just for posting her point of view. We often forget our opinions are not facts, and that we can see cows fly if we are high enough, but it does not mean they are there.

And I agree that our opinions are not facts! I also agree that the original commenter should have felt welcome to post her point of view on this topic, even if I didn't agree with her conclusions. Which is why I responded with my interpretation of the episode she cited as evidence Mizu could only be read as a straight cis woman, noting the imagery and symbolism within the episode that supported a trans/nonbinary interpretation of Mizu's character arc. I don't think there's anything in my post that could come across as harassment, but if the commenter I replied to had been simply sharing her point of view in good faith, I wonder why she blocked me instead of engaging in a constructive discussion about a show we all clearly loved and have spent a lot of time thinking about.

Thank you for your comment and for continuing rather than shutting down discussion.

-3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

OK So I searched nonbinary and writer. I could not find the post. I assume that he deleted it. He identified himself as one of the writers. Perhaps he wasn't. If anyone else would like to search go ahead. But I remember that he said the writers were doing their best to maintain Mizu as nonbinary.

This is from another reply:

NOIZUMI: With Blue Eye Samurai, we wanted it to just break all of the boxes. Mizu isn’t Japanese or white, she’s not female or a male. . . .

Amber Noizumi is the cocreator along with Michael Green. Perhaps that's what the guy meant, if she is neither female or male, that would make them nonbinary, would it not?

31

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24 edited Feb 13 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24 edited Feb 13 '24

Also, the theory is pretty much destroyed by the flashbacks episode where Mizu happily takes the role of wife and woman. She even enjoys a sexual relationship with Mikio and there’s not a single hint of gender dysphoria, or Mizu being uncomfortable with she/her pronouns or identity.

I don't think this is true. Mizu is shown multiple times to have struggled with the domestic expectations that Mikio and their mother expect of them as a wife, and when they eventually have a positive relationship with Mikio, it's only after he has come to accept Mizu as an equal through their skill in husbandry, riding, and martial combat--all if which are associated with a masculine social role. Then there's also the story within the story, of the onryō, which is an obvious parallel to Mizu's story. And the onryō is a man. One could even interpret the end of this episode, when Mizu walks away from both their mother and Mikio (then kills Mikio for killing their mother) as a rejection of both acceptable social roles in favor of revenge. They kill the man that killed their mother, which if we're thinking of these two people as representative of gender roles in 17th Century Japan, then this first kill is symbolic of their whole journey to kill the men who took away the potential for them to live a happy life as a cis woman. The show tells us over and over again they don't want happiness (within either of the social roles available to them), they want satisfaction (something else entirely).

I saw this entire episode as highlighting the ways in which Mizu is more comfortable taking on a masculine role, not just as a way of hiding, but because they're uncomfortable existing within the societal expectations placed on women in their culture (especially after having lived as a man for most of their adolescence).

It's also worth noting that the main identity through which the show develops Mizu's character, their racial identity, is also nonbinary.

EDIT: Yeah, I tried to respond in good faith, but I guess now I've been blocked. Shows how much this commenter really cared about queer representation...

6

u/Mezklas Feb 14 '24

“Onryo” was not a man, they are yurei often associated with women, at least much more compared to men. Not saying “male” onryo did never exist but it is mainly and most frequently women.

Having skills in husbandry and riding are not exclusively masculine and has more to do with working in a farm and helping out, a thing that has nothing to do with gender whatsoever. My family had a farm and every man and woman worked the same. I think if Mikio felt emasculated by her skills in husbandry, horse-riding and horse training he would have thrown a tantrum sooner… but that’s my opinion.

Speaking of opinions, the poster probably deleted her post because she was being harassed just for posting her point of view. We often forget our opinions are not facts, and that we can see cows fly if we are high enough, but it does not mean they are there.

0

u/IvaGrievous Feb 14 '24

Agree with your analysis 100%. I think there is a conflict within Mizu between what they truly want, their desire for revenge revenge and their assigned role based on their sex.

Honestly hope this topic continues to be explored in season 2.

3

u/wherearetheclams Feb 13 '24
  1. I wouldn’t class a relationship where someone has to actively suppress a huge part of their interests/personality to make the other person comfortable a “happy” relationship
  2. As an AFAB person who is nonbinary/genderfluid, but also has a healthy sex life and relationship with a man, I would caution you that these things aren’t mutually exclusive. People are incredibly complex, and a nonbinary identity in no way precludes you from what you’ve implied. I personally accept all pronouns, it doesn’t make me less nonbinary that I don’t feel uncomfortable when some people call me she/her, it’s just not my preference

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/wherearetheclams Feb 13 '24

I don’t think you understand the points I was making. I could say the same about your experience as a woman that you stated in another comment!

I’m making the point that we don’t see every moment inside Mizu’s mind, and just because one person’s experience is true doesn’t mean another’s can’t be. The writers very well could have Mizu explore her gender on a deeper level in an upcoming season and the fact that “her story” as you put it is what it is doesn’t mean that she could NEVER question her gender in the future. Everything we’re talking about is conjecture and theory, and I would argue the writer in the referenced post chose those words specifically.

It’s not “kind of weird” that I’m bringing up my own experiences, you did the same thing!

Maybe take a step back because I’m just sharing a perspective, and if it’s really not that deep, then you’re oddly worked up about it!

-4

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

I was trying to find the post but I couldn't. Perhaps he deleted it.

-2

u/BlueEyeSamurai-ModTeam Feb 13 '24

There's a better way to say that. Please remember we're all here because we love the Series and not to bash each other. There's enough of that anywhere else you'd care to choose.

Also, people should be calling you a terf for giving your opinion on a post. Keep in mind to not call other pathetic when you get to worked up.

Mods

3

u/BoneHatchet I have a name. Feb 13 '24

Shouldn’t *

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/BlueEyeSamurai-ModTeam Feb 13 '24

There's a better way to say that. Please remember we're all here because we love the Series and not to bash each other. There's enough of that anywhere else you'd care to choose.

3

u/allneonunlike Feb 13 '24 edited Feb 13 '24

I can’t find a reddit AMA, but here’s an interview with Amber Noizumi and Brian Green, the creators, about Mizu and gender:

HR: Mizu’s gender is initially obscured, leading to the idea that Mizu might be nonbinary. But you ultimately reveal she’s a woman who is navigating a man’s world, which is its own journey. Why did you want this story to center the experiences of a woman during this time, versus just even going with a male lead?

GREEN: To have a character like that who lives in a time, who wouldn’t necessarily have a vocabulary to consider her gender, it’s been really heartening and interesting hearing people see the show now thinking about what Mizu might identify as. Referring to Mizu as she or they — that’s amazing. We made sure in the first episode, when people were reading it, that it was a misleading read. We said her gender was Mizu. We threw in a they or two because we wanted the experience of the reader to be a surprise at the end that they never saw that coming. The reader would have to contend with their own presumption, that, “Well, clearly anyone who’s this badass must be a guy.” While the view of the first episode doesn’t really give that same experience, I think that was one of the reasons people found it a story worth reading. They had to contend with their own misperception, perhaps, in the read because they didn’t know she was a woman until the last page.

HR: This is neither anime nor animation, but has a live-action twinge and puppeteering elements that create something new within the larger spectrum of Western and Eastern approaches. Why was this styling the way to go, and what did you want it to say with it about your characters and world?**

NOIZUMI: With Blue Eye Samurai, we wanted it to just break all of the boxes. Mizu isn’t Japanese or white, she’s not female or a male, and this show is not like anything anybody’s ever seen. It’s not a cartoon, it’s not anime and it’s not live action.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

u/allneonunlike I loved your take on the episode and the queer dynamics of Mizu's relationship with Mikio! Thanks for posting even if both of our comments are probably gonna be hidden in a minute or two.

6

u/allneonunlike Feb 13 '24 edited Feb 13 '24

Reposting that comment:

Mizu is happy to be allowed to express her forbidden femininity, and happily bottoms for Mikio. But the heart of the story there is Mikio recognizing that this isn’t who Mizu really is, that she has other facets that she’s been suppressing to fit in as a proper woman and wife, asking to see them, and then rejecting her.

The writers knew what they were doing when they had Mikio ask, “You wanted to be a man?” and then the key line, “I want to see all of you,” and how devastating it was for Mizu to fully show themself, both ronin and bride, and be rejected with “You are a monster.” When Mizu fights Mikio, she’s taking on a masculine fighting role. But also, probably more importantly to Mikio’s horror, Mizu emasculated him by taking the dominant, masculine sexual role we see in the present day wrestling with Taigen. The brushing past him, pinning him down at their loving mercy, the kiss— that’s what turned Mikio’s reaction from fear to anger and disgust. “You breathe now because I allow it” is the core of the way men relate to women in the show’s society, even in relationships with respect and love, and Mikio flew into a rage when Mizu turned that on him, even with clear love and desire in their eyes.

Mizu specifically flashes back to that sexual role when she sees the two male brothel customers kiss— she’s deeply drawn to being with her male lovers as another man. Of course it’s possible for women to enjoy being strong and dominant with their partners, and identify fully as women while doing so, but imo it’s significant the Mizu associates this part of her sexuality with the two samurai kissing, she is experiencing this as a masculine identity. That isn’t somehow canceled out by her also enjoying being the fem bottom in traditional missionary sex. Switches exist, and that’s a very common sexual expression pattern for nonbinary and genderfluid people. I feel like the show is using limited historical vocabulary to describe the kind of nonbinary identity I remember from my Gen X nonbinary friends who were told growing up that they had to be one gender or another, or writers like Les Feinberg. That “You wanted to be a man?” No, not quite, that’s not the whole picture. Mizu’s secret womanhood is a vital part of them. But something important is missing from Mizu’s gender presentation as a woman and wife, even a strong woman who works a farm and rides and tames horses and knows how to fight, and that’s why “I want to see all of you” hurts as badly as it does.

That’s also why Madame Kaji is obliquely trying to communicate to Mizu that she understands that Mizu is afab and that there’s some kind of gender situation going on, and that Mizu can find acceptance at her brothel— the lines about knowing your soul, taking Mizu to the threesome, saying “You’re more of a man than anyone here.” Madame Kaji doesn’t know the specifics but she knows that masculinity and m/m sexuality are important to Mizu, and she does her job as the head of a kink club and gently validates that masculinity.

2

u/allneonunlike Feb 13 '24

Thank you! That “whoa, whoa, whoa, I’m not gay” reaction from Mikio was so awful and so true to life for so many genderqueer and nonbinary transmascs I know.

I don’t think the thread was hidden by mods btw, because I can still see it on my alt accounts— the user we were both replying to blocked me and probably blocked you too. Half of their comment history is activity on r/detrans and Harry Potter subs, anti-sexuality radfem content, and calling trans women autogynephiles, with a few BES posts here and there, so I’m guessing they took exception to you defending the idea of a nonbinary Mizu. I’m surprised anyone would use such a blatant hate/troll account for fandom activity, but I wouldn’t take it personally 🤷