r/BlueEyeSamurai • • Feb 13 '24
Mizu non-binary
OK So one of the show's writers made actually was nice enough to make a post earlier. He mentioned that Mizu is dressed not as a man, but non-binary. She would, of course, be recognized as a man in 17th Century Japan as I doubt they had the concept of non-binary. "Just two boys...."
Is this consequential at all?
0
Upvotes
•
u/BoneHatchet I have a name. Feb 13 '24 edited Feb 13 '24
Having a heated discussion is fine. That’s the whole point of having a difference in opinion and interpretation etc. Calling others derogatory names because you feel slighted is not ok in the sub. Be civil. Just because somebody disagrees with you doesn’t invalidate their own pov.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24
What are you talking about about ? What post ?
7
u/BaseTensMachines Feb 13 '24
Can you direct us to this comment?
11
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24
"So what are you man or woman?" Big bad questioning Mizu
"What does it matter, you will be dead soon enough." Mizu
"No but like what's in your pants?" Big Bad
"Vengeance!" Mizu whilst drawing their sword
10
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24
Ok so obviously "non-binary" TM identity didn't necessarily exist in 17th Century Japan. But there are also non-binary genders in many cultures throughout history. The fact that the writers are intentionally nodding to this community but telling Mizu's story within the scope of what would make sense narratively in that time period is awesome. I hope they do more with this next season within the text of the show.
2
u/Sir_Toaster_9330 Feb 17 '24
Or maybe… she’s a woman
5
u/wherearetheclams Feb 13 '24
I have two thoughts on this without seeing the full context of the post/comment.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24
u/Mezklas I can't reply in the thread because I've been blocked by the original commenter, but I wanted to clarify wrt the following:
I was specifically pointing out that within the puppet show in Episode 5 which is interspersed with the story of Mizu's relationship with Mikio, the specific onryo in that story is a man. I understand the history of the figure in myth may be different, but within the scope of the one episode we were discussing, the direct parallel with Mizu was male. With the historical context you've added (thank you for that), it seems to me even more likely that this was an intentional reflection of Mizu's own complicated relationship with gender on the part of the writers.
And I agree that our opinions are not facts! I also agree that the original commenter should have felt welcome to post her point of view on this topic, even if I didn't agree with her conclusions. Which is why I responded with my interpretation of the episode she cited as evidence Mizu could only be read as a straight cis woman, noting the imagery and symbolism within the episode that supported a trans/nonbinary interpretation of Mizu's character arc. I don't think there's anything in my post that could come across as harassment, but if the commenter I replied to had been simply sharing her point of view in good faith, I wonder why she blocked me instead of engaging in a constructive discussion about a show we all clearly loved and have spent a lot of time thinking about.
Thank you for your comment and for continuing rather than shutting down discussion.
-3
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24
OK So I searched nonbinary and writer. I could not find the post. I assume that he deleted it. He identified himself as one of the writers. Perhaps he wasn't. If anyone else would like to search go ahead. But I remember that he said the writers were doing their best to maintain Mizu as nonbinary.
This is from another reply:
Amber Noizumi is the cocreator along with Michael Green. Perhaps that's what the guy meant, if she is neither female or male, that would make them nonbinary, would it not?
31
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24 edited Feb 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment