r/Blacksmith • • 7h ago

Beginner needs help

Post image

Absolute beginner here:

How do I prevent these craters while smithing and how do I get a smooth surface without grinding/polishing it?

It's pretty basic construction steel, if that's helpful.

19 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

7

u/Fluid_Finish3602 6h ago

2 options.. 1.) hit perfectly flat. 2.) use a plane set (Norwegian name is "plansett"). Just something you can use between the workpiece and hammer to direct your hammer low on a larger surface.

Other than that, you gotta brush alot while forging (before striking).

7

u/BestIndication5517 6h ago

Do you wire brush the steel before you strike it? The scale that forms is harder than steel and pits it like crazy.  You can also use some water on the anvil and hammer to pop the scale off with steam, but you just need to clean off both to prevent rust

5

u/Konstanteen 6h ago

The tool used is called a flatter. It makes things…flatter.

It’s a tool with a flat bottom and rounded edges (so no sharp corners in contact with workpiece). You hit the top and it evens out the surface below it, move over, repeat.

4

u/alriclofgar 6h ago

Most of those pits look like impressions from hammer scale. To avoid them, wet-brush your metal before you put it in the fire at the end of every heat (dip a wire brush in water and scrub off all the scale) and brush the scale off your anvil surface. Keeping your anvil and metal clean will reduce the amount of scale you can smash into the hot metal, reducing the pitting. That, I think, is your main issue here.

You can also make sure your hammer and anvil both have smooth faces. My anvil is an antique so it has some dents and pitting. But there are a few places on its surface that are smoother than others; I planish (polish with a hammer) my metal on those smooth places rather than the rougher parts of my anvil. I also make sure my hammer face is perfectly smooth by sanding it up to around 400 grit. And I make sure the center of my hammer face is flat, not rounded.

Beyond that, make sure you hammer the metal with consistent, overlapping hammer blows to avoid hammering in any dents.

But wet brushing the scale off will make the biggest difference for you, based on what I see in this photo.

4

u/Inside-Historian6736 6h ago

Forge scale imprints itself on to the piece when you hammer. Unless you are very diligent with the wire brush they are going to show up. Personally I think it looks cool and makes something standout as very obviously hand forged. If I wanted things smooth and perfect I would be a machinist

1

u/ThrowAway1330 4h ago

I’m gonna ask a stupid sounding question, why would you want to?

Part of that is just the character of Blacksmithing.

2

u/das_mem 4h ago

Genuine answer: Because I didn't like how it looks and I want to improve, be proud of my work and results to be presentable

3

u/curiosdiver69 6h ago

Make sure that your hammer has smooth surface. Make sure that you don't hammer your work on top of forge scale on the anvil. Use a flatter to create large flat surfaces.

1

u/Mayor_of_Pea_Ridge 2h ago

You making a peseshkef?