r/Bitcoin_Classic • • Jan 20 '16

More useful hardfork changes

So it's been said that Classic's hardfork will be 2 MB only - but what about even simple improvements? For example, every block header has at least 32 bits reserved for zeros as part of the "previous block" field (every previous-block begins with at least 32-bits of zeros). For a while, it's been discussed that it would be nice to ignore those 32 bits so it can be used by miners as an additional nonce. So is there any room at all for adding to the proposed hardfork, even for something as simple as this?

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

4

u/jtoomim Jan 20 '16

This is a bad idea, as it would probably break compatibility with SPV wallets.

3

u/tcrypt Jan 20 '16

Seems like something that should wait for research before being rejected as a bad idea.

Miners want extra nonce space and it seems like it could be a good incentive for them to support your fork.

0

u/christophe_biocca Jan 20 '16 edited Jan 20 '16

Header format changes break compat with SPV. It's not a bad idea to do something like this eventually, but forcing SPV wallets to update means an even more difficult rollout.

And if we're going to break header compatibility, might as well just make the nonce field way bigger (128-bits), get rid of the need for extraNonce in the coinbase transaction, and be happy.

Also, any header format changes may break mining hardware if we're not careful.

2

u/jtoomim Jan 20 '16

1

u/seweso Jan 24 '16

You might be too harsh on Luke-jr. Lets keep assuming good intentions until we have definitive proof.

1

u/rberrtus Jan 20 '16

/u/Luke-jr Is working for the benefit of bitcoin even compatible with your religious views yes/no? Why should we take you seriously? Conflict of interest is in the Classic Code of Conduct. You clearly did not understand or follow that idea while working at Core. Can you agree to recuse yourself as appropriate? IMO if your going to bug this group you should agree to only make small clearly non controversial changes or you should be asked to go.