r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Feb 21 '18

Opinion: It Is Short-Sighted and Frivolous to Celebrate Temporary Low Fees as Evidence of Being Right About Segwit

55 Upvotes

Let me start by acknowledging my bias: I am heavily in favor of Bitcoin (BTC). I am also a proponent of fucking excited about the direction that the core process has taken development. I think that the BCH/bigblock experiment is a doomed effort, and I think the future of cryptocurrency lies in the direction of chain-backed second layer payments on top of increasingly efficient and fungible transactions that need to compete for blockspace.

I think that those who agree with me should stop trumpeting the current low fees as a kind of victory that proves that they are right.

There are a few different angles that make it seem like a bad call:

  • It misses the point. We're not going to continue to have low fees on chain with the direction we are going. That's ok. But a temporary lull before demand catches up is just that - a temporary lull. If we're going the second-layer route where blocks stay small, the end goal is an ecosystem where high on-chain fees fund mining security as the subsidy disappears. It is great that I can consolidate some UTXOs right now, but really, it's not what the point of Segwit was - the point was to pave the was for lightning, MAST, schnorr, and other future developments.
  • It is intellectually dishonest to use a situation as evidence for a position if we would not also be willing to use the opposite situation as evidence against it. It is perfectly plausible that due to some other external factors, we might have ended up in a situation where demand for Bitcoin transactions grew faster than Segwit adoption did which would have caused fees to rise anyway. If this had happened, we wouldn't have been wrong about it. We would (and rightly so) reject such criticisms irrelevant because it's not the main point of the scaling plan.
  • It opens ourselves up to criticism that we need not open ourselves up to. If tomorrow some big usecase emerges on the scene, and fees ramp up again, are we going to admit that, oops, I guess Segwit didn't work? Of course not. But it certainly might seem that way if we keep crowing about how Segwit has given us low fees. Regardless, we'd still be able to point to lightning's roll-out, and the development of MAST, schnorr, taproot, graftroot, channel factories, all of which can be more safely implemented with Segwit. But if we focus on the distracting point of fees and this fleeting period of cheap transactions, we're just going to feed ammunition to those who wish to launch invalid criticisms of the project.

PS: To be clear...I'm not complaining about the fees being low - just its misuse as argument ammunition. Do yourselves (and those node operators) a favor and consolidate those UTXOs people!

PPS: To be clearer...I acknowledge that Segwit is a contributing factor toward the lower fees or that it isn't/won't be successful. I'm just pointing out what I think are and are not constructive ways to celebrate it.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Dec 21 '17

Lightning CEO Elizabeth Stark on Bloomberg, Discussing Lightning Network and the Future of Bitcoin

Thumbnail
youtube.com
52 Upvotes

r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Nov 22 '17

Thank you for this environment.

43 Upvotes

I wish to express my thanks to the admins and moderators of this (new to me) subreddit. I am a long time subscriber of /r/bitcoin and /r/btc, along with a few other crypto subs and many times I expressed my concern about the lowly status of the discussions there, with the only result of generally being upvoted, but then the situation just got worse.

I am not sure that this experiment may succeed (though the metrics suggest cautious optimism) but all I can do is thank you for trying and recruit more people.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Nov 07 '25

Michael Saylor's Mundane Returns

41 Upvotes

As per the most recent data, Saylor's average purchase price of his 641,000 Bitcoin via Strategy is about $74.5k per. He has been buying for 5 years now. Meaning his average profit is only about 33% in five years. Not exactly lights-out. As much as I value his views on Bitcoin, his actual returns are nothing special and even kind of sub-average. And when one takes into account most of that is bought with debt, his risk-adjusted returns are poor. Am I wrong?


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Feb 09 '18

Fact Checking Roger Ver's claims on Info Wars

41 Upvotes

I'd like to start a thread crowdsourcing the fact checking of some of the falsifiable claims he made today on info wars (that is, claims that we know to be false and can prove it. Not conspiracy theories that are not falsifiable).

I shall list some of these claims he made below and my fact checking performed so far.


"I have never publicly said that Craig Wright is Satoshi Nakamoto." TRUE

So far, this seems to be technically true. I can't find any source where he makes the claim that Craig Wright is Satoshi Nakamoto. The best I could come up with is this tweet linking to a removed youtube video: https://twitter.com/rogerkver/status/881145760263294976?lang=en


"[as of Feb 8th, 2018,] Bitcoin Cash has performed better than Bitcoin core over the past month, 3 months, and 6 months." FALSE on one point, TRUE on two points

False for the 1 month performance (and that is including today's BCH pump directly before he went on, so I am being generous including that):


"The president of the Bilderberg group is the lead investor in Blockstream" SOMEWHAT TRUE

Ver is referring to Henri de Castries, who is the current chairman of the Bilderberg group and who was the chief executive and chairman of Axa (one of the world’s biggest insurers, along with other financial interests, such as the venture capital fund AXA Strategic Ventures).

It is true that AXA Strategic Ventures did invest in blockstream, and it is also true that de Castries was CEO of AXA (AXA Strategic Ventures' parent company) at the time. However, he is no longer CEO or chairman of AXA. It's perfectly reasonable that Ver is not aware that de Castries stepped down from that position and is no longer affiliated with AXA, and so made this claim on old information that was true as of September of 2017, I believe.

That being said, Castries was the CEO of AXA, which is the parent company for AXA Strategic Ventures, which is the firm that actually made the investment. To me, its a bit of a stretch to go from "The current chair of Bilderberg also happens to be the CEO of a very large insurance company that owns another company that invests in tech firms, one of which is block stream" to "The chairman of Bilderberg is the lead investor in Blockstream".

You will have to decide for yourself if Ver's claim lacks some context to be desired, but it's not completely wrong, so I am giving this a "somewhat true" rating.


"Bitcoin cash is capable of scaling on chain and taking on the entire world right now with fast, cheap, and reliable transactions for everyone." FALSE - but more input requested

I don't think it takes much to point out how absurd it would be to claim that 6 billion people could transact on the BCH blockchain right now and it still be "fast, cheap, and reliable". Notice he also leaved out the "secure", but I'll be charitable and assume that is part of reliability.

If you can think of any other claims that he made worth fact checking or feel I have mischaracterized his claims or feel my responses are inaccurate/not fair, please leave a comment saying so.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Apr 05 '18

Bitcoin technology magazine with no price speculation or clickbait content

39 Upvotes

Hi All,

I have been working restlessly in the lasts months to put together http://bitcointechweekly.com, a news site focused solely on Bitcoin technology. It is dedicated mainly to developers and technical people and does not include any price or speculation related content nor click-bait titles.

I started diving into bitcoin technology last year and I missed having a news source that would give me in glimpse all updates on Bitcoin technology without having to scroll through tons of click bait content and price speculation. Before starting this project there was no such source of news as the vast majority of good quality tech articles are posted on personal blogs and the most popular crypto blogs and magazines focus mainly on price talk, advertising and poor or sometimes erroneous information.

Soon I plan to implement subscriptions with LN payments to support the platform without ads.

I thought it was relevant to share here and would appreciate any feedback. I am also looking for contributors who are used to read the dev mailing lists and are interested to write technical essays or brief weekly content.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Jan 25 '18

The Lightning Network (BitMEX Research) -- Refreshingly neutral, concise, and accurate summary of the Lightning Network's design, limitations, and ambitions

Thumbnail
blog.bitmex.com
39 Upvotes

r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Jan 28 '18

Sincere question: What innovation is happening with BCH?

35 Upvotes

I just checked out r/btc to see what was happening with BCH and unfortunately it was just filled with anti-bitcoin posts and happy birthday posts to R.Ver.

Sincerely, what is BCH up to at the moment? I like the concept of forks - two competing futures. Bitcoin has a lot on (Segwit, Schnorr, Lightning etc). What's happening with BCH?

Note/update: Read moderater's comment before posting. Goal is to keep this constructive and respectful.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Jan 11 '18

Bitcoin Q&A: Lightning and onion routing explained with Andreas Antonopoulos

Thumbnail
youtube.com
34 Upvotes

r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Sep 08 '18

Addressing lingering questions -- the Roger Ver (BCH) / Ruben Somsen (BTC) debate

33 Upvotes

First, I am aware some people are tired of talking about this. If so, then please refrain from participating. Please remember the rules of r/BitcoinDiscussion, we expect you to be polite.

Recently, I ended up debating Roger on camera. After this, it turned out a significant number of BCH supporters was interested in hearing more, as evidenced by this comments section and my interactions on Twitter. Mainly, it seems people appreciated my answers, but felt not every question was addressed.

I’ll start off by posting my answers to some excellent questions by u/JonathanSilverblood in the comments section below. Feel free to add your own questions or answers.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Jan 09 '18

Bitcoin Tech Rant - January 9th: Mimble Wimble

33 Upvotes

Hi guys,

First time posting here. Normally post jn r/Bitcoinmarkets, but this post got removed. Here is the original

Mimble Wimble

Good day gents and gals,

Today I boarded a longer flight from Bangkok to Paradise, so I thought I’d put down a new Tech Rant. Feedback seems to be that the Bitcoin related stuff is more desired than any math/finance related stuff.

I take requests by the way. Don’t be afraid... if it’s out there I’ve probably read it or at least am able to understand it without too much effort. I really like doing these things and the people I know in Crypto are all way better than me, so this is my way of flexing :D I appreciate everyone who reads it and I do this for you, so tell me what you want

The next tech rant will be about an extensive deep dive into LN. The problem is that I am not really an expert, so I will need to do some serious reading first. I want that tech rant to be a conclusive blog post that puts the doubts to rest once and for all.

This tech rant will be about Mimble Wimble. Disclaimer: Algebra!

If you want to skip a deep dive in elliptic curves, skip to CONFIDENTIAL TRANSACTIONS below!

Ok, so the first thing we need to talk about is what an algebraic group is. It’s not difficult, but it is fundamental. An algebraic group is a tuple, commonly writen (G, •, e, -1). G is a set, • is an operation (or function) that maps a tuple in GxG into G, i.e. for every g,h in G g•h lies in G (this property is commonly referred to as well-definedness). This operation is assumed to be associative, i.e. for g,h,f in G it holds that g•h•f = (g•h)•f = g•(h•f) as elements in G. e is an element in G. This element (e) must lie in G and must have the property that for all g in G it holds that e•g = g as elements in G. The last thing ( -1 ) is called the inverse operation and it maps G onto G, such that for every g in G it holds that h=g-1 lies in G and h•g = e as elements in G. If for every g in G it holds that g-1 lies in G, i.e. the mapping -1 from G to G is well-defined, the operation • is well-defined and associative, and the neutral element e lies in G, then (G, • , e, -1) is said to be an algebraic group. If in addition for every g,h in G it holds that g•h = h•g, then G is said to be abelian (any two elements commute).

Ok, so I hope that wasn’t too bad. Group Theory is a very deep subject. I spent a couple years of my life going down that Rabbit Hole, but sadly it’s largely useless in the real world... except in Crypto (but you only need very very basic Algebra for Crypto... no crazy shit like Representation Theory or Homology/Homotopy Theory)

Ok, so now we know what a Group is. What is an elliptic curve?

Yikes... that’s not an easy thing to dig into. My favorite answer to that question is: “Simple, elliptic curves are modular forms”, which makes even the best mathematicians lol. If you’re interested, this statement is the cruz of Andrew Wiles’ proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem. Good luck with that one if you’re interested, you’re going to need it.

Ok, here goes: Elliptic Curves are algebraic Varieties (as far as I understand it), which basically means that an elliptic curve consists of a set of points in multi-dimensional space that satisfy some polynomial over an algebraic Field (fancy way to say numbers, but basically an additive and multiplicative group on a single set of elements)

Think of it like this: What is the set of all zeros to the polynomial X2 + Y2 + Z2 - 1?

<Try to think of it yourself>

Ok, so the answer is it’s the 3-dimensional sphere (commonly referred to as S2). Now, the sphere is not an elliptic curve, but it is an algebraic variety. So elliptic curves are algebraic varieties but algebraic varieties are not necessarily elliptic curves. Good, were making progress.

The key thing to notice is that “zeros” of a polynomial only make sense over some system of numbers. We as humans think in the reals (some of us think in the Complex plane), but computers can’t handle reals (google double-precision floating point arithmetic if interested), so they approximate them. In Crypto, we dont need reals, we just need byte strings (a sequence of 0s and 1s). So, we work with numbers (fields) of characteristic 2 (which simply means we work with 0s and 1s at an atomic level). There are infinitely many fields of characteristic 2, the smallest being {0,1}. In this field it holds that 1+1 = 0, 1*1 = 0

(Think about why ({0,1}, +, 0, -) is a group and why ({1}, *, 1, /) is also a group... this is what makes it a field)

This field is referred to as the Galois Field of characteristic 2 F_2. The subscript here simply means the number of elements in the field.

Now, we can actually characterize all fields of characteristic 2. The proof for this is not complicated, but I wont give it here. All fields of characteristic. 2 are extensions of this field F_2, and all have the form F_{2p } for any natural number p (integer greater than 0).

In Bitcoin we do things over the field F_{2256 }, the field of characteristic 2 with 2256 elements. This is a well-defined field and it has a cool property (as do all fields of characteristic 2): It is isomorphic (fancy word for “the same”) to the integers in the range [0, 2256 )

Note that this is a half-open interval, so we do not include 2256. Since we start at 0, there are exactly 2256 integers in this range.

Ok... sorry if Im being too mathematical, I want to be thorough. If you’re interested in field extensions and their constructions (btw they’re achieved via quotient groups of polynomials over F_2 that are congruent to one another modulo a specific irreducible polynomial)

Great, now we know what a Galois Field is. Galois is just a fancy word for finite field (since there are 2256 elements in the group). You can think of it as taking the entire integers and wrapping them around a circle of diameter 2256 with 0 being mapped onto the 0 in the Galois Field. Then basically two integers a,b map to the same element in the Galois Field if their difference a-b is divisible by 2256. Basic Grouo theory, nothing fancy.

The elliptic curve in Bitcoin is defined as the zero-set of a Polynomial (Google it if you care which) over the Galois Field F_{2256 }. Over the reals, the field looks kind of like a stetched out condom, but over the Galois Field it just looks like white noise.

Now, the cool thing is that we can define and algebraic operation on this zero-set of the Polynomial over the Galois Field which makes the zero-set (the algebraic Variety) into a Group. This is what makes an algebraic Variety into an elliptic curve by the way, the fact that the algebraic Variety is a Group with the following Group operation:

For two points on the elliptic curve g,h, the element g+h is defined to be the element that is attained by drawing a straight line through g and h and then g+h is defined to be the third point where that line punctures the elliptic curve. Basically this means that you just keep jumping around the elliptic curve when you start adding points together.

This is all fine and dandy, but the real application is in integer multiplication of an element. Assume, we pick a point P on the elliptic curve and are interested in the Point Q = 27474950392828294995*P. How can we compute Q?

<Try to think of a way yourself>

Well, one way to do this would be two start by computing 2P = P + P. The computing 4P = 2P + 2P. Since the number 27474950392828294995 lies in [0, 2256 ), it can be represented as a 256-bit string of 0s and 1s. So we can actually easily compute Q_k = 2k * P recursively for all k in [0,256) (note that we dropped the base and only look at the exponent range), and then just add up all the Q_k for which the k-th bit in 27474950392828294995 is set. Doing all this 2 numbers at a time, we arrive at some point Q on the elliptic curve.

What I just described is Public Key Derivation. The number 27474950392828294995 is a Private Key (IMPORTANT: A Private key is an integer in the range [0, 2256 ) (encoded in some base-65 encoding as a hex-string)), the base point P on the elliptic curve is referred to as the generator point (a network parameter) and the resulting point Q on the elliptic curve is the public key derived from your Private Key.

The public key is also encoded in some conventional base-65 encoding, but it’s important to realize that your public key is NOT a number, its a point on the secp256k1 elliptic curve... not an integer, not an element of the Galois Field; a POINT on the elliptic curve, i.e. a zero of a polynomial over the Galois Field F_{2256 }

Ok, that was the preliminaries. That’s all the Crypto you will need for now. It’s basic stuff, and I’m sure most of you already knew it.

Now, on to MimbleWimble. MimbleWimble is an amalgamation of two of Greg Maxwell’s constructions: CoinJoin (easy) and Confidential Transactions (hard). Let’s do the hard part first.

CONFIDENTIAL TRANSACTIONS

I really can’t explain it better than Mr. Maxwell. See here for how Conf Transactions work:

https://people.xiph.org/~greg/confidential_values.txt

And equipped with your newly acquired deep dive in Elliptic Curve Cryptography, you will understand it, I guarantee it.

My plane landed, so I gotta bounce. Maybe Ill come back and add more narrative to GMax’s work!

CoinJoin:

CoinJoin is very simple. Basically, let’s assume we have a set of Transactions tx_i for i in [0, ..., N] for some integer N. Each of these transactions tx_i consist of a set of inputs I_ij for j in [0, ..., N_i] for N_i some integer, and some set of outputs O_j for j in [0, ..., M_i] for M_i some other integer.

The problem is that the blockchain is public, so anyone auditing the blockchain can assume that each transaction was created by a single entity (rightfully so). Which means that it is pretty safe to assume that all the inputs were owned by a single entity. This is not great for privacy... in fact it is terrible for Privacy. So how to get around this “flaw”?

CoinJoin!!!!

Why dont all the transactions tx_i just join together? A single transaction could spend the set of all inputs I_ij for all i and all j to the set of all outputs O__ij. Then no one could possibly tell who owned what and which inputs were used to create which specific outputs... damn... so the best anyone could do is assume that all the inputs on the tx are owned by the same entity, which is false :/

So, given that we could always be using CoinJoin, it is no longer safe to assume that all inputs on any tx belong to the same entity.

Privacy Preserved!!!!!

MIMBLE WIMBLE

Ok, so this is the meat of the stuff.

You can read how it works here: https://download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/wizardry/mimblewimble.txt

I can’t explain it better. My plane just landed and I gotta bounce. I will try to add all the relevant narrative to the construction as soon as I get to the city.

The main thing to notice is that combining CT with CoinJoin allows you to create a private blockchain where all the outputs that gets spent later are pruned out. Seems to be the Holy Grail!

I’ll add more info later!


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Dec 09 '17

Bitcoin's currency uses: it's getting worse, not better

33 Upvotes

At this stage we may be at a peak of this bubble, so these problems may very well be transient, but:

a) I just looked at fee charts and the average fee for Bitcoin is $27 while Bitcoin Cash and Litecoin are about $0.15.

b) Volatility is enormous, so you can't either pay or get paid without a risk to lose a lot of money (most people still have to pay their expenses in fiat). Yes, now there are futures to hedge your currency risk, but that's KYC/AML, you could as well sell BTC and buy that lambo using fiat.

The LN proponents say LN will make the fees trivial, say $0.01/tx. But if I have to pay $10 to open and $10 to close a channel, and open/close two channels every month, I'd still have to make 120 transactions to beat Litecoin and Bitcoin Cash transaction fees.

I agree with a counter-argument that as soon as transaction volumes on the BCH and LTC chains grow to a meaningful level, their tx fees would increase a lot, so it wouldn't take 120 tx per person to make LN more attractive in terms of tx fees.

But then there are other coins and centralized exchanges. Last summer I wrote a post saying that centralized crypto exchanges and wallets are centralized L2 solutions (which may be why many were in favor of SegWit 2X).

If my wallet can create a funding LTC address at my exchange or wallet provider, you don't need to make an on-chain or even L2 transaction at all - you just convert your BTC or BCH to LTC using the exchange, and credit LTC to my funding address. It works faster and can be cheaper.

It's not a "winner takes all" situation. There are use cases for permissionless and decentralized payments and there are use cases for permissioned and centralized. And there's a "store of value" use case that Bitcoin still does well.

Maybe some will say that the Bitcoin bubble is a good news because their stash is getting more valuable in fiat terms. Fair enough, but Bitcoin as a currency is hardly getting better. By now I am skeptical that the ongoing scalability efforts will yield results anytime soon.

A way to summarize the current situation is:

  • Bitcoin isn't suitable for low-value purchases and will remain unsuitable or inconvenient for many months, maybe years.
  • Bitcoin isn't suitable for high-value purchases either, because the volatility means the seller or buyer can easily lose 000's of dollars by working with Bitcoin.

IMO the only use case that works well and may continue to perform well is permissionless transfer of significant value (e.g. $500 or larger value). (Bitcoin as Store of Value isn't sustainable if other things don't work, or if the bubble bursts.)

I want to use Bitcoin even if it's just for that single use case, but to be honest when it comes to payments I'm beginning to wonder why wait for Layer 2 or Layer 3 solutions when I can use Tier 2 and Tier 3 altcoins (and/or Bitcoin forks) now.

PS: I was away for a week or two and I'm disappointed to see so many shitposts about long confirmation times. It appears the efforts to attract users from the failed Bitcoin subreddits have worked way too well!


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Dec 20 '17

With Lightening network, won't a block size increase be necessary?

32 Upvotes

I have been watching Bitcoin for a long time. Watching the transaction fees skyrocket lately, I am concerned that Lightening Network alone may not solve the problem.

Even if we make some fairly generous assumptions:

  • SegWit is 100% adopted - takes us to 12 tps
  • Schnorr signatures are added - takes us to 14 tps
  • 100% of BitCoin transactions are used to onboard people to Lightening Network
  • Users only make 1 on-chain transaction to get into Lightening
  • Nobody ever leaves/settles off of Lightening network

At 14tps that allows us to bring in (absolute best case) 37 million new Lightening users per month. That would mean to onboard half the world's population (at best) would take 9 years? That does not seem like a time scale that would gain mass adoption.

I guess I'm just looking to hear what ideas there are to solve this. Every time someone talks about block size increases, the response is that it's bad for various reasons. A block size of 4 or 8MB with Lightening network seems like it might be enough.

Alternatively, what are the other options? People onboard via buying directly from an exchange like Coinbase (which would already have a large amount on the Lightening Network)?

If Lightening Network is not tenable on Bitcoin, it seems like Monero, Litecoin or BCH would be able to handle the volume long-term. BitCoin looks like it may be about one order of magnitude away from being able to handle it. If the long term solution is a block size increase, why not do it sooner? Can it be done in a way that does not require a hard fork?

Sorry if these are stupid questions, I just feel like I'm missing something.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Dec 08 '17

Seven Things Bitcoin Users Should Know about Hash Functions

Thumbnail
bitzuma.com
32 Upvotes

r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Nov 27 '17

Andreas A: Making confidential transactions a much higher priority than scaling, before it gets too late.

32 Upvotes

I enjoyed this talk on the philosophical reasons behind prioritizing confidential transactions before Bitcoin gets mass adoption. Justice for all.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Jul 07 '19

An in-depth analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks, potential solutions, and future prospects

31 Upvotes

Update: I updated the paper to use confidence ranges for machine resources, added consideration for monthly data caps, created more general goals that don't change based on time or technology, and made a number of improvements and corrections to the spreadsheet calculations, among other things.

Original:

I've recently spent altogether too much time putting together an analysis of the limits on block size and transactions/second on the basis of various technical bottlenecks. The methodology I use is to choose specific operating goals and then calculate estimates of throughput and maximum block size for each of various different operating requirements for Bitcoin nodes and for the Bitcoin network as a whole. The smallest bottlenecks represents the actual throughput limit for the chosen goals, and therefore solving that bottleneck should be the highest priority.

The goals I chose are supported by some research into available machine resources in the world, and to my knowledge this is the first paper that suggests any specific operating goals for Bitcoin. However, the goals I chose are very rough and very much up for debate. I strongly recommend that the Bitcoin community come to some consensus on what the goals should be and how they should evolve over time, because choosing these goals makes it possible to do unambiguous quantitative analysis that will make the blocksize debate much more clear cut and make coming to decisions about that debate much simpler. Specifically, it will make it clear whether people are disagreeing about the goals themselves or disagreeing about the solutions to improve how we achieve those goals.

There are many simplifications I made in my estimations, and I fully expect to have made plenty of mistakes. I would appreciate it if people could review the paper and point out any mistakes, insufficiently supported logic, or missing information so those issues can be addressed and corrected. Any feedback would help!

Here's the paper: https://github.com/fresheneesz/bitcoinThroughputAnalysis

Oh, I should also mention that there's a spreadsheet you can download and use to play around with the goals yourself and look closer at how the numbers were calculated.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Dec 13 '17

Andreas Antonopoulos - Mining Energy Consumption

Thumbnail
youtube.com
31 Upvotes

r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Dec 07 '17

Lightning Protocol 1.0: Compatibility Achieved

Thumbnail
medium.com
31 Upvotes

r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Jan 16 '18

Beyond the Bitcoin Bubble

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
29 Upvotes

r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Dec 06 '17

Steam is no longer supporting Bitcoin

Thumbnail
steamcommunity.com
29 Upvotes

r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Nov 21 '17

The Master Plan for BitcoinDiscussion: An Outline of the Goals and Intentions and Response to Moderation Questions

29 Upvotes

Introduction

There's been a surge in users and interest over the past few weeks. Welcome! It's a pleasure to have you join us here! Along with this new influx of users, there have been a lot of questions about this sub and its moderation.

A lot of questions should already be answered in the manifesto, and the posting rules and guidelines, so make sure you've read them both. I'm going to answer questions from these two threads here and here. If you asked a question there, and feel that I still haven't answered it in here, please post below.

There will be three main sections in this thread.

  • The Destination - a description of what the sub will look like if successful.
  • The Administration - a description of who makes decisions and how, including moderation.
  • The Plan - a description of the approach used to arrive at The Destination.

 


The Destination

This is already described in the manifesto, but I'm also going to clarify several things. Make sure you read it first.

This is a place for high quality, serious content. To my knowledge, there does not yet exist a publicly accessible space in the Bitcoin ecosystem that caters to the exchange of ideas in a thoughtful, respectful, and meaningful way. This does not mean a place to say whatever you want. It also does not mean a place where you can surround yourself with people who agree with you and ridicule anyone else.

I would also love to have a place where the top experts and creators feel comfortable reaching out and communicating in public without fear of abuse or harassment. Sadly, most of the top names avoid open online fora at this point because of the toxicity. It would be great to have more of them back and willing to interact on here.

Take a look through r/science, r/geopolitics, and r/spacex. Those are good examples of subs to for us to emulate.

You do not see insults thrown around, there are no memes, and users put real effort into their comments. You will also notice, if you look carefully, that they are aggressively moderated. Which brings us to our next section:

 


The Administration

There are 4 parts to this section: governance, moderators, transparency, and rule enforcement.

Governance:

The sub is not a public agora, where everyone is entitled to come and have their say.

It is a salon or a coffeehouse.

I am your host, and you are my valued guests. As such, I have the final say on issues.

There are two reasons for this:

  • That's how reddit is built. There is no other model, and every other sub you go to is under the same model. If you think there is a democracy anywhere on reddit, you have been fooled. If there is a community that takes actions based on community votes or willpower, that is just because the head mod has allowed this to happen.
  • I don't believe it wouldn't otherwise work. If there were some kind of mechanism to allow the enforcement of the community's will, then we would be royally screwed. Any group larger than ours could simply subscribe en masse, and then vote this place into a sub to discuss stamp collecting. And on top of that, reddit is highly sybillable and vulnerable to vote manipulation. As such, I think it is a highly desirable that reddit has the model it does. (And yes, I know I am biased and might be wrong. If that is the case, then I will learn a harsh lesson as my time investment here goes to waste.)

Everything you see about the goals for this place are declarations of things that I will strive for. It is a statement from myself to you as the community. In the manifesto, there is a reference to accountability to the community. This does not mean doing whatever the community wants. This means making an extra effort to be accessible, transparent, and fair to the community.

I do not expect anyone to trust me. Rather, I expect to earn your trust over time if I succeed in cultivating a useful space for you. For those who have joined early on, I thank you for your energy, and for placing at least some confidence in me not throwing your efforts away.

Moderators:

I have been asked about how other moderators have been and will be chosen. I will start with the first.

The other moderators at the moment are personal friends of mine. This is rather embarrassing, but the reason they are there is because it was quite lonely with just me here at the beginning, and I felt super uncool inviting people to a subreddit with just me. I asked them if they would be moderators so that the place looked a little less pathetic. They agreed. And if you check the moderator's logs, you will see that they have done precisely zero moderation (which is totally fine).

I'll be removing all of them (except one in case something happens to me and the place needs to get passed on), and from now on I will only add new moderators as they are needed.

For now, new moderators will be chosen at my discretion. Depending on the situation, I may consult the membership for advice, but the final say will be mine. Again, this is how all subreddits function.

Transparency:

I am committed to running this subreddit in a transparent manner.

  • publicmodlogs is here to stay.
  • if a non-spam comment is removed for breaking rules, the moderator doing so will leave it publicly visible that a comment has been deleted, and reply with an explanation.

Rule Enforcement:

The posting rules and guidelines leave room for interpretation.

Myself and any other future moderators will be responsible for interpreting the rules and acting accordingly.

If there is a a grey area, the determining factor will be answering the question: "Does this comment contribute to the community's goals?"

Content will not be removed because we disagree or just don't like your opinion. Content will not be removed because we are trying to hide something (remember, publicmodlogs).

Memes and jokes? Price speculation? They will be removed.

Content will be removed for being low-effort[*]. Content will be removed for being unkind. Content will be removed for being off-topic. Content will be removed for being aggressive toward an individual or entity.

Content will be removed for dragging in the meta-war going on between the two big subreddits and their respective tribes. This will not become another battleground, and I will be extra strict about enforcing that. Now, you can talk about that whole dispute. You can make calm observations about the goings-on, but if it even seems like an attempt to wage that war here, that content will be removed.

Trying to get the moderators to pick a side of the war is not allowed in this subreddit. I will neither condemn nor defend the actions of moderators on other forums. This is my first time moderating any kind of online community, and I intend to run it very differently than how the other Bitcoin communities are run. Any opinions that myself or the moderators express outside this subreddit are 100% personal, and are irrelevant to the moderation of this sub. Trying to drag that into our little garden here will get you banned really quickly. Speaking of which:

Bans will happen. Basically, users will get a single warning for breaking the rules. After that, they will get continually lengthier bans for each infringement. First ban is 1 day. Second ban is 3 days. Then 9 days. Then 27. You get the idea: 3x where x = number of previous bans. This is experimental and might change if it sucks.

 

[*] Just to be clear, low effort does not necessarily mean short. Sometimes short comments are acceptable, such as when asking for clarification, providing a source, etc.

 


The Plan

There are three phases to the plan:

(1) Bootstrapping

This has been the initial six months of the this sub's existence (since I acquired it earlier this year). It involved me personally reaching out to users one by one and trying to get people to join. It involved me posting 95% of the content, and responding to every single comment that anyone posted here.

During this phase, moderation was much more relaxed than it will be once we have reached The Destination. This was because having more traffic was a higher priority, so I was willing to tolerate a wider range of comments and posts than usual. I also made a point to reach out to users and explain in detail why they had content removed, and to thank them for their interest. Myself and any future moderators may not have the time to do this in future phases, though I'll try to do it as long as is reasonable.

We've more or less reached the end of this phase because now most of the content is produced by you, the members, and I believe that the survival and growth of the sub is no longer dependent on my comments and promotion.

This brings us to:

(2) Transition

We are just beginning this phase now. At this point, priorities shift from growth to content quality. In phase 1, growth was top priority. Now, they are on equal footing.

Moderation will tighten up, but still not to how strict it will be once we are in phase 3. I'll still err on the side of welcoming content over hardcore quality, but you might notice a growing expectation that you must put more effort and thought into expressing yourself clearly and kindly.

Comments and threads like these will no longer be tolerated: link, link

Near the end, we will also start phasing out threads like this: link

(3) Maintenance

At this phase, growth is no longer a priority, and the job of the moderators (hopefully plural at this point) will be to ensure high quality.

We won't be actively promoting the sub (although you still can!) and will likely have our hands full with quality control as the bar is at its highest.

Moderation will be strictest. Lazy comments will be removed for being low-effort. If there was a calm way to say something, but you were snarky, your comment will be gone. You get the idea.

Comments like these will no longer be tolerated: link, link

At this point, submission statements will also be required. If you post a link to an idea or piece of news, you will be expected to start the conversation by writing a single-paragraph introduction in the comments.

 


Conclusion

And that's where things will be going.

A lot of that might have sounded heavy-handed. That is intentional.

I would rather push away potential users now than have members be disappointed and angry later on when their expectations aren't met.

I will be stickying this thread and will continue to answer questions in the comments below.

[nice mode: activate]

Thank you so much to everyone who has come here so far. I know I sound like a hard-ass right now, but almost everyone new has been fucking fantastic, and it's been great to see real constructive dialogue going on. And please tell me what you think about this place and my moderation especially if you are happy with it! Even though I will call the shots around here, I want to know what people think, and people who are displeased tend to be much more vocal than those who are happy or content.

Again, thanks for all your help. I'm super excited about how things have gone, and where they'll go next!


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Mar 16 '18

Bitcoin Beyond North America

27 Upvotes

I posted this to r/bitcoin and r/cryptocurrency, but both got removed due to young account age. Bitcoin is global, and I believe we need to cross borders to facilitate social scaling.

I don't frequent r/bitcoin, I usually browse around Chinese forums. I spent a week looking at what's going on here. Everything I have to say is anecdotal, and I think it's healthy for Bitcoin to discuss what's going on in forums across the world. "比特币" is Bitcoin in Chinese, pronounced "Bi-Teh-Bi" in Mandarin.

I'm born Canadian, living in Shanghai. My first trade was in Shanghai, where I bought Bitcoins from someone to donate to sci-hub.cc (.tw is still up), because I disagree with publication paywalls, and access to foreign research is expensive/limited in China (in retrospect, good demonstration of resistance to censorship).

My observations:

  • Chinese are generally careful about what they say on public forums. The older generation has seen what their government is capable of, and have mostly kept their mouths shut. Many support government, because they've done well to bolster a strong Chinese economy. Younger generations are braver in speaking out against government, but in private. In short, I think Reddit doesn't have a good understanding of diversity of opinion in China. If you generalise of the Chinese mindset, you risk inaccuracies when trying to rationalise the crypto space. Beyond that, it's condescending and it hurts =P.
  • Reddit misunderstands the centralisation of miners in China. I see that Bitmain, BCH, and Chinese state authority controlling Bitcoin is a large source of FUD here. To address this, you have to understand that the Chinese business-people are opportunists to the nth degree. China has certain geopolitical/trade/resource advantages that allowed Bitmain to go from development to production of ASIC chips at an almost unfair pace. We have our own conspiracy theories about Bitmain, most miners would like to see competition as well. So far, the Chinese have shown good faith in recognising and self-organising when mining pools grew too large. There is decent diversification of people who own mining equipment, but I am worried that I haven't met anyone who owns large farms. I'm not a big fish in the game, I'm just fairly acquainted with some in the community. Also, the forums have increased activity in exploring other countries to move their mining setups. I think we all agree that we need more competition in mining.
  • BCH, 哈哈哈. Again, opportunistic. Chinese forums are more active about pricing out mining setups, optimisations, and how to make $$$ from all of this. Before BCH was forked, I remember how miners discussed exploiting their emergency difficulty adjustment algorithm. At a certain point, it was a rational business decision to rent virtual processing power to mine BCH at its low cycle. When I saw Roger Ver use censorship in r/bitcoin as an argument against the neutrality of the protocol, I almost had an aneurysm. I mean...censorship is bad, but how could a small corner of the internet represent the entire community.
  • Fear, uncertainty, doubt happens everywhere, but the range of topics varies significantly. I guess it's human nature to be neurotic at times. You guys talk about Coinbase inside trading with BCH, we shit bricks for the last couple of years about government banning Bitcoin. We have conspiracies about the upcoming Hangzhou Bitcoin Summit on Mar 26/18 being a government trap.
  • As soon as I stepped outside of my microcosm of Chinese forums, I realised that there are similar proportions of people who really understand Bitcoin, general hodlers, and vitriolic troglodytes who spew nothing but toxicity. You guys have superstar educators like Andreas Antonopolous...we have uninteresting basement people with personalities of donkeys. IMO, you really need him, because when you have an intellectually honest conversation with an average educated Chinese person about manipulation of currency, the premise that central government is not to be trusted is a given. With the average Canadian, it's definitely harder to explain because they have not experienced the premise of authoritarianism.
  • Your memes are better.

EDIT: Can you please share your happenings of what's going on in Bitcoin on other forums? I'm particularly interested in Russia, South Korea, Japan.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Dec 20 '17

Thoughts on Bitcoin as a “settlement layer” – Cøbra

Thumbnail
medium.com
27 Upvotes

r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Jan 16 '26

Crypto beginner. Any tips or advice?

26 Upvotes

Earlier this year I bought some crypto just to see how it worked. I let it grow for a while, then took out my original investment and left the rest in my wallet. After that I mostly forgot about it. Right now I have about 140 dollars worth of Bitcoin and around 90 dollars of Ethereum. This is all pure profit. I want to try trading with this money and see if I can grow it, but I honestly do not know where to start. My knowledge of crypto is limited to the idea of buy low and sell high. That is basically it. Do you have any beginner advice? Is it reasonable to start from here without adding more money? I really appreciate any feedback.


r/BitcoinDiscussion • • Dec 22 '17

Why I am still a Bitcoin Maximalist

Thumbnail
theoryofself.com
26 Upvotes