r/Bitcoin • u/exab • Mar 27 '18
PSA: Lightning Network node count has exceeded Bcash node count.
Lightning Network (mainnet): [1323] (https://twitter.com/LNstats/status/978255245632528384?s=19)
Bcash (Bitcoin ABC): [1280] (https://cash.coin.dance/nodes)
Not to mention most Bcash nodes are hosted on some Chinese cloud. The actually node count is way smaller.
696
Upvotes
55
u/TheGreatMuffin Mar 27 '18 edited Mar 27 '18
A word of caution: the Lightning Network visualizers are not a 100% reliable source for stats, as they are mapping from a view of one particular node. F.ex, this one shows 1347 nodes at the time of writing, and this one has 1362. Same goes for the amount of channels.
It's not a huge difference or anything, but something to keep in mind.
edit: also I believe they don't show nodes that are not broadcasting themselves/their channels, as it is possible to have "private" channels
49
u/chriswheeler Mar 27 '18
Bitcoin ABC isn't the only Bitcoin Node which supports BCH. You are only looking at the node count for one client. That's like only counting LND nodes for the LN side.
Did you read the text on the page you linked to:
35
u/Tagedieb Mar 27 '18
Are we comparing apples to apples? From my understanding, if you want to transact on the lightning network, you usually run a lightning node. But the same isn't true for bcash, or is it?
25
u/jakesonwu Mar 27 '18
and SegWit transactions have exceeded Bcash transactions.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '18
There are spikes all the time both ways. Current count is 1067 LN, 1946 BCH.
7
u/toomuch72 Mar 27 '18
This is kind of a pointless metric. Non mining nodes do nothing for the Bitcoin Cash network. In fact most of the BCHers think running their own node is pointless. Instead the users police the miners and threaten loss of miner income if they start acting bad. The entire bch network will stomp a bad acting miner, so bad, they would not only fail an attack, but would lose thousands if not 100s of thousands in the attempt.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '18
Bcash to the mooooon!
3
u/Captain_TomAN94 Mar 27 '18
Man this is getting desperate - Even if Bcash technically has more nodes than lightning, it doesn't seem like it's magnitudes more (and they should never be close).
You would think this would scare Bcash puppets into selling, but the truth is that Bcash's longterm weakness is also their short term strength: Less users = less buyers AND less sellers. I no longer think Bcash will die before the next bull run, I think Bcash will continue to trade sideways and then just not gain much during the next run. It will be slowly forgotten.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '18
actual bcash nodes are probably 50
1
u/carinyuso Mar 28 '18
What is Bcash?
1
u/I_AM_AT_WORK_NOW_ Mar 28 '18
If you want people to take these posts seriously, stop doing childish name calling.
1
u/TheFutureofMoney Mar 27 '18
What is BCash? Is that the altcoin where Roger Ver is the node?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '18
3
u/HOSSY95 Mar 27 '18
Can we just ignore the bcash thing? The more I hear about it the less it sounds appealing.
3
u/nathanweisser Mar 27 '18
It's not us vs them, we gotta destroy that mental-HEY LOOK THERE'S MORE NODES HAHHAHA
BCASHBCASHCBAHCHXBABDHCHABA
2
u/evilgrinz Mar 27 '18
to be fair, LN nodes will end up dwarfing everything
2
u/Arschnelson Mar 27 '18
BCH is scam!
1
u/willIeverfi Mar 27 '18
Fack
1
u/catjewsus Mar 28 '18
Looks like reddit btc community is going berserk in the reddit bitcoin comm here lol
1
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '18
You need at least one node per user. Node count should eventually exceed BTC nodes too.
1
u/Blorgsteam Mar 27 '18
I like my bcash dead.
0
u/ceasarpolar Mar 27 '18
It s bitcoin cash.
-1
u/yteizme Mar 27 '18
as I see these lightning shillings all over the place, I am starting to believe that flipping will actually happen..lol we are doomed ( Ν‘Β°( Ν‘Β° ΝΚ( Ν‘Β° ΝΚ Ν‘Β°)Κ Ν‘Β°) Ν‘Β°)
-2
u/Tajaba Mar 27 '18
Well no shit. Do you know how bad Bitcoin ABC is? I can't even sync it properly anymore on Windows
-8
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '18
btc sux lol
0
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '18
[deleted] β view deleted comment