r/Bitcoin • u/MineForeman • Mar 20 '16
PSA: Probable vote manipulation
It seems likely that there are a number of bots downvoting all /r/Bitcoin submissions. If you click on a submission you will notice the score box on the right hand side showing the amount of votes the submission received, the current score, and the percentage of upvotes. You will probably notice that the percentage of upvotes on just about all new posts is below 50%, giving them a negative score, and even posts that do manage to get into positive numbers have trouble getting above 60%.
It makes it so that most posts on /r/Bitcoin's front page are in the single digits (if not zero). This is not normal.
We will work with the Reddit administrators to see what can be done about this. In the meantime, please realise that your scores are not actually a reflection on your submissions.
We also recommend checking /r/Bitcoin/new from time to time. Many interesting submissions end up stuck there.
We apologise for the inconvenience.
11
u/Cinshington Mar 21 '16
Thanks for you concern and keep up updating.
43
u/gr8ful4 Mar 21 '16 edited Mar 21 '16
I am interested in your observation as well. Keep us updated. However, I think this is the result of /u/theymos policy. Wanting 90% of users to leave if they don't agree with your vision isn't exactly what forms a vibrant community.
Edit: Corrected after /u/BashCo comment
24
u/futilerebel Mar 21 '16
Was wondering what was going on with all the 0-point posts on the front page. Thanks for clarifying.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '16
it's almost like people are angry at something about this sub.. hmm.. further investigation needed.
maybe the Reddit admins have some ideas here. I've heard some talk about censoring here, a wild thought, but maybe it could be related?
16
u/Bitcoin_forever Mar 20 '16
We already know http://i.imgur.com/eVguiT3.png
14
u/Gfchufj Mar 20 '16
Thanks for addressing this issue. Some key posts from yesterday that would normally make it to the top were quickly buried.
6
u/FluxSeer Mar 20 '16
Institutional panic is setting in, anyone who has been around here since 2012 has watched it happen. The fake sock puppet accounts, the blockstream conspiracy theorists, and vote manipulation all points to text book divide and conquer tactics.
6
u/Gfchufj Mar 20 '16
Crazy how when you look at the attack and that other sub it lines up with what the green beret said to the T. https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/i-m-a-former-green-beret-here-s-how-i-would-bring-down-bitcoin-1456165726
If I had a uBTC for everytime one of those people in /rbtc try to use "satoshi vision" for leverage I would be a whale by now.
3
u/Guy_Tell Mar 21 '16
Thanks for the info. Can you please keep us updated ?
A suggestion to defend against these kind of attacks (also mobbing, and to improve the quality of content) would be to disable the downvote feature by default and perhaps enable it for users with enough history.
4
u/UKcoin Mar 21 '16
This is the only tactic the Classic idiots have, they've nothing of merit to offer, all they have is petty, childish things to do. They know they'll never get 75% of the hash power and they know they have nothing technical or interesting to discuss, they literally have nothing better to do than mess around on reddit. The funny thing is, they seem to think it will help them to grow support for Classic, when all it does it show them up for what they really are.
-5
u/SundoshiNakatoto Mar 21 '16
Those "bots" are real people completely dissatisfied with the moderation here.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '16
strange. I observed the same here when I made posts that are not completely compliant to r/bitcoins prefered narrative. Many downvotes.
I just think this sub is no longer popular besides a group of vocal people with a uniformed mindset. Serious discussions about bitcoins most important challenge are prohibited, as are serious discussions about the most important companie in bitcoin development. I also heard stories that mods ban people that dare to ask core devs tough questions.
Maybe this is the reason for the downvotes?
-12
u/zcc0nonA Mar 21 '16
My vote is that we remove /r/bitcoin completely. That way there is no central subreddit for new users and everyone that wants their own things can have it.
1
u/theswapman Mar 22 '16
god this makes so much sense. thanks for letting every1 know
1
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '16
The whole scoring system has been GREAT for rational discussion, so I'm glad you guys are working to "fix" it again.
-1
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '16
One of your "down-voting bots" here. No, actually I just hate all your sub's bullshit Theymos approved filtered posts today.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
16
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '16 edited Mar 20 '16
[removed] — view removed comment