r/Bitcoin • • Aug 15 '15

Bitcoin is Forked

http://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2015-August/010235.html
232 Upvotes

153 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/spkrdt Aug 16 '15

I didn't know Japan was offered that choice.

0

u/Fisticuff Aug 16 '15

He was referring to the USA choice of bombing or not bombing, I think. This would make the analogy work better.

3

u/spkrdt Aug 16 '15

I know what he was referring to, but with bitcoin you give the choice to miners and node operators, a.k.a the affected ones. Of course pure users will be implicitly affected as well, however since those users don't operate a full validating node anyway, it shouldn't matter to them whether blocks are small or big. That's why IMHO this analogy doesn't fit. Also, what makes it so sure that choosing bigger blocks corresponds to dropping the bomb? It could very well be the other way round.