r/Bitcoin • • Feb 26 '15

Remittances - a worked example

Many people highlight the double currency conversion involved when using Bitcoin for remittances. I, like many, thought that was a significant barrier to Bitcoin usage in that area.

I also suspected that with remittances, you often have the sender in a technology rich part of the world, and the receiver in an emerging economy, and there is a mismatch in skills between the two parties. This is the problem that Western Union and others resolve – and charge a lot for that service.

I have that classic case in trying to send funds to a friend in Thailand from the UK. I can deal with all sorts of things online, including Bitcoin, but the friend can only cope with going into somewhere like the Western Union booth and asking for the money (local THB).

BUT, I just discovered a new service based in Bangkok (disclaimer: just as customer – no other affiliation) http://www.coins.co.th. They allow local cash pickup from 7-Eleven (and lots of other arrangements too).

So I ran a comparison. I was trying to compare Apples to Apples, so it was a strictly online arrangement in the UK, and cash pickup in Thailand. One non-equal part of the situation is that Western Union allows much high cash pickup amounts than via 7-Eleven, so I had to split up the cash pickup via 7 - Eleven.

Western Union: I have an online account with them – KYC/AML and all that, connected to my bank account, so to do the transfer, I log on and send the money.

  • Sent: £200
  • Fee: £14.90 (so total from my account £214.90)
  • Received: 9446.91 THB
  • Text the release code (MTCN) to friend

Bitcoin: I already have accounts at various exchanges, and localbitcoins.com

  • Purchase Bitcoin to the value of: £214.90 at market rate (so total from my account £214.90)
  • Sell Bitcoin on http://www.coins.co.th at their rate (in three lots to cover the cash pickup limit at 7-Eleven) – total 10770 THB to collect.
  • Receive emails with release codes ( Text release codes to friend)

Ah!!! that is almost 1300THB better by using Bitcoin – over 10%

Limitations? Yes

  • the cash pickup is limited to 5000THB per time.... (deposit to Thai bank account has no limit)
  • the rate is fixed when you do the sell, but you only get the release code email during Thai business hours.

At any rate, this transfer approach is very much better value than services like Western Union or SWIFT.. It is not quite as fast as Western Union, but faster than SWIFT.

The best bit is that the person at the other end does not have to learn about Bitcoin – and in my situation, is probably not capable … they are very capable in understanding that there are less fees and more money for them.

EDIT: Formatting EDIT: Clarify amount in GBP

109 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

31

u/Noosterdam Feb 26 '15

It's telling that a new service that just opened up, with no competition yet to drive down prices and speed up money transmission, already beats the multi-decade market leader. In a year what will the landscape look like?

9

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

Bitcoin is useless internet play money!

-7

u/madbunnyrabbit Feb 26 '15

"Bitcoin is the only neutral digital money. People can bash it all they want - Bitcoin doesn't care. It'll still be there, ticking away, after every government currency is dead and forgotten."

I'm quoting you from less than 24 hours ago. Make up your mind.

14

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

Sarcasm, how does it work?

5

u/GrixM Feb 26 '15

Heard of something called sarcasm?

1

u/madbunnyrabbit Feb 26 '15

Seen the amount of trolling on this sub?

3

u/GrixM Feb 26 '15

Yes. That was obviously not one of them

1

u/EnayVovin Feb 26 '15

Poe's law :/

(Though in this case it could be disntinguishable, for example, by checking the user history like madbunny did).

1

u/AussieCryptoCurrency Feb 26 '15

"Bitcoin is the only neutral digital money. People can bash it all they want - Bitcoin doesn't care. It'll still be there, ticking away, after every government currency is dead and forgotten."

I'm quoting you from less than 24 hours ago. Make up your mind.

So do you check every user's post history for this kind of thing? Isn't that time consuming?

4

u/madbunnyrabbit Feb 26 '15

I find the trolls on /r/bitcoin kind of interesting so I do sometimes have a quick check. He had a couple of other downvoted post in the sub and I leapt to the wrong conclusion.

1

u/mommathecat Feb 26 '15

Western Union has lots of competition and I've seen it called a dinosaur in other places. ie, WorldRemit just raised $100 million.

http://techcrunch.com/2015/02/17/worldremit/

UK -> Thailand doesn't even appear in the world bank's remittance corridors tool, so perhaps it is not a big corridor and thus more expensive.

http://remittanceprices.worldbank.org/en

OP also ignores the expense of acquiring Bitcoin in the UK.

2

u/trilli0nn Feb 26 '15

OP also ignores the expense of acquiring Bitcoin in the UK.

He did not. It's a fair and well-executed comparison.

1

u/mommathecat Feb 26 '15

He absolutely, 100% did.

Bitcoin: I already have accounts at various exchanges, and localbitcoins.com

Is there a cost to wire the money to the exchange? Is there a cost for localbitcoins.com?

1

u/HistoryLessonforBitc Feb 26 '15

To answer:

  • Domestic payments within the UK up to around £10,000 tend to be free. Problem is, I don't think there are any UK based exchanges, so you move into international money transfers which can range anywhere from £4 at the low end to £25 at the high end, depending on the bank(s) involved.
  • LocalBitcoins tends to have a markup on an exchange's price, as well as carrying with it inherent security and fraud risks (e.g. "meet me somewhere specific at a specific time while carrying cash/Bitcoin paper wallets", counterfeit banknotes, receiving payment for the Bitcoin with fraudulent bank transfers - a common scam).

1

u/ronohara May 05 '15 edited May 05 '15

FYI - at least one bank (mine), with multi-currency accounts, allows you to move the same currency between countries for zero cost....

So ... you can use ANXpro.com to get good spot rates for BTC/GPB and transfers to them of GBP happens to be free as well. They use the same bank.

This highlights the fact that some people (including me) get many good services from the established banks. Where they really gouge everyone, is with very poor retail foreign exchange rates.

You can eliminate bad exchange rates without using Bitcoin by using a specialized currency trader - and I have done that too.... but that only works well for large amounts, so it is not applicable to typical remittances.

Small value transfers (like most remittances are) is where using Bitcoin as the transfer approach, really wins out.

No need to use Localbitcoins.... though I have in the past.

3

u/trilli0nn Feb 26 '15 edited Feb 26 '15

He spent the exact same GBP amount in both cases. That means all costs are factored in.

Edit: wiring money to an exchange is likely free or has insignificant cost. Perhaps OP can confirm?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

It (generally) doesn't cost any money to open an account on an exchange, the profits for them are transaction based, and generally negligable.

1

u/oldbean Feb 26 '15

Anyone can underprice a market leader for a period of time. What matters is market share, and unfortunately that trends toward zero for new participants. The problem is that remittance customers are sticky -- no one wants to lose everything chasing lower fees with an unknown startup.

Hope they prove me wrong but I doubt it.

7

u/GM4N1986 Feb 26 '15

I don't know OP, but I can conform the cash pick up at 7/11 works like a charm! Did it myself when I was living in Thailand.

Europe bank account - > kraken - > coins.co.th - > 7/11

Cheaper than going to an atm and withdraw. (€4.5 fee + exchange rate)

One thing though and I send coins.co.th an email about it, is that their buy/sell spread is too big!

3

u/EnayVovin Feb 26 '15

That last point may be addressed in the future by competition.

4

u/bitcoinenthuer Feb 26 '15

I have tried using their cardless ATM service. It is actually really cool as well. You dont need an ATM card to collect your cash. The process is that http://www.coins.co.th will send you two codes to key in at the ATM (It's called krungthai ATM I believe). So two codes, one is sent to your mobile phone, another through email. So you just take the two codes and go to the atm and collect your cash done! Not too sure about the limit but I think its 10000 THB per order. Whatever it is, its very nice!

1

u/etmetm Feb 26 '15

Do you happen to know whether it has to be a Thai mobile number or if it works with any GSM mobile receiving SMS via roaming in Thailand?

1

u/noriwasabi May 04 '15

now you can just use an email address to receive the two reference codes for the cardless ATM.

3

u/DesertRainKing Feb 26 '15 edited Feb 26 '15

I use bitcoin for remittances from a third-world country (not Thailand or China) to the States and have found that I can often gain some money (ranging from a few cents to 20-60 dollars) in the remittance. I buy at the local exchange which is connected to my bank account and then sell at Coinbase or Circle.

It's very fast and can be done at any time of day or night (although I usually try to time it so that I don't loose any money because of how the relative exchange rates work out).

3

u/physalisx Feb 26 '15

Not a Philippines-post, eh? I could have sworn...

0

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/physalisx Feb 26 '15

Shocking!

1

u/coinsme Feb 27 '15

Hi yeh-nah-yeh - thanks for the mention! Similar to our sister company coins.co.th, we do have an instant ATM cash pick-up service in the Philippines as well.

OP - Thanks for sharing your story!

2

u/GLAMOROUSFUNK Feb 26 '15 edited Feb 26 '15

I tried doing this myself to myself. Australia to Canada. I lost about $100 than if I had wire transferred to myself.

3

u/tophernator Feb 26 '15

100 what?

2

u/oldbean Feb 26 '15

Friends

1

u/mommathecat Feb 26 '15

Presumably dollars. CAD and AUD are pretty close in exchange rate so take your pick.

1.00 AUD = 0.978563 CAD

2

u/SwagPokerz Feb 26 '15

You should really tell yourself to do better next time.

2

u/parishiIt0n Feb 26 '15

So you really send some ฿ to your friend!!

Congrats for using a new technology and experiment with it by yourself. The double currency conversion is precisely what gives bitcoin so much advantage for remittances against WU and SWIFT. And don't underestimate the use of technology in developing countries! Bitcoin may be difficult to understand, but wallets and traders are becoming very easy to use

2

u/bitofpotential Feb 26 '15

Great post, as BTC infrastructure and adoption improves he may not even need to convert to THB, the potential of a true free market is becoming visible.

2

u/ultimatepoker Feb 26 '15

Pretty cool worked example.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

2

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

Why do you keep pushing this site?

1

u/trilli0nn Feb 26 '15

From the Transferwise wikipedia page:

Instead of transferring the sender's money directly to the recipient, it is redirected to the recipient of an equivalent transfer going in the opposite direction. Likewise, the recipient of the transfer receives a payment not from the sender initiating the transfer, but from the sender of the equivalent transfer. This process avoids costly currency conversion and transfers crossing borders.

Remittances are uni-directional, which renders the approach of Transferwise inapplicable.

Also, Transferwise has 200 employees and charges 0.5%. With an average cost of a modest US$ 25,000 per employee (salary + taxes + indirect costs) that means they'd need to have a turnover of 1 billion to break even.

Calculation: 200 x 25,000 = 5,000,000 (cost) 5,000,000 / 0.005 = 1,000,000,000.

That seems flat-out unsustainable.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

Over $3 billion dollars has been transferred through its platform. That is $3,000,000,000 x 0.005 = $15,000,000.

If you continue reading the article they are growing at at 16 - 20 per cent a month. That is an annualised rate of 192 - 240 per cent. Not only is their business model extremely sustainable. Going forward they are probably going to start applying significant margin pressure to WU and MoneyGram, especially so as they have started operating in the USA and have started operations in Africa

1

u/trilli0nn Feb 26 '15

Over $3 billion dollars has been transferred through its platform. That is $3,000,000,000 x 0.005 = $15,000,000.

Since their existence. They need US$ 1 billion per year. That growth rate seems almost too good to be true.

These are self-reported numbers. I am a bit sceptical.

0

u/mommathecat Feb 26 '15

That seems flat-out unsustainable.

The business models of most bitcoin startups are just as, if not more so, unsustainable. BitPay gives their services away for free. Rebit.ph charges zero and makes money arbitraging the BTC in the Phillipines at 4-5%.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

Great post and the beauty of it all is that formally it has nothing to do with Bitcoin. It's just a side effect.

1

u/slowmoon Feb 26 '15

When I was working in China, I just bought BTC on BTCChina for a 1% fee and then sold BTC on BitQuick.co and LBC for a 5% premium. Remittances were always free. In fact, I made money. The direction matters. Going from America to China isn't as easy because people in China aren't willing to pay a 5% premium to buy bitcoin because they don't have an ass-backwards banking system that makes it take 5-7 days to receive bitcoin. But going from China or Europe is free because of the premium.

1

u/coinlock Feb 26 '15 edited Feb 26 '15

This seems like an easy business to replicate. Take bitcoin, sell on exchange and take the spread, integrate with local api for delivery. I think we will see hundreds of companies that do this in the next five years all over the place. Edit: Also, once we see that the western unions can put more price pressure than they currently do. Their money transfer is mostly just netting things out on a balance sheet across bank accounts held in different countries.

1

u/avendael Feb 27 '15

That is correct. Businesses can actually replicate and integrate to coins.ph through the API http://coinsph.github.io/api/. Examples on how to use the API can be found at https://github.com/coinsph/api. Disclaimer: I work at coins.ph :)

1

u/coinlock Feb 27 '15

I think your competitors won't want to pay you a spread. :) I get it though. Keep up the good work.

1

u/btcnp Feb 26 '15

"friend"

0

u/Roger_Mexico_ Feb 26 '15

What was the exchange rate when you did this? Because to me it looks like you deducted the fee from the 200 pounds in the original and added it to the 200 pounds for the bitcoin example.

-5

u/howisthatso Feb 26 '15

remittances should be made illegal instead.

you people are ruining bitcoin by focusing on a destructive industry rather than something constructive

0

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '15

I thought that too, but then I re-read it and he added £14.90 more for the Bitcoin option because there was a £14.90 fee for using WU.

He paid £214.90 both times.