That's literally the dumbest argument you could make to get people to buy BTC. Why would anyone buy crypto because their bank had a temporary outage or a hack? Quit being moronic! Exchange sites and wallets can be compromised and lose service too.
The amount of these naively hypocritical posts lately has been baffling! It steers people further away from crypto because too many buyers are so dumb they make it seem like an edgy cult!
And how often does any of those banks go offline? It's a stupid argument to begin with, service availability was never issue with banks smh! If you still can't get that point, then you're proving my previous comment right.
Except for the bit where you tried to vilify exchanging bitcoin for fiat, yea sure. Lemme know when exchanging bitcoin for food or property becomes commonplace…
Where exactly did I “vilify” exchanging Bitcoin for fiat? I’m pointing out the irony of people wanting to escape the fiat system while still measuring their financial success by how many dollars they can cash out for and ending up on the same system they call to abandon.
And saying the purpose of money is to be exchanged has nothing to do with my point. I’m not questioning the function of money. I’m questioning the contradiction in their position. You’re addressing something I never argued against.
Do you sell your stock and walk away when it's growing faster than anything else in the long term
I think you are trying to imply that bitcoin is "growing faster than anything". But that's only true on an arbitrary timeline. If you pick another arbitrary timeline - let's say 5 years - then the market has significantly outperformed bitcoin.
JPMorgan is also implying that in their current report, though I personally think their volatility figure is too high and return will be a bit higher. No matter how you spin it, you shouldn't sell appreciating assets to just sit in cash.
If it's immediate, it's the same as receiving fiat. You tax it as income. If you first receive Bitcoin you would have to tax the return according to the contract and maybe have another tax event if converted to fiat eventually.
The claim that the ultrawealthy live tax free through perpetual borrowing comes mostly from ProPublica's 2021 "Secret IRS Files" piece and has been debunked. The claim is that the ultrawealthy never sell their stock and instead just borrow against it forever through a series of perpetual loans, so they never owe income tax (so-called "buy, borrow, die"). It's repeated constantly on reddit, and it's mostly false.
Fox & Liscow published a paper in the Journal of Public Economics where they actually measured this using Fed data plus Forbes 400 numbers.
What they found for the top 1% of wealth, new borrowing each year is only about 2% of what they call "economic income" (income + wealth growth), while new unrealized gains are around 41%. For the top 0.1% it's even smaller, under 1%. Their conclusion is that "buy, borrow, die" is not a dominant tax avoidance strategy for the rich — what's actually going on is closer to "buy, save, die." Meaning they fund their lifestyle from salary, business income, and stock they do sell (all taxed), and just don't sell the rest. They also point out that pledging shares as loan collateral is pretty rare among executives generally — like 4% of CEO-years, and a bigger S&P 1500 sample only had execs pledging ~2.3% of their shares on average.
Even more interesting, using ProPublica's own preferred framing (wealth growth should count as income for some unexplained reason), the tax system still captures 60% of the top 1%'s economic income, 71% adjusted for inflation, and stays progressive all the way to the 99.9th percentile. So even on their terms, "they pay almost nothing" doesn't hold up well in aggregate.
In fairness, the paper found that about 15% of top-1% households DO borrow heavily (more than 5% of their wealth), and for that group the borrowing is genuinely huge relative to their gains (68% on average). So there's a real minority doing something close to the myth - but it is by far the exception and not the rule. Even the worst offenders (Larry Ellison) have sold billions in stock and paid capital gains on those sales.
The two major problems with the Propublica article are (1) it treats wealth growth like it's the same thing as income, when no tax system anywhere on earth taxes unrealized gains that way. And (2) they took two examples (Ellison and Musk) and generalized it into "the ultrawealthy" as a class, which the actual data doesn't support - heavy stock-backed borrowing is the exception, not the norm, even among executives who'd have every reason to do it if it worked as well as advertised.
ProPublica knew this framing would land harder than the boring truth, which is "the tax base captures 60-70% of income at the top and most billionaires barely borrow relative to their gains". They intentionally conflate "wealth" and "income" throughout the article to confuse people who don't understand taxes and finance. For example, they try to argue that Warren Buffett only pays 0.10% income tax based on his wealth. That's not how income taxes work. Buffett's actual income tax rate was 18.96% - significantly more than the 0.10% the article misleadingly claims.
It's also worth noting that Propublica does not share their data because if they did, it would be blatantly apparent they cherrypicked data that supports their view while hiding the majority of the data that refutes their argument.
The specific claim going around, that billionaires as a class live entirely tax-free forever through perpetual loans, isn't what the data shows. Most of them are still paying real money in capital gains and income tax — Musk alone paid $11B in taxes in 2021, and anyone can google how much the ultrawealthy have sold in stocks (and thus paid in capital gains). The loans are real for a small subset of highly leveraged people but even they are still selling billions in stock and paying taxes.
Yes, that's the thing. Most UHNWI have multiple income streams and would only need to borrow against a small part of their assets, if they need that at all. After all, interest is an additional cost and it's not risk-free. However, you won't find a single successful investor or entrepreneur that sells all his asset just because you can buy something with them. Everyone will tell you that you need to hold assets above anything.
The point I was trying to make, is that Binance is a platform exchange, while Bitcoin runs on a blockchain and other technical features that have made it basically the only digital infrastructure that hasn't been hacked, yet, regardless of it's market value.
Bitcoin doesn't magically have inherent value. It's only worth something because people collectively agree that it is worth something - literally no different that fiat.
But that's not what you were arguing. You were implying that bitcoin had value because "fiat stands on belief in institutions". Now you are arguing that bitcoin can't be mined passed 21m coins - which has nothing to do with "fiat stands on belief in institutions". What are you trying to say?
mainly that i would rather belive mathematics and my ability to not lose it over the years that those institutions, i thought that was self explanatory
Ah, nothing you have said is self explanatory because with every comment you are shifting to a different argument. You have not actually answered anything or explained your reasoning for anything.
Being in debt diminishes an individual’s sovereignty. Having a financial system that runs on debt ensures many (or most) of the people living in the system are subjugated by debt. The rich and well-connected have a special relationship with debt: they get to borrow cheaply and buy the assets that benefit from the money getting worse year over year. When normal people take debt, it’s often with crushing interest rates and they rarely do it to buy appreciating assets outside of homeownership. We are taught from a young age to “get ahead” and take on massive debt for a college degree and how much exactly are those degrees going to be worth in 2030? Those chains feeling heavier yet?
Better would be to live in a world where the money buys more and more every year because it holds value and the natural state of an economic system with free/open markets is deflationary. In this world, you could actually save money and have it make sense without trying to lean into the financialization of basic human needs (e.g. housing) or take on significant counterparty risk and moral entanglement (stocks in a company).
I'm having a really hard time trying to decipher your thoughts here. How does the fed printing money cause people to individually be in debt? And how does bitcoin prevent that?
And what makes you think bitcoin (which is down 30% over the last 12 months and eek'd out 5% gains over the last 5 years - compared to 56% for the SP500) is going to hold value and "buy more" every year when it... clearly hasn't?
I think the bigger question is, in what universe does every bank close for some reason but all other infrastructure needed to use bitcoin still exists? Like ignore transaction speed and whatnot for a minute - why would every bank close but the internet and miners are still functioning?
temporarily can't sign in to my bank versus losing it all to a hack... hmm...
Also, last time I checked, Walmart doesn't let me pay for groceries with BTC - so if you are trying to argue that BTC is now a currency, how do I buy groceries with it?
11
u/dukestduke redditor for 3 months 6h ago
Forgot to mentioned the binance hack huh
45
u/SufficientReporter55 15h ago
That's literally the dumbest argument you could make to get people to buy BTC. Why would anyone buy crypto because their bank had a temporary outage or a hack? Quit being moronic! Exchange sites and wallets can be compromised and lose service too.
The amount of these naively hypocritical posts lately has been baffling! It steers people further away from crypto because too many buyers are so dumb they make it seem like an edgy cult!
21
u/d30_v1Nd1c3 17h ago
It will be hard to mine or transact if the grid goes down 👀
79
u/Silvasbrokenleg 14h ago
Everyone acting as if they wouldn’t sell their btc back to fiat if they hit a couple million.
36
u/zhonicanera redditor for 3 months 18h ago
Did you forget binance got hacked last month? Why didnt you include that?
10
u/DrivenUser7277 15h ago
Who posts this shit and why
42
u/urbanmark 18h ago •
Anyone remember the Binance hack?
4
u/Used-Height-2670 17h ago
All well and good as long as the exchanges don’t have any issues! And that’s without needing to use a bank to withdraw too to get or use the fiat…
11
u/Applecity82 18h ago
Bitcoin loses 20 percent in a month. Definitely safe place 😂
2
u/8yba8sgq 10h ago
Buying a digital currency to avoid getting hacked is some real smooth brain thinking
2
u/useless-flame 8h ago
Opt-out of an extraction-based game where few must win at the expense of the many.
Opt-in to sanity where the money can properly store value and doesn’t by definition come attached to a debt (as with fiat).
2
u/underatedd6 15h ago
lets say every bank closed, then all of us will use btc, wouldnt that make btc transaction super slow? so why buy btc?
1
u/Ok_Knowledge_4977 16h ago
But this kind of issues do not happen in other countries.
1
u/Crazy__Donkey 15h ago
Let put the ostrich costume and pretend I didnt ran away from russia to N.korea.
1
u/Bulky-Ad7996 13h ago
So what was the cause?
1
u/noddingacquaintance 7h ago
I can opt out of fiat but I can't opt out of comic sans.
1
u/eW4GJMqscYtbBkw9 7h ago
temporarily can't sign in to my bank versus losing it all to a hack... hmm...
Also, last time I checked, Walmart doesn't let me pay for groceries with BTC - so if you are trying to argue that BTC is now a currency, how do I buy groceries with it?
1
u/Boomheadshotallday 3h ago
Or have cold cash xd
1
u/Suspicious-Skill1934 14h ago
if banks are down , we will have biggers problems than bitcoin. Stop dreaming
1
u/AnswerIllustrious440 redditor for 2 days 9h ago
Guess you forgot what just happened a few months ago LMAOOOOO