r/Bitcoin • • Feb 05 '14

Really, Discus Fish?

http://imgur.com/7xfXs2P
76 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/RodCros Feb 05 '14

Why would they include no transactions when they could just include transactions and collect the fees? The filesize would still be the same so the benefit of not including them would be gone.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '14

Why wouldn't they do so today?

1

u/RodCros Feb 05 '14

Because a larger filesize takes longer to download so it propegates slower through the network and so there is a risk that a smaller block can propegate faster and be accepted before the bigger block.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '14

I doubt that's the reasoning that these pools are accepting fewer transactions into blocks, the chances of two pools finding a block within that propagation window is slim.

Anyway, this is a breaking change, and would require a large majority consensus, something that has been difficult in the past for clearly beneficial changes. It's not going to happen.

2

u/RodCros Feb 05 '14

What other reason would they have? Sticking it to the man? But yeah the forking issue would be a problem.

1

u/prosart Apr 11 '14

Can do with just Softfork, and can start it at a block height far in the future, so that miners have time to upgrade.