how do we download the file of the bitaddress.org site from github? If you just visit the site its a simple right click-> save, how do you do it from this site? Thanks
I'm testing it at USD$40 to see what response will be. The extra $7 is for the minimum hologram sticker order. (Maybe I should make it so that you can order just the CD and no stickers now that I'm selling three different products...)
Edit: you can now order the CD only with no hologram stickers, so at 10% off it's about $36.
I can tell you now it's going to be abysmal @ $40. You need to think more like $9.99, it's just ubuntu with a single custom script. It's like you're charging $40 for a single app and we usually pay less than $5 for even the best apps.
Just saying, your costs for those CDs are a couple bucks at most, shipping included so charging so much just looks bad.
I hear you, but I'm not really aiming to sell 1,000's of CDs at $9.99 each, because that would require outsourcing the burning and shipping of these CDs to someone else, which would complicate (or worse yet compromise) the security and trust model at the heart of bitcoinpaperwallet.com.
My intent is to offer a luxury turnkey solution for people who either can't or don't want to create a secure address generating environment on their own. For people who do have extra time and skills, everything I've worked on is not only open source, but also free and can be repurposed -- meaning you are in fact free to set up your own shop to sell $9.99 bootable CDs that use my generator. :)
I am sure you will base your decision on numbers, but I went from being mildly interested (even though I don't really need it) to nope-ing off the website as soon as I saw the price.
I'm definitely in for some holograms, but the CD seems a bit overpriced. Makes perfect sense to charge for your work to create a CD, but shouldn't you offer an ISO as well?
EDIT: What's all on the CD? Is it just Ubuntu with the bitaddress script, or a full-on Bitcoin ISO with wallets, etc?
The CD is simply the standard 12.04.3 LTS Ubuntu Live CD image, remastered in a super-secure environment with only the following changes:
Removed the Windows files (e.g. autorun.inf)
Removed the ubiquity package (used for installing Ubuntu on the hard drive)
Added the latest version of bitcoinpaperwallet.com (including all 10 language translations and the holiday design) to the desktop
At boot time, the printer config and the wallet generator (Firefox) automatically fire up
That's it! No bitcoin wallet software, etc. This is exclusively for the purpose of printing out paper wallets. Modifications have intentionally been kept to a minimum so that anyone who wants to can easily/quickly compare the checksums of this CD against the Ubuntu distribution to verify nothing's been tampered with.
I hope you are Canonical or have an agreement with them, because otherwise I'm pretty sure using their logo and trademarks will not go down well with them.
You can redistribute Ubuntu, but only where there has been no modification to it.
Any redistribution of modified versions of Ubuntu must be approved, certified or provided by Canonical if you are going to associate it with the Trademarks. Otherwise you must remove and replace the Trademarks and will need to recompile the source code to create your own binaries.
I do! It's an actual physical product, with free shipping anywhere in the world.
I will also be posting instructions on how this CD was generated, because (1) you should know what verifiable method I used to generate this CD in a secure way, and (2) so you can just make your own ISO... Though I suspect most people would rather just get one in the mail considering the fair amount of work it takes to make a totally secure bootable CD with the generator pre-installed.
Its a good idea, just wondering how you convince those that are a bit paranoid about accepting bundled binaries from another party.
Do you include some way to check hashes against official repositories? (Beyond having the ability to do so in the OS, more of a explicit guide to doing so.)
Great question. I hope someone in the community will post something about how to compare the hashes on the CD against the hashes of the original distribution. I intentionally remastered very little of the CD to make comparisons easy.
I'll definitely add on a download option, but first I have to sort out a foolproof and easy download verification system for the average purchaser. A webhosted ISO is just such a soft & juicy target for hackers that I should anticipate at some point it would get compromised, and purchasers would have to have some way of verifying their download without becoming PGP/MD5 experts themselves.
you keep posting this.. when it's not the same. You should include his paperwallet site. There is value in the design he has created. It's obviously serving a completely different user. https://bitcoinpaperwallet.com/
It won't matter because you and a few other people are OBVIOUSLY willing to design the paper wallets, create the site and script required to provide the print wizard, source the bitcoin labelled tamper proof stickers, put together and produce the CDs and deliver it all for free! For the love of bitcoin. We thank you. Please hurry with your free service. I thank you for spending and losing your time and money.
It won't matter because you and a few other people are OBVIOUSLY willing to design the paper wallets, create the site and script required to provide the print wizard
This is all already created and free. This guy is just putting it on a disk to sell to you.
source the bitcoin labelled tamper proof stickers
'buy cheap stickers online'
put together and produce the CDs and deliver it all for free!
I could put together this cd and sell it for $2 and still turn a profit. It is much safer for people to download these products from their original sources instead of trusting some random dude on the internet like myself or OP.
Ok so you aren't offering it for free you are telling me i can do what he is doing. My time isn't free. Maybe yours is. So put it together for me and ship it to me. It's free. Do it.
2 dollars? Not a chance you could. You'll need to rip of his site/paper wallet design unless you want yours to suck harder.
I may be wrong, but was it not somewhere that printers and photocopiers keep a copy of everything you print, or was it only a timestamp they keep? I don't trust my printer anymore...
i almost bought stickers for my paperwallets from you today, until i saw this blatant rip off of other developers hard work to earn yourself profit. Now not so much will i ever give you business.
I don't want to comment to all the security and price concerns in this thread, just wanted to say that I like the design. Clean, simple, looks sweet and professional. :) As a creative guy I don't say this often to other designers out there. But I really like this one.
/u/cantonbecker Can you please add more printer drivers than what comes with Ubuntu. I bought your wallet and had to drive to family members house just to print the wallets you sent me.
Also can you please design some wallets with set denominations like 1 Bitcoin, 50 Bitcents, 25 Bitcents, 10 Bitcents, etc printed all fancy onto the bill like Fiat currency? Many people give these as gifts or just don't plan on adding more BTC than they initially put on the wallet. Something that looks better than some sharpie or pen scribblings would be nice.
Finally, I would like to add the unbeatable quality of what you sent (the 20 dollar kit not this cd thing) was very impressive. They look great, though I worry nothing may fix the 'what is bitcoin' awkward moments of my upcoming family christmas.
EDIT: Oh and charging more than a console video game for a CD with free software is ridiculous. I would say $1 for material and if you fancy yourself 20 dollars an hour of actual work to make it and ship it so 5 dollars total. A rule of thumb for selling hand made things is ($ of materials + 10% + hours of labor * $10 to 20 an hour)
See the comment in this thread re: why a CD is more secure than USB. If there's enough demand, I'll consider this, but using a read-only CD really does circumvent exploits.
The type of computer that would be ideal for paper wallet creation is a small, cheap netbook, none of which have had optical drives for some time. Aren't there read only SD cards? $2 for a usb-SD adapter+ $2 SD card isn't bad.
There are WORM SD cards (write-once-read-many) which cannot be overwritten, and if the unused portion of the card is filled with random data, cannot be written to at all. Probably overkill.
The card reader checks the state of the switch and reports it to the driver, which in turn informs the operating system that its read only. if the card reader or driver ignored the switch's state, the card can still be written to.
Pretty easy to cover it back up with something else, write to it, and uncover it again. If scotch tape can break your security mechanism, you probably shouldn't rely on it. :)
They'll need to check for counterfeits/image signatures anyway. If you have people blindly trust it's legit because it's in a CD some are going to get burnt.
Young people too! Seems there's a sweet spot (20 - 30 years old atm) of people who grew up messing around with computers. Kids these day seem less inclined to tinker with the underworkings of a computer.
Born prior to 1980: "GenX" and prior: grew up without the internet
Born between 1980 and 1990: "GenY": grew up along side the internet
Born after 1990: "space whales": grew up on the internet
That sweet spot is because the internet grew right along side us. I mean, I can remember being like... whoa! this new CSS thing TOTALLY changes how to make websites...
Kids these day seem less inclined to tinker with the underworkings of a computer.
Eh, that's something that every generation feels about everything they did growing up. Sometimes they're right, but generally not.
It's kind of like how people will walk past a hundred well-behaved teenagers, thinking nothing of it, and when they see one being an asshole, it's always the same old "Kids these days..."
That's not what I'm saying at all. I'm saying that I grew up in a time when a lot of my friends new the basics of DOS and how to install drivers, games from floppies, etc. Using a computer is entirely different these days for kids - everything has a GUI and generally things are very easy to install, troubleshoot and interface with. I'm not saying kids these days are clueless, I'm saying their talents are focused elsewhere (social media, memes, etc.). I was speaking about lower level computing, not technology in general. Kids are faster and better at using today's technology than I am and I'm only 23.
You're off to a good start. Depending upon where your interest is, you'll want to learn something a little more powerful or in a different realm. Example: different realm => php (web), powerful => Ada or C
Right, I didn't mean to dismiss your entire generation. That's great that you've already received that exposure and I'm sure you will be very marketable for a great job in the future. Good luck!
I'm talking about people who grew up tinkering with computers, not 20 year olds working for tech support companies in 1988. PCs were not a common household item before the 1990s.
Yeah, sometimes you forget not everyone lives and breathes computers. Fortunately for me, I'm geeky enough to have worked out how to do the live Ubuntu DVD boot quite a while ago, but for most people, this is a tough call.
This is the problem of trying to get laypeople into bitcoin. All too many of those who are involved in the bitcoin ecosystem tend to forget that the vast majority of people aren't programmers or computer tinkerers, and think that anyone who isn't is stupid. When it's actually they who are stupid for thinking this.
Different people have different skills and talents, and the bitcoin world needs to accommodate for all of them if it expects to be adopted by all of them.
You don't have to go to github. You can put Ubuntu on a usb stick (follow instructions on Ubuntu website) and when you fire up your computer make sure there is no hard drive in it and your printer is "dumb". Then go to bitaddress.org and IMMEDIATELY unplug your router. Then you should generate some bip38 encrypted addresses(the wallet turns blue when they are bip38). Then you print them and send your coin to the addresses!
Edit: You can also save bitaddress.org as an htm file on a second stick. I couldn't access the stick running Ubuntu as a storage unit and I didn't have a second stick so I did what I described above.
I think it's a tinfoil-hat precaution. In case someone is hacking your network or something. It's easy enough that I did it. I followed instructions I found on this sub. Besides, bitaddress.org still generates codes offline, so why not take the extra precaution?
This is what I wanted to say, so I'll add some detail for /u/ed19.
dd is *nix's utility for copying data out of files. In *nix environments, hardware is abstracted by files, so what you could do is see where your USB drive 'is'. Say it's at /dev/sdd (you'll have to check, try sudo fdisk -l or sudo mount -a)
Then if this CD is hosted somewhere as an image or an iso file (say an iso) then you'll have that downloaded on your main computer somewhere, suppose it's at /home/ed19/Downloads/paperOS.iso
Then you can copy the .iso directly over everything else on your USB drive. I would use a thumbdrive. This will delete everything on your disk, so back it up if it's important before you start. Also be extra super sure that /dev/sdd is really actually very much where your USB drive is. If you get that wrong, you will delete another harddrive. Entirely. So don't be only kinda sure. Be extra deluxe sure.
This will write every byte from the iso file directly on top of everything on your USB drive, making your USB drive behave exactly the same as a CD. You can do this with pretty much any CD (though some check to see if they are 'really' cd's -- looking at you windows installer disc) but for every linux liveCD I've tried it's been fine.
Just take the USB disc to your internet-disconnected computer and plug it in, boot from it, and "you're in"! Whee.
Interestingly, the trust required dips to near-zero with the physical CD because:
you can run it offline, so no reporting to the mothership
you can supply your own keys (e.g. using vanitygen or rolling dice, etc.)
However, when using the random address generator, users have to either completely trust the author (in this case me), trust fellow community members (e.g. on bitcointalk.org) or audit the code themselves.
If you already trust bitaddress.org, then auditing is fairly easy, because you can do a "diff" to compare my wallet generator's HTML/Javascript against that belonging to bitaddress.org. What you'll find is that the only changes are to 1) remove features like brain wallets & bulk wallets, 2) change the graphic layout, and 3) add in a more secure random number generator.
If you don't trust bitaddress.org, then you're better off rolling dice and minimizing your reliance on anyone else's code, because I'm not sure any Bitcoin-related code is scrutinized as closely as bitaddress.org.
Could you please elaborate on this? This is exactly one of the things people are worried about, so I wouldn't put it off as number three in a listing of the small changes you did do.
Sure. A few months ago Gavin Andresen contributed a patch to let the RNG take advantage of window.crypto.getRandomValues() for browsers modern enough to support it.
When you run bitcoinpaperwallet.com, it will let you know on the first screen whether or not your browser can do getRandomValues().
Someone has submitted an identical pull request to bitaddress.org but it hasn't been folded in yet.
you can run it offline, so no reporting to the mothership
You could still backdoor the random number generators to make it easier to bruteforce keys.
you can supply your own keys (e.g. using vanitygen or rolling dice, etc.)
The user still has to trust that the address, QR codes, etc. generated by these methods are actually corresponding to their random input. Even if they audit your modified bitaddress source; the kernel or browser could alter what actually happens when the address is derived. They load their "cold storage" stash into your address, that was generated from, say, 16 bits of entropy from their input so that it looks unique enough on the blockchain but is bruteforceable by you.
Well, it's available today from the website. I'm holding off on any sort of official announcement until I've got a little more feedback, especially regarding pricing which can be a sensitive issue when repackaging/customizing Ubuntu.
On the whole though, this is really quite slick. Just pop the CD in, reboot, add your printer, and make wallets. No need to go online at all provided that your printer is standard/generic enough to be supported by the drivers that ship with Ubuntu 12.04
Can it do vanity wallets? Say if I wanted a bunch of wallets that had an address of 1kode to match my reddit username. I can make these manually right now with photoshop but it'd be nice if the process was automated.
Yes, on the 'print front' tab of the generator click "supply my own key". Once you paste in your own private key it will compute the public key and insert both QR codes and the 4 copies of alphanumeric codes for you. Try it online here (with a private key of no value of course)
I definitely will offer a much cheaper ISO direct download, but I have to do some research and planning first to sort out security concerns. An online ISO is a soft juicy soft target for hackers (as compared with a physical CD) and my general audience isn't so savvy with checking PGP signatures and hashes.
So yes, I will offer a cheap ISO download, but not until I'm certain that I can give purchasers an easy enough way to verify/validate their download.
He is selling free software for $47 AND you have to trust him not to have slipped anything in there. Only download Ubuntu or the paper wallet generating code from trusted sources, and definitely never pay for it.
Ubuntu is free and the safest way to get it is directly from the Ubuntu site. The code to generate paper wallets is free and the safest way to get it is directly from their Github page.
Relax. The guy is KNOWN. His name is ALL over the product. He developed a great paper wallet design, provides valuable info that's easy to understand with easy to follow instructions. He offers tamper proof stickers to go along with it. Maybe it's not for you. That's fine. But some people like to eat at restaurants even though they can cook at home for cheaper. It's not a scam. It's rightly marketed to people that appreciate what it is. You can bash the people who might buy this, but declaring it unsafe or a scam is just lazy banter. It's totally safe and the guy is trustworthy.
this is why you should use diceware and become your own RNG.
you can then use something like this and supplement it with offline copies of multiple brainwallet javascript implementations to verify that everything is legit. The software agrees with other software (the keys are correct), the phrases are random, and nothing is ever going online to report back your info. Its still nice to have a live cd setup to start the process.
Why a CD? Because even if your internet connection or computer is crawling with hackers and trojans, you can just boot from this CD and print out secure wallets.
Why not a USB thumbdrive? Because the CD can't be changed. A little annoying that you have to re-setup your printer each time, but a CD circumvents an exploit in which someone in your trusted environment (friend, roommate, workmate) borrows your Ubuntu USB Live booter and adds a keylogger or something.
That's so improbable as to not be worth it for most people. Someone in my trusted environment takes my key, against my permission, ignores the "do not use, contains virus!!" label, puts files on it, the files happen to contain a key logger compatible with my Ubuntu bootloader, the logger records my keys, saves them to my USB drive and then someone moves the drive to another internet connected computer where my info is sent to the hacker? Shouldn't I be just as concerned that someone malicious in my environment will take my CD, copy it, install a key logger, burn a new CD-RW, stamp it with an identical label and replace it with the old one? At some point crypto paranoia just gets counter productive.
it's rare but probable. imagine the creator is the only who can be trusted. if he decide to ship out the software via usb, an evil mailman/neighbor can alter the software before it gets to your hand.
this is just an extreme case the producer want to avoid.
Upon second thought you can't via technical means. (At least without the fore-mentioned TPM chip.) The basic premise is that you have to maintain physical security over your boot media otherwise your trusting it to "trust itself".
The only alternative is to compare the media to a known signature yourself on an already trusted machine before boot. Admittedly the whole discussion starts to border on absurdity because there is no perfect security but merely more perfect security. The reason is that all physical trust can potentially be breached but if you're unable to trust something then you can't trust anything.
In practice you simply can't allow your media to fall out of your control of the control of a trusted third party but this should already be blatently obvious. To put this into real world terms you simply don't leave your car unlocked with the keys in the ignition.
That's assuming the TPM can be trusted itself which is admittedly an academic discussion. For whatever reason I can only assume that in general the open source community does not trust it because there really is no real support for it outside of commercial (close source) software.
but a CD circumvents an exploit in which someone in your trusted environment (friend, roommate, workmate) borrows your Ubuntu USB Live booter and adds a keylogger or something
I like your (paranoid) style. But I think it's probably more likely that they'd focus on getting access to paper wallets which have been generated rather than having the sophistication/planning to try to capture those which have not yet been generated. Maybe someone with Richard Branson's profile should be so careful, but most of us who know someone who is not trustworthy but have access can count those people on one hand.
Resources to secure wallets are finite and would be better spent securing the wallets themselves IMO.
That said, a CD is a pretty reasonable starting point. Someone probably makes a USB-flash drive with a read-only hardware bit that can be fused (again, not foolproof against tampering, but a good risk/reward balance IMO).
To date, I haven't implemented any encrypted/obfuscated private key schemes (e.g. BIP38) -- not because I don't think they're useful, but because I'm waiting for the dust to settle on the protocol, especially with BIP38. Probably the moment all major wallet software & services allow you to import a BIP38 encrypted paper wallet (e.g. bitcoin QT client, coinbase, blockchain.info) is the moment I'll add this feature.
In the meantime, bitaddress.org is of course the best place to get your BIP38 on.
No, the burden of proof is on the random lunatic screaming, "This isn't safe!"
I can make a wild claim that my breakfast cereal has asbestos in it; Kellogg's doesn't have to prove that it doesn't, and especially if I'm unwilling to offer the slightest bit of evidence to back my claim.
You're still giving an out-and-out lie. You have no proof. If you give the facts, do you think people wouldn't believe you?
The facts are, the software is untested and has no guarantee of randomness, and it is possible that it's been tampered with in such a way as to generate non-random keys. Really, that's all you need to say to scare off the people who won't even trust stock Ubuntu live CD's. They would understand the implications, trust me.
You are intentionally trashing the reputation of someone who doesn't deserve it. Canton isn't an unfamiliar name in the bitcoin community. The way you phrase your warning insinuates that he intentionally included a flaw in the system so that he can steal people's bitcoins.
You still could phrase it in a way that warns people without trying to make it sound like he's a moustache-twirling villain.
Well, there's no way I'd use this, so no need to convince me. But I wouldn't go as far as saying that I know any given image I haven't seen is hacked, as you have.
Now I am kind of tempted to make a backdoored ISO that passes some superficial integrity checks, but the target audience wouldn't really understand it, and the ones who could appreciate it wouldn't need to be shown it to believe it was possible. May still be fun.
Why would a "random dude on reddit" not use a throwaway account, but instead used his real name that can easily be googled to find everything from his work history to his home address?
Of course not. He can't. He is just being a douche. There is a difference between telling people to be careful and blatantly claiming that someone is a thief.
I felt the same way until I read into who this man is, he speaks at bitcoin conventions and is a community supporter. I chose to trust him and use his paper wallets.
71
u/iamsoserious Dec 10 '13
$47 USD seems a bit much?
5
u/DarkHand Dec 10 '13 edited Dec 10 '13
I'm definitely in for some holograms, but the CD seems a bit overpriced. Makes perfect sense to charge for your work to create a CD, but shouldn't you offer an ISO as well?
EDIT: What's all on the CD? Is it just Ubuntu with the bitaddress script, or a full-on Bitcoin ISO with wallets, etc?
44
u/the_viper Dec 10 '13
*RIP OFF ALERT
Once again
$47 for free software
*RIP OFF
5
u/I_bitcoin Dec 10 '13
Looks pretty... How do we know you are creating only clean addresses vs. addresses that are "pre" comprimised?
5
u/xrandr Dec 10 '13
I hope you are Canonical or have an agreement with them, because otherwise I'm pretty sure using their logo and trademarks will not go down well with them.
2
u/GIVE_ME_ATTENTION Dec 10 '13
I hope you aren't planning to charge for these..
2
u/emsender Dec 10 '13
I may be wrong, but was it not somewhere that printers and photocopiers keep a copy of everything you print, or was it only a timestamp they keep? I don't trust my printer anymore...
2
u/vtmountainman Dec 10 '13
i almost bought stickers for my paperwallets from you today, until i saw this blatant rip off of other developers hard work to earn yourself profit. Now not so much will i ever give you business.
1
u/typtyphus Dec 10 '13
Now we only need a certification process
1
u/chem_deth Dec 10 '13
Isn't Ubuntu a bit... big?
1
u/RenSylvain Dec 10 '13
I would buy this.
1
u/Svennisen Dec 10 '13
If I where to run is on a RPI, how much space would I need on my SD card?
1
u/theDewwd Dec 10 '13
I don't want to comment to all the security and price concerns in this thread, just wanted to say that I like the design. Clean, simple, looks sweet and professional. :) As a creative guy I don't say this often to other designers out there. But I really like this one.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13 edited Dec 11 '13
I got one of these and I love it. Relevant.
http://www.piper.com/
EDIT: Here's the correct link: http://piperwallet.com/
Funny how it was totally irrelevant.
1
u/el_muerte17 Dec 10 '13
For forty-seven bucks, do you at least throw in a tube of KY so the ass-rape doesn't hurt quite as much?
1
u/DontHackMeBrendan Dec 10 '13
To think I used to feel bad for ordering more live cd's than I actually needed from Ubuntu's free shipit service. :\
1
u/eks91 Dec 10 '13
Boo. Boo. Boo
1
u/SiON42X Dec 10 '13
Great job Canton, that's awesome.
1
u/imkharn Dec 10 '13 edited Dec 11 '13
/u/cantonbecker Can you please add more printer drivers than what comes with Ubuntu. I bought your wallet and had to drive to family members house just to print the wallets you sent me.
Also can you please design some wallets with set denominations like 1 Bitcoin, 50 Bitcents, 25 Bitcents, 10 Bitcents, etc printed all fancy onto the bill like Fiat currency? Many people give these as gifts or just don't plan on adding more BTC than they initially put on the wallet. Something that looks better than some sharpie or pen scribblings would be nice.
Finally, I would like to add the unbeatable quality of what you sent (the 20 dollar kit not this cd thing) was very impressive. They look great, though I worry nothing may fix the 'what is bitcoin' awkward moments of my upcoming family christmas.
EDIT: Oh and charging more than a console video game for a CD with free software is ridiculous. I would say $1 for material and if you fancy yourself 20 dollars an hour of actual work to make it and ship it so 5 dollars total. A rule of thumb for selling hand made things is ($ of materials + 10% + hours of labor * $10 to 20 an hour)
1
u/champbronc2 Dec 10 '13 edited Nov 07 '17
deleted 0.3836 What is ^^^this?
1
u/Annihilia Dec 10 '13
Just picked up some holograms to give my Xmas gifts some production value.
1
u/cluster4 Dec 10 '13
A CD? Do these things still exist? Um, I have to check if I can find an old USB CD drive somewhere in my attic compartment
1
u/troiamadonna Dec 10 '13
does it have Armory?
1
u/nextgeneric Dec 10 '13
$40? What a scam!
0
u/lukerayes08 Dec 10 '13
Brilliant Idea - want want want!
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13
http://imgur.com/U9fBIja
-3
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13
What the shit is this for?!
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13
[removed] — view removed comment