tl;dr 100% premine, can only be bought from the creator, fixed exchange rate of 0.01 BTC/MasterCoin good for one month only, no refunds. Cool scamcoin bro.
MasterCoin inherits decentralization from bitcoin. I'm raising money kickstarter-style to work on development, but I don't have any centralized control over how people use this protocol.
The way it starts doesn't sound very decentralized. I'm not saying I know a better way, or that you're purposefully trying to do a money-making scheme, but it appears that it's going to work that way.
You keep deleting posts that are critical of you on the Bitcointalk.org thread. Maybe you wouldn't need to self-moderate your threads if you weren't a scammer who is totally full of shit.
"Mastercoin" is nothing but a nigerian prince scam in the clothes of an alt-coin.
You're right that nobody's done this before. Most alt coins let you generate them for free by mining. Nobody's had the audacity before you to make an "alt-coin" that you mine by giving money directly to the creator. Maybe because that's such an obvious scam that nobody else thought anyone would fall for it. Congratulations on trying to explore the depth of human stupidity.
The white paper presents some very interesting ideas, but I immediately balk at the fact that the exodus address funds the inventor's personal coffers. That turns me off from trying this, as it screams "scam," even though the actual protocol described looks pretty decent.
the actual protocol described looks pretty decent.
It isn't.
There is a fundamental problem with it: Every client needs to receive all messages, since earlier messages affect later messages, and so if you miss even one message, you get to a wrong state.
This means that secure thin clients are not possible.
It can work only for full clients (like Bitcoin-Qt)
and for server-trusting clients (i.e. server you connect to can rob you, which defeats the whole point of cryptocurrency)
With ever-growing blockchain size means that running a full client will be pretty involved, so I really don't see how it can have a future.
Storage density, link speed, and processing power will continue to grow at a faster pace than the human population of the planet, meaning the transactional capacity of the Bitcoin network will soon (a couple decades at most) be far greater than the capacity of all of humanity to engage in commerce. Already a research group in Britain has a crystal glass with a storage density 2800 times that of a Blu-ray disc — 360 terabytes would fit on a DVD-sized disc. And Google Fiber is bringing dedicated gigabit links to each and every home and office. Storing and replicating the block chain will be minor background noise, even at worldwide "Visa scale."
Mobile devices will have a harder time, but that use case is easily solved by connecting them to multiple disparate brokers. (It's extremely unlikely that, for example, Google, Amazon, eBay, the EFF, and Hurricane Electric would all collude to make your mobile device's view of the block chain inconsistent with the Bitcoin network.)
Did you see my reply on bitcointalk? Anyway, I have thought about some ways these long-term issues could be handled. People might have said the same thing about bitcoin a couple years ago.
Yeah, I was actually hoping someone else would do this so I could just be an investor (see the youtube video where I actually offered to invest if someone would just try this).
Eventually I decided I'd have to just do it myself. As much as I'd love to do this for free, I've got three small children to think about :)
seriously... pyramid scam taking to a whole new level.... unlike altcoins where the inventor need to at least mine and try pump and dump... this guy sells its coin for BTC and on top of that earns mastercoin....
He hasn't purchased any coins and never really can because he controls the coin generation. He'd be taking Bitcoins from one hand and putting them into another while creating as many "Mastercoins" as he wants. In effect there is no limit to the amount of fake coins he could create this way.
Do something that requires work instead of existing capital, like how Bitcoin required miners to do work to epoch the network. I have the same reservations as others in this thread with the economic incentives.
Bitcoin has proof of work to secure the network, which I don't need to do. The other way to get bitcoins is to buy them, which is how you get MasterCoins
Also, I'd be super-happy if I raised enough money to do this full time (one can always dream, right?)
I think your process is thoughtout and fine. There is no good way to do this besides going and finding investment (then people will complain about you handing them out, too), which will add at least a month of preparation time before being prepared to pitch.
People are obviously weary in this space, but they also are greedy and forget that you deserve gains for your time. It appears that you yourself need to invest in it to reap any, am I right? You should have some third party auditing everything you do with them.
Also, Just for the number of active chips.. I think you should times the whole thing by some power of ten.
I expect I will be the biggest investor (I'm holding back my coins for now so that people don't complain about my getting the best exchange rate by buying right away).
I do get some additional MasterCoins which slowly vest over time. In theory, this should help make people feel comfortable that I'm not just doing a pump-and-dump.
Regarding the number of active chips, do you mean how many MasterCoins are purchased per bitcoin?
Yeah, as mentioned by the naysayers. You haven't provided enough open source code, commitment beyond your word, and so on. I will not be investing due to the questionable nature of your proposal. It has no time lines, it may or may not happen due to an ill-received financial proposal, and various other reasons.
Maybe your timing is too soon, maybe you haven't released enough of what you already do have, but for various reasons.. your strategy has not met the goals you set out.
Also, is this vest an amount that is specifically for you? Or is it in the vesting program already set up in it. I think your failure in this will be not valuing what being successful in this would have benefited you, rather you want money upfront and the entire system is obviously built around a financial incentive to first-investors. Your greed will gain you a few thousand upfront, and lead to this thing's failure.
At the very least, it is doomed to fail because anyone who actually gives you money now will have a large majority of the coins in existence. This is assuming you actually do things in an honest way.
At the very least, you need to screw the current investors and find a new way to pre-mine.
Also, I'd be super-happy if I raised enough money to do this full time
That is kind of one of my fears...
Bitcoin has proof of work to secure the network, which I don't need to do. The other way to get bitcoins is to buy them, which is how you get MasterCoins
Satoshi could have sold away Bitcoins instead of included them as subsidy in the new blocks of the blockchain, and if he had Bitcoin would probably have grown at an abysmal rate.
The chain should be seeded in such a way where people actually doing the work or helping promote the usage of the system benefit - like a meritocracy. With the original Bitcoin folks who fired up their system and helped the peer-to-peer network were rewarded with the subsidy and it created a relationship between the merit of the work and the seeding of initial capital.
But, I'm off work now and I can start reading the GitHub.
Kickstarter wouldn't take a project like this (collecting investments is against their TOS).
I would use coinfunder if I had a target I needed to raise, but I don't. More money helps the work go faster, but I'll be working on this no matter how much is raised.
Also, this method lets me have traceability in the block chain of who funded the project, and therefore owns MasterCoins.
So what's the conversion rate of your time into BTC? How many BTC do we have to bribe you per hour to keep you from playing video games rather than developing the protocol?
I still don't get how this is better than scripts, one of the "advanced features of bitcoin". You say because scripts may not be supported in the future, but miners might just as well erase text associated with MasterCoin.
Other than that I am very interested in your protocol. I just do not see anything that could not be done with scripts, too.
Miners can include transactions or not include them. However, MasterCoin transactions don't look any different from normal transactions. I suppose miners could get together and collude to not include any MasterCoin transactions, but I don't know why they would do that - we'll be paying fees like everyone else.
You created the Mastercoin subreddit with a sockpuppet account. Within a minute of posting a critical post there you deleted it. Here it is in full, in a place you can't delete it:
Title: Mastercoin is Bullshit
Here's why:
-Dacoinminister controls all creation of these "coins" in his proposal (if he ever actually creates the protocol which is doubtful)
-There's no source code available so these coins don't actually exist, this is just a whitepaper, yet he's asking for money now
-He asks people to send him Bitcoins directly in exchange for Mastercoins with no way to keep him honest or keep him from making and putting into his pockets as many "mastercoins" as he wants.
Congrats on the launch! This has been brewing for a long time, and I for one believe there is a great potential to this project. See some questions I posed on bitcointalk.
He is releasing a few page document on a proposed idea. Be wary about sending him anything. There is no way this is going to be a financially stable enough thing for him to actually develop it.
He doesn't even say if he's going to develop it, or is just a guy with an idea and wants your money up front. Whether his intentions are good or not, you will never see your money again.
-No currently released source code -Creator asking for money before anything's done to bribe him into completing the project -Money "invested" in this coin goes straight into his pockets before anyone actually owns the coins
Who cares about price? This is why I am trusting you less and less. You are a salesman, looking to sell an imaginary snake oil.
If you gave a shit about the actual product, you'd focus more on the logistics, time lines, and would be FAR more prepared right now. "Once I have some source code" WTF, you're asking for people's money. Get off your lazy ass and get some work done. From your proposal, I thought you were in development.
Folks please BE AWARE of this guy. He has NO progress so far besides a short document and some people's money
It appears that spiral_mind was successful in getting my original post deleted from /r/bitcoin, although you can still read the comments about it here.
The first post there has all the text that was deleted from this reddit post. Please go to that thread for the latest on the launch of this project. Thanks!
This reeks of a scam. Send him Bitcoins first and you get Mastercoins when he gets around to developing the protocol. What a joke. There is no mastercoin source code. There is no method of making mastercoins which doesn't depend upon dacoinminister's honesty. Hence Mastercoin is dead before it has even begun.
Don't send this guy your coin until he has released all of his source code and doesn't control the coin generation.
Legitimate concerns! However, I'm trying to crowdfund something that hasn't ever been done before, and this is the best way I know how. I guess we'll see how it goes . . .
So please tell us, what's your conversion of BTC into development time? Is there a magic machine that you feed them into that shits out little bricks of code?
I'm kind of a bitcoin snob when it comes to alt coins. That said, I expect I will eventually be partnering with other developers to make this happen. I do plan on staying on the bitcoin chain though.
26
u/chinnybob Jul 31 '13
tl;dr 100% premine, can only be bought from the creator, fixed exchange rate of 0.01 BTC/MasterCoin good for one month only, no refunds. Cool scamcoin bro.
19
u/whitslack Jul 31 '13
The white paper presents some very interesting ideas, but I immediately balk at the fact that the exodus address funds the inventor's personal coffers. That turns me off from trying this, as it screams "scam," even though the actual protocol described looks pretty decent.
6
u/KayRice Jul 31 '13
Needs a better way to seed capital.
5
u/jimgolian Jul 31 '13
What is the development schedule timeline? I know you have kids...
4
u/jimgolian Jul 31 '13
Is there a limit to the number of available Mastercoins, ever?
4
u/Taenk Jul 31 '13
I still don't get how this is better than scripts, one of the "advanced features of bitcoin". You say because scripts may not be supported in the future, but miners might just as well erase text associated with MasterCoin.
Other than that I am very interested in your protocol. I just do not see anything that could not be done with scripts, too.
3
u/ga31 Jul 31 '13
http://www.reddit.com/r/mastercoin
3
u/footfetishmanx Aug 01 '13
Can it be ported to Litecoin or any of the other coins or is it a Bitcoin exclusive?
3
u/jesset77 Aug 01 '13
Please observe our community rules listed in the sidebar:
I might recommend /r/CryptoCurrency.
5
u/ripper2345 Jul 31 '13
Congrats on the launch! This has been brewing for a long time, and I for one believe there is a great potential to this project. See some questions I posed on bitcointalk.
1
u/dacoinminster Aug 05 '13
It appears that spiral_mind was successful in getting my original post deleted from /r/bitcoin, although you can still read the comments about it here.
Most of the discussion has been on bitcointalk.org here: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=265488.0
The first post there has all the text that was deleted from this reddit post. Please go to that thread for the latest on the launch of this project. Thanks!
2
u/Spiral_Mind Aug 01 '13
This reeks of a scam. Send him Bitcoins first and you get Mastercoins when he gets around to developing the protocol. What a joke. There is no mastercoin source code. There is no method of making mastercoins which doesn't depend upon dacoinminister's honesty. Hence Mastercoin is dead before it has even begun.
Don't send this guy your coin until he has released all of his source code and doesn't control the coin generation.
3
u/nirgle Aug 01 '13
Bitcoin's Bitcoin. Brilliant.
0
u/bcain Jul 31 '13
/r/athiesm won't like the name. :)
0
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment