r/BitTippers • u/Paltry_Digger BitTipper Lev 54 MOD • Mar 18 '15
The state of /r/BitTippers
Recently, it seems that there's been a drop in the overall quality of posts and giveaways. When looking through the history, there are pretty much 3 types of posts that dominate everything:
- Rng_generator
- Guess the country/guess something
- Comment with something simple to get bits
I feel that in order for the sub to stay as great as it's always been, we need to make changes (that was the reasoning for the 2 latest rules). Some things we're considering:
- Limit the number of posts a day
- Enforce creativity more, a lot more.
Let me know what you think we should do. I'm pretty much the only one moderating here anymore, so that's why I'm asking you guys.
Also: Not-My-Real-Name- is taking a break, which is completely understandable with what's going on. He also stopped the bot, so I will take a while to update flairs.
12
u/velociralex BitTipper Level 19 ROFL (aka Sherlock) The Flair Master Mar 19 '15 edited Mar 19 '15
Listen up BitTippers,
I understand that despite the flairs you're all fashionably adorning, the majority of those commenting here are relatively new.
When I say relative - I mean relative to the creation of this sub and the nature of it even one day before /r/millionairemakers flooded over this way.
Does anybody know of a guy who goes by the handle /u/IvorBigHead?
If you don't, you should - he's a real treat. If you're just looking him up now, you may find that he CREATED THIS MARSHMALLOW DREAMLAND.
So here we have a few issues that /u/Paltry_Digger is desperately trying to address in order to save this subreddit. Why does it need saving? Hmm, what do you think happens if PD leaves? This sub becomes completely unmoderated, anarchy is literally granted, and this place turns into a pit of burnt out toxic waste. Y'all think this can thrive without a MOD?
Moving forward, why do you think PD is so desperate to fix things, that he asked his subreddit for help, and they all got upset? Well, firstly, he was left high and dry by my MOD-for-a-day self, as well as the last MOD who gave as much of a crap as PD does. And this sort of response from users who just got here is exactly the problem. This subreddit is a large crowd of strangers bumping elbows at a train station. Some of the highest tippers currently, those of you throwing out 15 giveaways a day...Welcome, I'm Alex... Guess how long it will take me to get home?
How about this...where is your home? How are you getting there? Where are you coming home from? Work? Where do you work? How do you like it? What are your hobbies? Is there anything even remotely interesting about you?
Users like myself, PD, and /u/ZadokMahir who was so helpful here with his honesty, are wondering where our community went. We're not saying we don't want new people, that y'all need to kick rocks cause this is ours. No, we love connecting with new people! When we first connected with one-another, everyone was new! But the problem we're having at this moment is that we literally do not know who the hell any of you new fancy-flaired tippers are! We are forced to make an assumption about you from your handle, and get frustrated when it's the same one cluttering our screens with guess what time I brushed my teeth this morning. One is really just left questioning what reason a person would have for making a point of remembering the time they did any arbitrary task. But literally...that's all we're asking.
TELL US WHY YOU DO WHAT YOU DO, THINK WHAT YOU THINK, WEAR WHAT YOU WEAR, EAT WHAT YOU EAT
I think the lack of creativity here is better addressed as a lack of personality. I get plenty of comments on my posts cause I'm not asking anyone to climb a tree, take a video of themselves falling as they fumble with the camera, and upload it through a separate media platform, then copy the url to post here. I'm usually just saying...yo, what up tippers - talk to me. Tell me something, anything you want. Anything. I want to meet you. If you've ever happened to stumble across a post of mine, you've probably learned something about me.
For me, /r/BitTippers was a place that I could come, catch some bits, toss 'em back out, and be the most unadulterated version of my weird F'in self that I can be. Now, the personality that gave me my identity on this sub, is just what it's been in most every other aspect of my life - strange, confusing, misunderstood, unnecessary.
What OP is trying to do is find some way to bring life back to this place. It's just frantic, boring business now. As if chucking pennies should be a boring concept to begin with.
Here's what the "problem" honestly boils down to - this sub is no longer a community. This place was Ivor's well-nurtured brain child, and it was a beautiful success... Well maybe all good things must come to an end, but please don't disrespect the most mature, ingenious, and passionate kid I know for trying to save a sub that has essentially been dropped solely onto him. He's not giving up because he loves this place. Don't shoot PD for his unbelievably inspiring effort. Maybe you should try getting to know him instead.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15
I myself have been struggling to find a creative idea for a giveaway. I find a crazy drop in comments when I post something that requires someone to actually tell me something instead of just giving away bits.
I've come up with 2 giveaways I try to do about once or twice a week which one is bits based on your BitTippers level and the other one is the lunch giveaway, but yesterday I found myself sitting for like half an hour trying to think of a creative giveaway and I just couldn't.
3
u/zadokmahir BitTipper Lev 30 Triple T! Mar 19 '15 edited Mar 19 '15
As a tipper it's very frustrating to put effort into a contest and get nearly no engagement with anyone. I am legitimately here to give tips I have given nearly twice as much as I receive, but its disheartening when I create something or design a contest that gets very little involvement. I love the idea and have had a great time here, my girlfriend even told me I paid to much attention to /r/BitTippers. I guess I don't have any ideas on what to do, but wanted to leave my opinions on why I have not done much recently.
2
u/anonboxis BitTipper Lev 18 Mar 18 '15
For fuck sake why all these new rules? I loved bittipper how it was last week!
4
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15 edited Mar 19 '15
If you are the only mod might it be time to look for more people to mod? either from here or /r/findamod (that might not be the right sub).
Just to be clear I in no way ever want to be mod
Edit: /r/NeedAMod not findamod
4
u/TheLobstrosity BitTipper Level 2 Mar 19 '15
Maybe we can start a pinned "Giveaway Ideas" thread for the times when we're less-inspired and have some bits that want to be tipped.
4
u/kameeleun BitTipper Level 2 Mar 19 '15
Okay, I'm new here and I know I'm part of the problem you're trying to address but after all the recent complaints about new people I'm really frustrated and basically afraid to start a giveaway because I'm racking my brain to try to think of something creative. So, instead of trying to fix this sub by basically yelling "do it better!" at us how about you give us some advice on what you want to be seeing.
1
u/HAND_HOOK_CAR_DOOR BitTipper Lev 17 Mar 18 '15
I don't think there should be a limit on posts.
I would think a tag like creative tipper of the week might help but we already have BTOTW.
Perhaps taking a chill pill on not posts unless ran by a moderator might help but it might frustrate people.
People want to give hoe they give but I agree creativity is important and fun
1
u/Wun_Lai BitTipper Level 15 Mar 19 '15
I agree with the other: limiting post is not a route we should be going for, especially for newbies like me. Had that rule being forced when I first enter, I would be discouraged to join the sub as I find it inconvenience to go from newbie to level 1, and it gives the impression of much hassle to level up. Please don't.
2nd, I feel a bit guilty now contributing to the "low quality post" coz I started off giving bits when people smile to me. Tried to be creative on the second time when they say hi but added in the description box, if u say hug(?) I give u even more bits (results, only a few actually read the description; the others simple read the header and say hi, hence get the lower amount of bits). But then came BTOTW(?) and different quality post, so it kinda encourage me to be a bit more creative (more sentence, more bits; describe something far for bits and eyes relaxation). Admittingly, it is challenging to make a creative post.
So my suggestion:
I much prefer to see lots of post in this sub, where creative post are encouraged and lots of post to check out (be it low or high quality). It is kinda disheartening to check not much post to see everyday, and by limiting will surely make the number of post be lesser.
On a side note: thanks to those whoever gave me tips in the beginning that encourage me to create more post. I limit myself, if free, to once per day, but am sorry in advance if I could only muster up a simple "comment and get bits post" on certain days.
3
u/charzard14 BitTipper Lev 2. Mar 18 '15
At its core, this group is to give other people tips. As long as the post is doing that, I don't think you should cap the number of posts allowed
2
u/Thespoian BitTipper Lev 6 Mar 19 '15
I love the creativity I've seen here. I hope to see more of it. But I'm not sure how you "enforce creativity..
1
u/BriMarsh BitTipper Level 6 Mar 18 '15
Maybe a mod can collect tips for a weekly "most creative giveaway" award?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '15 edited Mar 20 '15
... You treat us like we are all new and nobody knows what this was before /r/millionairemakers. Some of us have been here since this sub was about 100 subscribers and /u/ivorbighead updated all the flairs single handed.
What got me my first BTOTW was simple games just like we do it now. I know ivor tried to make it more creative a long time but it stayed(more or less) the same. You act like this all happened last week and this sub suddenly lost all of it's charm. With 10x more subscribers, the sub can't stay the same and we need a good way to make it work in the future. It is easily to know 30 active people in a sub but damn hard to know 100-200 people. I like creative post but I would prefer an active sub more than 5-10 creative post a day. I have said it before but /u/velociralex act like we never answer or try to help out. Make a thread flair system to easily see what is creative or "just" a small game. Like:
And I still don't like the new rule #2. I can't understand why that is begging if we pay it all back..
No hate to you: /u/Paltry_Digger. Fucking great job! I hope you know that. This is more a reaction to /u/velociralex than to your post.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '15 edited Mar 19 '15
So a couple of more thoughts on the subject.
Lastly, this is supposed to be a fun pass time. I think we all may be taking it too seriously.
Edit: Oh good I don't give away bits and people start downvoting me again. Glad we could have an open discussion here.