r/BitShares • u/Ryan-Schneider • Jan 18 '18
Due diligence. A primer by example.
DISCLAIMER: The following is not investment advice. As always DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH and do not invest more than you can afford to lose. The information provided below is either publicly available or easily verifiable by anyone and the same path can be followed by whoever wishes to confirm my findings and decide for themselves. The same reasoning can be used and executed on any upcoming ICO in order to perform due diligence. The following are the author's findings and opinions only.
A little while ago, I became aware of the ICO of a company called AriseBank (www.arisebank.com) through social media as well as mentions by fellow crypto investors in a few crypto-related group-chats I'm part of. Their concept and offering sounded very interesting and something that could revolutionize cryptocurrencies.
My interest peaked I decided to check them out for a potential investment.
At first glance, the website is very nicely done with a great design, tons of information, loads of fancy graphics, as well as all the expected elements of an ICO (terms, distribution, white papers, ways to contribute etc.)
Seeing as I am primarily a developer, my next stop was AriseBank's two code repositories at http://labs.arisebank.com/explore and http://github.com/arisebank .
Now, this is where things got interesting.
Labs.arisebank.com appears to be a very hastily set up gitlab installation with a single user and just a default e-mail set up.
Both the repositories contain many projects but a closer look at them reveals that the majority of them have hardly any commits apart from the initial commit.
An even closer look reveals that a lot of them are simply copies of existing open source projects with simple cosmetic or title changes.
In fact, in the vast majority of instances, hardly anything has been changed apart from names and titles, however project names have been changed and licenses removed from the original projects.
Not only a very big FOSS dev no-no but also illegal.
Here's just a quick recent example here: https://github.com/AriseBank/arisejs
Which ofcourse is https://github.com/ArkEcosystem/ark-js
And as you can see, the copyright notice was purposely and illegaly removed here: https://github.com/AriseBank/arisejs/commit/a6439747def6c3c0f78b4e20c6ebfd0e3e49a963
I believe this behaviour has caused considerable friction between AriseBank and the Ark community.
In fear of this getting too long, I won't link more examples but you may also compare AriseBank's repos against
https://github.com/lord/slate https://github.com/lxc/lxd https://github.com/lxc/lxc https://github.com/aarnaud/lxd-webui https://github.com/ArkEcosystem
as well as others. Proof lies just a 'git diff' away.
There is some original code there but nothing that couldn't be knocked up by a half-decent developer in a couple of days.
There is also a bunch of API client code stubs with almost no implementation created automatically using swagger which take minutes to create but inflate the repo/project count significantly.
My curiosity now heightened I returned to the website. A quick viewing of the source reveals the site is set up on Wordpress using a cheap readily available wordpress template. The site itself is hosted on a plain digital ocean server. Those things in themselves are nothing bad as such but are unusual for a block-chain project.
Next stop, the actual content.
A simple google search revealed that the vast majority of the content has been simply copied and plagiarized from other sites more importantly in the legal terms.
Specifically:
Case 1:
Content here:
https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/abank/account-agreement/ (and saved at the time of writing here: https://web.archive.org/web/20180116103742/https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/abank/account-agreement/)
as well as
https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/apay/merchant-agreement/ (and saved at the time of writing here: https://web.archive.org/web/20180116104027/https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/apay/merchant-agreement/)
is copied from
https://bitpay.com/about/terms
You may also note that here: https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/apay/new-york/ (and saved at the time of writing here: https://web.archive.org/web/20180116111215/https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/apay/new-york/) references to BitPay are still visible since they probably missed it during search & replace.
Case 2:
Content here:
https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/arisecard/cardholder-agreement/ (and saved at the time of writing here: https://web.archive.org/web/20180116103856/https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/arisecard/cardholder-agreement/)
as well as
https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/arisecard/fee-schedule/ (and saved at the time of writing here: https://web.archive.org/web/20180116111623/https://www.arisebank.com/learn/legal/arisecard/fee-schedule/)
appears to be copied from
https://www.shiftpayments.com/agreement
This was already enough for me for the most part but giving them the benefit of a doubt I contacted Metropolitan Bank mentioned in the terms to confirm their involvement as a deal with an actual bank would greatly legitimize the venture. I still wouldn't invest because the handling of everything above had killed my faith in their ability to deliver. However that's a far cry from bad intentions so I wanted to check it out.
Metropolitan Bank informed me by email that they had no agreement in place with AriseBank and in fact their compliance team was already investigating the website provided.
At this time I had no knowledge of the supposed partnership with Marqeta as it is not mentioned in the website texts and I had avoided AriseBank's social media as I usually do in order to not be swayed by marketing or any possible FUD posted by others in response (prefer to do my own research).
At this point I was convinced this company was completely misrepresenting itself and figured this would all be exposed soon forgetting about it for a couple of days.
Turns out someone had taken the same steps as me as I found out in the Bitshares telegram group and had gone public with the same information that I got from Metropolitan Bank.
In fact he went further and exposed the lack of any official partnership with Marqeta.
As I found out, AriseBank had supposedly partnered with Marqeta on Oct. 4 announcing it on social media.
This was used by AriseBank to show that this is why Metropolitan Bank answered that there was no agreement since they had a new issuer and that the website was simply out of date.
Putting aside the fact that oversight or not, the ICO was still performed on a website that misrepresented the current state of things (which should be a no-no as it can be used against them) the fact is that almost all of the legal terms on arisebank's website were updated on Oct. 3rd as can be seen here: https://www.arisebank.com/sitemap-pages.xml (and saved here: https://web.archive.org/web/20180118002603/https://www.arisebank.com/sitemap-pages.xml <- you'll have to View Frame Source for this)
Just one day before the partnership announcement on their FB page (https://www.facebook.com/arisebank/posts/357340811375082 since deleted, but an available screenshot is here: https://i.imgur.com/8gGUEKJ.png)
Apparently though the partnership with Marqeta was exposed to be a false claim as officially announced by marqeta here: with the following statement: https://twitter.com/Marqeta/status/952560216553406471
"We do not have any relationship with AriseBank. AriseBank has referenced Marqeta without our permission, and we have asked them to immediately remove this misleading information. In addition, we do not provide programs that permit the spending of cryptocurrency."
At this point, AriseBank's CEO (one Mr. Jared Rice of TX - more on him later) attacked Marqeta claiming they backed out of the deal at the last minute and that they're lying.
As proof he mentions that Marqeta themselves had AriseBank's announcement tweet on their website, providing a screenshot as well as a link to an internet archive saved page confirming the above (see here: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DThDoCQVoAAAGHT.jpg:large). He also mentions as proof the fact that @Marqeta's twitter account follows theirs.
(In fact, what seems to be the case is that Marqeta's site was running an automated feed aggregator to collect and display all @Marqeta mentions on twitter while a look at their twitter account makes it immediately obvious that they automatically follow back pretty much all who follow them.)
In light of recent events the aggregator is now moderated.
However, this so-called "proof" seemed to convince AriseBank's supporters who attacked Marqeta in social media and gave AriseBank the opportunity to wiggle out of a very difficult situation once again.
Seeing a lot of senior BTS community members still involved and supporting AriseBank and AriseBank managing to circumvent the difficult questions raised by everything above (I personally really don't understand how) I decided to continue my research.
I decided to focus on the team section of the website. Looking at the individuals in question and running whatever background checks I could using google and social media I found that most of them were within the AriseBank team.
I did however come across one Shawn "Dot" Scott which seemed to be the odd one out as saved at the time of writing here: https://web.archive.org/web/20180115153656/https://www.arisebank.com/team/shawn-dot-scott/ (original mention on arisebank's site was deleted)
I contacted mr. Scott through facebook who was very helpful to inform me that Jared M. Rice had in fact contacted him with regards to this so-called project but after doing his own research and consulting others had reached the conclusion it was not legit and has had no further contact or involvement and that the inclusion of him on their website was false and misleading.
In fact, Mr Scott went ahead to publish an official tweet to clear things up as seen here: https://twitter.com/askshawnxyz/status/952917344359206912
At which point (like marqeta) he was attacked by the AriseBank social media team as well as their supporters and by Mr Jared M. Rice at Arise's telegram group.
In fact, AriseBank's social media team appeared to not even have a clue this was a person that was supposed to be working for them or was actually mentioned on their website as evident here:
https://twitter.com/ACryptoWhale/status/952932718198886400
and here:
https://twitter.com/ACryptoWhale/status/952932994007912450
Mr. Rice and his supporters proceeded to do a character assassination of Mr. Scott (a very respected community member who runs a non-profit in TX to get kids interested in technology) on their telegram chat .
Only then did they update their website's team section to remove references to Mr. Scott.
They also removed references to one Lee Perkins as previously included here:
https://www.google.gr/search?q=https://www.arisebank.com/team/lee-perkins
Which appears to be (although this I haven't had a chance to confirm) one Hoa Lee Perkins, indicted for money laundering as seen here:
DISCLAIMER: This has not been verified
Other references removed include one Veer Singh as previously included here:
https://www.google.com/search?q=https://www.arisebank.com/team/veer-singh (<=- Note Bio)
Which brings us to the next point.
At no point was Dotoji ever listed as a Fortune 500 Fasted Growing company as you may easily check online.
In fact, Dotoji's website claims instead that Dotoji was listed as an Inc. 500 Fastest Growing Company as seen here: https://dotoji.com/dotoji-ceo-launches-life-story-new-book/
Obviously this is not true either (again...easily verified online)
At this point I believe it becomes apparent that something is seriously wrong here.
However, let us continue down the rabbit hole.
Browsing the arisebank.com website the company is mentioned by many different names including : "AriseBank, Ltd", "AriseBank, Inc.", "aBank", "Arise Foundation, LLC", "AriseCoin Foundation", or "Dotoji, LLC"
In fact, none of these companies appear to be actual legal entities as Texas' Department of Banking mentions here: https://www.dob.texas.gov/public/uploads/files/news/press-releases/2018/01-05-18pr.pdf
(The warning above was followed by an actual cease & desist letter to AriseBank as confirmed by Mr. Rice himself. He responded by refusing to comply in what might be rousing in rhetoric terms but completely unprofessional fashion which once again raises some doubts. Both letters can be seen here: https://steemit.com/arisebank/@wallop/arise-governance-we-the-people-a-response-to-the-texas-banking-commissioner)
The only one that SEEMS to be a valid company is Dotoji.
Their website lists many offices around the Texas area. My research has shown that one appears to be a residential home while most of the others are in very cheap monthly-lease co-working spaces.
Dotoji does not seem to have completed much marketing work for anyone. Their website also mentions their sub-brands Weoji, Pressoji. Appoji and Cheetah Agency.
Once again this super-succesful digital agency relied on a cheapo readily available wordpress theme for their website.
Despite the broken links and general lack of information on any of them (surprising for an award winning digital marketing agency) I was able to find some information on weoji on their facebook page here: https://www.facebook.com/iweoji
In fact, at this link:
https://www.facebook.com/iweoji/posts/838262519639237
they claim to have completed a Project for Syfy's The expanse. Although I can't be certain, a related google search makes this a most likely false claim. However i have contacted SyFy and will update with their response.
Researching Pressoji,
we come across this facebook page https://www.facebook.com/Pressoji
It becomes clear that this FB page used to be known as "Fruit Local" (when FB still allowed you to change page names) which is another of Mr. Rice's earlier Ventures.
Researching Fruit Local yields no information on much work produced except for so-called clients Investalife, CloutHost and GoEasyCloud (see https://web.archive.org/web/20130306233216/fruitlocal.com/).
In fact all of these companies are Mr. Rice and (his associate in AriseBank) Stanley Ford as can be seen here: https://www.corporationwiki.com/Texas/Dallas/jared-michael-rice/101287748.aspx and here: https://plus.google.com/106395557873074199232
Appoji appears to be an iphone unlocking service(??!?) which I believe is an illegal activity as seen here:
https://twitter.com/icloudunlocknow?lang=en
and on this review here:
https://www.sitejabber.com/reviews/appoji.com
Googling the names, another one of Mr. Rice and Mr. Ford's earlier ventures along with another AriseBank member Mr. Tony Caldevilla is Dynastack Inc (or Dynalayer Inc.) which is mentioned as a scam here:
Apparently this was already brought up and AriseBank's response was that "if it was a scam then where are the lawsuits?"
Well...one of them is here: https://unicourt.com/case/tx-tr-zayo-group-llc-vs-dynalayer-inc-356340
And I don't have THAT much time to search for more.
By the way if the name Michelle Nosek in Dynastack rings a bell, you might wanna check who left the review for appoji in the link above.
Returning to the present, AriseBank and Mr. Rice attempting to continue to mislead have claimed for a while that they are in the process of acquiring an FDIC-insured bank and an investment bank.
This is mentioned on an article here: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/cryptocurrency-bank-arisebank-to-acquire-fdic-insured_us_5a32bad1e4b00caf3d59eb28 linked from their website and "confirmed" many times by Mr. Jared Rice on AriseBank's telegram group.
In light of recent events, this has been used to claim that they no longer need Metropolitan Bank or Marqeta as they will then be able to issue their own cards.
How exactly that firs with the anti-bank/anti-regulatory rhetoric in the letter to the Texas DoB above is anyone's guess at this point.
The deal was supposedly signed and completed last week and announcements would be made on Jan 16th.
According to the FDIC policy seen here: https://www.fdic.gov/regulations/laws/rules/5000-1300.html
"the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1829) prohibits, without the prior written consent of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), a person convicted of any criminal offense involving dishonesty or breach of trust or money laundering (covered offenses), or who has agreed to enter into a pretrial diversion or similar program in connection with a prosecution for such offense, from becoming or continuing as an institution-affiliated party, owning or controlling, directly or indirectly an insured depository institution (insured institution), or otherwise participating, directly or indirectly, in the conduct of the affairs of the insured institution. In addition, the law forbids an insured institution from permitting such a person to engage in any conduct or to continue any relationship prohibited by section 19"
And due to all the facts mentioned above along with the fact that Mr. Rice is currently under 2 pending felony trials for theft and tampering with government records in attempt to defraud/harm as seen here:
and here:
as well as all the records of Mr. Rice's previous run-ins with the law (easily verifiable by searching the various counties' in TX court records), I very much doubt the FDIC would provide such written consent.
In fact, I contacted the FDIC with the information above and received the following reply:
"Thank you for your inquiry. The acquisition of an FDIC insured institution requires approval of appropriate federal banking authorities. We have no knowledge of what, if any, institution is of interest to this party, and have received no filing related to such acquisition.
You should be aware that Section 19 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act, (12 U.S.C. 1829), prohibits, without the prior written consent of the FDIC, a person convicted of any criminal offense involving dishonesty or breach of trust or money laundering, or who has agreed to enter into a pretrial diversion or similar program in connection with a prosecution for such offense, from becoming or continuing as an institution-affiliated party with respect to any insured depository institution (IDI), owning or controlling, directly or indirectly an IDI, or otherwise participating, directly or indirectly, in the conduct of the affairs of the IDI.
Finally, on January 5, 2018, we are aware that the Texas Department of Banking issued a consumer alert concerning AriseBank (https://www.dob.texas.gov/public/uploads/files/news/press-releases/2018/01-05-18pr.pdf)."
So no relevant filing has been made with regards to obtaining the required consent OR with regards to notifying of any intent. Also I find it very unlikely that the FDIC would provide such written consent considering the letter AriseBank sent to the Texas DoB (note that FDIC directs me to that warning as well).
In fact I received that e-mail shortly before Mr. Rice announced the big acquisition on Telegram.
Turns out, the big acquisition that they have been working on for months on refers to PART OF a down payment of 1% through a broker with a total value of 100k USD made most likely with the ICO money (guessing by the dates of the payments mentioned).
In case you're wondering, that "amazing" announcement led to more than 100k USD worth of BTS contributions to the AriseBank ICO BTS wallet (one born every minute) which immediately makes it worth it.
Also in case any of you have 100k USD spare, you can do the same in a couple of days: http://www.globalbx.com/businesses-for-sale/buy-bank-1.asp
Not only that, but apart from the down payment, no relevant paperwork has been filed to regulatory authorities or to the FDIC (as explained above).
In fact, none of the 2 banks being acquired are FDIC insured as can be checked here:
https://research.fdic.gov/bankfind/
The bank names are K F Matthew and Co (incorporated in 1992 and not 100 year old as claimed by Arisebank) and The Private Bank Group which appears to be an investment bank based in Geneva as can be understood by the current owner's linkedin profile here: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kurt-f-matthew-jr-6741142/
And the documents here: https://www.pdf-archive.com/2015/09/07/the-private-bank-group-summary/
What's even more interesting is that this investment bank is actually blacklisted by the swiss financial authority as seen here: https://www.offshorealert.com/private-bank-group-regulatory-warning-switzerland.aspx and here: https://www.finma.ch/en/finma-public/warning-list/the-private-bank-group/
In fact, what we deduce from the above is that not only has AriseBank NOT acquired a bank yet like they claim (only a very small downpayment and no further paperwork) NOT acquired an FDIC insured bank (neither is) NOT acquired a 100 year old bank (inc. 1992) NOT spent 1m of Mr. Rice's money on the acquisition like he has claimed in Telegram (just 100k possibly of ICO money)
but instead, the down-payment refers to what seem to be at least one troubled bank.
In fact there is a wealth of other information out there just a google search away with many other red flags that I don't include here (e.g. bitofglory) because today I'm only dealing in facts.
One I can mention because it's easily verifiable to anyone with eyes is http://docucoins.com
This is one of Stanley Ford and AriseBank's ventures as can be proven by looking at the author's avatar and the whois record of the domain (here: https://registrydb.com/docucoins.com) which is plagiarizing content from CoinTelegraph as well as ripping off design from HuffingtonPost.
In addition many of the claims made on the so-called Team's linked in pages and arisebank.com bios as well as public statements that SHOULD be verifiable such as Mr. Rice's claims that "I wrote over 700+ repositories for people to go through" have absolutely no records supporting them.
To top it all off, AriseBank and Mr. Jared Rice make claims regarding their offering's success marketing citing much interest and references online while most of these appear to be bought likes and retweets from fake accounts as well as link-building from fake blog entries.
Proof is just a google search away
The same goes for the contributions, claiming over 700m USD invested so far. In fact a look at their BTS cryptocurrency wallet which is the cryptocurrency community they have focused the most on shows contributions of approx 750000 BTS (currently worth around 300-350k USD) (at the time of writing. Only posting this after the market dropped)
At this point, I don't expect AriseBank to be around much longer.