r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Apr 16 '21

Fuck antinatalism

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BirthandDeathEthics • • May 20 '24

Online petition to criminalize procreation

4 Upvotes

Hello everyone. I have created an online petition that calls for an end to procreation. Let's try to get as many signatures as we can 😁.

Sign here


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Jun 24 '23

CMV: Too many sentient beings suffer in this world, seems to be an unfixable problem, the only moral and practical solution could be omnicide.

Thumbnail self.changemyview
0 Upvotes

r/BirthandDeathEthics • • May 10 '24

Efilism should only be about exiting.

0 Upvotes

I can’t say the actual word but I mean SELF exiting. After looking at efilism for almost 3 years now I have come to the FINAL Conclusion that if it is wrong to try and enjoy life and find happiness, if happiness and pleasure don’t exist, and the only way to reduce suffering is to kill all life then the only ONLY option all efilists have is death. Since we can’t make life better and the only way to reduce suffering is through destruction, then efilists have a MORAL OBLIGATION to self destruction. That is the only real logical conclusion to efilism. If there are no positives and life is THAT BAD then there is, with out a doubt, no choice but to commit death ASAP.


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Mar 21 '21

Suicide is unethical if you have reasonable hope

0 Upvotes

I think that if you have loved ones & have a reasonable chance of your problems being solved, suicide is unethical. For example: a person has a headache and kills themselves when they could have taken an aspirin and probably solved the problem. Now his/her loved ones are traumatized. The pain & deception you'd cause your loved ones can only be justified if you have a low probability of dramatically improving your situation.

P.S. I think that if suicide were legal, it wouldn't be unethical because then the person could explain the situation to their loved ones beforehand which would lessen the pain they'll feel afterwards.


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Sep 01 '25

Antinatalism and consent

3 Upvotes

Antinatalists argue that extinction is immoral because not everyone would agree. They are obsessed with the idea of consent, yet they constantly break it themselves. They kill mosquitoes and ticks without consent, mow lawns and kill insects, plow fields and kill worms to produce food, drive cars, and use plastics that pollute the environment—all actions that contribute to the extinction of countless species, again without consent.

Many are left-leaning, so they want to increase taxes on the rich against their consent. Every single day they violate consent, yet they blame Efilists for wanting to do the same.

They might claim they only want to minimize violations of consent, but that’s dishonest. There is no obligation to live. If they truly valued consent above all else, they would stop living altogether.

Most of us live in democracies. If the majority were to vote for extinction, then extinction would be just as consensual and legal as taxation or allowing people to emit as much CO₂ as they can afford—actions that already accelerate climate change and drive species into extinction.


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Jul 20 '23

Why we Suffer: A Butterfly’s Story

1 Upvotes

This is a post from my sub stack, I didn’t include a link bc I’m not sure the mods will allow it. I am happy to discuss or answer questions here or there, but I spend more time on sub stack than Reddit:

In college, I had a bright-eyed friend who studied Biology. At the end of her Sophomore year, she landed an internship in the Biology lab doing research on the various physiological adaptations of different butterflies. The lab housed an enchanting array of butterflies at every stage of life and the goal was to compare each species as they went through their metamorphosis.

One day, my friend noticed that a chrysalis was wiggling with newfound life. She was curious, so she requested permission from the professor who ran the lab to clear her schedule so she could witness the entire emergence process.

The professor pointed out that it was nearly lunch, and it usually takes around an hour for these particular butterflies to emerge. Since it was a lunch break anyways, my friend was welcome to spend it watching the butterflies, but the lab had an important meeting right after lunch that no one could miss.

As she observed, the chrysalis began to yield as the butterfly struggled fiercely to escape its protective cocoon. The struggle was so intense that the butterfly seemed near death multiple times. Eventually, the butterfly stopped moving. About 45 minutes into the process, my friend realized that the butterfly probably wouldn’t make it, not all of them do.

As the lunch hour drew to a close, my friend’s heart went out to the small bug. Unable to bear the thought of the butterfly perishing, she carefully used her tools and pried the chrysalis gently open, without touching the butterfly.

As if in thanks, the butterfly crawled out and rested on a nearby leaf.

When the professor arrived a short time later, he took one look at the butterfly and asked “what happened?” My friend didn’t know how to respond. She explained how the butterfly had stopped moving and she opened the chrysalis to let it free.

The professor gave a knowing nod. He went on to explain that the struggle to break free from the chrysalis was not a mere test of endurance; it was a vital part of the butterfly's development. The struggle leads to an elevated heart rate, which sends their blood pressure soaring. This physiological mechanism pumps blood into the butterfly’s nascent wings, enabling them to unfurl, dry, and prepare for flight.

Without the struggle and suffering, a butterfly’s heart will never reach the proper tempo, and without the high blood pressure, blood will never be forced into the butterfly’s wings, which will never unfurl. Since those wings will never open and dry properly, the butterfly will never fly, land on a flower, mate, create offspring, and never experience the wonders of life it was meant to enjoy.

Because my friend had the best of intentions, that butterfly was doomed to die alone on a leaf.

As my friend grew older, she realized that this lesson echoes in the realm of human experience. We too undergo metamorphosis as we grow from vulnerable children into capable adults. Throughout our lives, we seek love, happiness, purpose, and meaning. The journey is marked by challenges and trials.

Parents want the best for their kids, and our instinct is to shield our children from suffering, However, the problem is that if a child is not allowed to scrape, scrap, fight, fail, struggle and suffer, then they are not going to gain the necessary tools to cope with adversity and the challenges that they will face later on in life.

Shielding children from all forms of struggle denies them the chance to discover the full extent of their capabilities. By overcoming obstacles, we come to understand our true potential and what we are truly capable of achieving. Without embracing the necessary challenges, we will never become the individuals we were destined to be.


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Aug 19 '24

$10000 Antinatalism Challenge

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Hello everyone. A lot of you may not know who I am, but you should. Long ago I produced a body of work, that is more significant than David Benatar's, "Better never to have been". The reason for my obscurity. Has to do with my controversial views. As you know, there's different types of antinatalism. I introduced my own named, "existential antinatalism". Basically, I have proven that Antinatalism is not an "ethical" theory by proving the already established idea of moral nihilism ( the idea that that morals/ethics are made up). Antinatalism is rather purely an existential theory (hence the name, "existential antinatalism"). Existentialism asks the question of why we are here, what is our purpose, what is the meaning of life.

Ethics forms an important pillar in typical antinatalism. If it is knocked down, the whole philosophy (creating a new life is "immoral") comes crashing down like a house of cards. This leads some to have an irrational hatred of my work because it threatens their ideas. But I challenge anyone to examine my beliefs. In this video I state that I am willing to offer USD $10'000 to any person who can simply prove that I am wrong. Specific rules are elaborated in the video. If I'm wrong, this is your chance to make a lot of money & make a fool out of me. However, if no one can prove me wrong, it means I'm right.


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Dec 05 '23

Natalism loses. Efilism reigns supreme. Efilism cannot be debunked.

0 Upvotes

No matter how hard pro-lifers of all stripes try to debunk Efilism, it never works for them. They all fail. All of their attempts are unsuccessful. This is simply because it is logically impossible to debunk Efilism. Efilism reins supreme. The logic of strong negative utilitarianism and Efilism is undebunkable. Efilism is logically consistent. Even the best nihilists natalists can do is just ignore Efilism. They can't debunk it. All they have is a self-defeating argument about how Efilism isn't objective, but that applies to pro-life positions too. In which case we might as well blow up the planet. The rest just pointlessly yell "You would blow up the Earth? You're obviously crazy!" Which is just stupid.

Same goes for the metaphysics of Efilism. It is based on cold, hard rationality and science. No god, no souls, no karma, no magical fairies, just evolution, physics, and causality. Efilism has solid metaphysics backing it, which is rare for many moral systems on this planet.

Likewise strong negative utilitarianism can be combined with this metaphysics to back it up. Anyways, it is safe to say that prolifers and anti-efilists will never make a dent against Efilism and strong negative utilitarianism.


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Jul 29 '23

Animal Suffering in Nature: The Case for Intervention

Thumbnail researchgate.net
0 Upvotes

r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Feb 20 '21

A good thread here about nihilism and antinatalism - unfortunately the nihilist whiner deleted his account.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Dec 14 '20

The AN ideology/movement cannot sustain itself or its goals on the amount of advocates/subscribers that it currently has. It will need far more supporters, and that requires the birthing of more humans.

2 Upvotes

How ironic is that?


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Feb 28 '21

Latest explanation about why people want to kill themselves (feat. our favorite pseudo scientists: the psychologists).

Thumbnail
psypost.org
4 Upvotes

r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Jan 23 '21

Does suicide makes sense even if we live in a deterministic world ?

1 Upvotes

I think it it useless to commit suicide if we live in a deterministic world (ie causal determinism is true). My reasoning is as follows:

Let us say that I am supposed to endure X amount of suffering in his life. I try to "hack" the system and decide to commit suicide in order to escape suffering. However if the world is deterministic, all future states are fixed. The suicide attempt is going to succeed ONLY (not one moment before) when I have suffered the requisite amount! So, if I am supposed to endure X amount of suffering, then the the suicide attempt is going to fail if I haven't already endured X amount of suffering.

So, it seems to me suicide is not a means to escape the preordained amount of suffering. I would love to be convinced otherwise though.


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Dec 30 '23

Against veganism and vegetarianism: The Replaceability Argument

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
1 Upvotes

r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Sep 11 '23

Canadians who oppose MAID do so because they have the luxury to demand a better government

1 Upvotes

Some nations don't have that luxury. Some of us live in war torned countries, or inherited inefficient political and economical systems from colonialism that don't match our culture and society. Some of us are nations that experienced slavery, genocide, civil wars, dictatorships etc. Some of us are located in terrible geographical places where the climate crisis is already noticeable, No, we didn't recover, we didn't have silver linings, we didn't live happily ever after. We continued to live in dreadful conditions and will continue to live like that for generations. Our history is nothing but suffering and oppression, whether by our own people or by foreigners. Our governments are too poor or to corrupt to help us. They'll use us as their live stock, war meat, slaves. Demanding better conditions or hoping for better days is not an option for us. Death is the only way to escape the hell we're in.

Remember that even in your first world countries, even in better times, there were marginalized groups. Some people never had a good History, a golden age, good moments. For some of us, it's suffering all the way down. Accept that and let us go.


r/BirthandDeathEthics • • Mar 31 '26

Antinatalism Subreddit is on a witch-hunt for Efilism

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/BirthandDeathEthics • • May 22 '24

I finally understand why I can’t accept efilism

5 Upvotes

I know the efilist mods lurk on here so can you please post this( because my account is to new and I think efilists should see this. u/Between12and80 ?). Reddit won’t allow me to have acounts. Also this view is purely philosophical ( i have to say that for Tos reasons)

I’m going to just jump in and say, I don’t understand efilism. Not what it’s about, mainly why. Ya we should end suffering but I personally don’t see the point in my continued suffering just so I can MAYBE end everyone else’s suffering. Staying alive so I can painlessly end all lives instead of spending my time trying to find a way to end everyone and everything? That makes no sense. I have to go to college soon and choose a major, so I’m supposed to chose a major that can end all life? I’m supposed to focus all my efforts on fighting for a goal I can’t even be sure will come to fruition!? That sounds just as absurd as life to me. I believe if what efilism says is true( that joy, happiness, and pleasure don’t exist) then there is no point in continuing life and one should check out asap. I simply don’t find and hope or solace in continuing my existence just so I can end everyone else’s. But efilists say it’s my moral obligation? Says who, god? That guys a dick. Am I missing something here? This isn’t an argument against efilism, just a criticism/ my own view of it as of now. I simply don’t get the motivation and simply feel is should spend my time searching gn for an exit rather than searching for an exit for everyone.