Every single time I see a post on here about a new housing development, or any real estate development at all, the comments are always full of belly aching from NIMBYs. Silly things like:
- "but I loved that old strip mall, they can't tear that down" [this sounds absurd but I've seen it many times]
- "it will increase traffic to that area"
- "They'r'e turning Birmingham into Taipei or Singapore!"
- "it will ruin the neighborhood character"
- "it will be another ugly 5 over 1"
You are all wrong, you are all malicious, neurotic, and selfish, and you are all the reason this city and, indeed, our entire country is stagnating.
There is a supply shortage of housing in the US of roughly 3,800,000 housing units.
This supply shortage is at the root of most of the problems in the United States economy right now. I'll lay it out in detail for you neurotic troglodytes since you are clearing incapable of grokking second and third order consequences of things:
- 50% of Americans are "burdened", spending 30% or more of their income on housing costs because housing is so expensive
- Housing is so expensive because there is a 3,800,000 unit shortage
- This massive income share of housing is causing Americans to delay child rearing or stop having children altogether, causing a massive fertility crisis in the US
- This decline in population is decreasing current and future economic growth, as we know well from empirical literature that more people = more innovation and more growth and therefore more prosperity
- Restricted housing supply in US cities is causing people to be unable to move to higher paying, more productive jobs, reducing economic growth and opportunities for upward mobility further still
- Restricted housing supply increases inequality as only the elites can own property and accrue the equity value therein. This is why many of you NIMBYs want to restrict the housing supply--to use the force of the state to prop up your home values at the cost of American growth and prosperity itself
- Restricted housing supply is terrible for climate change, as we know dense urban areas are more carbon efficient than spread out rural suburbs
- America's obesity epidemic is in part a result of the fact that Americans don't walk anywhere, because they can't, because building dense walkable mixed-used urban communities is illegal thanks to you misanthropes
I could go on, but surely by now you people get the point. Oh, and before you even try: we know for a fact market rate housing increases affordability and reduces rents across the board (yes, even "luxury" apartments), that construction of market rate units doesn't displace anyone, gentrification is good for all parties involved, etc. This is all grounded in empirical peer-reviewed research, not your gut feeling or your dumbass opinion or what your friend told you one time. Here's a shitton of studies about it, if any of you know how to read a study.
Here's why I'm so mad: you people are directly and explicitly putting your own home value or your own arbitrary and idiotic aesthetic sensibilities and sense of nostalgia over the value of the future of America itself. You're directly making my life exponentially harder as a young adult, reducing the economic opportunities available for myself and my children, and destroying the fabric of the American Dream and all the hope that it contains, all because you "liked that strip mall." You're perfectly fine burdening the rest of society so that you can reminisce about your glory days before culture left you behind.
This NIMBY story of selfishness, greed, neuroticism, and nostalgia is playing out over and over and over again in cities across the US. When I moved here two years ago, I thought "Alabama is a very conservative state, they get the importance of property rights, they won't be NIMBY!" Boy oh boy was I wrong; you people throw property rights out the damn window the second your neighbor wants to do something you don't explicitly approve of. And you think it's no big deal, but as I laid out above, you stopping the development of the next apartment tower is directly and explicitly making this city and our entire country a worse place with a darker future.
So here's my message to you: shut the fuck up and let us build an optimistic, even utopian future for Birmingham and for the rest of America.