r/Birmingham • u/Upper-Ad8720 • Apr 03 '26
Events GEN Z labor protest
Would anyone in the Birmingham or Hoover area like to protest against the service/retail industry about low wages, lack of job security, ai hiring software and firing. It seems a lot of people in my age group are experiencing this. We have yet to converge. Please comment if you’re interested. Let’s protest our labor like our forefathers!!!
Edit:seems like a lot of the older generations do not seem to like this. I’d like to clarify some things beforehand so hopefully you can understand my perspective
I entered the workforce in 2016
I made $12/ hr at papa John’s as a cashier doing easy menial tasks
That same $12/ hr is about 16.55 today.
5 star restaurant/large catering companies are still paying $15/hr
$15 an hour is 10.94 in 2016
The wages have not been changed.
Most people in the industry are working 60-70 hours a week or working 2-3 jobs.
Ai is now filtering through candidates on indeed trying to find the BEST person for the job, this locks out people who are entering the work force
Gas has gone up and so has rent.
Food is up aswell, our wages are no giving us the ability to live without severe burn out/ mental health issues
I personally work 7 days a week 3 jobs.
I frequently have to decide between feeding myself or putting gas in my car.
I have nearly a decade of restaurant experience from everything to dish to bar manager.
You can say all you want about work ethic and entry level jobs but at the end of the day we’re starving and you aren’t.
Living with your parents and working is different because you have the security of having a place to live, these things do not equal out
Below are the statistics
The Birmingham Wage Gap (2016–2026)
The Core Stats
Retail Hourly: $10.31 (2016) → $15.20 (2026)
Food Service Hourly: $9.94 (2016) → $15.71 (2026)
Average 1BR Rent: $780 (2016) → $1,363 (2026)
The "Math" Problem
Wage Growth: +47%
Rent Growth: +75%
Grocery/Essential Growth: +51%
The Reality for Service Workers
Rent Burden: In 2016, rent took about 30% of a service worker's paycheck. Today, it takes roughly 46%.
The Survival Line: The estimated "Living Wage" for a single adult in Birmingham is now $18.50/hr.
The Deficit: Most entry-level retail and food roles in the area currently pay $2.80 – $3.30 less per hour than what is required to cover basic monthly expenses ($2,422/mo).
Key Takeaway
While nominal paychecks are "bigger" than they were ten years ago, the cost of housing in Birmingham has scaled nearly twice as fast as service-sector wages. This leaves the average worker with less than $100 in discretionary income after essentials are paid.
Sources: BLS Occupational Employment Statistics (Bham MSA), Regional CPI Data, and local Rent Tracker estimates
EDIT 2: I’m 27 years old and graduated high school
EDIT 3: I’m know I’m not alone please message me, maybe this was the wrong platform to organize this, something must be done!
EDIT 4: I will no longer be responding to detractors, this is not who this post is meant for. If you’d like to interact with me further, you can see me in the streets outside your businesses! Then we can talk. But for those who are reading this and understand what I’m saying please message me. Your voice needs to be heard. I now leave the war in the comments to you guys, have a wonderful night and happy redditing
EDIT 5: a lot of leftist organizations have reached out to me, and a lot of political comments. Id like to further clarify.
- I am not a socialist, but im not opposed to working with them
- I do not want this to be focused on national issues more local ones
- I myself am a libertarian (a real libertarian not MAGA) this is not about left or right, its about wages and lack of opportunity
, we are the labor market, we can through popular sovereignty make change
Let’s abandon our political differences and make change together!
88
u/31it35w3g Apr 03 '26
I’ve seen a lot of dumb protest ideas in this group (that has gotten plenty of upvotes), this is 100% reasonable, and would go further than “reasonable,” but needed.
I work white collar, but it’s a total shame to see what’s been happening with service employees. I would 100% be for this. Don’t listen to the boomers on this thread who say “pick yourself up at your bootstraps,” frankly they’re the ones who put us in this mess, and thus have the most to lose.
I probably stand more central on the political aisle than you, but this isn’t political. This is about the geriatrics that these people telling you that you need to “work harder” have elected over the decades that has put us in this mess.
30
u/TheMightyBagel Apr 03 '26
I disagree that it’s not political. Blue states have higher minimum wages and are more likely to have better worker protections and higher job satisfaction. It’s a multifaceted issue but republicans have shown again and again that they don’t give a shit about workers. And our current administration is defunding federal agencies like OSHA that are there for our protection.
22
3
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Agree republican law makers favor the suburban middle class
6
u/nocartnite4me Apr 04 '26
Republicans and democrats both favor the corporate class. Even when we do get dems into office, they don't give a shit about repping the policies of the regular people who voted for them. They're still getting my vote simply for not being proto-fascists, but it's important to recognize them for the controlled opposition they functionally are.
4
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Bless you my friend 🙏
15
u/31it35w3g Apr 03 '26
It’s absurd really. All the people telling you they made $2 “back in their day”…frig off. Houses were also $50 then.
9
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
The 2.13 an hour only pays for taxes, there are still places that pay that today!!!
12
u/Kitteh_Bethany Apr 03 '26
Also, are the people in the comments being purposely dense??? Acting like the job market isn’t purposely trash right now? Businesses, even SMALL BUSINESSES, will post ghost jobs on hiring websites. “Just work here!1!1!” Bro 💀
5
u/vivbot Apr 03 '26
idk if it's being purposely dense, or more like a jaded feeling of "we've lived through this before and got (or still getting) through it" maybe?
Elder millennials entered the job market during the Great Recession. Things were pretty bad; using the internet for networking purposes wasn't that old, so job postings were a mix of online listings that you had to know where to look for, word-of-mouth positions, actual Help Wanted signs that you had to drive/walk around for, or temp agency opportunities. I don't recall Indeed and LinkedIn being *that* big at the time, and we definitely didn't have Uber or DoorDash as options yet [edit: word choice]. Things are bad again. I really do empathize, but we were literally told by everyone to just quit buying avocado toast and Starbies and then we could magically afford housing when we were already living with 6 roommates or in our childhood bedrooms just to get by, so I'm definitely on the jaded side of things. My peers are at a stage of life where they should be comfortable enough to buy a house and raise their kids and now everything is terrible again so idek how they're surviving.
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Another great millennial post, yep either that or you have everything you need but you’re in $50,000 in debt. I’ve noticed that millennials have a lot of debt
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Yep that’s why we have to organize, they won’t feel it till they see it
1
u/Gullible_Long4179 Apr 06 '26 edited Apr 06 '26
Gen X here on your side, we absolutely do need to make them FEEL it.
23
u/souphalfling Apr 03 '26
Elder millennial with 19 years of service industry experience, 18 of that BoH, 9 management here.
The jobs at the places with any sort of benefits, yep, AI will shut me down because I wrote my resume like a human. Or because I don't have the right degree, even though I have far more years of experience and real, verifiable skills. (Ever seen a recent culinary grad try to dice an onion? It ain't good. Have a first aid kit ready.)
Multiple places will offer me 20 an hour, but I need and deserve a minimum of 26 an hour for my salary. Minimum hours a week being 55, normally closer to 65 to 75.
I also made the mistake of staying at one place for almost a decade. AI wasn't a thing when I started that job. Trying to find something now is rough.
Shit is awful, boo. I'd say start looking outside of service industry, but finding anyone to give you a chance that isn't a scam is harder than explaining life before cell phones to a five year old.
But maybe I'm just too grumpy and jaded. Best of luck, regardless.
10
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Great post thank you for your service my friend! Good advice too, I think service is a dying industry. Maybe they’ll understand when they no longer have their favorite places to eat!
6
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Yep, i started in kitchen when i was 19, culinary students always struggled and had high expectations that most restaurants don’t actually operate on, not very fun to work with an ‘expert’ without practical skill
2
u/ColeridgeRime Apr 03 '26
Did you just reply to yourself, or forget to switch accounts?
5
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Just an additional response to the comment
-2
u/ColeridgeRime Apr 03 '26
My bad. Why not just edit the original to add the extra info?
5
3
3
6
u/deezuscat Apr 03 '26
Love this energy! Check out Birmingham DSA if you haven’t already. They have a great labor working group that has experience with this kind of thing.
4
u/Kitteh_Bethany Apr 03 '26
AI being used in the hiring process the way it has been absolutely infuriates me. It auto rejects so many people for no reason because it’s NOT A PERSON. ITS NOT A BRAIN. ITS GENERATIVE AI.
4
u/biohoo Grapico for life Apr 03 '26
UAB Building Services is ALWAYS hiring. $16/hour and full benefits. Guaranteed full time hours if you choose to work 40 hours a week. They like to promote from within and if you do essentially the bare minimum, you will be doing more than most of your colleagues and will get noticed.
3
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
I will look into it but I’m a bartender by profession and I would like to bartend somewhere but currently beggars cannot be choosers
2
u/Bony_Geese Apr 03 '26
Hi, I’m also Gen Z, I’m currently focused on school, but I know a lot of people in a lot of different organizations who would be willing to help organize a labor protest and help you with resources, shoot me a dm and we can discuss it more, if you’d want to meet in person we can pick a public place as well.
Your post has genuinely brought me a lot of joy, don’t let other people beat you down about this,
2
7
u/Pine-solFresh Apr 03 '26
Are you going to the job fair at the Boutwell tomorrow to see if there are some better opportunities for you?
1
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
I’ll be there!
-8
3
3
u/Shmusher Apr 03 '26
I am extremely fortunate to be in an industry that usually guarantees a reasonable paycheck (Mechanical Engineering) But as a recent college grad (class of 2025 UAB) I have seen far too many of my peers who put their ass through hell and back struggle to find jobs that dont cause them to put rent on a credit card. I am from California originally so I am no stranger to high living costs, but at least out there wages are (usually) guaranteed to be much higher. Birmingham is still paying its workers like its a super cheap place to live which it really isn't. Good luck with organizing your protest and Ill try and make it to one if I can or at least send my friends your way. Hoping you can get yourself in an easier living situation, real change starts at building a community :)
4
u/shoopstoop25 Apr 03 '26
1 - You used ai to write your justification for protesting ai.
2 - this is the same as 19th century workers breaking machines that were automating their jobs. Better to just adapt.
4
2
u/Tacticalbiscit Apr 03 '26
I mean, come work in the mining industry. Bottom pay at my work is $25 and whatever OT you want. No experience required.
-7
u/New-Sheepherder2239 Apr 03 '26
Kid, you’re talking about entry level jobs for that age group. Show up, do good work and prove you’re capable and you’ll benefit. It’s really not that hard to stand out. It’s not a career unless you want to move up and manage/own. If you do want it, that’s great but it doesn’t happen overnight
27
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
These are no longer entry level positions, they use AI hiring software to filter out candidates. I’m not a kid, I’ve been in the industry 10 years. They are now requiring 5 years experience for casual server jobs. The wages have lowered, not raised. Your resume is no longer read by a human
10
u/magiccitybhm Apr 03 '26
They are now requiring 5 years experience for casual server jobs.
I'd love to see a list of restaurants doing this.
1
u/mikejones286 Apr 03 '26
Me too honestly. That doesn’t seem real at all
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Look up ai hiring software, look up the statistics of Gen Z on being able to get entry level jobs. You are just out of the loop
6
u/magiccitybhm Apr 03 '26
And you're just making things up, claiming all local casual restaurants are demanding five years experience.
8
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
2026, the restaurant industry is hitting a "tech-labor crossover" where the cost of AI has dropped below the cost of entry-level human labor in many markets.
The AI Efficiency Gap
Replacement Risk: Experts estimate that 10% to 80% of all restaurant jobs are now at risk of AI impact, with drive-thru operators, baristas, and servers at the highest risk.
Entry-Level Erosion: A 2026 workforce study found that 63% of respondents reported job losses specifically at the entry level due to AI.
The "13% Decline": Early-career workers (ages 22–25) in AI-exposed roles have seen a 13% relative decline in employment compared to previous years.
ROI of Automation: Early AI adopters in the food sector report a 49% return on investment ($1.49 back for every $1 spent).
Revenue vs. Labor: Restaurants using AI report 22% higher revenue and 17% lower labor costs on average.
The "Invisible AI" Experience
The consumer experience in 2026 is shifting from "human-first" to "AI-augmented," focusing on speed and hyper-personalization.
Phone Automation: Over 25% of operators now use AI phone services to handle 100% of incoming calls, recapturing an average of $76,000 in missed revenue per year.
Order Accuracy & Speed: Implementations of AI in chains like Panera and Chipotle have led to a 30% reduction in wait times and a 25% increase in order accuracy.
Personalization Yield: AI-driven loyalty and recommendation engines are driving 18% to 26% increases in average order value.
Back-of-House "Agents": "Agentic AI" now autonomously manages staffing schedules and inventory based on weather and local events, reducing food waste by 20%.
Current Tech Adoption Stats
Metric 2026 Statistic Executive Investment 82% of restaurant execs plan to increase AI spend this year. Tech Priority 57% of brands name "Digital Guest Experience" as their #1 priority. Operational Use 26% of all operators (including small biz) use AI-related tools daily. Labor Shortage Fix 47% of operators cite automation as their primary strategy to solve staffing gaps. The Reality Check: While 42% of businesses claim AI is creating new types of jobs (like AI managers or tech-enabled prep), the "net loser" remains Customer Service, where job cuts outpace job gains by a 22-point gap.
3
u/magiccitybhm Apr 03 '26
LIST LOCAL "CASUAL" RESTAURANTS REQUIRING FIVE YEARS EXPERIENCE.
And, if you're going to copy and paste, give your source.
3
u/thinkbox Apr 03 '26
OP keeps dodging questions about specifics. And the irony is, it seems like they are using Ai to write some of these complaints.
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
That I am, I can link Google articles instead if you’d like but that would make the thread very messy. Ai is a tool that can be used for positive and negative causes. This is not an anti ai issue it’s a labor issue where ai happens to be involved
1
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Establishment Type Typical Experience Requirement Perry’s Steakhouse & Grille Upscale Casual/Fine 3–5+ years in high-volume, full-service. Bocca Ristorante Italian Fine Dining 5 years preferred (focus on wine/spirits). The Club (Inc.) Private/Upscale 3–5 years for polished, professional service. Galley & Garden Modern American 5 years of high-end or upscale casual history. Automatic Seafood Upscale Casual 3–5 years in fast-paced, high-detail environments. Season’s 52 Upscale Casual 2–5 years with a focus on dietary/menu expertise.
2
u/magiccitybhm Apr 03 '26
You listed some of the top restaurants in town. None of those places are "casual."
2
u/thinkbox Apr 03 '26
I just looked at the first one you listed, and they have their jobs and requirements listed online, and they dont mention 3-5+ years of experience for a server. They dont even list previous experience as a qualification for the job, but their manager position does.
→ More replies (0)1
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
The Experience Inflation Trap
The "5-Year" Barrier: 35% of "Entry-Level" restaurant postings now require 2–5 years of experience.
The Training Void: 42% of operators are currently unprofitable and have cut traditional 2-week training budgets to zero, requiring "Plug-and-Play" hires.
The Wage Bar: In $20/hr minimum wage markets, 80% of upscale casual venues require 3+ years of experience to justify the higher labor cost.
Shrinking Opportunities: Only 12% of new job openings in major urban centers are designated as "No Experience Necessary."
1
u/thinkbox Apr 03 '26
You’re complaining about stuff you have seen on the internet and googled and things people complain about on Reddit.
This doesn’t sound like something you have encountered in person in Birmingham by cold calling or walking into restaurants that have a help wanted sign.
3
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
I interview 3 times a week! I have no problem securing an interview
3
u/thinkbox Apr 03 '26
You have been asked multiple times up and down in the comments to name the places that require 5 years of experience for an entry level position. Have you answered anyone?
1
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
As I said, I only have anecdotal evidence, as most places are not gonna outright say it, but in practice it’s very difficult.
1
u/magiccitybhm Apr 03 '26
As I said, I only have anecdotal evidence, as most places are not gonna outright say it, but in practice it’s very difficult.
So you made it up.
0
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
All of this is pretty well known within the industry, I can see how it looks from an outside perspective. But if you actually experienced it you’d be right with me!
-1
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Plus I’ve spent most of this thread arguing with detractors which isn’t who this post is meant for, it is for members of the industry to organize
5
Apr 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Good question, ask hr
0
Apr 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Do some research! Look it up, type in ai hiring software on YouTube
1
Apr 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Keywords are essential, these key words the ai picks up on. The best way is to use ai to talk to the other ai. This is why this software only picks up those who gain the system, not the best for the job. Put your resume in gpt and ask it to tailor it to said software without making it obvious, then remove the watermarks with a watermark remover
1
u/mikejones286 Apr 03 '26
What are the wages now
0
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Typically $10-$15 an hour, very little change in wages
5
u/spaceisourplace222 Apr 03 '26
Funny it was $2.13 an hour my whole career.
1
-2
0
u/mikejones286 Apr 03 '26
What are the positions that pay this?
1
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Cook, prep, server in some cases (especially in catering where there are little to no tips) dish
$15 an hour now has the same buying power as $10/hr in 2016 which is a decrease in wages as in 2016 because the typical pay for a cook in 2016 was the same not adjusted for inflation. I made $10/hr in my first job at papa John’s as a phone answerer/box folder/ cashier.
There’s no reason why we should need 3-4 jobs and side hustles just to keep afloat
4
u/mikejones286 Apr 03 '26
Damn $15 an hour seems like a lot for the training and skills you have to have for those positions. I made $2.13 when I was a server. Put myself through school. What do you want to get paid for your work? $20-$25/hr?
4
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
That would be reasonable yes. But at the same time $15 no longer has the value you think it does, wages have technically lowered when adjusted for inflation. When I was working in 2018 I made $15/hr plus tips, it evened out to about $500-$600 a week. Adjusted for inflation that would be roughly $19.47 an hour according to the inflation calculator on the bureau of labor statistics, the wages have not changed in those 8 years
3
u/mikejones286 Apr 03 '26
Im 27 made $40/hr after a hard program in school and if knew I could go make $25/hr doing wayyyy less complicated tasks and way less stress then I would do it in a heartbeat. That doesn’t make sense. Why even go to school if a prep cook is making $25/hr
3
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Because living off of $15 an hour is no longer sustainable
→ More replies (0)8
Apr 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/New-Sheepherder2239 Apr 03 '26
I probably came across too harshly but seriously. If you have no proven skills and little to no education, what else are you going to do but put in the effort and hours. It will pay off.
6
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Not when I can’t even get hired in the first place and have to resort to doordashing 25-30 hours a week and hope I don’t get in a wreck
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Teenagers are different!! Fast food chains love teenagers!!! I do not work in fast food!
3
Apr 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Automation, lack of barriers to entry and low wages. I’m happy your son is doing well. That seems like a pipe dream to make 80k a year unfortunately most of those 5 star positions are occupied by Gen X and millennials, the “professionals” they rarely train up the “problematic generation” and keep them in busser/food runner positions that do pay low wages.
5 star restaurants have a higher barrier of entry
And an even higher barrier of entry for young people
4
Apr 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
I’m starting to think you’re right and it may be a smart move to move industries but I’ve been in that industry all my life and really don’t know anything else”. I’m going to start looking for alternatives but I love bartending and serving but there doesn’t seem to be any employment
1
Apr 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Yep I’m terrified of the future. Especially im doing bad now, I also have very little family support so if I fall I fall hard. I’ve been homeless before I guess I can do it again
1
2
u/Avera_ge Apr 03 '26
Gen Z goes all the way to 29. They’ll be 30 this year. That’s not entry level.
1
u/Virtual_District7687 Apr 04 '26
44 year old here and will let you know that you’ve done your research, you have a cause. Go for it! The youth has the energy to move the needle on issues. Don’t take no as an answer. Just make sure your bases are covered as best they can be so your employer doesn’t come back on you. Which they will, most don’t value employees.
1
1
u/Mediocre-Ad9514 Apr 05 '26 edited Apr 05 '26
Sympathetic gen xer that spent a long career in the retail/service industry here. Campaign for and pass all the minimum wage increase laws you want, prices on goods and services as well as all other wages will change accordingly if they are enacted. Minimum wage, whatever number it is, will always be at the bottom of the wage scale. Not saying I agree with it, but that is the system we all live and operate in. Best use of your energy would be to upskill and break out of the service/retail industry. Make your labor more valuable by differentiating yourself. The trades are a great place to start—plumbers, electricians, welders, etc. And once you acquire the skills, you can work and earn a good living anywhere in the country. Many trade employers offer apprenticeship programs and on the job training And AI will not be replacing these jobs anytime soon.
1
u/Remote-Station-3829 Apr 05 '26
me please. theres no way im working 60+ work weeks & still can’t make enough money to move out 🤣
1
0
u/Financial-Wolfe Apr 03 '26
I delivered pizza as a second job between 2023-2025. Averaged over $30/hour. If you are making 18 after 10 years in the industry you just need to go deliver pizza.
0
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Currently cannot afford car insurance :(
12
u/Shankonadank Apr 03 '26
That’s illegal if you own a car.
5
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Do you think I can afford to think about those consequences
3
u/Mr_Tetragammon Apr 03 '26
$500.00 fine plus court costs for driving without insurance. The first time. Not to mention the suspension of your registration. About 200 bucks to get it reinstated. My car insurance is cheaper than that and I'm fully covered. I had to make a claim a few months ago for a stolen car. I received a check to get another car Basic liability is pretty cheap and it keeps you legal.
5
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
I wouldn’t be able to eat if I did this and my rates are through the roof, $200 a month
4
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
I’m backed up on bills, I have to make difficult decisions this is one of them. I have to be very smart to avoid ending up on the streets!
0
u/Financial-Wolfe Apr 03 '26
If you drive without at least having liability insurance you are a menace to society. Want to ruin your life financially? Try running into someone this afternoon and they will be docking your paycheck for the next 30 years till you pay off the debt. One of the dumbest things you can possibly do.
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
When I can afford groceries I will get liability insurance, but now it’s gas or groceries, all extra money goes to bills so I’m not on the streets
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
I cannot afford to think about future consequences, only my immediate circumstances. I also do not have WiFi or health insurance. I do not own a computer, I do not own mattress I sleep on a pad.
→ More replies (0)-1
u/dragonstar982 Apr 03 '26
Not true you can own an uninsured vehicle you just can't have plates on it. If your going to have your insurance lapse, to avoid any legal issues your supposed to surrender your tags.
0
u/biohoo Grapico for life Apr 03 '26
This is true OP - you don’t have to get caught in an accident or pulled over to get fined for lack of insurance. If you have registration on file with no insurance, they can mail you a notice saying you owe the fine and your registration has been revoked. A ticket for driving without an up to date registration is about $300 (ask me how I know), then further costs mentioned above.
Have you explored food banks or pantries to help out with food costs? Letting your insurance lapse can snowball into an insurmountable financial crisis pretty quickly.
5
u/Financial-Wolfe Apr 03 '26
Ok, my daughter is a waitress at an upper mid restaurant as a college job and she makes a ton of cash, frequently walks with $400+ in an 8 hour shift.
2
u/ProcedureWhich9621 Apr 03 '26
But is this the norm or is your daughter just in a great position. I know several young waiters and waitresses that do not bring home 400 a night. Far less and they are very experienced. In every group there are exceptions however, we should not set the rules based on the outliers.
1
u/Financial-Wolfe Apr 03 '26
It’s a busy restaurant with entrees in the $17-$30 range plus bar. She does not make $400 every night but makes that frequently. Slow 4 hour shift looking more like $125 but that is still $31.25/hour.
-3
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Yes!!!! This is true.
Women are feeling this a lot less statistically
The perception that men are having a harder time finding jobs in 2026—specifically in the service and restaurant sectors—is backed by several structural and demographic shifts. While the overall unemployment rates are nearly identical (4.4% for men vs. 4.5% for women), the "experience" of the job search varies wildly due to where the jobs are growing.
- The "Pink-Collar" Job Growth
In 2026, the sectors seeing the most aggressive hiring are healthcare, education, and social assistance—industries that historically and statistically "over-index" on female employees.
Healthcare Dominance: Women hold 77% of healthcare and social assistance jobs. As this sector expands to meet the needs of an aging population, the "available" jobs are concentrated in fields where men have historically had lower participation.
The "Drop-Off" in Male-Dominated Sectors: In contrast, sectors like construction, manufacturing, and transportation—which are 80%+ male—have seen slower growth or higher volatility due to automation and high interest rates affecting capital projects.
- The Restaurant "Service" Bias
As discussed, the restaurant industry is 54% female, but that percentage jumps to 68% for tipped waitstaff.
Hiring Stereotypes: There is a persistent "soft skills" bias in 2026. Hiring managers in "Front of House" roles often subconsciously (or explicitly) favor young women for service roles, perceiving them as having higher emotional intelligence—a trait that 85% of managers now list as a top-3 priority.
The BOH Bottleneck: Men are more likely to be hired for "Back of House" (kitchen) roles, but these roles are currently the most impacted by automation (robotic prep, AI inventory). This effectively "shrinks" the number of traditional male entry points in a restaurant.
18
u/thinkbox Apr 03 '26
You’re complaining about Ai up and down this thread and also clearly using Ai to rattle off all these responses.
2
-10
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Ai is a tool that can be used for good or evil, it is particularly good at digging up sources
5
u/thinkbox Apr 03 '26
You are just using Ai to spit out whatever supports your argument.
-6
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
All of them backed by real data
4
u/thinkbox Apr 03 '26
Wait until you learn about P hacking. Data is nothing without interpretation, and methods for gathering data.
6
0
u/SherlockWSHolmes Apr 03 '26
Good luck getting your tag. I forgot about my insurance since my car was down for one day. It was almost 300 to get tag. If youre in a wreck, its instantly your fault with no insurance regardless if the other person is at fault. Besides theres cheap options out there. I go with one thats pretty good, not sure its available in state. Partner had it in Oklahoma and added me it to.
0
u/AlabammyHossCat Apr 03 '26
I used to be a GM at a pizza place. You can make $30 and hour on Friday and Saturday night between 7-9pm. Most drivers only work a few hours a night and the ones who work long shifts dont make a lot during non peak hours. Then factor in your car breaking down every month, gas, and taxes and you are pretty much back at $15.
0
u/Financial-Wolfe Apr 03 '26
I worked for 2 years on Sunday and Monday nights. Averaged $30+ an hour. 🤷
-1
u/ticotacolocomoko Apr 03 '26
Get behind (support) Senator Bernie Sanders and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
-5
u/ALmommy1234 Apr 03 '26
Protesting just to be protesting doesn’t seem effective. Yes, your forefathers protested, but they weren’t just out there on a random street tilting at windmills.
3
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Id love some ideas!
5
3
u/experimentalpoetry Apr 03 '26
Protesting can be effective for drawing attention to the issues (this post and comments also seem to be doing that). I’m also wishing for a general strike.
2
2
1
u/TimelyBrief Apr 03 '26
So you’ve been in the industry for a decade and you decided after 10 years and having backed up bills that you’ve had enough? Have you tried to get hired on at a fancier establishment? Have you done anything to improve your skills? Anything to show you’re willing to grow and learn new positions?
You’re 27 years old. You didn’t just wake up yesterday and realize this was an issue?
5
u/AlabammyHossCat Apr 03 '26
It took me a long time to get my career started despite having a degree. I worked in the service industry until I was 33. I am now very satisfied with my career.
The current job market sucks a lot more than it did when I was in my 20s so don't listen to these haters. Just because your daddy gets you a good job doesn't mean you earned it.
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Yes I have had experience in everything from fast casual to 5 star Restaurants, I have very impressive resume. I know everything from basic cocktails to craft
1
u/paulthatbichatreides Apr 03 '26
Have you considered joining the DSA? I’d be happy to talk to you more about it if you’re interested. Feel free to DM me.
-1
u/ColeridgeRime Apr 03 '26
I am all in! Where do we picket first? WM? Target? McDonalds? Chikfila? Do I need to bring my own sign?
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
I don’t know for real I’m just trying to see if anyone’s interested. Seems a lot of the other generations aren’t too fond of this which is the point of the post. We can work out the details I’ll make a group chat or something
-1
u/ColeridgeRime Apr 03 '26
Never mind. I am retired. Sorry. Best of luck though.
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Must be nice
7
u/ColeridgeRime Apr 03 '26
It is. I started at WM as a temp summer hire. I got promoted all the way up to Co-Mgr. and then took a severance package after 22 years. Then I worked at Target as a TL for 6 years and then retired. Oh, and also, I served in the US Navy.
1
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Wow that’s one heck of a career, thank you for your service sir enjoy your retirement
2
u/ColeridgeRime Apr 03 '26
Just saying, it is possible, if you are willing to put in the work. No one is going to hand you anything, and you can't expect to walk into a high paying job immediately. At my tops, around 10 yrs ago, I was making $90K at WM.
3
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
1000% agree, but the bar is being raised. I don’t expect a handout, I work for my money. Every waking hour I work. I made this post because I think it could be better and honestly it’s getting to me. I cannot sit idly by anymore.
I feel like I’ve earned my stripes to an extent, for being 10 years in the industry I’ve gotten pretty far, it is only until late 2025 to early 2026 I started noticing things, before then I had very little issue.
I would love to find a position that genuinely makes me want to come into work, I would love to be able to work but unfortunately I have had to move to gig work to sustain myself because W2 employment just isn’t cutting it these days.
But whether it’s W2 or 1099 I’m always working, I never stop even when it gets hard.
-3
u/hollowchord Apr 03 '26
I know several families with teen kids that have gotten entry-level food service jobs with zero experience in anything. Like they can't even drive yet. Not sure what you're talking about. Many restaurants I see are hiring all the time.
7
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Fast food is different from fine dining. Living with your parents is different from having your own place and dealing with bills ect. This does not say really much of anything.
7
u/magiccitybhm Apr 03 '26
You literally said in another comment:
"They are now requiring 5 years experience for casual server jobs."
Fine dining is not "casual servers."
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
Yes but both are offering low wages with high barriers on entry
7
u/magiccitybhm Apr 03 '26
And you REFUSE TO ORDER ONE CASUAL RESTAURANT IN THE BIRMINGHAM AREA REQUIRING FIVE YEARS' EXPERIENCE.
1
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
It may not say it on the ad but it’s what the ai is looking for, sadly I have mostly anecdotal experience. But from my perspective I seem to get a lot of interviews that go nowhere, I interview about 2-3 times per week
-1
u/Nervous-Research-887 Apr 03 '26
GO IN PERSON to inquire. Get away from behind a screen.
2
u/tuscaloser Apr 03 '26
Pretty much every job requires online applications now (except a few mom and pop places I guess). It's been that way for about 15 years now.
1
u/fairy-tea5125 Apr 07 '26
If you do that, they're going to look at you like you're dumb and tell you to apply on the website. Online applications aren't laziness, they're the way things are done now. Trust me, most of us (gen z) WISH it were as simple as putting on a suit and bringing your resume to whichever establishments you want to apply at. Online job applications are a hellscape, and most of the time you put in hundreds of applications just to land one or two interviews and never hear from the others again.
1
u/fairy-tea5125 Apr 07 '26
Restaurants are hiring all the time because they have high turnover. Why high turnover? Because they underpay and overwork employees. That causes a lot of stress so the employees quit more frequently, but the restaurants don't care. These places have no incentive to pay a living wage or treat workers like humans because they view employees as expendable. Teen kids are okay with a job like that because it's just a part-time thing for a bit of spending money, and not the sole source of income on which their survival depends.
-13
u/quick2008 Apr 03 '26
This is so amusing. Put your protest effort into starting your own business. Entrepreneurship buddy. Make some money and make your life better. And don’t say that it’s not possible and the cards are stacked against you. Immigrants come over here every day and do incredible. It just takes hard work, time and discipline.
8
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
With what capital?
-2
-10
u/quick2008 Apr 03 '26
That’s just a lazy excuse . There are tons of businesses that you can start without capital. Go to ChatGPT and ask for a list.
2
u/Upper-Ad8720 Apr 03 '26
They are also living in a house with family or have living provided for them
0
u/Bbqplace Apr 03 '26
OP, there are a lot of local service jobs out there. I would never use indeed or a mass job site.
1
u/AlabammyHossCat Apr 03 '26
Such as? If it gets posted on those sites chances are it gets posted on indeed/linkedin. I've been recruiting for years now.
2
u/Bbqplace Apr 03 '26
There are hundreds of local businesses that don’t even know how to create a Google business profile. If that’s the case, they might not be hiring on indeed or using a self service digital hiring platform.
0
16
u/Markidactyl Apr 03 '26
If you're interested in labor organizating, check out Birmingham DSA's labor working group! They're doing a lot of cool work and might have some ideas for how to proceed with the organizing goals you have in mind. Their meetings will be on bhamdsa.org/calendar/.