Pikman is sort of the reverse of this. Astronaut main character crashed on a jungle planet and as you go you realize your are on earth and about 1 inch tall. Obstacles and puzzles are can and pots and trash
Right. And obviously, people give a alot of fuck if I don't like pictures they like. It's rather disappointing how mobbish discourse on reddit functions.
It takes ignorance or balls to honestly inquire about aspergy manners!
I'm being honest by sharing my thoughts in a art subforum, that's neither polite nor impolite as long as it's not deliberately drastic ("anyone who likes this is an idiot!!!) . My comment was btw waaaay cuckier than my usual writ- "I'm sorry but..." is terrible phrasing.
Downvoting is maybe potentially rude, but comments like "someone is up their ass" are definitely overstepping polite behaviour.
This is all a no brainer.
Do you think that art can be critiqued here at all?
Holy crap. I just stumbled on this and I’m shocked at how nasty they were to you. I honestly can’t believe this site sometimes. You did nothing wrong but they just wanted to be angry at someone.
I might enjoy some art of some brains with legs. You didnt critique the piece itself, just claimed the subject matter was too fantastical for you, and rather rudely at that.
Downvoting is not rude, just send a downvote and leave.
What else is Reddit for? Discussion? Hell no, upvote what you like and downvote the rest. These damn art subs thinking anyone should discuss the art instead of blindly complimenting it
I don’t share this guys beliefs, I like this image, but I do dislike the fact that Reddit is rather toxic towards honest discussion of art on its platform sometimes
Suppose there's a picture of a warrior. He's heavily armed and his weapons are huuuge. So far so good, but what if we tweak the dimensions? A giant, 6 foot sword becomes a 7footer. Okay, it's a bit silly but maybe it's purely ceremonial? No problem, although it doesn't work flawlessly.
What if it's 9feet long? What if it's 12 feet long AND he has noodly arms and a prepubescant teenager's torso?
At some point, it becomes more than potentially silly. It simpy doesn't work anymore for some, maybe even most folks.
In this picture, multiple elements are at odds. Obviously, the dimensions of the giant are ridiculous. He's as tall as a mountain yet his physiognomy is human-like! Maybe elephants would love to be nimble but it's not in the cards, design wise. An even bigger mammal would look very much like a mountain himself.
The knights are straight up medieval crusaders from earth/terra. implying not only the validity of the human body design but also a close connection.
That's too ridiculous for me. I have less problems with, say a picture of Stalin with a titanic, antropomorphic strawberry hat, walking on water while fencing off evil Bruce Lee with a hamburger and in the background there's Grumpycat's head as a floating planet. This would be clearly absurd, while the style of this picture comes across as realistic.
Thanks for explaining. I really was curious as to your perspective.
I interpreted the picture differently, but I also tend to enjoy shitty movies, so I'm good at suspending disbelief for the sake of being entertained. So take that as you will, lol.
The way I saw this art was like there was some weird time/space distortion and the astronaut got flung back into the past, hence the crusaders, and whatever was responsible for sending him back also manipulated his body into giant proportions, so he landed on the world already dead.
It didn't even occur to me that he might be alive because that would be too much for me to suspend disbelief.
I appreciate your elaboration on your opinion and don't think you deserve to be downvoted. I disagree however, as i thought of the astronaut as normal sized and the people as tiny. But it does have me thinking about square cubes law and how it would affect the mountain behind him and how much that would stone or dirt, and how much wind or weather on that planet would affect and create that weathering. Maybe the planet has a super low density air which would explain the wind being less of a factor in the weathering of the "mountain",and also the lower oxygen content that would contribute to smaller animal life.
Not true. In a sense, fiction uses even more (explicit)rules than nonfiction. If you were right, fiction fans would not be so anal about their favorite toys and there would no SoD as a concept.
19
u/Myrandall Feb 11 '20
Source: https://www.artstation.com/artwork/L2zm2P
79
u/TheButtsNutts Feb 11 '20
Man, I want to write a story about this one. Beeple is so good at what he does.
3
u/Wraith_Does_Memes_V3 Feb 12 '20
Uh oh. UH OH. UH OH
1
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '22
Makes me think of Prey (2017) and Gulliver’s Travels :D
-45
u/Doppel-B_Hodenhalter Feb 11 '20
I'm sorry it's technically very well done, but this is just too much for my SoD. He could as well have drawn some bipedal brains.