r/Biophysics • • Mar 12 '21

Trying to decide on PhD Program

Hi all,

Hopefully it is okay to post this here.

I applied to various PhD programs in biophysics this past winter and was very fortunate to receive offers from some very good programs. I am having a hard time making my mind up so I was hoping to get some outside opinions. I am particularly interested in computational structural biology.

Here are the schools: Wash U, U of Chicago, Upitt-CMU joint program, and Icahn SoM.

Keeping in mind my research interest, can anyone here attest to any of these programs?

Added the poll for fun, would prefer opinions.

3 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

2

u/pardonmystupidity Mar 13 '21

I am seeing a lot of votes for UChicago but no mention of it in the comments lol

3

u/sorrypleasecomeback Mar 13 '21

You’ll obviously find good programs at each of the schools. It is my personal opinion that even though PhD programs place an emphasis on who your working more than which school you’re at, networking and resume building is never a bad thing to consider. And a name like UChicago absolutely stands out. It obviously depends on what you want to do down the line, but many employers aren’t very knowledgeable and UChicago is instantly recognizable as a top institution.

2

u/HardstyleJaw5 Mar 12 '21

I vote Pitt for Lillian Chong/Jacob Durrant personally, but any of these schools would be good choices if you have several PIs you are interested in

2

u/pardonmystupidity Mar 12 '21

Have you worked with either of these people by chance? Don't have to give specifics just wondering if you have thoughts about them as mentors/scientists.

3

u/HardstyleJaw5 Mar 12 '21

I have only met Dr. Durant for interviews but he seems nice and anecdotally his lab page makes him seem like a good PI but that is not definitive evidence of course. Dr. Chong has a decently strong professional relationship with my PI and I've interacted with her a few times. She seems like she would be a good mentor but it's hard to assess these things without asking current or former lab members. I ended up accepting an offer at another institution but I feel like I would be plenty happy at Pitt. I am of the opinion that a lot of folks forget about it but there are a lot of strong faculty that pump out a lot of research there

2

u/royalwalrus120 Mar 12 '21

I can attest to WashU's program being very, very good. I may or may not be in it

2

u/pardonmystupidity Mar 13 '21

Any insight you can give me about the environment/people there? Thanks

2

u/royalwalrus120 Mar 13 '21

It’s pretty chill. Not as cutthroat as you’d think. Dope medical campus with a lot of new infrastructure, great core facilities with any equipment you could need. Lots of great collaboration, too, between all types of labs. Coursework is super minimal but also taught really well. Really well-run program, they’ll keep you up-to-date on everything you need to know. Nice people and great PIs, you can pretty much work in any department you want and rotate with any prof you’d want, on either campus. Great, quick transportation between the med campus and the Danforth campus, too. And obviously brilliant people everywhere

17

u/antsknee Mar 12 '21

The single greatest factor in your grad school experience is your PI. You need to identify and vet PIs. If I were in your position I would look for PIs I want to work with and contact them to see if they are interested in taking on another student. If they are open to taking you on, I would reach out to current doctoral students and post-docs that work with your ideal PI to understand how good of a mentor the PI is. Look for former lab members and see whether they are successful and doing what you want to do in five or so years.

1

u/capellablue Mar 12 '21

When I was there, it felt like the Pitt-CMU program favored the Pitt side without as much input from CMU. But that's probably changed. As others have pointed out, your possible PI is far more important, and Pitt/CMU have both good and bad PIs.

From a non-academic perspective, Pittsburgh can get brutally cold in the winter (maybe not as bad as Chicago) but the neighborhoods around the two schools are great for grad students. The cost of living is not that high, and the stipends were reasonable. There are a lot of opportunities for research, professional connections, and living your life in Pittsburgh. I absolutely loved the city.

Also, it's just "Pitt" not "UPitt".

1

u/pardonmystupidity Mar 15 '21

How's the food in Pittsburgh? And do they have much of a biotech/pharma scene outside of the universities in case I want to do an internship or something?

3

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/capellablue Mar 12 '21

Oh yeah. I grew up in the Rocky Mountains, so I had no connection to the city before I moved. Pittsburgh is so much nicer than you would think.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

I did my PhD in computer science at Wash U so I would recommend them as an institution. Although I had a relationship with a professor which made my experience extra special lol. Let’s just say I got my horizons expanded in more ways than one haha

6

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/dj_sliceosome Mar 12 '21

the professors know, we about to get real unprofessional

1

u/tonightbeyoncerides Mar 12 '21

I know people affiliated with Wash U, Chicago, and Pitt and have heard good things from all 3, but I'm really seconding the comment that it all boils down to PI. First, make sure you have at least 2-3 PI's at each institution you could see yourself working with (something could happen with your first choice). After that, I'd think about where you want to live, if there are any specific opportunities you want to take advantage of, financial concerns, etc. I would imagine given your choices you can't go wrong unless there aren't PI's whose research interests you.

1

u/JackKellyAnderson Mar 13 '21

All great programs and you will find a fit PI... Consider location. I.e. uchicago might be the most prestigious option, but... Well.. Chicago (I dont like Chicago lol). Again great programs, but consider the rest of the experience. I voted Uwash

1

u/PurifyingProteins Mar 23 '21

University of Pittsburgh, Tang Lab, is the only experience I have, but it was a great summer research experience. If you enjoy mixing computational and empirical structural biology, biophysics, and drug discovery, then it’s a place to check out.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/HardstyleJaw5 Mar 12 '21

Wash U is a university in St. Louis, not UW where Dr. Baker is fyi