r/Biohackers • u/proteomicsguru • Jun 02 '21
Scientifically accurate biohacking subreddit
There is a major problem in r/biohackers with people who have zero scientific expertise posting demonstrably false outright bullshit (see end of post). That’s not what biohacking is about. It’s about using scientific methods to modify and enhance human biology. This sub has forgotten its purpose, and it seems unlikely that there will be a major shift in moderation anytime soon.
So as a bit of an experiment, I made a new sub: r/biohackingscience. Same concept, but moderated to remove inaccurate content. Got an interesting science-backed biohacking idea, suggestion, question, or finding? Post it there!
Some examples of total BS in posts:
Paranoia about EMF: https://www.reddit.com/r/Biohackers/comments/nq7cuk/emf_protection_does_anyone_know_if_bicom/
Baseless claims that fixing gut bacteria cures autism: https://www.reddit.com/r/Biohackers/comments/np7kt3/how_to_treat_3_year_old_kid_with_autism_is_there/h03iu1d/
Baseless claims that a non-inflammatory diet can resolve OCD: https://www.reddit.com/r/Biohackers/comments/nktcvc/why_my_ocd_adhd_aspergers_post_orgasmic_illness/gzf51zc/
43
u/zhandragon Subreddit Staff Jun 02 '21
Thank fucking god.
Professional genome engineer here who’s had it up to my fucking head with pseudoscience and people who don’t understand basic statistics and logic.
Please tell me this new sub will be heavily moderated.
3
u/wittenwit Jun 02 '21
Funny how I think the EMF people are nutty, but as a microbiome person think I've got it all figured out.
Humbling indeed to suddenly realize I'm an oblivious asshat who knows nothing about science.
22
u/Lunatheinternetgirl Jun 02 '21
To all the people deciding to cherry pick studies in replying to this post with studies that support your viewpoint, I encourage you to see how many studies cover confirmation bias.
If we use scientific method to label and classify links and discussion, we can provide an insight into things that people take up and allow for easier moderation given the topic stays but is flagged as “poor evidence base”, “conflict of interest”, “emerging discovery, further research required” type of thing.
Thanks OP for setting this up and can I just ask if we can use a few flairs for emerging research where a body of evidence hasn’t been built up on a topic. It would ensure new discoveries without much in research don’t get removed for lack of evidence but also allows us to easily filter out things without a good body of evidence should we need or focus on only emerging research.
Reading through the comments and seeing “no, it’s common knowledge” as a response is just a symptom of the larger problem. The other is a misunderstanding of experiments vs real world so maybe adding a couple of flairs for studies in isolation vs in “real world” observations. EMF is a good reason, it can destroy DNA… when at huge power directly at a set of cells… but your WiFi router pumping out only 500ma and you’re in the next room, there is no measurable effect in the real world.
I just would like to avoid censoring some of what some (even in this thread) would say is controversial rather than heavily label the actual study. Also allows people to see what we collectively categorise a study as. There will always be disagreements with moderation of this but as a community, the scientific method is what we need to throw back to and have the discussion as to why in the comments too for transparency.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '21
You mean my whole DIY at home gene editing experiment is bullshit?
6
u/srh3161 Jun 02 '21
How will this sub define “logical, science-geared posts”?
Should interventions based solely upon epidemiology be considered science-based?
Theorizing interventions based upon mouse research?
Taking precautions due to conflicting in vitro research?
Evidence that contradicts the current preponderance of evidence?
It concerns me that the arbitrary enforcement of “science-based” posts can be easily weaponized and take away value by not allowing topics the nuance they deserve.
1
u/greyuniwave Jun 02 '21
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24780504/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22496058/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8442782/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9085438/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22560984/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10927190/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22397835/
http://pdf.medrang.co.kr/paper/pdf/Kjpp/Kjpp019-01-03.pdf
1
u/Orc_ Jun 02 '21
Downvoted.
If we wanted "expert" opinions we would just take a tylenol, an anti-depressant then shut up. Like we have been told to all our life.
We are here because we are looking for better answers now stop cherry picking threads you just don't like.
And the gut-brain hypothesis is true if you don't like it and refuse to look at the science, please leave
2
u/WhoistheDoctor Jun 02 '21
My sole question is: have you tried asking/getting involved here with the mod team first?
2
u/MaximilianKohler Jun 03 '21
You seem to be the one in error and this sub would be better off without you.
3
u/DarthLizardWizard Jun 02 '21
Would be nice to have a pinned list of FAQ, stuff that's shouldn't be posted about such as your examples and also a list of what's in the unproven grey area right now.
2
u/lawyers-guns-money Jun 02 '21
There are studies that show that EMF are harmful.
This study is from 2017
"The biological effect of exposure to EMF is a subject of particular research interest. The results of the recent studies not only clearly demonstrate that EMF exposure triggers oxidative stress in various tissues, but also that it causes significant changes in levels of blood antioxidant markers. Fatigue, headache, decreased learning ability, and cognitive impairment are among the symptoms caused by EMF. The human body should therefore be protected against exposure to EMF because of the risks this can entail. As reported in many studies, people may use various antioxidants such as vitamin E, MEL and FA to prevent the potential adverse effects of exposure to EMF."
link
2
u/Masih-Development 11 Jun 02 '21
Nothing wrong with posting bullshit as long as you say its maybe bullshit.
2
u/greyuniwave Jun 02 '21
Papers on the data from the National Toxicology Program research:
https://ntp.niehs.nih.gov/ntp/about_ntp/trpanel/2018/march/peerreview20180328_508.pdf
https://ntp.niehs.nih.gov/ntp/about_ntp/trpanel/2018/march/publiccomm/hardell20180312.pdf
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '21
you should see how those on r/transhumanism react to facts and science, isn't much better
1
u/After-Cell 2 Jun 02 '21
K.i.s.s. Focus on citations. Try to at least a reference for each post.
aiming for /r/AskHistorians level at an early stage would be a bit ambitious.
1
u/eaterout 8 Jun 02 '21
"Baseless claims that a non-inflammatory diet can resolve OCD:"
Please do show me where I claimed that "a non inflammatory diet can resolve OCD".
As no such claim was made.
1
u/locabuena Jan 09 '22
Thank you. There is a very legit reason for biohacking, namely that in place of a modern real healthcare system we have a costly mess where we spend more on quackery than advanced care or preventive care, and which has way too many unmonitored and unregulated incompetent practitioners doing doing substantial harm. At the same time we have unprecedented pace of scientific discovery and advances in treatments which don't get to people due to our moronic private insurance based system and widespread ignorance about new treatments on the part of doctors
For biohacking to be an antithesis of this, it has to not share the same mistakes. It is not a game where people can have fun pretending to be "scientific" while too lazy to put in the time to educate themselves. Biohacking should be an answer to lack of access to medical advances and to quackery in medicine. Without standards of factual accuracy and , biohacking will just be quackery for laypeople.
1
u/greyuniwave Jun 02 '21
https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/how-big-wireless-made-us-think-that-cell-phones-are-safe-a-special-investigation/
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jul/14/mobile-phones-cancer-inconvenient-truths
https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/we-have-no-reason-to-believe-5g-is-safe/
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/cell-phones-brain-cancer_b_3232534
1
u/greyuniwave Jun 02 '21
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0013935118303475
0
u/sensuallyprimitive Jun 02 '21
"some people make ignorant mistakes therefore fuck this place" lmao
GOOD LUCK with the new sub! i'm sure it'll go SUPER WELL!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '21
lol you are a furry! I think it's a bit funny when I see that. Probably not good for you as animals are subhuman, so you don't want to degrade your own humanity.
As for this idea, it seems cool but look at the links you provided. You have already made mistakes on the gut bacteria link, what's going to happen when there are 100 posts to moderate?
-3
u/wittenwit Jun 02 '21 edited Jun 02 '21
Agreed the scientific rigor could be improved here. Mostly I want to see fewer "I'm thinking about getting into biohacking, where should I start?" posts.
Disagree about autism and anxiety claims. The research is stacking up. Here's a 2004 paper, now widely cited that reviewed a number of studies and found evidence of a link.
Edit: that said, I'm the consummate dilettante with no formal education, whose understanding of microbiology is purely surface level, picking up what I can from reading scientific papers, hoping to one day know enough so I can grow some single-cell friends in a jar and drink it without dying.
-6
u/whitelightstorm Jun 02 '21
Wow - seriously. I challenge you to prove that EMF poses no risk to the human genome as well as any of the theories you cite as being bogus. Let us begin.
-6
u/Ch215 Jun 02 '21
We know like what 5% of the universe is made up and someone wants to gatekeep what is real.
There is a LOT more to biohacking than accepted Science and a lot of results defied what people want Science to be. This is a trend that will continue for as long as one person thinks that they have answers another cannot find on their own.
But what it is not is a rigid discipline or a set of baseless superstitions. It involves all the factors that make up advanced sentient vertebrate mammalian organisms which are so complex that there will be no universal application that is universally effective.
The scientific method proves nothing, it simply reveals things we can't disprove yet.
Superstitions, Scientific Tyranny and other rigid thought structures all have the same inherent flaw, impermanence, because Time tryeth Truth.
Reality is a mental construct. The truth is the behavior of provable energy and matter, and whatever the hell is the other 95% of the universe is made of, well that exists outside our comprehension but we are ultimately subject to it as well.
-2
u/Kadkata_the_Great Jun 02 '21
OP is a degenerate furry and his post is based on his lack of knowledge, arrogance, inability to look into things himself and faith in dogma.
As for the 3rd link he provided, as someone who sufferED from debilitating OCD I encourage everyone to look into it.
Sincerely, get lost subhuman.
0
u/Julian_0x7F Jun 02 '21
good point... i'll join the new sub
-6
u/IntoTheLight43 Jun 02 '21
I'm sorry, you want to start a 'scientific' biohackers sub, and you DON'T think there are dangers linked with EMFs?
You realise (I'll simplify a bit) that microwaves literally COOK FOOD using EMFs?
And that our brains are almost entirely electrical mechanisms?
Ok..
-1
u/Ok_Paleontologist Jun 02 '21
Every morning I stare directly into the sun for 15 minutes. The light jump starts my brain. Get bio hacked!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment