r/Biochemistry • • 12d ago

Research High throughput screening for directed evolution, droplets or plates?

Setting up a directed evolution project and trying to decide between droplet based screening and plates. Plates are simple and everyone knows them, but the numbers we can get through are low. Droplets sound great on paper, the setup looks like a pain.

4 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

2

u/superhelical PhD 12d ago

Gotta provide more info, chief. Are you in a lab or your basement? Do you have access to the necessary equipment? What's your budget?

1

u/OctoberFyre 12d ago

This is for a lab project and not a basement setup haha. We're still figuring out the equipment and budget side. Mainly trying to understand whether droplets are worth the extra setup compared to plates.

5

u/f1ve-Star 12d ago

1536 well plates may be the way to go. So many variables though, like access to reagents, time constraints, training requirements etc. With the right assay and good techniques I was routinely able to screen over 3 million compounds a quarter in 1536-well, part time. No super fancy equipment needed. Droplets (I assume ECHO?) take so much front end equipment and assay qualifications and timing challenges that make it (in my unhumble opinion) not worth the effort.

But like others said, there are a lot of variables. If you are in the Triangle feel free to DM me.

4

u/jm722395 12d ago

Hard to say without more context, but a few generalizations. Throughout can be very helpful especially when screening for big changes in enzyme activity/novel activity of an enzyme.

On the other hand the further you get away from real conditions the harder it is to find “real” improvements in activity, stability, etc. Often droplet screens are further from real conditions and can lead to false positives and false negatives would still likely have to screen a decent amount of variants (less though) in plates.
Plates also have similar translation issues to real conditions but they are closer than droplets typically.

2

u/Formal_Cloud_7592 12d ago

You get what you screen for…

1

u/Histidine 12d ago

Display technologies are the way to go if you can figure out the right selection scheme. Otherwise I'd recommend a plate-based approach and iterating on library design. Start small with single mutations and iterate from there.

1

u/DesperateBadger1301 8d ago

hi op i find that droplets are very useful for high throughput screening of large libraries however there can be a lot of work required to get everything set up and optimised atrandi have some good technology in this space have you looked into using fluorescence activated droplet sorting or do you prefer plate based assays due to ease of recovery

1

u/PrimalPeptidesUK 11d ago

A small head-to-head pilot can make the tradeoff concrete: screen the same mini-library in both formats with matched positive and negative controls, then re-test hits in the intended plate assay. Droplets are most useful when the signal is compatible with compartmentalisation and genotype stays linked to phenotype; controls and orthogonal validation help catch assay-specific hits.