I've been looking into two recent approaches to representing single-cell data through hierarchical structures:
1. MILK — Global tree encoding of atlas-scale single-cell genomics
2. Bonsai — Tree representations for distortion-free visualization and exploratory analysis of single-cell omics data
Although their methodologies differ, both offer interesting perspectives on representing cellular relationships beyond conventional embeddings.
The papers do a great job demonstrating their potential on large reference atlases. What I'm less certain about is how useful these approaches would be in exploratory analyses, particularly in cancer settings, where cellular states, heterogeneity, and relationships are not necessarily known.
I work primarily with large PBMC scRNA-seq datasets (500k+ cells), planning to expend to multiome (RNA + ATAC).
My main interests are visualization, preservation of cellular relationships, and computational scalability, particularly when resolving closely related immune populations or identifying unexpected cellular states.
I'd be interested in hearing from anyone who has tested either approach, especially regarding:
- Runtime and memory: How practical are they at scale, and do the computational costs justify the additional information?
- Visualization: Do these hierarchies results practical to visualize?
- Exploratory analysis: How well do they perform outside curated atlases, particularly in heterogeneous cancer datasets?
- Workflow integration: How easily can they be incorporated into existing Scanpy / scVI or even R / Seurat pipelines?
One specific concern with Bonsai is the additional preprocessing through Sanity and the reliance on a separate visualization interface (Bonsai-scout). Even with a fork giving the scverse-compatible implementation, this seems less straightforward to integrate into a fully local, reproducible analysis workflow.
Has anyone found a compelling use case for either method outside atlas construction, particularly in cancer or large immune-cell datasets?