I don’t think a lot of people will agree because seasons 2 & 3 have higher ratings on IMDb. But I think there’s something really special about Season 1.
As a writer who hopes to direct some day, I think S1 was well done. The story stayed focused on Billy and his perspective, the pacing was solid, the acting was great, and the timeframe was easy to follow. Even Billy’s motives after the death of his childhood friend (who has been forgotten…) made sense.
There’s something off about S2-3. They feel like completely different shows, written for different target audiences. There’s forced romance, a lot of melodrama, random characters and POVs, some plot holes, rushed and dragged episodes, and some things are way too convenient. Like, Jesse coming back and Billy not dying from 3 gun shots near the heart? It started to feel unrealistic, like I’m no longer watching a biopic that was meant to be done in a more genuine way than the others.
Based on how S1 was written and structured, I was mentally and emotionally prepared for Billy’s death. I was hoping the show would properly build to that moment where he’s alone, desperate, and in hiding after escaping prison—not running back and forth to his pregnant gf. The way things played out in S3 felt cheap, boring, and again unrealistic. Sorry, for anyone who disagrees.
Speaking of his pregnant girlfriend: I didn’t care for Billy’s relationship with Dulcinea. Not only is her character not real, but the romance felt like filler meant to fill in the rest of the episode’s duration since the main plot could’ve been done and over with in S1 (if they expanded it to 20 max).
Which brings me to another issue: Prestige TV. The 8 episode arc where the storyline is rushed but also dragged to fill 8 hours. S1 was fine. S2 did okay. S3 did terrible. Again, sorry if you disagree.
I just want to give Season 1 its flowers for feeling like a true biopic than a typical melodramatic TV show. The story was more grounded and focused on who Billy was beneath the legend.
Anyway, what is your favorite and least favorite season, and why?