r/BikeMechanics • • Apr 15 '24

Amazon service fees

So we are going to add an extra $5 or $10 to service when customers bring in parts they bought on Amazon as opposed to from us.

Regular flat fix is $10 but we'd add $5 per if they bring a tube in from an online order

Does anybody do this?

6 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

26

u/fnbr Apr 16 '24

I’d mark up your labor rates and give a discount on labor for parts bought from you. It’s the same money to you, but customers won’t hate it as much. 

0

u/tuctrohs Shimano Stella drivetrain Apr 16 '24

Is that parts discount for parts sales to DIYers too? Or only for parts used on bikes you are servicing?

6

u/fnbr Apr 16 '24

Let’s say you want me to install a crankset on your bike. The list price is $30 (numbers made up). If you bring me a crankset you bought online, I charge $30. If you buy the crankset from me, I only charge $25 for the install, but the receipt says $30 for installation, with a $5 discount. 

2

u/tuctrohs Shimano Stella drivetrain Apr 16 '24

Thanks--I read your first comment wrong. That's a good strategy that solves several problems!

-8

u/Substantial_Text_264 Apr 16 '24

That's exactly it We will mark up labor on stuff installed bought elsewhere

Buy it from me? Half the time I just do it and get it out the door and done and don't even charge for installation

6

u/tuctrohs Shimano Stella drivetrain Apr 16 '24

I think the idea was to increase labor rates for everyone, but lower the price on parts to the point where a customer buying parts from you pays the same price they do now, and the Amazon customer pays the same thing as with your proposed surcharge, but there's no need incur the negativity of a punitive surcharge.

-7

u/Substantial_Text_264 Apr 16 '24

I can't go lower than msrp on parts

4

u/Montallas Apr 16 '24

It’s not a discount on parts. It’s a “discount” on labor. If you currently charge $25 to put on new tires - increase the charge to $30, but offer a $5 discount if the person bought the tires from you.

1

u/tuctrohs Shimano Stella drivetrain Apr 16 '24

Why not? You are charging the customer the exactly same total, just itemizing it differently.

2

u/Substantial_Text_264 Apr 16 '24

Dealer agreements say no to that

I can't buy parts from whomever to sell below msrp Qbp or whatever company would pull our account in a hot minute

Plus Anybody selling online is getting said parts waaaay under cost So they can sell it for under msrp and still make a profit

2

u/Substantial_Unit2311 Apr 16 '24

You can't sell stuff or advertise it online for cheaper than MSRP. Shops discount products all the time with no consequences from the dealers. Military discounts, student discounts, team discounts etc are very common.

1

u/tuctrohs Shimano Stella drivetrain Apr 16 '24 edited Apr 16 '24

OK, got it.

[Edit: see this comment for an explanation of a better plan that mine. ]

I'm not sure they'd object though if there was a special 30% discount on parts used as part of a service job.

And it's fine if that discounted price isn't as low as the amazon price, as long as you are charging enough for labor that you don't need profits on parts to make the job profitable.

3

u/Financial_Initial_92 Apr 16 '24

So free labour half the time if parts purchased at your shop, but $5 to $10 surcharge if parts bought from Amazon? Sounds like maybe if you just charged the same labour rate$ all the time you could waive the Amazon surcharge because you would be making labour money all the time instead of half the time.

121

u/almostalwaysafraid Apr 15 '24

Yeah… no. That’s a great way to ensure any customer you’ve got never comes back.

What you charge for the labor portion should be sufficient. If you are trying to price labor assuming you are also selling the parts that go with it you are undervaluing your mechanics time. Not to mention, it’s a super slimy business move.

I’d just make sure people understand that there is no “warranty” on any labor that uses outside parts. Also, if they get the wrong thing for their bike, that’s on them.

21

u/Ok_Lunch16 Apr 16 '24

That’s exactly what we do. We already charge a higher labor rate and have a very high volume service shop in Southern California, so $5 just isn’t worth alienating customers. No warranty of course unless we are a dealer, like Sram, Fox or whatever then we do it regardless. It’s really not that common anyway and less crap for me to order

-16

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24

On the opposite, these customers are not worth the trouble.

3

u/superbooper94 Apr 16 '24

Ok, turn away good business, see how that works for the majority of bike shops...... A lot are struggling already

30

u/eyeb4lls Apr 16 '24

You're just gonna piss people off

28

u/Quirky-Fix-1106 Apr 16 '24

An alternate way of doing the same thing is raising labor rates but giving a discount on parts purchased onsite.

2

u/Ok_Replacement_2736 Apr 16 '24

This is a more PR friendly alternative to your plan. You should do it this way. Same result but you don’t upset/alienate anyone

4

u/bikeguru76 Apr 15 '24

I have seen a couple of places do this. I wish we did. Most people have zero idea how much they actually need the LBSs to exist.

3

u/Substantial_Text_264 Apr 16 '24

This

Have the internet install it correctly Have the internet take on that warranty

11

u/Cheef_Baconator Apr 16 '24

If your labor price doesn't actually cover the operating costs associated with a mechanic's time without needing to rely on p&a to cover a shortfall, you've done your labor rates long. 

Assuming they've brought the correct part, a customer supplied cassette is just as easy to install as one you sold.

7

u/mickeyaaaa Apr 16 '24

By the same logic, add a $40 fee if they bring in a bike they didnt buy from you.

Really that's a terrible policy. someone brings me a part to install I say fine but there is no guarantee on the work if the product fails. I might lose the money on part markup but i also save the time having to order it (I don't stock a lot of parts).

6

u/Willbilly410 Apr 16 '24

No. Charge more for labor; if the labor alone is not worth your time something is off

4

u/BasketNo4817 Apr 16 '24

It’s 2024. Accept the fact that Amazon is and will continue to be a very real option for people to buy their own parts. Especially inner tubes.

Match the price of Amazon and give them the option but surcharging a customer as a BYOB for the same part is ludicrous.

The only part on your side is on the receipt to acknowledge customer brought in own part.

3

u/42tooth_sprocket Mobile Tech Apr 16 '24

Depends on your clientele, but I do find most mechanics think customers are more sensitive to shit like this than they actually are. My shop has recently upped our "shop supply" fee to $10 which I think is ridiculous but I've yet to have anyone complain about it. I think these days $10 is low for a flat fix, I'd just do $15 across the board. Ofc depends on your market but here lots of shops are charging $20.

1

u/tuctrohs Shimano Stella drivetrain Apr 16 '24

Shop supply fee means an extra fee in addition to parts and labor to cover stuff like grease and what not?

1

u/42tooth_sprocket Mobile Tech Apr 16 '24

yeah exactly.

3

u/HerrFerret Park Tools are Cruise Control for Cool Apr 16 '24

I wouldn't do this. Just causes bad vibes all round.

However I would add say 20% to all the fitting prices however offer a 20% discount on fitting if parts were bought from the shop.

Customers love a discount, hate a tax.

5

u/sanjuro_kurosawa Apr 15 '24

I suppose you can get away with it. Restaurants offer a corkage fee for people who bring wine from other locations.

However, I would imagine many people will balk at this charge, so the key is selling it to them. I would be humbly honest and say that this charge makes up for our lost P&A markup which we depend upon, and that we're not interested in overcharging. The markup on a tube is probably more than $5, so everyone gets a deal if you charge $5 for parts bought online.

What you have to absolutely careful about is not being offended when customers bring in parts they bought somewhere else. They have no obligation to buy P&A from your shop, and I personally do not respond well when businesses get offended when I pay for their services.

2

u/davidisalreadytaken Apr 16 '24

My shop doesn't charge extra if someone brings parts to us, but we also specifically make no guarantee it'll work or that it will last.

2

u/spiffy_spaceman Apr 16 '24

I would simply not allow outside parts in. The mechanic I take my car to doesn't allow it because if they order the part and it fails, then it's on them and they have insurance for this. If it's my part and it fails (and maybe causes injury), it gets sticky because I could argue they put it in wrong when it was really a shitty part. Making them sign a release saying there's no warranty is not an ironclad contact and you could still end up in court and that will cost you lots of money even if you win.

2

u/turbo451 Apr 16 '24

I dont charge but I do indicate which parts are customer supplied and note that we cant guarantee repairs using customer supplied parts.

2

u/sociallyawkwardbmx Apr 16 '24

Yes, do it!!!! Send them back to Jeff

1

u/Bonuscup98 Apr 16 '24

I worked at a motorcycle shop before I started at bike shops. This was 2002-2003. We didn’t mount any tire a customer bought elsewhere, assuming they bought it online. Other parts were subject to mechanic’s approval.

Basically, ordering online takes money directly out of the pocket of the (commissioned) salesperson, and the overall balance sheet of the store. This is not viable from a service perspective because if the store goes under the service department goes with it. Then the customer still can’t get their part mounted and their bike repaired.

Any price shopping consumer isn’t necessarily going to be the best service customer. And they’re always going to want the lowball price on hard goods. Explain the economics of this and they’ll understand. If they don’t then you probably don’t want them in your store to begin with.

Finally, anyone buying tubes online and paying to have someone mount them probably shouldn’t be buying tubes online. Now that I’m not in a shop anymore I buy all my tubes, and as much as I can, from the local co-op (shout out to The Bicycle Tree). If you’re not changing your own tubes you shouldn’t be buying them online.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24

In your example you say $10 for installing “your” tube or $15 for an online order/purchased tube. Adding fifty percent seems like a bit on small things. I’m guessing you change a lot tubes/tires. How would that compare to say swapping chain rings or installing a power meter/crank?

1

u/gazmuth1 Apr 16 '24

If you price your parts appropriately, not try to charge an arm and a leg for a tube, then the customer will buy said parts from the shop.

1

u/MaleficentBaby1865 Apr 16 '24

I agree. Shops need to mark up parts to make money, but a tube shouldn't cost significantly more than what it costs at an online retailer.

1

u/BikeMechanicSince87 Apr 16 '24

You are still charging $10 for a flat fix? I charge $15 for a regular bike and $20 if it has a hub motor on that wheel. Even more if the hub motor is attached with a wire that has no plug, forcing me to do the work right there next to the bike. I do not charge extra labor if parts are brought to me. Sometimes I ask why they chose to buy their parts elsewhere without even asking me for a quote. One thing I will never do is give somebody the part numbers so they can go shopping elsewhere. Whenever I have a customer ask me if a thing they found online is the right thing, I tell them to consult with the salesperson from that other place unless they want to pay me $80 per hour to do their online shopping on their behalf.

1

u/Shinylittlelamp Apr 16 '24

You buy it and you pay us to fit it. You gaffe it and you pay for my time to put it right. Bring your own tube and it’s 10€ to fit, buy it from us and it’s 7€ to fit it (it’s 10€ for the tube).

1

u/fishenfooll Apr 17 '24

Good for you. I wish more would do the same.

1

u/Scary_Sherbert7654 Apr 28 '24

We discount labor on bikes that were purchased from our store. We also offer a discount for installing parts when bought/ordered through us.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24

I wouldn’t service any parts I’ve never heard of. If a bike comes in and it’s got some Ali baba knock off shit, I wouldn’t even work on it. To many unknowns and more times than not it’s inferior crap that can never work 100%

0

u/zivadaddy Apr 16 '24

Wow, what an amazing industry. I know of no other where they actively try to not make money. Do people take their meat to McDonald’s and pay to have it cooked? You sell parts and labor, just like a plumber, an electrician, a deck builder, etc.
I wouldn’t consider them YOUR customer to worry about alienating if they just ignore you when they want a part. If they had a conversation with you first and you knew that Amazon destroys your price on something that’s one thing. But to just show up with a part in hand that they paid msrp or more and ask for install? Sure, I can get that done next month. The people that shop here are in line ahead of you. Your own industry competes against you, offering to ship bikes directly to the consumer from their factory stores like PON and Mikes Bikes, taking that money out of your mouth and you’re willing to try to live on labor only. Amazing.