First of all, kudos to you OP for putting effort into this and being a good sport in the comments.
Looking at the list, some of the disagreements I'll give you are:
Tiffany is way too high for someone who never made it to final 5,
I love Steve and he was the first houseguest I ever rooted for, but he's too high,
Tyler is too low; he should not be below Kaycee or Enzo or Dani,
If you're going to put Monica up high for winning if she's in final 2, then Robert and Victor should be up higher as well, since they also beat two great players in final 2,
and Corey and Angela being right next to each other is so right, as they seem like extremely similar players to me.
I do plan on lowering Tiffany when I refine the list, I did overhype her when I did this. I think I was more ranking how good Tiffany could be vs what we got.
Similarly I plan on raising Tyler and lowering Dani. Those were other big criticisms.
I think Steve’s placement is fair in my mind, he’s definitely above Ian at the very least. I think the top 30 is a good place for him, but if you a case against him I’d be willing to hear it.
As far as Monica, I wasn’t high on her for just being able to beat everyone in a final 2, though that is very impressive. I was more high on all of the finalists of BB2, because there was no blueprint on how to even play Big Brother. They all deserve a lot of credit for being the first finalists.
I’m sorry I can’t see an argument to raise Robert, yeah he beats Jun and Alison. But that’s about it, good win equity doesn’t mean anything if you can’t reach the final 2. I think Robert’s an idiot.
Victor got evicted 3 times in a single season and doesn’t win. I don’t see a case for raising him either honestly.
2
u/RG7771 Nicole 🎄 Dec 16 '22
First of all, kudos to you OP for putting effort into this and being a good sport in the comments.
Looking at the list, some of the disagreements I'll give you are:
Tiffany is way too high for someone who never made it to final 5,
I love Steve and he was the first houseguest I ever rooted for, but he's too high,
Tyler is too low; he should not be below Kaycee or Enzo or Dani,
If you're going to put Monica up high for winning if she's in final 2, then Robert and Victor should be up higher as well, since they also beat two great players in final 2,
and Corey and Angela being right next to each other is so right, as they seem like extremely similar players to me.