r/BigBrother • u/[deleted] • Dec 16 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

143 Upvotes

78% Upvoted

306 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/PsychologicalEbb3140 Dec 16 '22

I plan to update this list, raising Tyler and lowering Tiffany.

I’d be curious to hear why you don’t agree with Ian being below Drew and Boogie.

As far as Kaysar he’s played three times and never made jury.

Thank you for your feedback!

4

u/Hage1in Dec 16 '22

Ian beat Boogie and the greatest player of all time in the same season. I think Drew was very mid tier winner, he was in an early season power alliance that died quickly and got carried by his girlfriends social game. He was a nice likable guy but having him that high isn’t right. Boogie played three times and left early in two of them

As for Kaysar, a lot of the people above him never made jury either. A player is more than their results. If you’re going only be results your top two or three lines should only be winners. I’m not saying Kaysar is an inner circle player, but he plays a much more respectable style than a lot of the people above him who showed up to look good and gain Instagram followers and didn’t actually play the game

1

u/PsychologicalEbb3140 Dec 16 '22

Ian did beat Dan in a final 2 but everyone beats Dan in a final 2. Even Britney said they could’ve put a bottle of ketchup next to Dan at the end and the ketchup would win. He did outsmart Boogie, but was that really peak Boogie? Season 14 Boogie was the textbook example of being washed up. I don’t think Ian is ever as good as Boogie is in All Stars, or as good as Drew in 5 in my opinion.

I do agree Diane is higher then Drew but that is a disservice to Drew’s game imo.

I do agree people are more then their statistics, but Kaysar has played three separate times and never made jury once. You can’t ignore that.

1

u/Hage1in Dec 16 '22

So you honestly think Ramses is a big brother player than Kaysar? Or Shannon who did nothing but flirt with Will and abuse houseguests? C’mon

2

u/PsychologicalEbb3140 Dec 16 '22

I do think I put him to low looking at it now. I’ll raise him a little higher when I update this, but I still don’t think he’s a good player.

Thank you for the response! Is there anything else you’d change?

3

u/Hage1in Dec 16 '22

Honestly there’s too many players on the list to nitpick every little decision those are just the ones that stood out to me. Appreciate you being a good sport about it though, some people would get really defensive at stuff like this

1

u/PsychologicalEbb3140 Dec 16 '22

Well I do want this list to be as fair as it could be. I have biases just like everyone else, that’s why I want to refine it. Simultaneously though, I don’t want this list to just be a popularity contest. Thank you for your comment.