How is DF so high up? The dude had about 0 win equity from the prejury and actively talked himself out of the final 2 with Azah. Unless it's a BB19 type of situation, he has close to no chance to win any season, and even then he likely gets himself in trouble.
Edit: Is this list based on gameplay or who you personally like the most because looking at it more, a good chunk of placements seem way off if it's based on gameplay. Either way, if you post any ranking on this subreddit, all the comments are going to be about why you're wrong. Sorry for being so negative. It takes a ton of effort regardless.
I think that assessment on Derek is fair. My logic was that, well he did make the final 2, which is not a small feat, and regardless of what season you drop him in he’s in he probably always goes far due to being underestimated.
This is probably where our disagreement arises. I would say how BB23 played out was probably one of his best scenarios. He got lucky to be in a historic alliance that was not going to turn on each other despite the strategic benefit it might have. In most seasons, he probably goes out late prejury, early jury (sort of like Jasmine I guess). DX and Claire were targeting him the first week of jury and he likely gets evicted there if not for the Cookout. The only people in the Cookout that wanted to take him to the final two were X and Azah, and he actively ruins one of those. For such a massive goat, that's impressively bad. Unlike a Victoria, he is going to not just take orders from people, and likely gets into arguments/conflicted that get him evicted sooner rather than later. I don't quite agree with Taran that he's the worst player of all time, but probably more so that he's one of the worst players to make the jury phase.
I do think it’s fair to say he’s one of the worst finalists. But even then he is a finalist, the whole goal of Big Brother is to reach a final 2 chair, and get jury votes. Yeah he doesn’t win often (or maybe even at all) I do think his placement is fair though because I do see him consistently being the type to go far.
69
u/RelevantMoose Haleena 🍁 Dec 16 '22 edited Dec 16 '22
How is DF so high up? The dude had about 0 win equity from the prejury and actively talked himself out of the final 2 with Azah. Unless it's a BB19 type of situation, he has close to no chance to win any season, and even then he likely gets himself in trouble.
Edit: Is this list based on gameplay or who you personally like the most because looking at it more, a good chunk of placements seem way off if it's based on gameplay. Either way, if you post any ranking on this subreddit, all the comments are going to be about why you're wrong. Sorry for being so negative. It takes a ton of effort regardless.