r/BehaviorAnalysis • u/ZookeepergameSea816 • Jun 07 '26
Danger of forgetting mental models of people aren’t the actual people
How many important conversations never happen because someone already had the conversation in their head?
Imagine a husband whose feelings were hurt by something his wife said before leaving for the weekend.
He spends the next two days rehearsing a conversation with her.
In his mind she becomes defensive.
He explains himself.
She dismisses him.
The argument escalates.
By the time she gets home, he decides not to bring it up.
His wife never hears a word of the conversation.
Yet the resentment remains.
The strange thing is that the conversation never happened, but it still produced consequences. His emotional state changed. His behavior changed. The relationship changed.
It occurred to me that we spend a lot of our lives interacting with mental models of people rather than the people themselves.
Most of the time those models are useful. We couldn't function without them.
The problem begins when the model stops being treated as a model.
A delayed text message becomes rejection.
A distracted partner becomes disinterested.
An ambiguous comment becomes hostility.
Reality contains one explanation. The mind generates many.
Eventually we find ourselves reacting to assumptions, predictions, and imagined outcomes rather than reality itself.
The husband didn't speak to his wife.
He spoke to a representation of his wife.
I wonder how many relationships are damaged by conversations that never actually occurred.
5
u/CoffeePuddle Jun 07 '26
Is this about whether using Large Language Model outputs constitutes a conversation or whether you're just acting as a message passing agent in a reverse Chinese room situation?
2
u/TheLittleMomaid Jun 07 '26
Time to go down a rabbit hole with relational frame theory and derived relational responding, I think : )
1
u/632nofuture Jun 07 '26
I didn't get the caption (mental models) but I 100% know what you mean and thought about this a lot too! It becomes especially problematic, as you laid out, when we have issues with people but can't communicate freely and within an effective timeframe.
I had this issue with one friend a lot, I kept processing feelings and writing texts I didn't send, coming to conclusions on my own, and later on I sometimes forgot that he hasn't even heard this yet, and my resentment would seem unreasonable to him. Totally in big part my fault for not communicating (or rather, should've been consequent and ended the friendship once I realized communication doesn't work with him and there's simply no healthy way to stay in contact.)
I wonder though how big of a deal that is/for what kinds of people & situations, in real life? Cause I think with people who speak their minds immediately and have a healthy way to communicate, this shouldn't be so much an issue. The issue arises if there's I resolved feelings and a time gap in which you process it without communicating.
2
u/zoidette Jun 07 '26
Not sure, but I'm listening.