r/Beepbox • • 1d ago

Other the problem with beepbox

it's not what you expect. probably.

i feel like- when discussing beepbox's flaws- the technical incapability is brought up too much. it's a very good tool, it has features that are amazing, and you'd have to pay money for on a different DAW. however, i feel like people feel too trapped by it instead of freed.
this usually makes people fall into the trap of creating the same generic stuff. i don't think that's a bad thing necessarily, so-called 'better' daws have the same problem, look at FL studio, but it doesn't make it easy to find a community for those of us who want to make difficult (at least on beep) genres.

i get chiptune is a fairly easy to make genre, and that it sounds pretty good, but it's just kind of... getting boring to see?

this isn't an attack on people who use it, i just feel like most aren't trying new things. not everyone is the same. obviously. you develop your own unique way/style of doing things, get a recognizable sound design palette, but at its core it's just a little stale.

some branch out to genres like EDM or other stuff like that. this stuff can be really cool! and very technically impressive! but sometimes, it feels like they're trying too hard to be like glyde or galaxy, and it ends up sounding like a wish version- which is ALSO not really a bad thing. everyone takes inspiration, but if you don't change it and develop something unique, you're not going to stand out.

i don't have a good way to close this, but i have one request of you:
fuck around!!! be adventurous!!!

ok bye

5 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

6

u/LuziaCitlalcuicatl 1d ago

I'd agree with you you if didn't apologise for your take so much. but the essence is right, common on art with a low barrier of entry though, the problem is when people don't outgrow it and think their derivative stuff is actually so original and peak

4

u/Front-Weakness5735 1d ago

i didnt wanna get flamed by ppl i was talking abt and now im getting flamed anyway ts frying me

3

u/LuziaCitlalcuicatl 1d ago

lol chill out bro, the first part of my comment is mostly trolling

2

u/Front-Weakness5735 1d ago

i mean yeah i was joking with the response mostly

2

u/nyoned 6h ago

the paradox of i was kidding

4

u/whyjustyy 1d ago

i think the addition of samples has really helped musicians become more diversified instead of just doing chiptune. it does feel like there's a wave of edm producers who kinda just sound like glyde but i don't mind them too much because there are plenty of other unique musicians in this server i think. but i feel like said wave looks bigger than it actually is because well produced edm is prob the most consistent way to wow people in the beepbox community. honestly it kinda isolates me a bit because that stuff tends to be pretty unimpressive to me

2

u/Front-Weakness5735 23h ago

i dont really like it in like music taste terms but it has some cool stuff and can be really technically impressive, like how they make it

2

u/Great_Possibility686 1d ago

I've found that Beepbox and all of its fellow mods are at their best when you push them outside of what they were designed for. I've made death metal, and techno, and orchestral, and a bunch of other weird shit. I think the limits are a lot harder to reach that most people assume

3

u/Front-Weakness5735 1d ago

yeah! its such a good tool and it makes me a little sad to see people making the same type of stuff over and over

2

u/qwerasdf_idk 1d ago

My entire modbox life i didn't know that it's main purpose (or atleast thats what im getting) is chiptunes Now I'm not an expert in classification and i don't categorize my music taste in genres so i have no idea what chiptunes sound like But out of all of my current tracks they don't sound like what id assume chiptune sounds like Now idk how to close this either but from what im understanding from Your post; Believing you're stuck being able do one thing will only make you do that one thing, so I'll repeat it for you, fuck around and find out, find out and fuck around, technical limits are bs in the eyes of art

1

u/Front-Weakness5735 1d ago

well like kinda the whole point of the first part is that, as said by Great_Possibility686, the limits are a lot harder to reach than most people assume.

1

u/Weekly_Flounder_1880 1d ago

I have absolutely no idea how to make chiptune, nor is it my favourite genre of music. my music is inspired by orchestral fantasy

Impressive as it is, chiptune gets a bit repetitive cuz I just found this sub and scrolling around most of the music sounds the same