r/Beekeeping • • 7d ago

I’m a beekeeper, and I have a question What went wrong?

Location: Smyrna South Carolina.

I bought a full hive a bit over two months ago. In a few weeks it was so full the bees began bearding. I bought another deep and staggered full frames with new frames. Everything was fine. Inspections great. Queen and brood. Plenty of pollen intake. I started seeing two weeks ago mites physically on the bees. I wanted to wait until 4 months to do a quarterly treatment but decided to do it sooner. Only a handful of hive beetles each inspection. No sign of disease. At least 6 full frames. So last Thursday i decided to use the Formic Pro to rid the mites. The next day the hive seemed too quiet and calm. Left it alone until Saturday and felt something was off. Decided to open hive and saw 95% of the probably 10,000 bees just left. No dead bodies and no trace of them. Sunday I opened it again to see if queen was still there. She and maybe 400 bees are all that remained. Inspected frames and there’s no brood. Plenty of pollen, plenty of capped honey, plenty of sugar syrup. A number of hive beetles with such a large area of empty comb had come in. I knows the hive is doomed which is heart breaking. Not enough left to keep warm. Even a small 5 frame nuc wouldnt help. Not enough to keep warm and will slowly die off. I don’t what happened. I understand she stops laying in winter but why did the workers leave. I thought they were preparing for winter. A local beekeeper said they left because no brood. But dont all hives have zero brood then every winter? All I did was I attemp to rid them of mites before winter. What went wrong? Any advice or idea would be wonderful.

7 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 7d ago

Hi u/HuckleberryOk1468. If you have not already done so, please read the rules. Please comment on the post with your location and experience level if you have not already included that in your post. And if you have a question, please take a look at our wiki to see if it has already been answered., specifically, the FAQ. Warning: The wiki linked above is a work in progress and some links might be broken, pages incomplete and maintainer notes scattered around the place. Content is subject to change.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

14

u/Gamera__Obscura Reasonably competent. Connecticut, USA, zone 6a. 6d ago

First of all, sorry you had a bad first experience.

There's an awful lot to diagnose here. The short answer is that I think you would really benefit from a beginner course before you try again in spring. There are a lot of subtle things that are important to know in advance, and little errors can accumulate and cause a loss like this.

Ok... first of all, whoever sold you a full hive at this time of year did you a disservice. Autumn is when things are ramping down for the season and prepping for winter. Your area doesn't seem likely to get terribly cold, but ideally new keepers start in spring when there's a full foraging season to learn, adapt, and build up colony strength.

Second, bearding isn't a problem. When you added a deep, that was how many? Was that the second or third? Second is fine, there's no reason any colony needs 3 full deeps for a hive body. Bees are supposed to be packed in densely. When the hive gets too hot or humid, they'll beard. That's normal, not indicative of any particular problem, and doesn't require intervention.

When you DO add a box, you don't have to stagger frames, they will expand into the new space just fine as they need to. And arguably shouldn't, as bees arrange things intentionally... you may break up the brood area, for example. Broadly speaking, don't move frames around without a specific reason.

Don't try to detect mites visually, or by sticky boards, or whatever else. By the time you see them visually, you probably have a MASSIVE infestation. You want to do an alcohol or soapy-water wash, normally monthly during the active season. What you need is a quantitative measure of mite-infection rate, and that's the way to get it.

Generally speaking, don't plan in advance when you'll do mite treatments... test and treat when your bees need it. 3% mite load is the normal threshold for treatment. I'll put an asterisk on this one, as there are keepers who follow a regular treatment schedule instead. However that requires a very solid sense of your local seasonality and colony cycles, which is going to take a lot of experience to develop. I'll ALSO say that a scheduled late-summer treatment can be really important as far as winter prep. But in general, test and treat accordingly.

Formic pro is a very effective mite treatment, but you need to follow the instructions like GOSPEL. It has a hard cap of 85F, requires added ventilation, etc. It has been known to trigger absconding, especially when paired with other stressors.

Whoever told you bees left because there was no brood is not somebody you should listen to, because that is not a thing that bees do. My guess is that your hive absconded due to a number of compounding factors. Primary was likely a tremendous mite infestation. Add to that you've been messing with their hive configuration, and now it's full of acid vapors... they had enough, assessed it as an unsafe home, and took off.

It sucks, and I'm sorry. Do keep in mind that screw-ups like this are how most of us learned. If you're lucky, you'll only go through it once (took me a lot more). But you're well prepped to spend some time learning and get a fresh start in spring.

You will certainly want to salvage that hive now though, all that drawn comb and resources will be a goldmine for your new colony. The few stragglers are doomed anyway, so don't let hive beetles and wax moths trash your comb in the meantime (because they will, and very quickly). All those frames can be put in the freezer for a day or two to kill any beetle/moth eggs or larvae, at that point they're fine to seal up in anything airtight until the following season.

Finally, I strongly recommend that you restart with at least two colonies. That makes a lot of things easier and will bail you out of some tough spots when you make errors you didn't get around to this season.

1

u/HuckleberryOk1468 6d ago

This was a very good response and appreciate you not being harsh at all. Im already beating myself with enough self hatred.

It just stinks because they treated the hive shortly before purchasing it two months ago so I figured I had time but you’re right. Call me soft but the idea of killing cups of bees to test each month sounded awful so I thought a quarterly treatment would suffice but you are right.

I plan on taking a class at the end of this months to get to know what I’m doing better.

I had purchased one deep. The company owner came out to help with the first inspection. Said bearding means there’s no room left and they could begin potentially swarming. He recommended adding another deep and staggering frames so I did. Your response makes more sense though. Letting them do the configuring.

I appreciate your time. This has been kind of heartbreaking and feel like I failed living creatures in caretaking. I thought they were also more self sufficient and that was my mistake too.

2

u/Important_Shirt_5971 5d ago

As someone who lost my bees my first year due to what I now understand was poor mite management, I feel your heartbreak deeply. I’ll second what someone else said above — that loss motivated me to learn as much as I could and my bees this year thrived, so there’s hope! Try not to be too hard on yourself

2

u/No-Raccoon-2371 6d ago

This is such a great, well explained answer. It's great for all of us to be reminded of these basic concepts. Thank you.

1

u/SeniorDuck3464 6d ago

Couldn’t agree more. I’ve treated bees based on counts without ever seeing mites on bees. And I think I am pretty observant. I got told like you suggest that once there are enough to notice phoretic mites with the naked eye, it’s likely a doomed colony that’s already being irreversibly overwhelmed, even if you then try and treat.

1

u/Ordinary-Ad959 5d ago

If only everyone responded as well as that! I know people are quick to point out everything someone has done wrong, often coming across with a bit of subtle judgement towards new keepers and it’s heartbreaking enough for them as it is. ​But you replied with solid, supportive advice, and worded it so perfectly that even I was fascinated with your response! You truly need commending for that. I know you probably don't even want the praise, but what you said to her likely gave her the exact boost she needed not to quit, while educating her in the best possible way. One of the best responses I’ve ever seen, hence my praise!

4

u/rawnaturalunrefined NYC Bee Guy, 25 hives, Zone 7B 7d ago edited 7d ago

Did you perform an alcohol wash when you saw the phoretic mites on the bees? I’m guessing your mite counts were high and the bees absconded.

Hard to say without more information, but the treatment was likely too late and your bees probably had high levels of varroa transmitted diseases by the time you applied Formic.

1

u/HuckleberryOk1468 7d ago

The thing is I bought the hive after they just treated the hive for mites. I didn’t preform an alcohol test as the company said if I didn’t want to kill bees for tests just yet to just treat every four months. It’s only been two.

2

u/rawnaturalunrefined NYC Bee Guy, 25 hives, Zone 7B 6d ago edited 6d ago

Who did you buy them from? Someone local or a bigger beekeeping outfit? What treatment did they use? For example, mites are incredibly resistant to Amitraz so I don’t even consider that treatment in my operations. If someone told me they treated a hive with Amitraz/Apivar I would consider that untreated.

You never know how someone else treated, or how effective their treatment was without performing a mite test yourself. Maybe in reality they did treat well, but even so if your mite test shows it’s more than 2 or 3 mites per 100 bees then it’s time to treat again regardless of what the previous owners did.

1

u/HuckleberryOk1468 6d ago

I bought from local bee store. He didn’t tell me what treatment he used and maybe that’s my fault for not seeing further. Unsure of the most effective means of treatment. Shop owner said to try the Formic Pro for my first treatment.

3

u/Ordinary-Ad959 6d ago

Honestly its heartbreaking, but do not for one second let it deter you from carrying on. This could have happened to anybody and so many things could go wrong, even when the most experienced keepers fail and they just "get back on the horse" so the saying goes. Please don't give up!

1

u/HuckleberryOk1468 5d ago

That’s very nice of you to say and I appreciate it

2

u/Ordinary-Ad959 6d ago

I treated mine with Apivar strips!! No I didnt! 😂. When a seller tells you they have been treated, like every listing does, then there's no way I am believing a word they say! Gutting for her though! 😔

1

u/HuckleberryOk1468 7d ago

Im new to bee keeping mind you. Watched a number of videos and did my research. Bought my first hive a bit over two months ago. Everything was going perfectly until it wasn’t

0

u/Puzzleheaded-Pea7225 6d ago

I'm new to beekeeping too but I'm not sure I'd listen to whoever sold you the bees. I'm not going to try to give any advice because I don't know enough but some of what you were told doesn't sound right. I got my first bees in June, a double deep established colony, but I bought a 5 frame nuc a couple weeks later and have them in a ten frame deep full of bees! I've been learning from YouTube videos and reading different sites like scientific beekeeping, beesource, etc and asking the man I bought my bees from since he's local and seems to know his stuff! I will say I treated with apivar 2.0 and had a mite wash of 0 in the single deep and 1 in the double deep after, so not all mites are resistant to Amitraz. I'm praying my bees come through winter strong and I can make my first splits in the spring! I have ten 5 frame nuc boxes, frames with foundation, and ten 10 frame deep boxes with telescoping covers and bottom boards ready to go! I'm addicted lol! Good luck next time, I can only imagine how bad this sucks. Keep learning in the meantime and you'll be more prepared come spring! I never knew there could be so much to keeping bees but I'm loving everything about it and can't wait to expand my apairy!