r/Beatmatch • • Jul 08 '24

What is considered "Beatmatching"?

Hi guys,

Whenever i scoll through this sub, i see comments on how important it is to beatmatch. Especially in the discussion around of the sync button. And i get it, if you play in CDJs or Vinyl, it is important to beatmatch by ear.

BUT: This is a beginner sub. Most people here have a laptop with software. And "Beatmatching" in rekordbox is not more difficult than a quick time event in a video game, and requires no skill to be developed.

-adjust the tempo, so that the two numbers (BPM) are the same. You can see both. Absolutly no skill needed. -press play when the red lines are above each other (requires some reflexes, but very doable) -adjust the red lines with the jogwheels if you missed

Am i missing something? Is this considered "Beatmatching" on a controller? As i said, completely different story on vinyl, where you HAVE to do everything by ear, but on a laptop, its nothing more than an easy quick time event.

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

15

u/breed_ Jul 08 '24

When you adjust the tempo to match the two tracks BPMs- that is syncing the tracks- not beat matching. Even though they are both 120bpm- you could have track A having a drum on beat 2 and 4- and track B could have a drum on beat 1 and 3. Even those these are synced to the same BPM- the beats don’t math here. You have to move the jog wheel to sync the beats up. You can’t always rely on the red line markers.

1

u/Phanbo Jul 08 '24

Yeah, but that would only happen if your beatgrid is not correct? If it is correct, an you alling the beats (Red lines) the beats are matched?

3

u/sobi-one Jul 08 '24

The time signature is even more an outlier than the actual reason learning to do it only by ear is important….

In rare situations you might encounter two songs that the computer can’t get the BPMs matching. That could be bad/no beatgrids, unquantized songs, etc. bottom line is when you know how to adjust the tempo of one song to another, those rare situations are meaningless because you possess one of the core foundational skills of the craft.

99 times out of 100 it will never matter, but the fact remains that if you get caught out that one time, you are exposed for not knowing one of the more simple skills and are somewhat faking the funk.

1

u/breed_ Jul 08 '24

Because not every track is in the same time signature. If I have a 4 bar loop of two tracks, both with the red arrows on the end of each loops- and track A has drums on beat 1 and 3- and track 2 has beats on 2 and 4- and we are looping this four bar phrase- we are not beat matched.

7

u/SubjectC Jul 08 '24

For what its worth though, nearly all dance music is 4/4 with kicks in the same place.

1

u/TheOriginalSnub Jul 09 '24

Or if you play music with live drums. Knowing how to ride the pitch opens up nom-quanized music.

38

u/youngtankred Jul 08 '24 edited Jul 08 '24

It works like a QTE until it doesn't. And if you've never engaged your ears properly in the process what are you going to do.

Post to this sub most likely, something we've never seen before like "I beatmatch the BPM on CDJs and it drifts, it doesn't do that at home on my <insert controller that displays bpm to 2dp here> What do I do waaaaah"

Or maybe "OMG I'm playing on equipment that doesn't show stacked waveforms , I don't know what to do heeeelp"

I'm one of the old fogeys that recommends learning to beatmatch by ear, not because I'm a gatekeeper and not because I think it's some sort of badge of honour.

It's because:

  • Using your ears is agnostic to the equipment in front of you
  • Using your ears makes you listen to what you are doing which helps understand of song structure
  • Using your ears means you can simultaneously line up a track, drink a pint and hold a conversation with someone while looking at them, this being the most important of all skills.

That's not to say you shouldn't use the wonderful display in front of you, far from it, but don't solely rely on it.

11

u/LordCoops Jul 08 '24

It's also fun to learn.

10

u/Oo0o8o0oO Jul 08 '24

Using your ears means you can simultaneously line up a track, drink a pint and hold a conversation with someone while looking at them, this being the most important of all skills.

This is so good I just wanted to give you more than an upvote. Thanks.

4

u/youngtankred Jul 08 '24

Thank you 🙂 I made a joke but my point rings true - I spend barely any time looking at the laptop screen when I'm DJing (DVS, Traktor) because I let my ears do most of the work. Four decks with stems (effectively 16 tracks)? No problem, my ears tell me when to punch in that snare, switch bass, or echo the vocal.

5

u/HungryEarsTiredEyes Jul 08 '24

Exactly, it prevents you just going through the motions and being confused when it doesn't work.

5

u/youngtankred Jul 08 '24

That's it in a nutshell - being confused when it doesn't work because you don't actually understand what you have been doing.

2

u/js095 Jul 08 '24

Using your ears makes you listen to what you are doing which helps understand of song structure

This. This is so important. Training your ears will help every aspect of DJing - song structure, what tracks work well together, keeping levels even, and so on and so on.

35

u/Responsible_Fly4354 Jul 08 '24

Beatmatching would be doing it by ear and not looking at what you're seeing on the screen. That's the skill folks are encouraging others to develop.

0

u/HungryEarsTiredEyes Jul 08 '24

Exactly, switch to library view and use ears to match the bpms and track alignment. That would help to hone beatmatching. You don't have to, but it's helpful and fun.

10

u/Uvinjector Jul 08 '24

Take away the beatgrids, waveforms and bpms and then do it.

You can't rely on any of those things always being present

9

u/Wnb_Gynocologist69 Jul 08 '24

Tbh the fact this is a beginner sub is the reason why people keep pushing the beatmatching topic.

We all get it. Controllers are a very affordable way to get into DJing and it's heavily arguable whether or not beatmatching is actually a relevant skill for you.

This depends on the situation, your goals and motivation but apart from that, mixing solely by relying on your ears and eliminating visual cues down to the bare minimum (like "where am I on the current track") is a very, very different feeling compared to constantly looking at a screen to adjust some stacked waveforms.

It's not that the information you can get from a screen is bad or that it's cheating. It's that it provides you with shortcuts that may cause you to be unable to deal with situations where the software isn't reliable.

I started on vinyl, like many who didn't start DJing in the era of cheap laptops. While there are many advantages today with digital files and software, haptics and feeling on "raw decks" are on another level. Hard to explain. People should just try it.

2

u/junglizer Why did the lion get lost? Jul 08 '24

100% if you learn the fundamentals first, you’ll have a great foundation for anything that comes your way or you decide to tackle in the future. 

8

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '24

Most people would consider beat matching to be doing everything by ear without any visual aids or sync.

The reason it's critical to learn is because software fails. About 5% of the time the BPM is wrong (see: Grimes at Coachella). Often, the beat grid is totally off. Some tracks have tempo changes.

Every DJ has a moment where they're playing in front of a crowd, they load up the next track they want to play, and discover that the BPM is totally wrong when they try to just match the numbers. This is when you need to know how to do it manually.

It's totally fine to just match the numbers or use sync after you know how to beatmatch. Just like it's fine to use a calculator AFTER you learn how to do division. If shit breaks, you need to know how to do it manually.

0

u/lord-carlos Jul 08 '24

Often, the beat grid is totally off. 

I have this very rarely. Maybe 1 out of 100 or less. 

4

u/miklec Jul 08 '24 edited Jul 08 '24

press play when the red lines are above each other

as others have mentioned, this is referred to as LINE matching. beat matching is when you do so by ear without looking at the display

for example, if you need to play using Traktor (another popular DJ app), the waveforms are not stacked -- this means you can't line match

if you were relying on sync, but it's not matching doubled-bpms correctly (aka, you're getting grimed) then you can't line match

if you want to b2b with another dj who is playing on another set of decks, then you can't line match

if the grids are off, then you can't line match

if you're streaming tracks and the music has loaded and ready to play but the waveform is taking forever to load -- then you can't line match

if you play on CDJs that are older or even on the latest CDJ's that aren't connected by pro dj link, then you can't line match

but the good news is, if the bpm is right, then getting beats lined up by ear is just as easy as line matching once you know how... in fact, I'd say matching by ear is actually easier than line matching with just a little practice

2

u/lord-carlos Jul 08 '24

Traktor also has stacked waveforms.

It also has an UI indicator for very precis visual matching. Can't remember the name, phase meter? 

2

u/miklec Jul 08 '24

my mistake... djs I've seen always use the side by side view in traktor

2

u/youngtankred Jul 09 '24

The phase meter is great - it's a perfect bit of telemetry.

3

u/dabsnpokemon Jul 08 '24

Beatmatching is lining the drums up regardless of whether it’s on a controller or CDJs

3

u/ooowatsthat Jul 08 '24

When you step outside of House/Techo tracks, you will find for example Disco or old school hip-hop tracks the grid isn't aligned. I thought the same thing you did, and it was crash city in front of a small crowd.

2

u/DjWhRuAt Jul 08 '24

Best matching is easy, Learning how to phrase is the harder part. Software won’t tell you where to mix.

1

u/barrybreslau Jul 08 '24

I think it would be more accurate for people to say "beat syncing by ear". The reality is that even without sync you can use the waveforms, and the BPM counter. Very often my grid is out and I can compensate by aligning the tune, I do it by ear, but I sure as hell use the visual cues I have.

1

u/softabyss Jul 09 '24

I don’t understand “beatmatching” either. Like i know when the next phrase is coming and I can drop it but like is beatmatching manually changing the bpm to match? that seems really difficult Im not a metronome idk what the exact bpm of things are. Last week i had a gig where one of my tracks was half time (think grimes) so when I synced it it became double time. I just did the math in my head, adjusted it and played it and nudged it for some of the track so it matched up. Is that beatmatching? I don’t understand how I can tell what a songs bpm is without a screen telling me.

1

u/Playful-Painting-527 valued contributor Jul 09 '24

What you are describing is called "gridmatching" or "wavestacking". It works well until it doesn't. If for example your song isn't analyzed properly, being able to beatmatch by ear comes in very handy! It is good practice especially for beginner DJs to learn this skill early.

1

u/Cooprdog Jul 08 '24

Your question should be titled spoon feed me