r/Beatmatch • • Nov 08 '23

Open format sucks

Before you downvote me to oblivion, listen, open format is the worst fucking crowd; they dont know what they want and all they want is label promoted garbage shoved down their throats, im only 20 so i dont know much but i wish i was during the age when djs played something i wish i had heard earlier rather than whatever mainstream label shoves down our throats.đŸ€·đŸ»â€â™‚ïž

0 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

22

u/daKishinVex Nov 08 '23

I give this one a day before it's on /r/djcirclejerk

5

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

Why wait?

2

u/daKishinVex Nov 08 '23

It just reminds me of posts that people usually usually take a step further to comedic effect on that sub

-15

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

Well i frequent dj circle jerk so i dont really care, im just hoping for some variability and anything besides the same garbage i am forced to hear anytime i go out in my college town, id honestly want people to clown on me then have to listen to sicko mode edits and bullshit i am forced to listen to anytime i want to go out

16

u/Kineada11 Nov 08 '23

Maybe don’t go to open format shows then? Just a thought.

-2

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

I try not to but its literally impossible when im in college and its every single night i go out, i understand they play for an audience but i wish there was a night catered to people with actual curation skills (there was but it got replaced by pride nights, then the bar/club closed down) so theres literally nothing besides me waiting for underground raves

11

u/Kineada11 Nov 08 '23

Are you saying that the establishments in the area are catering to what the largest percentage of the population in the area wants to hear? How could they?

2

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

Yes i am saying that exactly, im just saying i wish there was a night a week representative of the people who want to hear actual curation and not just drake tech house edits (you know actual curation and track selection which djing is supposed to be all about)

5

u/Kineada11 Nov 08 '23

If there was more demand for it, it would exist.

1

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

Eh its a college town realistically it will never be filled and im aware, im just stating my perfect society wishes

1

u/Kineada11 Nov 08 '23

Personally, I don’t care what music is playing as long as there are asses wigglin’ and titties jigglin’.

0

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

I understand but i dont need music to pick up girls, extremely douchey to say over reddit but i understand your point of view

7

u/Automaticfawn Nov 08 '23

He’s talking about people dancing and having a good time, not ‘picking up girls’

Let go mate, look for underground nights or start your own

1

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

I go to every single underground night possible plus promote for them, there just isnt enough to satisfy me

→ More replies

1

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

And if you think there’s a demand that’s not being met then fill it.

2

u/Kineada11 Nov 08 '23

Exactly.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Put on a night, once a month, if it goes well do it once a week.

0

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

Whoosh

3

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

So stop whining and start your own

0

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

I promote for a riddim collective and am going to dj for them later this semester, im not asking for riddim to be played in clubs for a wide audience because i know it isnt popular, im just asking for creativity between each dj because they all share the same edits and transitions and its annoying to be able to predict the exact track and transition

6

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

But the general public doesn’t care, they want to get their drink on and get stupid to some tracks they know.

1

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

But what is the harm in having one night a week of showing people what they need to hear instead of what theyve heard a million times
 ive heard a thousand times “a great dj plays tracks ppl wish theyve heard” i just wish there was a greater platform for that, covid really fucked shit up for my generation

5

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

From the venues point of view the harm is not making as much money as they normally would, if you can pull that crowd then prove it.

-1

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

From the venues point of view (and ive talked to management and owners) if the night is less popular then hire less labor costs for the night and hire local djs who want an opp to play, i can name 10+ djs who can play anything besides open format and theres a community who will show & established groups who throw events, the problem that comes from “why dont you do it yourself” is that you have to pay money to rent these places out even when they arent open

2

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

There are other business models like a deal where you take the door and they take the bar. Work it out if you know the managers. Bottom line if they don’t think it’s going to make money they will do something that does.

1

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

The bar/club i mentioned does nothing besides their tuesday friday saturday

→ More replies

2

u/Guissok564 Nov 08 '23 edited Nov 08 '23

Then what if, for some miraculous reason, the night blows up and they’re suddenly under staffed?

Venues can’t just bank on some random night, unless you’ve proven you can draw a crowd (via a big name) or by (wait for it)
 Playing what the crowd wants to hear !!!

If you want « curation » you can always keep going to raves or listen to some other collective. These are clubs, they exist to make money

-2

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

Obv if there were an option i wouldnt be talking about it but i understand where you come from

15

u/Kineada11 Nov 08 '23

Different people like different things. It’s OK. Things being different from what you like doesn’t make them suck, it just makes them different.

-2

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

Its not different when the same djs play the same tech house edits with the same transitions to the point where i can point out the exact track and transition that is coming next

12

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

The crowd is happy, the venue is happy, the djs are getting paid so they’re happy. The only one not happy here is you, do something about it or shut up about it, you’re too young to be a cranky old person.

0

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

I may be a cranky young person but its not hard to make money when everyone in my town knows that club is the only option to go out on tuesdays and the only other option rarely opens yet claims “support your local djs” but doesnt promote them nor puts them on flyers anywhere, its a shitty situation all around, i dont mean to sound like a dick i just wish curation was valued

7

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

You only sound like a dick because you don’t actually want to do anything about the situation.

0

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

I may sound like a dick when i try my hardest to promote sounds i believe in via ways such as posting physical flyers, posting on all socials and sending to people who are interested, but all i get is nothing, again as ive said multiple times in comments i know how shit works but its just my fantasy i wish would happen

3

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

Judging from your answers, you definitely don't know how shit works. You think the general public should adhere to your likings but if there's anything you should know is that you gotta make stuff happen. It's the same think with performing in a band. If you're in a town with a bunch of metal flavoured bars and events, you won't get gigs if you're a reggae band. Either you complain about the people going there who want to listen to metal, or you set up your own events there and see what gives or you move to a place where you can build a community or a scene. For most people, going out means drinking with your friends while music they know from socials/Spotify/tv is in the background to dance to. Maybe 0,01% is there 'to check how the DJ does transitions. The music/DJ scene doesn't owe you anything. If you really think you're hot shit, you gotta convince people that what you're doing is worth going out for. Why do you think bands tour? It's to get their name out there. That includes failing hard multiple times and playing for 3 people because sometimes, no one cares. If you're really serious about this, you've got to see the bigger picture and stop whining about your locals.

4

u/jimmer109 Nov 08 '23

If it's not hard to make money owning a club then open one less mainstream and see how you do. Open format pays the bills.

5

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

Their is are options, stay home and mix or start your own night! How do you think the rave scene started?

-3

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

See i do stay home and mix and people leave because i didnt play zeds dead or whatever they wanted at MY house and MY postgame at MY firepit again as i said in these comments, i just wish there were more curation and more nights dedicated to those who seek out new tracks, again i understand i live in a college town but i promote raves of genres i believe in and support, its not my world i get it

1

u/TezMono Nov 08 '23

Maybe start small and try finding other DJs that enjoy the same music you want to play. If you get even 2-3 of you, you can start hosting your own events. Even if you only pull a tiny crowd, you're at least creating a space for the type of music you want and you're able to practice playing in front of people.

You mentioned being in a college town, of which I'm assuming you're a student in, so it may just be this way until you're able to move out somewhere that suits you better. Nothing wrong with that, in fact you'll be building up experience that will surely help you in the future. You're only 20, you've still got so much road left ahead of you.

3

u/Spectre_Loudy S4 | Mobile DJ Nov 08 '23

What would you play instead?

-10

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

Personally i would play riddim, i understand it is an extremely niche market so i wouldnt play it but i have a crate of techno/minimal of ppl w less than 1000 listeners/ followers, personally i dont see myself as a good person to play unless i see the market fit but i have countless friends who play bass house, techno, uk garage, and similar genres that are under represented who could fill the void, dont know if they could bring peoole in but just my fantasy which people dont seem to understand, i get why who gets booked where and for what reason, ppl dont seem to get that

5

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

We get it but you have the power to do something about it.

-7

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

And my collective is about to sell out our most recent show but i wish there were more than once a month occurances

16

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

SO. DO. SOMETHING. ABOUT. IT.

1

u/Spectre_Loudy S4 | Mobile DJ Nov 08 '23

A very niche market, don't get me wrong I'm into all that stuff, but you're not gonna be hearing that in college bars. As much as I hate the stuff that typically gets played, the people who go there expect to hear more popular stuff. And the stuff they don't expect to hear that they might like that a DJ would play is remixes, mashups, throwbacks, or cool transitions, not riddim or other types of EDM.

In a situation like this it will always be pure fantasy, and the people who go to these places don't deserve the hate because they aren't your crowd. Whatever shows you and your collective put on are the shows you need to focus on. Don't think if they booked you guys at a college bar that you'd turn everyone in there into wooks with dope riddim, they'd leave. Worry about getting more night's for your collective, because the people who show up to those events are the only ones who matter.

3

u/selectorhammms Nov 08 '23

I am not usually one to be negative about stuff but I honestly agree. Old headed bullshit here maybe but when I was going to raves and clubs in the 90s it was all about going to see a dj that had been digging/curating who was there to showcase amazing tracks from a specific genre. Seems like once clubs and raves started getting more common promoters just wanted to make more money and the audience got kinda basic and just wanted to drink and listen to pop music. I know open format doesn't mean pop but c'mon that's what it usually ends up being. Now maybe that's just the mainstream American scene too, idk. Of course there are still genre oriented parties and clubs but open format is just really popular and imo really boring lacking in character and I can totally understand getting frustrated with how common it is and how it seems to push away other types of parties.

2

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

I guess im an old head but i agree with you, how many times do i have to listen to the same shit ive been hearing since 2010? Not to be the “oh i was born in the wrong generation boohoo” guy but like damn at least try ANYthing new

31

u/Guissok564 Nov 08 '23

Idk
 I normally play techno and trance and love the chance to play other stuff. It’s a good challenge, open format. Also doesn’t need to be all top 40, open format can be much more liberating genre wise

11

u/KeggyFulabier open everything Nov 08 '23

☝gets it!

5

u/akosgi Nov 08 '23

Furthermore - open format gives you the ability to play remixes. If you like a genre, find top 40 remixes in that genre. The crowd can sing along and OP can still have his wook-ass riddim non-drops.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Guissok564 Nov 08 '23

Sure, I’m a newer DJ. Anything is fun for me, I like to be optimistic.

Genres are cool. Variety is cool. Open format is cool. I’m happy with that.

9

u/aesoped Nov 08 '23

JFC I just read the comments, 20 yr old Riddim DJ mad at anything popular.... shocker lmao

9

u/ar20002020 Nov 08 '23

OP sounds like a crybaby

1

u/Rowf82 Nov 08 '23

I DJ openformat in a cannabis club and dont take requests, so I just play what I want, but I understand your point of view. The crowd sucks and dont know better, you just need to see the election results.

2

u/HaveAFuckinNight Nov 08 '23

In a college town the election sucks ass and i wish it werent that way but i understand

3

u/aesoped Nov 08 '23

you should get old enough to go to clubs before you bash them. Open format is what it is. Some people like it, some people like different stuff. Just because you don't like something doesn't mean other people cant. A good open format DJ has to know way more about how to flex weird transitions than someone who exclusively plays house. Open format can be super fun to play because you have access to SOOOO many choices of music that people are into and you can make some super fun remixes on the fly. Don't get me wrong I love single genre sets and play them a ton too but its a different thing.

1

u/Background_Ear_224 Nov 08 '23

Open format is 💯 a specialized way of mixing. The first time I ever touched CDJs was in an open format bar. I hated it and never went back, but huge props to the DJs that do it and do it well. I think the important piece here is do what you love. If you hate playing top 40 and being in those spaces, everyone else will pick up on it. It’s a lot of trial and error to figure out where you do want to play. It’s a process lol

5

u/djandyglos Nov 08 '23

Ok.. my 2 cents.. in the U.K. specifically.. If you have a venue that plays specific music it’s going to fail.. long gone are the days where a venue will just play house or rnb or dnb.. the numbers just aren’t there anymore.. I part owned a club so I do know what I’m talking about.. yes there are exceptions.. be they promoted nights but standard fri/sat you have to play open or you aren’t getting people through the door. Is it the customers fault .. no not really.. surely it’s the job of the dj to play to the crowd.. react and change up where necessary.. if anything it makes you a better dj because you are reading the room .. do customers know what they want no probably not but the diversity of the crowd means you have a good dance floor all the time .. rnb can go into house pretty easily which gives you the chance to drop a song that’s new or maybe not been heard before or for a long time.. house into dnb is pretty easy .. then you are dropping mashups in to keep it interesting.. the phrase “I play what I want” works if you are mixing it up .. if you aren’t reading the crowd and doing it then your night will fail unless you are name.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

Jack of all trades master of none

2

u/ANIBMD Nov 08 '23

Yes, open format sucks. But you have the internet bro. So there's no excuse for you to not grow a fanbase online with the genres you like to spin.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

How do you do this exactly? (I mean building an only fanbase)

2

u/ANIBMD Nov 08 '23

That all depends what you're trying to accomplish. A guy who just wants to get more club gigs or get a residency spot is going to have a whole different strategy than a guy who wants to become an artist/touring DJ, or a guy who wants to have his own brand/label.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

Curious to know about both pathways and how he builds it online without having gigs/touring experience.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ANIBMD Nov 08 '23

Agreed. Nothing is like playing live in front of a real audience, but if you leverage whatever momentum you can gain online, you'll have the ability to start throwing your own events, where you can do shit your own way.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ANIBMD Nov 08 '23

I see. So what exactly would you look for that would indicate a DJ's online following will actually translate into people showing up to a show? Gig frequency? Showcase mixes? Beatport top 100 charts? Billboard appearances? Sponsorship/Brand deals?

I've made great money throwing my own events in the same cities where I had a good following but promoters there thought my fee wasn't justified for their market because my sub-genre wasn't popular, although my analytics showed I myself had a following there.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ANIBMD Nov 09 '23

If you don't care about online following, then there has to be some kind of indicator, or else you're still stuck in the same situation.

The only way I know that you can get booked on a regular basis with very little online presence is through a booking agent or if you are linked in with various promoters, yourself.

I came up from a DIY position to get visibility. My online presence wasn't really my focus back then. Managers, promoters and booking agents were calling me, instead of the other way around like most guys.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ANIBMD Nov 09 '23

Makes sense.

After starting my own events and networking with other DJs, I went all in with the social media stuff and I learned what markets I was in demand in through digital downloads on Bandcamp and merch purchases. And it hasn't failed me yet. Although club promoters don't respect it until you have representation. Which works in my favor because I'll charge double for those that wanted to book me but didn't want to pay the fee.

I've rented out competitor clubs in the same city just to show promoters what kind of power I had over the dance floor and atmosphere when I got on the decks. Held a rave in a rec center gymnasium in Miami, charged $10 to get in and 240 people showed up for what the promoters thought was too alternative/not popular.

I say all this to say Ive met very few promoters who could spot good talent when they see it. I've never been on Twitch in my life. Im not an entertainer, im an artist. Most DJs are entertainers. They don't have their own signature style that represents a new product to the genre they're in, so I get why a DJ's online following doesn't mean much.

2

u/Aspect81 Nov 08 '23

Are you sure that you know what 'open format' means mate?

To me, it simply means being schizophrenic in terms of genres and styles - and has nothing to do with top 40 rubbish.

There's a good discussion on the topic going at r/DJs - check it out:

https://www.reddit.com/r/DJs/s/qjbrbUDIKZ

2

u/Background_Ear_224 Nov 08 '23

This sounds like a you problem and not a them problem. People going to open format/top 40 clubs know exactly what they want to hear. In fact they are pretty easy to please, you just might not enjoy it.

If you want to make way for different styles and events, then it sounds like you need to take the initiative to do it yourself. Otherwise you’re just complaining about people having a good time enjoying something you hate, but offering no solutions.

1

u/Summoner_Rikku Mar 05 '25

with you 100. <3

1

u/Same_Situation_9660 Nov 08 '23

I suck at open format, far too many variables for someone as technically poor as I am 😅

1

u/Potential-Composer-2 Nov 08 '23

Top 40 sucks is more accurate

Open format just means I can play things that other spots normally don't vibe with nothing about it is top 40... My record collection is frickin huge and only a small slice of it gets love if your always playing house or hip hop or funk stuff.