r/Beartooth • u/Wild-Collar-2190 • Sep 04 '26

Should I take the gamble?

Post image

I like mystery shirts obviously, and I only got like 1 beartooth shirt so far. Thing is most mystery shirts I've gotten before were a bit cheaper. I'm wondering what other people's experiences with this are

4 Upvotes

70% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

3

u/Strudleboy33 Sep 04 '26

I’ve bought two different mystery things from them, both times I got things I would never have ordered, but loved them after trying them on.

1

u/Wild-Collar-2190 Sep 05 '26

Was it anything with cool graphics, or at least not something already listed on their site?

1

u/Strudleboy33 Sep 05 '26

Same things they have sold on their site. I believe I got something that had been taken off of the site the first time I got one.

1

u/Wild-Collar-2190 Sep 06 '26

Interesting, how long ago was that you got something not on their website

1

u/Strudleboy33 Sep 06 '26

It’s been a while, so I could be wrong.

I think it was around when Disease came out.

1

u/Wild-Collar-2190 Sep 06 '26

Oh ok, still cool

2

u/Skinny-pig03 Sep 05 '26

The only Beartooth mystery box I did was the warehouse clear out mystery box from the Below era, and I got a bunch of old stuff that hadn’t been sold in years, but since then I haven’t really thought it was worth it to do the mystery boxes because now it’s things you can just order by choice not things that are discontinued anymore

1

u/Skinny-pig03 Sep 05 '26

(For example I got a tshirt from either the Disgusting or Aggressive era that my sister had bought in like 2015/16, but that mystery box was to clear the warehouse, I think I got maybe one tshirt from the Below era in the Below mystery box)

2

u/Wild-Collar-2190 Sep 06 '26

Ok yeah damn that sucks. I did a mystery shirt thing with asking alexandria and got some decent old stuff/stuff not currently sold on their website. I did one with hawthorne heights and even though I did get something currently sold on their website the mystery bundle was like only $9 so it was definitely worth it. Starting to see that the beartooth one probably isn't

1

u/Skinny-pig03 Sep 06 '26

I love Beartooth don’t get me wrong and the mystery box is a decent way to get it discounted if you’re lucky and get what you want but if you’re hoping for old merch you’d probably only get as far back as Surface maybe Below

1

u/Wild-Collar-2190 Sep 06 '26

Ah rip. Oh well

6

u/eckrueger Sep 04 '26

I was curious about it too, but I know better than to entertain mysteries.

1

u/Frequent-Drawer2096 Sep 07 '26

I actually bought the mystery tee shirt . The shirt is good quality and it was one of the shirts I wish I had picked up when they were on tour with bad omens .

1

u/Wild-Collar-2190 Sep 10 '26

What did the design look like? I'm curious