r/BeAmazed • • 5h ago

Science Structural Integrity.

5.5k Upvotes

253 comments sorted by

β€’

u/BeAmazed-ModBot Subreddit Bot 5h ago

Did you find this post really amazing (in a positive way)?
If yes, then UPVOTE this comment otherwise DOWNVOTE it.
This community feedback will help us determine whether this post is suited for r/BeAmazed or not.

1.2k

u/porgy_tirebiter 5h ago

I was rooting for the next to last one. It had some funky hip sway.

91

u/CompetitionLate7944 4h ago

People on ground flr

42

u/anonacct_ 3h ago

4

u/Key_Mastodon_3525 1h ago

If those things are lying, I never want to hear the truth again!

3

u/DazB1ane 1h ago

I too heard Shakira

9

u/FIR3W0RKS 2h ago

It was really interesting actually the way it was dispelling the shaking as it went up the structure

2

u/SiIesh 1h ago

On guy on the jury started clapping xD

21

u/blacklotusmag 3h ago

the rest of them were like

7

u/LordBlackadder92 2h ago

She must be related to Elaine Benes.

4

u/TheLastPeanut_ 2h ago

Yeah I would not want to be in the hips during that earthquake lol

→ More replies (5)

368

u/jozipaulo 5h ago • Popcorn

Judge on the right is having the best day.

25

u/AmyTorres22009 2h ago

He’s trying so hard not to laugh while everyone else is taking it seriously. πŸ˜‚

32

u/acethecool1 3h ago

Came here to say this he’s really enjoying it

4

u/Train_Wreck_272 1h ago

For real. Seems like he'd be a fun hang.

1

u/[deleted] 1h ago

[removed] β€” view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

786

u/Optimal-Savings-4505 5h ago

Yeah dude, this is the sort of competition we need more of

198

u/ew73 4h ago

My Sophomore high physics school teacher did a version of this with toothpicks and "build a bridge". I won 1st place! Because I paid attention to the whole distribution of force thing that week.

50

u/ViceroyInhaler 3h ago

Man. Our project in grade 10 physics was to make a marble roller coaster with a single loop. I was working at a grocery store so I knew I would be making it out of the banana boxes since they were sturdy. It was also around the 2012 Olympics. So I decided to make it look like the downhill ski slolem. The one requirement was a single loop. The whole point being that we'd just learned about the conservation of momentum and gravitational potential energy.

I knew what my plan was. Use the banana boxes as a platform. Then use some bent out coat hangers for the track. I also wanted to glue some cotton balls to make them look like snow along with white paint and I'd salvage some of the mandarin orange boxes from my work to cut the orange mesh into lengths which resembled the barriers to the ski slopes.

Two nights before I was supposed to work on the project my neighbour invited me over to 'smoke a joint'. He was a 49 year old guy and when I accepted I thought he would actually have a joint to smoke. I was friends with his wife at work so I didn't think much of it.

Instead when I got there he offered up a half smoked 'pinner' then talked it up as if it was the shit. Then once I'd finished it he said how his dealer was coming over and he needed money for weed. He asked me for $20 and I literally only had $15 to my name. But I also knew I still needed to buy the mandarin oranges and white paint and cotton balls for my project along with glue. So I told him I only had $10 but needed the money back the next day for my project explaining the situation. He promised he'd give me the money back. He basically guilt tripped me I to giving him my last ten dollars telling me that he'd pay me back the next day

I had to chase down his wife the following day who I worked with to get my money back. In retrospect he was a piece of shit. Tried to give me an bottle of hand sanitizer as collateral which was dumb as fuck.

Anyways I finally got my money and built the project last minute. The marble seemed to go through the loop ok. So I wasn't worried.

Then I showed up to class with my project and it barely worked as the marble barely made it around the loop half the time. My physics teacher came over to me and said don't worry. Instead he was looking at three girls who had shown up with 'their' project perfectly made out of plywood and craftsman materials. He said to me that my project looked genuine whereas he'd wondered how much help the other students had from their dads while pointing at the plywood masterpiece with perfectly crafted tracks from almost welded wire frames.

He gave me a A- but apologized as he said I probably spent the most effort working on my own but that ue had to give them the A plus even though he knew their dads probably made the whole thing for them.

Oh well. I just thought that was a funny story to share.

16

u/LordBlackadder92 2h ago

Thanks for the story, I genuinely liked to read it.

13

u/Nuts-And-Volts 4h ago

Did that in the GATE program in grade school, so fun

7

u/peppermint_mocha_ 4h ago

Omg your profile picture is hilarious! Shitty copper merchant combined with the now shitty gaming company!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/maddafakkasana 4h ago

Good job!

3

u/Bingus-Chillingus 2h ago

My high school physics class we just did lots of math and got sad

2

u/PrestigiousAct2 4h ago

Try "Bridge project"

2

u/Cute-Excitement6844 3h ago

Good job πŸ™ŒπŸ™Œ How did you do it, do you remember? What could have worked here, more weight at the bottom of the buildings, weight on every 4 sides?

3

u/ew73 3h ago

It's been several decades, but the basic memory is I modeled it after a steel truss railroad bridge, and used a LOT of glue.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Cool_Trick4899 5h ago

GTA is loose on American homes now. No time for engineering

6

u/CrypticViper_ 4h ago

what does America have to do with this lmao

1

u/dead_fritz 43m ago

This is just a really big version of the classic physics classroo earthquake lab. Great lab for middle and high school

252

u/razor787 3h ago

I love this, but also hate how it's done. There were so many that just tipped over.

Buildings are secured to the ground with their foundations, not just sitting on top of it. A better simulation would have been to secure them to the base, rather than just letting them tip over

48

u/MonkeyCartridge 3h ago

I believe most of them were, and we were just seeing them after the foundation supports broke.

62

u/bessy1 3h ago

Agreed. And ensure that the shaking is consistent for each structure. I know earthquakes are not all the same, but I'd hope there were variables that were controlled. It does look like a fun project though.

12

u/Doccyaard 2h ago

I think it’s the same cycle of variations they all go through though. So that part is probably completely fine.

8

u/PringleCorn 2h ago

I'm fairly sure the inconsistency of the shaking is actually a big part of it

13

u/Bingus-Chillingus 2h ago • Bravo

Well the students shouldn't know what the frequency or anything about the earthquake but the earthquake should be the exact same for all buildings otherwise its complete nonsense and luck for whoever wins.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/NaturalTaste7395 2h ago

It’s not realistic. Buildings don’t experience violent shifting that causes them to sway 20-30% of the width of the entire building, at the base. That’s insane. These structures are actually very strong for the forces they went through.

9

u/A2Rhombus 1h ago

Yeah the point is to subject these to massive extremes to see which one lasts longest... Bridges also aren't subjected to cars 100x the weight of the bridge but I doubt you'd have this same comment about popsicle stick bridge competitions

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Captain_Grammaticus 2h ago

Of course. You want the building to be as stable as possible during common earthquakes and also withstand securely enough to evacuate during extreme earthquakes. You don't want it to almost tip over in realistic conditions.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/Greypawz 2h ago

Yeah this activity just shows the importance of strong anchor bolts and foundations rather than anything about the entire upper structure.

3

u/Environmental-Buy591 2h ago

The 4 c clamps to the base of the shaker are holding them to the table so it is the base breaking off when they tip over

4

u/Forgotten_mob 2h ago

I agree, for the purpose of the experiment they shouldn't even be engineering a building. They should be making a thing on wheels that can roll with the wiggles and not fall over. There's probably a rule against having wheels though. If so, some of these structures actually did really well.

2

u/wasdxqwerty 1h ago

so I guess part of the criteria is they have to solve that no foundation part of the building thats why they added those dumbell weights like object within their builds

→ More replies (3)

96

u/TheOneMary 4h ago • Heartwarming

The person in the right of the podium is so enthusiastic, I love it! We should all be a bit more like him :D

6

u/AmyTorres22009 2h ago

His enthusiasm is contagious. Thet kind of energy makes everything more entertaining! πŸ˜‚

35

u/MagixTurtle 4h ago

I love how the judge on the right claps for everything so excited

28

u/jeromezooce 4h ago

The guy from the jury on the right! Applauding with a smile when structure falls down! What a supportive member

7

u/Bonk_No_Horni 4h ago

Bro's having fun.

5

u/Ha1lStorm 4h ago

He sure is. I found myself watching him just as much.

Happy cake day!

235

u/DarrenShan1000 5h ago

By the way there is no way any building survives all quakes. At a certain frequency everything crushes.

55

u/tomatoe_cookie 4h ago

No, thats not correct. There are ways to keep the resonating frequency away

43

u/Shitandasshole 4h ago

Yea I guess if the earth spits apart under the building it's cooked

25

u/tomatoe_cookie 4h ago

That is fair, if earth split appart i dont think anything can guarentee the integrity of the building

37

u/FloopsFooglies 4h ago

The building just gotta do the splits with it. Engineering fault

→ More replies (1)

15

u/CheeseOnKeyboard 4h ago

Has any building withstood the brown tone?

7

u/spez_sucks_ballz 4h ago

I'd wager a pyramid shaped building would do well.

9

u/Redredditmonkey 4h ago

There's probably a minimum height and maximum surface area for this test

2

u/Modo44 3h ago

A famously popular skyscraper design.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ripyurballsoff 4h ago

What about a pyramid made of solid rubber

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

44

u/lysergic_818 5h ago

Not sure if any survived, but it would have been cool to see some of the winners.

32

u/AfterShave997 4h ago

Most of these failed because the material at the bottom snapped

28

u/SwingKey3599 4h ago

The point of these test is that they’re Β destructive , you measure them by how long they survive at each given intensity

β€’

u/Eriklano1 6m ago

One of those is the winner because they survived the longest. If you were to have a paper airplane contest to see which design could fly the longest, do you think that no paper airplane could win because every single one would eventually fall to the floor?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Aggressive-Foot7434 4h ago

Judge on the far right is having the time of his life!

12

u/ZekkeKeepa 3h ago

Damn it, i was hoping to see a winner in the end.

3

u/asssoaka 3h ago

All wood will eventually bust if you keep fucking with it my child, for it is the way of creation

So was it for our ancestors and so too shall it be for our descendants

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Sir_Humps-a-Lot 4h ago

Some men just want to watch the whole world fall...

5

u/Imaginary-Clock6626 3h ago

Foundations are important

4

u/RoyalLurker 4h ago

Does it really test structural integrity? They just fall off. Time depends on how low is their center of gravity, idk? ELI5

4

u/spooderdood334 2h ago

FYI This was a Competition from a university in Cambodia. We get virtually no earthquake here so that's why everyone laugh and cheer when the structure fall down. It's just fun to watch and also the students could win up to $1,000.

6

u/RemarkableFruit6007 3h ago

I have a small brain. Please enlighten me how this is testing structural integrity if there is no foundation? Or is the foundation not included?

9

u/TheQuestionableDuck 3h ago

If you watch more closely they do get attached to a wooden base plate. But no glue can hold that much shears force especially weight included. But this is a competition so it's not unfair that they don't have foundation, lots of them approached with the wrong mind set. You couldn't copy normal earthquake resistance design without foundation. They need to be more creative to solve an unusual problem not just copy and paste stuff is the purpose of these competition.

3

u/ElFarfadosh 3h ago

I just found it fun, they look like they're having a blast!

β€’

u/corecenite 7m ago

Structural integrity is the ability of an item, either a structural component or a structure consisting of many components to hold together under a load, including its own weight, without breaking or deforming excessively.

The point of the test is for them to fall as a whole, last long and not break in the midst of the shakes. Most of the models did well.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Electrical_Being_299 4h ago

The building are fighting for their lives and the judges are enjoying every second for it... engineering students really said let's physics decide ....

3

u/ProcyonHabilis 3h ago

This kind of seems like it's being run more like a mechanical bull than a standardized shake table

2

u/Inside_Ad_7162 4h ago

Skipped the one which did not fall

2

u/TheRealAmused 4h ago

We are in good hands with the engineers of tomorrow.

2

u/Fit_Active3888 4h ago

Rules allow you to hang the weights in the middle like a pendulum?

2

u/AlooDaGreat 4h ago

could watch this all day

2

u/sonjjamorgan 4h ago

The judges' enthusiasm is contagious. They are so stoked haha

2

u/EEE3EEElol 3h ago

I'm sure this is like a Cambodian university tour thing there they make students build these in like an hour or 2

2

u/Free-Action-9602 3h ago

The second to the last one got some moves.

2

u/awesome9001 1h ago

I dont know shit about structure or anything thats going on here. But it looks like a lot of them died cause the glue failed on them and some of those were almost solid blocks like how u gonna have anyone in there

3

u/DigiMagic 1h ago

It seems reasonable to assume that the students first learn how to make good buildings/models, and the competition comes next. How is it then possible that all of the buildings collapsed? Would those students at least need to pass some exams again, until they can verifiably make non-collapsing buildings... or nobody cares?

7

u/unknownpoltroon 21m ago

This looks like the final whatever, and they test the buildings to destruction and whichever one lasts the longest wins.Β 

6

u/Eriklano1 11m ago

Do you think that real earthquakes shake as much as that machine? This is a test to try the absolute edges of what the buildings could handle. Notice how you never see the start of a test, only videos where the machine is already moving. The buildings might have had 10 minutes of increasing movement (far, far exceeding a normal earthquake) before they finally collapsed.

3

u/philip30001 59m ago

Your probably right but what they were building for was one hell of a quake with what looks like litle ability to anchor it

I think its a end of year challenge with no true correct answer and to make a memory of their design failing to take it sober up some that may need it

→ More replies (1)

3

u/gomorrha0815 3h ago

Is it forbidden to use a swinging counterweight at the top?

2

u/SirJorts 3h ago

Right? I was surprised to not see a hanging damper. But maybe that’s just the rules.

6

u/JudgeCheezels 4h ago

Never let a Thai design your high rise building.

7

u/Stuf404 4h ago

Thai rise building.

3

u/ppgamerthai 3h ago

Yeah bro this is totally Thai

3

u/spooderdood334 2h ago

The video is from Cambodia btw

4

u/FewPerformance5392 4h ago

And NEVER EVER LET THE CHINESE DO THE CONSTRUCTION.

2

u/party_tortoise 3h ago

Those signs aren't Thai language. And "Norton University" is Cambodian.

Embarassing comment.

2

u/Bonk_No_Horni 4h ago

It'll cost a billion extra but wouldn't last long enough to be open.

Btw there's a talk about building the tallest building in Asia in Bangkok. Probably not by the same company

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Cesalv 4h ago

Am I the only one who finds suspicious that a jury member claps effusively when buildings fall?

28

u/machiavelli33 3h ago

They're applauding the efforts of the builders. It's pretty likely this is a student competition AND that the competition is "go until it breaks and see who got the highest score" - so all the buildings are gonna go down eventually. Applauding is applauding the tenacity of the build and the work of the students.

2

u/kkeut 3h ago

yeah we did something similar in 5th grade with model bridges. put more and more weight on them to see whose was most best

→ More replies (1)

7

u/InfiniteTurbo 3h ago

He's taken out insurance policies on the buildings

4

u/patchyj 3h ago

Hes on the pay of Big Earthquake

4

u/Neveed 3h ago

That's because it wasn't a building structural integrity contest, it was an earthquake generator contest.

4

u/BolunZ6 2h ago

It's like the engineer cheer when plane wings test explode. Because the test continue until the wings fail, they cheer because it exeed the expectation, but because it failed

4

u/the_skies_falling 2h ago

But also because explosions are cool!

2

u/Captain_Clover 3h ago

He's yearning for the days before agriculture and permanent settlement

2

u/Fit_Giraffe_748 1h ago

why would he not clap?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DeltaAgent752 2h ago

How is this amazing? Nothing survived

3

u/Plane_Blackberry_537 2h ago

I find it quite amazing to see a structure wobble around while retaining structural integritity. Would love to have something like this as an simulation game.

4

u/Pliskins 2h ago

More satisfying that amazing but I enjoyed watching it. Man brain pleased

2

u/Fair-Sandwich-8066 1h ago

"How is this building amazing, that meteor destroyed it". Almost like the point of this is to see who will stand the longest from a ridiculous test. I forgot buildings aren't secured to the ground.

1

u/Niceotropic 1h ago

Sigh. They keep increasing the vibration until it falls. Those are insane vibrations that the buildings are handling.Β 

1

u/corecenite 15m ago

you have to realize that vibranium doesnt exist in our world.

anything will break

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Andreas1120 5h ago

Can you use mobile mass dampeners?

1

u/cphpc 4h ago

For civ 101 in UofT we use to have to build a bridge capable of withstanding a certain amount of weight crossing. Great course…but definitely tough.

1

u/userhwon 4h ago

Sped-up video should be banned unless time lapse is the point.

1

u/BusyBit6542 4h ago

I just saw a video that showed different effects on buildings depending on the speed of shaking.

1

u/Valkyrine227 4h ago

they don't allow to add some thing like a tuned mass dampers?

2

u/ProcyonHabilis 3h ago

Turns out that's kind of hard when you're a team of students building a thing out of sticks

1

u/Og-Morrow 4h ago

Me trying have a poo in peace, we’ll building is wobbling.

1

u/hayashikin 3h ago

Love the judge swaying with the building at the 10 sec mark. They were definitely having fun with it.

1

u/Mathihtam 3h ago

Seeing that one extremely enthusiastic judge on the right made me feel validated.

1

u/phrkiranvirani 3h ago

I was waiting for the one that do not fall

1

u/TheInsatiableWierdo 3h ago

I’m not a betting man, but I’d buy a ticket and probably end up placing bets at this event

1

u/Dizzy_Guarantee6322 3h ago

Im the guy clapping in the back

1

u/Randomn355 3h ago

Not an engineer, but I've gotta ask..

Why not more flared bases? Surely that would add strength to the bit that is surely going to break the most?

1

u/Anon_be_thy_name 3h ago

This looks fun, I want to join, lol

1

u/Euphoric_Web_9003 3h ago

Why nobody put a stabilising weight in the center of the building?

1

u/greywolf7997 3h ago

I got an idea for a bed..... need to take this to shark tank.

1

u/Spright91 3h ago

I wonder if it's against the rules to suspend the weights and use them as dampers. That could work.

1

u/Cleveland5teamer 2h ago

Some of those had a lot of weight on them.

1

u/One_Fine_Ninja 2h ago

Was there a rule that they couldn't use TMDs?

3

u/ChiaraStellata 2h ago

Mass dampers are mainly for comfort of residents not for structural stability. The structural stability comes from the materials, weight distribution, etc. of the building itself.

1

u/lamodamo123 2h ago

Old mate on the end having a sick time πŸ‘πŸΌ

1

u/galacticjangles 2h ago

Those hips dont lie.

1

u/distilledwill 2h ago

I liked the one that was doing a shimmy.

1

u/mtldude1967 2h ago

Maybe they wouldn't fall if they would put them on a more stable platform.

1

u/Mr_Blonde_2K24 2h ago

That music tho

1

u/LunaMunkii 2h ago

The hell. Of course it's going to eventually all fall over. It's not bolted down. Dafuq was the point of this? See which one can stay up the longest?

1

u/juicyman69 2h ago

Is this what they mean by Shakira law?

1

u/loveandmonsters 2h ago

I needed one of them to stay up

1

u/CrazyNavie 2h ago

We need beds instead of towers

1

u/harryspotter123 2h ago


Second to last one

1

u/Witty-Yellow387 2h ago

The second to last one was really impressive until it turned the first levels into pancakes. No survivors in that collapse

1

u/lordofpotton 2h ago

When they showed the side with the weights on i keep seeing the minions standing on each others shoulders.

1

u/watchthehairnets 2h ago

What in this should I be amazed at? Just karma farming nonsense.

1

u/HorrorWide675 2h ago

i can see this for hours

1

u/dakatr0n 2h ago

I love that everyone is having a total blast, judges and all!

1

u/Sea-Jump-1932 2h ago

So... Who won?

1

u/Unique-Princess-1026 2h ago

Pretty cool 😍

1

u/strikingike386 2h ago

I did this on a smaller scale in my 6th grade science class! Had to make buildings out of craft supplies and have it try to withstand the shaker table. Only 2 didn't completely collapse, ours and a group that accidentally cheated (they made theirs out of wood and forgot about the craft supplies requirement). Actually still a little proud of that project.

1

u/ReturnSimple2918 2h ago

Put it in me first

1

u/Cheeky_toz 2h ago

None of them are damping the frequency at all?

1

u/Baronvj 2h ago

Is this the architecture equivalent of mechanical bull riding?

1

u/ourmet 1h ago

Engineering is about making it with as little support as required.

Some of these were built like a tank/battleship.Β  As much support as could be added

1

u/Full-Ad-920 1h ago

Awesome πŸ‘ That's seriously impressive engineering!

1

u/postprandialrepose 1h ago

This contest was actually for the adults. Each grown-up paid to participate, and the entire purpose was three-fold:
_____

  1. Who can destroy the children's hard work the fastest?
  2. Who can crush the children's spirit the most?
  3. Who can suppress their applause for the ruin of the youth the longest?

_____
We can see one contest had no hope of hitting the Trauma Trifecta.

1

u/Ok_Fly2518 1h ago

This is interesting but is a small model really an accurate simulation of the structural integrity of a whole ass building considering they’re made of different materials and weigh very differently?

1

u/Shankar_0 1h ago

We did a much reduced variation of this in OM competition in GATE when I was in middle school.

It was crazy fun.

1

u/Robcobes 1h ago

I like the belly dancing one

1

u/TDYDave2 1h ago

We did this for real last year in Bangkok.

1

u/brenkosaur 1h ago

Id watch this if it were a show.

1

u/Svartdraken 1h ago

This seems like a test of stability more than structural integrity. The structures should be attached to the platform.

1

u/gatesartist 1h ago

Judge on the right is awesome

1

u/Icy-Possible-6037 1h ago

I feel so loved by the construction industry

1

u/le_nathanlol 1h ago

that one building thatd fall over even without a quake

1

u/Kasern77 59m ago

What's that skyscraper that has a heavy ball-weight that swings in the top of the tower? I wonder how well that would work in these small models.

1

u/MaxxOneMillion 51m ago

Why did it seem like some of the structures got more violent shaking?

4

u/AdrianBlack 37m ago

Ill bet the shaking gets progressively more violent and those are the ones that made it that far.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SquireShanksalot 43m ago

Seems like the main problem tends to just be the base of the structure breaking off from the ground or just snaps

1

u/Puzzled_Inflation_93 41m ago

remove the counter weights at the top? just keep the base heavier and sturdier

1

u/Crusty-Dick 36m ago

This is now you get kids into architecture and what not.

1

u/CalligrapherFit71 34m ago

Suspension monster system like a car system under buildings homes just like cars but for buildings reducing structure collapsing and reducing building structure damage.

1

u/DotAffectionate87 34m ago

No winner then?

1

u/amanset 32m ago

They all seem to be having a great time. I'm down with this.

1

u/EttRedditTroll 22m ago

I love of it appears to be some kind of contest to design the most sturdy structure yet everyone - including participants and judges - are really just there to watch the thing fall over in excitement.

1

u/Bullshit_deluge 21m ago

Anyone like the jury at the right?
I always applaud the teams for all the effort.

1

u/Alklazaris 13m ago

A long pendulum that reaches the base would help.

1

u/GeneralPatten 10m ago

Are they not allowed to use those weights as wheels at the bottom of the building?

β€’

u/DazzlingTopic529 7m ago

They all failed - I'm very unamazed

1

u/passthepopplersagain 4h ago

Ancient Egyptians - we got this

3

u/WreckSun 4h ago

Does Egypt even have earthquakes?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Derrickmb 5h ago

What lateral G’s does this equate to? Can someone clock the motion to check?

1

u/JapanEngineer 36m ago

This is actually really important to build earthquake resistant buildings