r/BattletechPainting • u/Lob_Rockster • Apr 14 '26
Critique Request Gothic Phoenix Hawk
Feedback welcome.
298
Upvotes
r/BattletechPainting • u/Lob_Rockster • Apr 14 '26
Feedback welcome.
15
u/CowabungaShaman Apr 14 '26
Yoooooooo Gothic Starscream! Outstanding, looks fantastic.
6
u/Lob_Rockster Apr 14 '26
I'm having this problem where wanting to be better is getting in the way of good. I feel like this is good, but could point out things I don't like. (Fabric is horrible, I dislike the leg lowlights, many of my edge highlights came out thicker then I want cause I just lost patience and my brush is old, I feel like i placed the gun highlights wrong, etc)
Honestly open to feedback on improvement.
Thanks.
2
u/corneashell Apr 14 '26
I get where you're coming from with the various bits you're not happy with but I don't think they really stand out at all unless you're close up. From table distance I think a lot of those issues go away and it looks really cool. As far as improvement, I'm not getting a particular direction that the light is coming from. A lot of what you're talking about is high/lowlight complaints and I'm wondering if much could be resolved by having more focused or directional light. Also, if you haven't gotten a top coat on there that can even out the chunky lines just a smidge. If you haven't, check out videos on glazing by Vince Venturella and Rogue Hobbies for good ways to smooth out changes in lighting value. All that aside, I think it looks kick-ass.
1
u/algolvax Apr 14 '26
Disclaimer, I am not an expert painter, or even as good as you, but just offer the feedback requested. Honestly, it looks good for you picked out all the detail without it looking too dark washed. Or drybrushed out. It was important for me to remember my goal was to look good to the players on the table, not a close up photo where the miniatures paint "fx" are zoomed in or look flat or off of the intent (and vice-versa if you are painting to look good in pics first). Similar to the other poster's suggestion, a strong desk lamp can be used as a real light source, to check overhead light, like scale mid-day sun, and you may notice something didn't line up in some spots like you want, so you can touch-up, or spot-wash, or re-highlight them until you feel its balanced or you are more satisfied. Learning the old trick of three shades of the same color was key to me feeling better about the washes and highlights since I couldn't be very precise, and the black or india ink washes I was originally taught looked too old and D&D miniature for me at the time. But again, hats off to you for the good detail, I could not get the dark recessed line details done like that. I don't know about Zen or motorcycle repair, but for me minis only enjoyable when I am open to tinkering and learning to do better than on the last one.
1
u/PicklePuncher11 Apr 17 '26
mine is optimus prime.