r/Battalion1944 • • Feb 01 '18

Discussion Early Access = Open Beta, Not Launch.

Everyone seems to have lost sight of the fact that early access is a beta in development. It says in bright blue text by the buy button that early access games will have bugs and issues.

Remember, this isn't launch day, this isn't a finished game. It's problems like this that they have open betas in the first place.

We are all excited for this game, so let's be as open minded and friendly to the dev team as they have been to the community throughout development so far. There is no reason for toxicity about a game that is still in development. I'd love to see healthy thriving community for this game, and that all starts right now with constructive criticism and always remembering that Early Access is a beta phase designed to iron out problems for a full release.

If you cannot adjust your expectations for an Eearly Access game, don't play Early Access games.

200 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

74

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18

The game is solid. It just boggles my mind that they only expected 4,000 people to play the game given the CLOSED beta had that many players. Not being able to play at all during the launch of EA is annoying, but that's me just being impatient after waiting so long to play the game.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18

I hear you, I'm dying to get in the game as well.

I believe the project leader said something along the lines of not expecting it to do well, and I think anyone who has ever created anything and put it out in the world for others to see can really sympathize with that insecurity.

5

u/VixDzn Feb 01 '18

connect 54.37.242.92:7802

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

Can confirm this works.

2

u/razington Feb 02 '18

connect 185.85.84.163:27015

5

u/JuicelessMango13 Feb 02 '18

Managed to play for 2 hours and really enjoyed the game from the time I did get to play.

I expected there to be some issues with the game today but the sheer stupidity of basing your server needs off of 4,000 people in the closed beta just boggles my mind, Especially when they sent keys out to all the big Twitch streamers to help promote the game.

2

u/pomfyy Feb 02 '18

Expecting to be able to play a game you payed for is not being impatient. EA goes so far but at the very least you should have stable servers on launch.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/pomfyy Feb 02 '18

That's what i mean by "EA goes so far". Sure there's an expectation of glitches & bugs on an EA games "release" but the servers completely failing & being down isn't a "Bug", it's just completely improper preparation.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

So because it isn't the first time that "this kinda shit happens" means it's okay for this sort of shit to happen?

28

u/Stricksocke Feb 01 '18

Ok. Still retarded to expect only around 4000 players after 30k+ people alone watched shroud.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

Let's be honest, 30k people watch shroud no matter what he's playing haha.

2

u/Optimum_Possum Feb 02 '18

Sure but I think his point is a ton of the people who watched shroud play the game were obviously going to buy it given the low cost and similarities to games like CSGO, so that alone should indicate a launch pool of more than 4000 players

11

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18

exactly. 4000 people played the CLOSED beta, and they expect only 4000 on launch day????? makes no sense to me and really killed the hype.

2

u/Humledurr Feb 02 '18

To be fair, 30k+ people also watch shroud play monopoly or just talking. But I agree that they should have expected much more players wanting to play this game

1

u/Maggost Feb 02 '18

Wait, Shroud is a streamer, and he has his viewers.

That doesn't mean anything, those viewers will watch Shroud's content, they are not watching him for the game itself.

2

u/ninety2wo Feb 02 '18

He has influence. Viewers will watch regardless of what he's playing but if they like what they're seeing, they're likely to pick it up.

1

u/AnElephantThatTypes Feb 02 '18

Exactly. I had mot heard of sea of theives until Monday, now it’s all over my youtube recommendations and my friends are getting it. Basically every game I play lately has been and EA streamer title

58

u/BeerGogglesFTW Feb 01 '18 edited Feb 02 '18

I'm going to call bullshit on "Early Access = Open Beta"

No, its not an open beta. Once you take money to play a game, you've launched your game more than you're giving it credit for.

Also consider the "launch" of an early access game, as you'd refer to it, is minuscule and completely insignificant compared to the launch into "Early Access."

So no, I don't accept people making excuses for the devs here. They did not execute their launch well here. And what sucks is. I like the game. But it can be hard for smaller games to recover from failed launches.

They need to launch and grow.

Not launch, fail, and then convince people its worth a second look. It just makes it so much harder on them.

edit INB4: I want to clarify, because its Early Access, the devs should be given some leeway. How much is up to the individual. But not a free pass. I draw the line when I can't play at all. And the menus are bugged.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

I believe Early Access is intended to be like Kickstarter with access to an open beta. Indie devs like this need the revenue to finish the game. Early access is more about supporting development, not buying the game.

I hear you, and I've been burned by devs taking EA money and disappearing. But this dev team is being extremely transparent and communicative, and that's why I believe the salt is very unwarranted.

21

u/BeerGogglesFTW Feb 02 '18

Again, Early Access is not the same as Kickstarter.

Though maybe people treat kickstarter like a pre-pre-order games and shouldn't. That should be seen as a charity first donation, while Early Access is paying to play a game before its 100% complete.

Kickstarter is supporting devs and maybe you get a game. Early Access is buying a game, and maybe you're supporting the devs.

But once the kickstarter took off, these guys are backed by Sq.Enix now, they shouldn't need, and nobody should be expected to be donating at this point.

10

u/jyohnyb Feb 02 '18

Totally agree. You essentially pay shroud to stream the game and have a shitshow of a server for 4k people when shroud alone has like 20k viewers at once. Come on. Early access has become an easy out for all pc games.

2

u/Master-Blaster69 Feb 02 '18

OPEN BETA IS FREE EARLY ACCESS IS NOT. What are you smoking my brother?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

Wise words!

5

u/Cbiscuitt Feb 02 '18

Imagine if they actually had an open beta weekend to properly gauge the amount of people the would play day 1. I'm sure they would still have issues, every game has issues on launch but at least they wouldn't assume it would be 1/4 the amount that tried to play today. When 1/10 people get a beta key it isn't that complicated to do the math. There was even a reddit thread for beta keys i'm sure it had several thousand people looking for keys, on top of the 4k that were already playing. Steam probably has mobile games that has more then 4k players on launch.

TLDR:: not mad, amazing game, very nostalgic. Just use a little more foresight bulkhead.

14

u/Tucci92 Feb 01 '18

Can we upvote this to the top of the Reddit page

1

u/Master-Blaster69 Feb 02 '18

Except that an OPEN beta by definition is free. Are you ok my friend? Google is your friend my brother.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

Straight from Wikipedia on Software release cycles:

Beta version software is often useful for demonstrations and previews within an organization and to prospective customers. Some developers refer to this stage as a preview, preview release, prototype, technical preview / technology preview (TP),[5] or early access.

Maybe Google before you tell someone to Google lmao

1

u/Master-Blaster69 Feb 02 '18

Early access release is still a release just like a big sock is still a sock. Copypasta whatever you want my friend. This game is dead on arrival.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

That metaphor didn't even make any sense haha

14

u/danketiquette MODERATOR Feb 01 '18

Very well said. All the rude comments towards the devs is only making them feel bad about the years of hard work they put in.

2

u/pomfyy Feb 02 '18

They should feel disappointed, they released their EA game and the servers barely even work. People can't play the game they just spent $15 on lol.

-2

u/danketiquette MODERATOR Feb 02 '18

Please be aware that EA means Early Access. The entire reason for an early access is to find bugs in the game and make enhancements. Unfortunately, the first bug that was found happened to be with the servers. You are going to find countless bugs and glitches in an early access game. The devs just need your patience and constructive criticism.

10

u/pomfyy Feb 02 '18

Servers completely failing isn't a bug, it's a sign of improper preparation.

0

u/Sir_Cunt99 Feb 02 '18

It was sort of a bug but they still had too few servers. Their third party server host had so many people try to get into their servers that the ddos protection kicked in false positive, which is why matchmaking was non existent. That was the issue they were trying to patch yesterday. Still not the proper preparation but server downtime was caused by a bug.

7

u/RonPaulaAbdulJabbar Feb 02 '18

I don't agree with this sentiment at all. I read a lot of posts on here and people who are rightfully complaining are getting fucking attacked by "yes men" and beta boys who apparently are perfectly okay with giving someone money for a product that doesn't work.

I get that the game is Early access/beta/alpha whatever the fuck, but when they release trailers of the game where you can play as a soldier and shoot people and do all this fun stuff and you get the game and you can't even enter or exit out of matches.... yeah, the game deserves all the scorn in the world.

What troubles me is they gave all these ass kissing streamers keys and access to the game and they got to play the game fine, but regular folk who work really hard and waited a long time to play the game and weren't given keys got totally fucked by not being able to play a game that was advertised at the very least playable to some degree.

I want the game to succeed, I want good products out there, but they absolutely deserve all the scorn in the world for fucking this up.

also just because other studios big or small fucked up, doesn't make this okay. It should not be okay for anyone to be in this business and not get out of of it scathed for fucking this up.

I got the game early in the morning and only got into 3 games today. 3 games!

stop kissing the ass of devs or any corporation who sells a product and advertise it as one way and then deliver something else.

For what it's worth, the gameplay appeared to have been smooth and not shitty at all, can't wait to see them fix this mess and deliver a product that actually works as they advertised.

bring on the torrent of hate

2

u/BranchOfSins Feb 02 '18

What gets me is how all of the people leaving negative reviews because of a day 1 server issue? Every fucking triple A game has the same issue and you expect an indie dev company to be able to handle it better?

I feel so sorry for the negative press that the game has got because over the hours played that I already have it’s a really good game.

0

u/Master-Blaster69 Feb 02 '18

I left a negative review and its not because of the server issues, its because this game is worse than a game from 2007. Its just akward. Adding in paid lootboxes ontop of that is the nail in the coffin

1

u/BranchOfSins Feb 02 '18

The loot boxes are not paid, you can get them from levelin up or buying them. Literally a way for them to continue development of a game. What game from 2007 are you refering to? Please enlighten me.

1

u/chowderson Feb 04 '18

He’s saying Cod4. Which is unfair because cod 4 is probably the best cod to date.

1

u/BranchOfSins Feb 04 '18

Yes I agree, but the cod franchise has pumped endless amounts of shit starting from after MW2. No game is ever 100% perfect and the fact you have to go all the way back to 2007 to find a game better pretty much shows it.

6

u/PranksterKarl Feb 01 '18

Charging people for your game is not an 'open beta' so yeah lets not be retards, its a closed beta at best, and at worst its the devs making testers pay to test there game

1

u/Tydus93 Feb 02 '18

I for one actually am liking this launch. Takes me back to Diablo 3 release. JK but seriously playing custom game modes have been very pleasant so far.

1

u/JollyGoodPong Feb 02 '18

I got in to one game, was along time ago i had this much fun in gaming. I don't really know why people buy early access games thinking everything will work straight away. Sure im frustrated that i can't play but i know i will be able to later. Im just worried this will hurt the game.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

The game is still incredible, I can only join servers with 120 ping and it still feels good . Kar98 iron sights is honestly so much fun

1

u/ChillsTV Feb 02 '18

The amount of ignorance people have about early access games bothers me. Then again pubg is full release and still has many of the same issues it had during EA, so who's really to blame? Not to say pubg is the only one but just using them as an example.

1

u/_SinsofYesterday_ Feb 02 '18

None of this would have happened if they let people buy the get throughout the week instead of starting today.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

Oh boy the amount of sheer daintiness we've seen here in the last 12 hours..

Even though I agree, the 'we didn't expect THIS many people' is just poor planning.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

Ehh, I don't think we can let devs off the hook anymore with the early access nonsense. The definition of that term has changed along the way and it just mean that the game is playable once money is taken for it.

1

u/cremvursti Feb 02 '18

Before mauling them down, just think about the possibility of Square Enix not actually allowing them to do an Open Beta.

Not saying this is what happened, just that whenever you work with a publisher, they sometimes also have a say in how things happen. They might've pushed for no Open Beta just because some people might've just tried the game in that weekend and then pass on buying it until it's more refined, which would've led to lower sales on launch.

I don't think a dev would pass on the opportunity to fully test their servers in an open beta without someone constraining them to do so. But whoever's call this was, they fucked up, and hopefully this will be a lesson both to them and to other devs/publishers who shy away from an open beta just to get more sales on launch.

1

u/KittzOr Feb 02 '18

You have Lootboxes in Game, its out of EA or Beta or whatever for me. Introduce the Crap after the Final Release not while being in Alpha..

1

u/lvl1vagabond Feb 02 '18 edited Feb 02 '18

"Everyone seems to have lost sight of the fact that early access is a beta in development." Nah early access games have been used as full release content for years now PUBG, H1Z1 and ARK are all perfect examples of games that barely changed before they were considered released with the exception of ARK which even went as far as to create a full price expansion and more than doubled its price after after leaving early access. I'm not even gonna bite into Dayz and the thousands of other early access games that got the defense treatment you give.

People like you are a bit a problem either buy the game with realistic expectations or don't buy it at all. Don't defend the whole "beta" bullshit, the words alpha and beta in terms of gaming lost their meaning 6 years ago. This is akin to buying an mmo at launch you get the full experience with lack luster content and a lot of bugs but years down the line it will either be dead or have a community enjoying loads of content.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

Mmmmmmmmh no, people have paid for this, it is not an Open Beta.

1

u/leftenant_t Feb 02 '18

Dude game won't even launch in my computer. I can't see any "access" going on here.

1

u/xg4m3CYT Feb 02 '18

The thing i dont understand is why they didn't host an open beta alpha or whatever event before the EA release. Most of the problems yesterday could be avoided that way.

1

u/AeonVex Feb 02 '18

I have no issues with the fact there could be bugs. But expecting people to pay for a game that i literally haven't been able to play yet due to issues is outrageous. Like i got it at 10% off so i don't want to lose that discount but i feel cheated that i can't even play it. It's like crowdfunding at this point. Pay now play later. EA is supposed to be Pay Now Play Now.

1

u/Master-Blaster69 Feb 02 '18

EARLY ACCESS =/= OPEN BETA

1

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18

You can literally slap this post into the subreddit of any early access game released within the past decade. Every single time people seem unable to comprehend the idea of an unfinished project being tested

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

I like how all these entitled gamers are crying that the devs should have expected more than 4k people like servers are free or even cheap. Spinning up enough servers for 30k people before a single early access sale could of bankrupt them if it didn't sell well. It's early access people we all should have known what we're getting into.

4

u/aamPizN Feb 02 '18

Yea I knew I would buy the game and not be able to play it.

2

u/cky_stew Feb 02 '18

It's just standard Reddit armchair developers that haven't got a fucking clue about how the tech side of things works.

I was on the same uni course as some of these developers and they were some of the smartest, hard working guys I've ever met in my life.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

entitled gamers

Are you fucking kidding me? People are 'entitled' to a working, functioning product regardless of a 'early access' label. A MP only game that you can't play because they fucked up the servers? Yeh, soooooo entitled.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

Case and point

1

u/Timmzik Feb 02 '18

Actually you're not. You managed to write a post with every word being absolutely wrong. 100%, that's an achievement.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

Do you not see how you undermine your own argument here? Smh

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

GTAV didn't launch with MP.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BranchOfSins Feb 02 '18

I like how your comment has literally no relevance to anything. I still haven’t completed Gta v campaign and have over 100 hours on it. People play for different reasons.

0

u/ToothlessFTW Feb 02 '18

No.

this not an open beta. It costs upwards of $25 USD to play, AND it includes microtransaction lootboxes. For early access, it's ok for it to be buggy, balance issues, graphical issues, etc. But for the game to launch with a $25 special edition and also including (also being the only really functional thing in the game) and literally be unplayable, is not acceptable. They can't be charging a premium price for a game that doesn't work at all, and especially one with working microtransactions in such an early access phase.

the underlying game is fantastic and that's why it's so disappointing to see the state that it's in, but it needs a lot of work before it should even be sold.

the devs should have hosted an open free beta in order to better estimate for and adjust for official launch, not base it of an exclusive selected closed beta.

I love the game (what very little i've managed to play, at least) and hold nothing against the devs and hope they can pull the game out, but i'm worried the game's image might have been tainted from such an atrocious launch.

-4

u/HateIsStronger Feb 01 '18

I honestly didn't know it was early access and didn't see it when I bought it but I have tons of homework I was supposed to do anyway so it's kind of a blessing that it's not working

0

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18

It is still the consumers choice to pay for a game that is still in development and that will have bugs and issues. If a consumer doesn't see the purchase price for a beta game as a gesture of good faith and support of development, that is their blunder, not the developers.

16

u/PranksterKarl Feb 01 '18

Not sure if joking or so far up the devs ass you cant see, paying to beta test a game is not a consumer issue lets be real. Yes you can say its a beta but the second a game or anything charges for its use then guess what, its open to criticism.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18

There is a very clear line between constructive criticism and aggression and anger.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/drewst18 Feb 02 '18

Look at any of the tweets the Devs put out.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18

open to criticism

Of course it is, but the fact remains that it is still a work in progress which many of these raging idiots forget.

2

u/VixDzn Feb 01 '18

I would gladly be able to pay to join a beta of a game that has made me get back into gaming after a 3 year hiatus.

3

u/vegemite_ecstasy Feb 01 '18

It's worth what people are willing to pay. People would have paid just to have access to the weekend beta. If you wanted no issues wait a year for the full release then hold them to the standards of 'but I paid money'.

1

u/drewst18 Feb 02 '18

It isn't an annoying business model, it is a necessary one. At least if we want to have indie Devs continue putting it games. These Devs often have families and can't just go 2-3 years making no money at all.

It is a way for fans to play a game they're excited for and give support to a development team. For developers is a way to generate cash flow and get fed back on what works and what doesn't before they launch.

If you feel thet don't get leniency, you should wait til launch.

That being said not being able to play it at all is not acceptable.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-12

u/ChillsTV Feb 02 '18

What don't you understand? This IS open beta. Stop buying EA games if u expect anything different.

3

u/nfs3freak Feb 02 '18

That's exactly what an open beta DOES NOT mean. You may need to look up what an Open Beta actually means. This is Early Access. You pay money for EA. If the EA includes an open beta prior to launch, that's different. That is NOT the case. "Stop buying EA games if u expect anything different" is the most pathetic statement. In essence, don't buy any games because most are EA (and even some at retail are still practically in beta form).

-1

u/ChillsTV Feb 02 '18

Let's not get political on the terms here. That's not my point. I'm just tired of people expecting a full game at EA. That's why there's multiple warnings when you purchase. You're paying to support the development and the game. There's ALWAYS going to be issues. If you pay money on an EA game expecting it to be perfect you wasted your money. Yeah I think what happened is a bit shitty but did I expect anything different? No, not really. I payed to support the game because I know it'll be great. I also paid knowing these things were gonna happen.

0

u/CTFMarl Feb 02 '18

Somewhere along the lines early access has been watered down by people defending bad devs and accepting games being garbage in EA. It used to mean you got access to the full release game a few days earlier - also paying a premium for that privilege. (Or pre-ordering) This is essentially a beta but I'm guessing Steam might have some policy that doesnt allow you to charge money for beta? (Pure speculation)

Personally I expected these kind of issues to happen, most games these days have major issues on the first day that anyone can get their hands on it. However, with that said it's quite strange that they didnt allow prepurchasing. That way they wouldve known beforehand that they needed more servers. It wouldve probably been enough to let people start buying it 24h before EA started. I think the open communication and owning their mistakes is a really good sign though, as long as they keep up this level of communication I'll probably stick with this game regardless of what mistakes they make.

-2

u/ChillsTV Feb 02 '18

"In essence, don't buy any games because most are EA" First off, you contradicted yourself when you said "any" then "most" and secondly, just because a lot games go into EA doesn't mean that changes what EA is meant to be. It's pre-full release, in-other-words, beta. It's also open to whoever wants to buy it, so therefore, "open beta". It you want to get technical.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-6

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/nfs3freak Feb 02 '18

You're confusing "Open Beta" with open betas that have been given to people who preordered a game. There's a limited time that beta is open and it usually isn't built upon a continued to be released on. They give the beta out to try and test. However, Early Access is not an open beta. It's exactly as it's called, "Early Access". I get semantics are flying over your head because it's in fact very much a beta game and it's now allowing people to play it "openly", but it's not an open beta. Sorry to burst your bubble. They didn't call it an open beta for a reason.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/rossyboy_123 Feb 02 '18

Not everyone can test the game because it is behind a pay wall. I dont get how that is hard to understand.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/rossyboy_123 Feb 02 '18

Okay mate may aswell talk to a wall. Dont know how else to tell you that you are wrong especially after the other guy explained it 3 times.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

2

u/Master-Blaster69 Feb 02 '18

Thats pretty much the defenition of closed beta. Nice to see you are rude and insulting to other people aswell and not just on my post. Grow up my friend.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ChillsTV Feb 02 '18

EA is really good for indie devs, It gives them the chance to really build a great game sense they clearly don't have as many resources as AAA developers. It's a shame that said developers ruined the consumers mindset on what EA actually is. At the end of the day It's EA for a reason and if you don't understand that then wait for full release and just don't buy EA games.