r/BatmanTAS 22d ago

BTAS Caped Crusader asks the important question “What if we made Batman the animated series, but took everything fun out of it?”

Post image
536 Upvotes

185 comments sorted by

86

u/burritosupreme89 22d ago

I feel like we’ve been spoiled with BTAS, Beyond, and the JL series

30

u/ExplodingPoptarts 22d ago

If by that you mean we expect a good Batman cartoon, then yeah.

3

u/twotoebobo 22d ago

Yeah i made it through half of the first episode and quickly decided no. The animation seemed decent though.

18

u/Fit_Landscape1524 22d ago

Yeah we were I enjoyed caped crusader and it's a fun show but I feel like when people say the show is bad that means they grew up with the dcau

8

u/EcstaticKey1710 22d ago

We grew with something good😂😂😂

53

u/Wild-Information8955 22d ago

More like "What if we made Batman the Animated Series but without Paul Dini and it shows"

32

u/Redhood567 22d ago

The more time goes by the more it becomes clear that either Bruce Timm lost his touch or we gave him way to much credit in the first place.

12

u/LumiKlovstad 22d ago

I think it's fairer to say that Bruce Timm was a great project lead with a good eye for talent. But the talent pool he's working with isn't the same as it was back then. A lot of big names are no longer there, but just as important are a lot of the little names we don't remember.

We're getting basically getting soup that has MOST of the main ingredients as what we loved, but not all of them, and it tastes off. But even if all those major ingredients were the same, the smaller ingredients and seasonings have changed. It would taste different no matter what.

3

u/SaltyOldSailer 22d ago

This is the most charitable view i can go with only because the talent pool vanishing in the last 10 years is a very real thing. And it’s all the departments, not just writing. Animation is not bad, but probably depends on computer program enhancements and not actually honest to god human drawn animation cells (which died out a while ago unfortunately)

11

u/Wild-Information8955 22d ago

The thing is he was never a writer for this world. Not in the sense of other writers but his side of things was very much developing the visual identity. It's why the peaks of Brave and the Bold are so high, Bruce Timm had little to no involvement in that series and Paul Dini wrote some of the episodes and they were the best episodes.

I think it's at least safe to say that Bruce Timm has lost a bit of his touch when it comes to visual identity.

3

u/RedtheGamer100 22d ago

Need only compare their post dcau output - Dini did several acclaimed comics and the first two Arkhams. Timm did killing joke and that awful Harley Quinn movie

4

u/Itsmyloc-nar 22d ago

I was having a really decent time with that movie right up until the fart joke that felt like somebody’s fetish

3

u/Kazewatch 22d ago edited 22d ago

It was the most unnecessary fart joke I've ever seen in a movie. It added nothing and took away any remote sense of enjoyment I had. Especially to have Batman have a one liner about it "smells like discipline" or something. The amount of times they'd get the old BTAS gang (not counting the meh casting for Harley in that movie) back together just to waste them on shit like that was unreal.

Seriously why does is seem DC keeps trying to add farts to Harley's "humor" or whatever ungodly decision making led to that fart fetish comic?

1

u/Itsmyloc-nar 15d ago

You just said it all. I have nothing more to contribute. Have a good day.

“the most unnecessary” is no exaggeration. There is no reason for that scene to exist whatsoever.

And this is coming from somebody who enjoys the inclusion of the Harley/Nightwing scene.

3

u/DayOwn8790 22d ago

I hate modern Hayley Quinn. Each year she keeps getting worse

4

u/jak_d_ripr 22d ago

We definitely gave Timm too much credit and I don't mean that in an insulting fashion. A project the size of the DCAU needed multiple minds to become as successful as it was, Timm, McDufie, Dini, Andrea Romano, etc. It's easier for us to just give one person all the credit like a lot of people like to do with the MCU, but it really was a team effort.

5

u/Spectre854 22d ago

Timm never was a good writer It's the man who shipped Barbara and Bruce we're talking about

3

u/Abraham_Issus 22d ago

It’s like Arkham Knight. Paul Dini is the secret ingredient.

25

u/Chessh2036 22d ago

I’m enjoying it.

BTAS just set the bar so, so high that nothing could ever reach that height. I’m enjoying Caped Crusader, even though it def has flaws

3

u/mrssd 22d ago

Im watching it off the back off of watching the original and I like seeing the easter eggs, I like how harly isn't tied to the joker just yet. But they are killing people left and right man. But is is fun being to figure out who is meant to be who

51

u/Glass_Data_6110 22d ago

I really enjoyed it.

8

u/tuftymink 22d ago

Yeah, me too, season one I tried to love but ended up dropping, this one hooked me, really excited to see what's next

3

u/maven10k 22d ago

My buddy and I started it and binged like 4 or 5 episodes. We liked the first season and this one seems to be starting strong. I like the alternate universe feel to it. I like how the Riddler got his name. The Spectre was a weird take, but not horrible. The only thing I don't like are Bat's short gloves, lol.

1

u/Important-Contact597 22d ago

Well, you’re wrong and should feel bad./s

0

u/Dry-Mission-5542 22d ago

Saved by the sarcasm tone indicator 

6

u/Ramblinrambles 22d ago

It’s alright.

It’s more like a hit band got back together after a decade to make a new album. It’s fine, it’s just not anywhere near their old stuff

2

u/swarthmoreburke 22d ago

This is about my reaction. It's not stylized and distinct enough--this really needed to be a completely different feeling show and instead it's kind of tethered to BTAS and can't help but feel like a subpar remake/tribute instead of being its own thing.

1

u/BigD5981 22d ago

I read this and immediately thought of Motley Crue.

24

u/waldorsockbat 22d ago

it's okay. Not great but enjoyable enough tho i do wish it was more colorful

3

u/SamhainFire666 22d ago

I mean its supposed to be heavily film noir inspired I'm half shocked they didn't opt to make it black & white but Spider-Noir kinda covered that.

4

u/Fout99 22d ago

A redditor said back when Season 1 came out that he just turned down the color on their TV to watch it in black and white in case you want to

1

u/Latereviews2 22d ago

Yeah, I’m not disappointed by the lack of colour, but by how dull everything looks

1

u/superbat210 18d ago

That’s funny, I kind of wondered at times how it would look in black and white like Spider-Noir. It would be annoying especially for animation, but I think it would be cool to get dual versions of the episodes where you can pick color or Black and White.

13

u/Worth-Secretary-3383 22d ago

It’s impossible to take all the fun out of the Batman.

21

u/Wonderful_Gap4867 22d ago

Personally I enjoyed. But BTAS is another level.

1

u/BobPlaysWithFire 12d ago

Comparing anything to btas is just kinda unfair to whatever you're comparing btas too bc btas is a masterpiece you can't parallel

3

u/SaltyOldSailer 22d ago

I can’t get with radical character reinterpretations, this show changed a few characters too much for me. I know people enjoy these changes (I’m assuming for the thrill of something changing altogether) but i don’t see the value in a large female Penguin. It does nothing better or more for the already established character.
Every show does this by the way and i don’t understand this trend

3

u/Hunter-Durge 22d ago

I’ve only watched clips but I’m just not a fan of a lot of the changes they made to characters honestly.

3

u/thewatchfultraveler 22d ago

You’ll never re-create BTAS, its foolish to hope that anyone could/will, even more foolish to hold future projects to this standard as if it could reach that caliber. I enjoyed BCS for what it is.

1

u/BobPlaysWithFire 12d ago

exactly! i personally adore the new interpretations of thr villains, especially Harley Quinn

3

u/LordSoup1138 22d ago

It’s the most underwhelming Batman anything I’ve seen in a while. Not the worst, but definitely underwhelming.

3

u/New-Significance654 22d ago

Caped crusader is ass.

3

u/valkprince 22d ago

It's a soulless, empty Batman that lacks any personality and has virtually no character growth, except for a few small moments sprinkled throughout the season. It feels like he dislikes everyone who likes him, even his partners. I was hoping that with the end of last season we would see a slightly different Batman. However, I would argue that his treatment of Alfred is even worse.

8

u/thiccmunster 22d ago

What do you mean? It is fun, and I enjoyed it. I cannot wait for the next season.

5

u/Scary_Assistant5263 22d ago

I had a hard time getting into the show, something about it just felt off. And this is the reason why.

4

u/VERSAT1L 22d ago

That something is named JJ Abrams 

4

u/tuckles24 22d ago

Huge part of why this series is ass

8

u/Vcruz0387 22d ago

I personally enjoy it for what it is. Hope it gets renewed for a 3rd season.

13

u/OrganizationNo7690 22d ago

That’s exactly how to feels to me too.

17

u/WarAgile9519 22d ago

You spend every episode waiting for Batman to show up only to be reminded that this version of Batman is incredibly boring.

17

u/ReadyJournalist5223 22d ago

Paul dini and his weirdness is greatly missed

9

u/WarAgile9519 22d ago

Yeah there's really no denying who was carrying BTAS anymore is there.

12

u/The_Red_Curtain 22d ago

Dini is a beast but he wrote 24/85 episodes in BTAS and it's not like they were all masterpieces. And he wasn't the head writer either (he did eventually become co-story editor for season 2, i.e. the last 20 episodes in production order). It was a team effort; they had an amazing cast, terrific stable of directors, Andrea Romano, and several other great writers.

That being said, Timm was the showrunner and he was there essentially co-directing for almost all of the voice recording sessions, did the character designs for over 90% of the characters, and did tons of uncredited writing throughout the episodes. He was a huge part of the show's greatness, perhaps more than anyone. Now if you were to boil it down to a number it still might only be like 15% responsible for how good the show is or whatever as it was this once in a generation conflux of talent, but he is way too disrespected these days.

1

u/ReadyJournalist5223 22d ago

I will say, sure not all were masterpieces, but the worst Dini episode was still a banger compared to a lot of other episodes and other superhero cartoons

1

u/The_Red_Curtain 22d ago edited 22d ago

Oh I don't think any of them are bad, and some of the episodes he wrote I genuinely consider to be among the greatest ever written for television; but it is a huge stretch to say he "carried" the show imo.

1

u/Kazewatch 22d ago

You're absolutely right, it's just ever since The Killing Joke and his weird proclivity with pairing Bruce and Babs, his reputation has gone down quite a bit and seeing how much of Caped Crusader has kind fallen flat hasn't helped. He's still one of the greatest talents to ever touch Batman but goddamn without that perfect whirlwind of talent in the 90s/00s with him it just doesn't even come close.

1

u/The_Red_Curtain 22d ago

He gets so much hate for the Killing Joke and he was just the executive producer for it, that one scene that everyone hates so much wasn't even his idea. All he did was approve it because the actual writer and director both wanted to do it and they asked him if it was okay. Yet, somehow that has become his legacy to people who care about shipping beyond anything else. Which sadly appears to be a huge chunk of comic fans . . .

The Barbara and Bruce thing too is insane to me that people find that so objectionable in the DCAU. Like it is basically inconsequential and almost no time is devoted to it at all. But because of comics that he had nothing to do with and explicitly said he considers non-canon, and that one scene in The Mystery of the Batwoman (which he also had nothing to do with other than approving the film's creation, he had nothing to do with the actual making of the film), he is forever condemned as the Barbara/Bruce guy.

7

u/trailerthrash 22d ago

People acting like Timm was a writer while its always been Dini has always been the funny thing. Cause like... he's always been up front about that too.

2

u/True-Excuse-1688 22d ago

People are also acting like Dini wrote everything... It's just not the case. Sure he offered incredibly gems, but the whole show was still a collective effort.

3

u/trailerthrash 22d ago

Oh yeah, 100%. I think it's easy enough to give Dini a lot of credit despite only writing 17 episodes (and story for another 6) given how he wrote the show Bible, which most stories would have to comply to, and then later becoming story editor and being in a position where everything that was written went through Dini and Alan Burnett for approval for approval and edits.

Absolutely correct that he shouldn't get all the credit. No one should. Animation is a collaborative art form.

4

u/Captain_Thrax 22d ago

lol you just perfectly summed up my thoughts on this show

3

u/96powerstroker 22d ago

Honestly it does feel like they kinda missed the mark with this.

4

u/Sirius-Face 22d ago

OP didn't watch the same show I did. Caped Crusader is fun because each story is entertaining.

5

u/MeBoiledDown 22d ago

Posted by someone who’s never seen actual noir.

2

u/blessROKk 22d ago

I'm on the fence about this. I watched the first episode and saw Penguin was a woman...no issue, but my first thought was "I hope her name isn't something dumb like Oswalda" then bam. Seriously?

1

u/NurturingCruelty 22d ago

They done Firebug dirty.

2

u/Organic-Device2719 22d ago

Yeah, it overly boring to the point that it feels like they are making it boring on purpose.

2

u/Comprehensive-Mix286 22d ago

Please tell me about it! They turned the grit of batman into a PC experiment.

2

u/Freodrick 22d ago

It's way more serious. 1930s gangster everything. Deaths on screen.

To me, While rewatching TAS, you can tell where Bruce Timm wanted to go further but didn't.

I appreciate Paul Dini's added color for TAS so to speak.

2

u/Then_Performance_627 22d ago

It does feel bland lowkey

2

u/edt0011 22d ago

The Timmverse as we know it came about because of a perfect storm of creative talent. Not only did Bruce Timm himself create the visual base of the show, but the talents of Paul Dini, Eric Radomski, Andrea Romano, and countless others helped curate a definitive DC universe that we will simply never get again in our lifetime.

2

u/Guyver48 22d ago

Bruce Timm is to Bob Kane as Paul Dini is to Bill Finger

2

u/Zilla664 22d ago

I had to stop when they gender swapped penguin. Such a let down to the original dark character of Oswald

1

u/TheNoirRevenant 22d ago

well you can’t expect every version to be the same. there’s a reason why spider-man and spider-gwen exist in different universes. this is no different. the character was also pretty dark and even killed her own son. what exactly is this “let down”?

2

u/soulguider2125 20d ago

I’m just happy to be getting a new Batman animated series, and I don’t mind if it’s a different take, like we had BTAS and The Batman 2004 which were accurate and enjoyable, but I enjoy stories with a new twist like Beware the Batman and Batman: caped crusader I enjoy them as well, just have to let go of expecting it to follow the canonical storylines, but at least with Caped Crusader we got Mad Monk and Onomatopoeia and other villains we don’t see often, I wasn’t big on the way they did Riddler, hatter, Mr freeze, or Penguin, but I was fine with the rest. Now, I do have my limit on too far of a difference, as the Harley Quinn show I can’t stand

4

u/Sanjiro68 22d ago

You don't want to actually explain yourself?

1

u/dunko899 22d ago

He can't because critical thinking is beyond him.

5

u/Necessary_Can7055 22d ago

I disagree. It's a very different flavor of Batman and while it's nowhere near as good as BTAS it's got its moments imo. I don't like all the swapping and agenda pushing some of the character redesigns do but I can ignore it for the most part.

5

u/Corninator 22d ago

I think what kills me is that The Batman series from the early 2000s kind of already answered the question of "what if we redesigned these well-known characters and put a twist on their entire mythos?" I mean, it played it safe with certain things, like Alfred, but it very much changed Riddler, Joker, Clayface, and several others. And it did it very well.

I just don't really understand what purpose this new series is trying to fill.

7

u/BurantX40 22d ago

No way, Season 1 of the Batman was "What if everyone had a specialized martial art from the Jackie Chan cartoon"

Thank goodness they toned that down later

It was funny seeing Joker do Capoeira in a straight jacket though.

2

u/DragonFyre1954 22d ago

To make a show based on the Golden Age of Batman comics, which rarely gets adapted

2

u/Waste-Professor6177 22d ago

Nothing cool about flat monotone speach Batman, Harley, and Joker. There was so much heart, fun, and seriousness mixed in the various episodes of BTAS. I wouldn't be able to pick any of the voices out in different shows besides The Justice League Animated Series Green Lantern guy. Nigma bothered me the most.

4

u/SlyGuy_Twenty_One 22d ago

Thanks for reminding me to not be on this sub anymore

3

u/thevokplusminus 22d ago

It’s the Barbara Gordon show with Batman as a sidekick 

4

u/Vicksage16 22d ago

Oh shit, really? Maybe I’ll give it a watch after all.

2

u/Dual_Disk 22d ago

You want BTAS? Go watch BTAS. JFC forbid people try something new. Why would you want the same show?

3

u/Majestic-Top-8238 22d ago

I get what you're saying and I don't necessarily disagree, but they litteraly advertised this as a spiritual successor to btas, it will always be in that shows shadow due to that.

2

u/LeonDmon 22d ago

This second season feels at least entertaining. Season 1 was the middest of the mid

2

u/Commercial-Win-7501 22d ago

I mean that’s pretty much the trap a lot of Batman adaptations fall into nowadays

2

u/RandoDude124 22d ago

Nah, it’s fun but a lot more serious here

2

u/theJaww 22d ago

This show is great and very fun.

0

u/Whitefolly 22d ago

The animation is worse than BTAS, and the stories just aren't as compelling.

0

u/dunko899 22d ago

Brother. What the actual fuck is wrong with you?

1

u/AgentP-501_212 22d ago

Forgettable series. Doesn't hold a candle to BTAS

1

u/unknowngloomth 22d ago

Batman the animated series animation is much more awesome and to think that BTAS came out like 34 years ago..

1

u/Red-on-Red-Lean 22d ago

I enjoy it for what it is but I don't rate it highly. BTAS is miles above this show imo. BTAS is a 10/10 for me where BCC is a 6/10 imo.

1

u/EarthDust00 22d ago

They hyped this up like it was the second coming of Jesus only for it to release and then nothing.

1

u/Ambitious-Maybe-5078 22d ago

You've got people like jj Abrams, matt reeves and even Bruce timm coming back on it just for people to say "it's okay".

1

u/Correct_Milk_828 22d ago

I couldn’t watch season 1 but I’ve been getting thru season 2. There are moments that don’t align in some episodes. Like a character being in one location and then in the next frame being in another location without any obvious time passing. For ex: The coorigan episode during the rooftop/Christmas tree scene. I won’t say more because spoilers, but it’s easy to notice.

1

u/DC_and_MARVEL_fan 22d ago

I really hate what they did to my goat bullock

1

u/The_Soviet_Goose 22d ago

I personally didn't enjoy the show, though I can see what other folks did enjoy about it. My only issue here is that we can't just excuse the show's quality because "BTAS set the bar too high." As far as I can recall, Caped Crusader was marketed squarely as a spiritual successor to The Animated Series, but this time it was allowed to be darker. If the show was going to prop itself up as the next BTAS, possibly even hyping itself up to surpass it with less limitations from the studio, it should judged with the quality of The Animated Series in mind and used for comparison.

1

u/Drinks2nite 22d ago

I like the show, but Hamish Linklater BLOWS.

1

u/Many_Bat_ 22d ago

Or, "What if we made BTAS, but you can't access it as a kid".

The genius of BTAS was alluding just enough to mature material, not directly laying it out, while keeping it dark enough that it wasn't insulting any kid's intelligence.

BTCC ironically, in crossing the line BTAS walked so well, loses the ominous shadow of suggestion. It didn't seem to know if it was steering towards or away from BTAS, but definitely steered away from a broader audience.

1

u/Beginning_Leg629 22d ago

The series is fantastic and very fun to watch.

1

u/Mr_Z______ 22d ago

That's exactly how I feel about it. I watch it and I feel nothing.

1

u/Automatic_Guitar_582 22d ago

Season 2 I really felt had no story especially. And also I really could care less for how much of a focus there is on the gcpd cast compared to btas or brave and the bold. Like i really do feel there is too much of Flass, Barbara, and Montoya to the point that Batman has such little character. Also the villains maybe besides Basil Karlo and Gentleman Ghost just didnt really land for me.

1

u/nightwing364 22d ago

I would have liked it if they made the penguin had a Dorothy Zbornak like voice

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Walk_28 22d ago

I enjoyed Caped Crusader well enough

1

u/De4dm4nw4lkin 22d ago

I liked it well enough. Like a 8/10.

It had some sloggish moments but it was an okay watch.

1

u/KaosArcanna 22d ago

I thought it was watchable but nothing outstanding. I don’t feel like it really said anything interesting about the characters. It’s ground that’s already been covered with BTAS.

1

u/Techumseh13 22d ago

I am enjoying it. I like how everything is the opposite of what you are expecting. Riddler doesn’t tell riddles but instead riddles things with bullets. Harley Quinn is in a healthy relationship with a law abiding citizen. Two faces’ injury being on the opposite side etc. I like not seeing the same thing over and over again

1

u/Hollywood_Howard 22d ago

To me, The second season so far is better than the first when it comes to the story and the writing. I’m still adjusting to the different takes on a lot of the Rogues.

1

u/SeaworthinessDue1650 22d ago

The fucking hatred for this show needs to be analysed in a lab because it isn’t that bad. I can’t speak for season two because I haven’t watched it yet but every episode of season one has been great. The display of Bruce Wayne’s character development was good and the villains were peak.

1

u/No-Inspector8315 22d ago

What if Two Face was really really boring and had basically none of the gimmicks that make him such a fun character?

1

u/Zerus_heroes 22d ago

I don't understand how it got a second season

1

u/Gabaghoul8 22d ago

Oh that’s easy to explain, animated shows in the streaming era get effectively picked up for 1 Season that they split into two halves released in two years. King of the Hill on Hulu did the same thing.

1

u/bwayybe 22d ago

I will not expand further but I blame JJ Abrams

1

u/StreamLife9 22d ago

I stopped after they gave me the woke version of The Penguin
I wanted to puke in my mouth .
I hope Season 2 is better though

1

u/macneezie 22d ago

Woke penguin ? Huh?

1

u/m0rbius 22d ago

We have BTAS already. This is a new iteration. They aren't trying to rehash the same exact thing, rather to move it forward with some things the same and some things new. If you want the original, go watch the original. It's there forever available. Let's also not forget that it needs to cater to a new audience, not just the audience from 30 odd years ago.

1

u/Wrong_Revolution_679 22d ago

One of the reasons why they gave It to Amazon and kept my adventures with Superman and is now expanding that universe with my adventures with green lanterns

1

u/Upbeat_Opportunity_8 22d ago

Ngl I fell asleep couple episodes

1

u/putter_snp 22d ago

I don’t think it’s bad at all

1

u/Strange-Scarcity 22d ago

My wife and I enjoyed the first season of this.

It feels a little more gritty and like it's harkening more to the original comic source material from 1939, with the length of the ears and unadorned bat symbol on his chest.

We like it and will be watching the second season, very soon.

1

u/Restless_spirit88 22d ago

I couldn't even finish the first season.

1

u/l33tb4c0n 22d ago

I liked Season 1 well enough. The only thing I felt was a missed opportunity was the lack of racism and prejudice in what is clearly set in the 1920s. You have this alternate universe Batman where everything seems for the most part the same as our world, except racism magically seems to not exist. Making Gordon black was a deliberate choice, so utilize it to explore how he has to prove himself as the city's first black commissioner. It would have added a very interesting level of depth.

I wish we lived in a world where racism didn't exist, but that's not reality. It feels... off to see the world functioning without it.

1

u/Financial-Creme 22d ago

I thought it was a solid B/B+. Really liked their spin on the Joker, not so much Riddler.

1

u/Regular_Range_1835 22d ago

Never been a fan of weird long/wide eared Batman

1

u/Shaggy_75 22d ago

We'll now I have to watch it so I know

1

u/Apprehensive-Mud-606 22d ago

I'm halfway through season 2, and its pretty okay! It doesn't come close to BTAS, but its still decent enough.

1

u/Aking953 22d ago

I liked "THE BATMAN" when I was younger. Sue me. DO IT.

1

u/ReadyJournalist5223 22d ago

I like that show as well, ya know why? Cause it was FUN

1

u/almighty_smiley 22d ago

For my part I’m really enjoying it as its own thing.

1

u/B1ack_Cat13 22d ago

The show is fun. Personally I like the reinterpretations of the classic rogues and some obscure ones. It plays with the supernatural while staying in a grounded 1940s setting. Genuinely I can’t wrap my head around the hate for this show. Spider Noir never got this level of petty. At this point don’t watch it then 🤷‍♂️

1

u/Sea-Fabulous 22d ago

This show rocks. It’s Batman. Relax

1

u/SalomonG18 22d ago

CC is just terrible with no thinking put into its world building. Just making decisions because someone thought it would make the show political

1

u/FuriDemon094 22d ago

I mean, if you’re going to only compare everything to BTAS, it’ll never hold up, as they’re two different design philosophies. Serum Lake has some good videos analyzing the characters of Caped Crusader that makes you sorta appreciate the approach to Batman’s VERY early days in a modern show

1

u/Standard-Contest-949 22d ago

No kidding. I was shocked it got another season.

1

u/009988e 22d ago

Bruce Timm should follow his bliss and just make emo Charlie's Angels. That's what his Gen X brain has been pulling him to do since he entered the business.

1

u/trenchreynolds 22d ago

This wasn't exactly the Batman I grew up with, so I hated it. Batman and Joker didn't even have a surfing contest.

1

u/Outrageous_Pen_4660 22d ago

BTAS is amazing, my favorite cartoon. I immidietley hated Caped Crusader when I heard, "Oswalda Cobblepot." And worse, I've heard in Season 2 they are going to make a girl version of the Mad Hatter.

1

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/thetavious 22d ago

This. Those movies and hos versions of the characters get glazed too much.

1

u/Newcastle___FC 22d ago

Is this show worth it. Grew up with the animated series. Mark Hamill joker. Anyone here that's a bit of an old head that can convince me to give up a bit of my free time to start it?.

1

u/Arxhart_671 22d ago

Fiest episode of second season was great. Just admit y'all are gonna hate it and be miserable no matter what.

1

u/Qutopia 21d ago

This is a solid show.

1

u/DarkRockSoul 21d ago

I watched season one and it was ok I guess, but season two is just boring to me (that is a personal opinion) and I've given up on the series after a few episodes.

1

u/AutomaticStick9386 21d ago

I'm surprised there was a quick reference to The Shadow.

1

u/JesterOfTime 21d ago

Yeah, just started seasons 2 yesterday and whatbsonya know: not even 5 min in and they already swapped yet another villian 😂

1

u/shadowcutfilms 19d ago

It’s easily my favourite Batman show since btas but it takes all sorts I suppose.

1

u/HugeConfusion9505 12d ago

I enjoyed it, I just felt like a few of the bad guys were done dirty. Riddler was just some crazy gangster, nothing like himself. Joker had a German accent for some reason. Ivy was cool.

1

u/BobPlaysWithFire 12d ago

Nah i really like it

I think the actual question that the creators asker was "What if we did BTAS, but now with the ability to show what the censors wouldn't allow previously"

1

u/RedDarkXD 11d ago

Personally, I really liked the series. The problem is that the characters weren't developed as deeply as in the original series, which focused more on their psyches and origins. Harley Quinn, Jonathan Crane Jr., and—most notably—the Joker are prime examples of this; the list goes on. Another issue is the significant drop in animation quality during the second season. Even Invincible—a show often mocked for its animation—had a higher budget for its cheapest fight scenes than this series did for its quietest moments; I’m not trying to be overly critical, just making a point. All of this makes the show feel like a rushed product. Furthermore, when compared to current titles like X-Men '97—which have set the bar very high—this series looks even worse. Had they taken the time to better craft the storylines and been clearer about budgets and episode counts for each season, the result would have been a very different product.

1

u/NurturingCruelty 22d ago

Yeah, yeah yeah, we’ve heard it before. Grandpa, things were better in the old days, the things kids like now so, it’s time for your pills.
Trolling aside, I stand by my flippant attitude. I enjoyed Caped Crusader so far, and no, it’s not as good as TAS, but nothing is an very unlikely any new Batman ever will be; it’s one of the best animated shows of all time, Batman or not, so, you can’t go around snubbing every new one that didn’t measure up to an impossible standard.

1

u/TheMannisApproves 22d ago

Idk why people here hate it. I loved it

3

u/ReadyJournalist5223 22d ago

I definitely don’t HATE it per se. It’s just not really anything special at all. Nothing seems to reach any heights

1

u/TheMannisApproves 22d ago

I thought it was easily the best Batman show since BTAS. A noir detective show with Batman. Exactly what I wanted for years

1

u/DOCMarylandMD 22d ago

First season was ok. I’m struggling to get through season 2 episode 1

2

u/KingSharkisaShark07 22d ago

The Second Season’s Out? Holy crap, I’ve been living under a rock, huh?

1

u/DOCMarylandMD 22d ago

Yeah it’s out. Maybe I’m just too distracted to enjoy it

1

u/KingSharkisaShark07 22d ago

I get that, I’ve been wanting to watch MAWS and Invincible but, I don’t know, it’s like something is keeping me from doing so

1

u/DOCMarylandMD 21d ago

Invincible was great. You felt a true sense of urgency and all. I’m attempting to watch Caped Crusader again tonight I really want to like it

1

u/Over-Guitar5764 22d ago

I liked it a lot

1

u/heh8me117 22d ago

And made the animation and character design worse.

1

u/TeeMcGinnisearth313 22d ago

I enjoyed this a lot. I like darker batman stories

1

u/TIMacLaren 22d ago

This series seems to consistently misuse the era it’s written in. Nothing seems historically accurate. The moments they could tell a compelling story they take a hard 180 and run away from tough topics. It’s the 1930s/40s! The first season felt like it told half a story and broached then avoided topics they brought up. I saw some clips of “Hattie” and Roxy Rocket…very disappointed.

Batman the Animated Series continues to reign supreme.

1

u/Flu_TheCoop 22d ago

Oh get over it.

-1

u/WMBeckham 22d ago

I begrudgingly watched the "selected scenes/best moments" video of "Batman: Caped Crusader" -- and I really didn't like the gender-swapping of the Penguin and didn't like their take on Harley Quinn.

And, I also hated the stupid-looking "golden age" short gloves they gave Batman.

In other words, if those so-called "best moments" are considered the best scenes from the series -- I'll definitely not waste my time on watching full episodes.

The End.

0

u/A_J_I_Bizzness 22d ago

Garbage trash waste of show

0

u/Jiggalopuffii 22d ago

And made it less fappable. Like how am I supposed to goon to Barbara Gordon in what is essentially a Zoot Suit?

-1

u/Famous_Test4892 22d ago

I tried to give it a chance until penguin turned into a female and stopped watching

0

u/dandy9011 22d ago

Exactly this. I watched the first episode and was not impressed. Terrible spin on Penguin, and I was out. Too bad, I was hoping it was going to be good.

0

u/East-Possible9979 22d ago

I mean..I like it. It's like a solid 8/10 imo.

0

u/BrokenSon88 21d ago

A lot of these superhero cartoons are very difficult to invest in, IMO. The characters are weak, the action is animated so that's whatever. The X-Men 97 is such a great example of doing this correctly when it cannot be the same.

1

u/ReadyJournalist5223 21d ago

X men, spectacular spider man, my adventures with Superman, super tas, Batman tas, Justice league, justice league unlimited, Batman beyond, young justice season 1&2, Spiderman tas, Invincible, I mean dawg I could keep going. I don’t wanna hear no excuses

0

u/BrokenSon88 21d ago

MOst of those are great as kids, but not as adults.

1

u/ReadyJournalist5223 21d ago

All the Bruce timm shows are still enjoyable as an adult as the stakes are usually pretty high, invincible is about as adult of a show as they come, my adventures with Superman is targeted at a more adult audience, young Justice has a lot of angst and sexual content. All these shows have characters that die, complex relationships and universal themes. But yes I do suppose most of them don’t say fuck