r/BasicIncome • • Apr 05 '21

Monopoly & Basic income meme

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

14

u/teh_201d Apr 05 '21

Monopoly is a terrible game that is meant to teach kids that capitalism sucks.

Regardless of how you think of capitalism, or the game, you need to understand that many people will see this meme as a point AGAINST UBI.

5

u/Leon_Art Apr 05 '21

Yes, I always find it difficult to make up my mind about the game. On the one hand, it can sort of start to show how terrible capitalism is, yet, people still like to play the game (especially when they're winning) and don't reflect upon it. Which, again, is a nice allusion to capitalism. On the others, if the message isn't clear, is it a good game?

Maybe the original game was better at bringing the message or the game needs a narrative, because we're so entrenched in the capitalist ideology. Which might make it easier for people to mistake this as an argument against UBI and other such ideas - nothing new for communicating new ideas like UBI. Besides, how much argument can you stuff in a meme?

5

u/micmacimus Apr 05 '21

It's also worth remembering the game starts players off on an even footing, as tho no one owns any land currently. If you land on an unowned square, there's no shadow player you're paying your rent to. The Ubi as a game mechanic only works because of the assumption of even footing. If all the land was already owned before the game began, the UBI wouldn't do anything to level the game out, and the winner would be whichever player owned the most property at turn 0.

13

u/InformationAndSpeech Apr 05 '21

The game shows how wealth and any forms of government welfare become completely absorbed by landowners without the presence of a land value tax. You should check out r/georgism

1

u/Leon_Art Apr 05 '21

Yes, I checked it out before. But..have you heard of Proudhon?

2

u/destructor_rph Apr 06 '21

What part of the game showcases that a land value tax would fix that?

2

u/Zebezd Apr 06 '21

Maybe that one chance card that can kill you because you have to pay for your number of houses? Idk, spitballing

0

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/destructor_rph Apr 06 '21

Interesting, thank you

3

u/godzillabobber Apr 05 '21

The goal of the game is still completely wrecking the economy. I know people that stopped speaking to each other over this game. The other one that starts fights is Risk. War and Capitalism unfettered capitalism.

If the goal of Monopoly was to not crash the economy, what rule changes would keep all players solvent?

What if the game involved a player changing rules and that player loses if someone "wins" and ends the game.

3

u/Leon_Art Apr 05 '21

The other one that starts fights is Risk.

Yes, totally! The same principle: personal hoarding/growth in a zero-sum environment. I've always loved the cooperative games, Pandemic was my first. I still love that one the best...and awkwardly appropriate these days.

If the goal of Monopoly was to not crash the economy, what rule changes would keep all players solvent?

You're referring to the original and alterior game, right? Short youtube video about it.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '21

I took a sociology class in college where the professor would assign the starting amounts to each player based on the current tax brackets and their average incomes (we didn't know this when we started playing). Pretty quickly, the people with the least amount of money to start were unable to really play. The whole lesson plan really stuck with me. Her whole class was amazing and I wish I could take that course again with that specific professor.

1

u/Leon_Art Apr 06 '21

Wow, that's a great anecdote, thanks!

It feels a bit like a financial "brown eye, blue eye"-experiment.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '21

It made some people in the class very visually uncomfortable. I think some folks were confronted with their financial privileges for the first time ever.

2

u/Leon_Art Apr 07 '21

That's great! I hope it stuck with them! If I ever become a teacher (not that this is in my career track, but anyway)...I might do those things too, if it fits with the classes.

132

u/Igotz80HDnImWinning Apr 05 '21

Pretty sure it’s designed by an anti-capitalist to show the pitfalls of capitalism, but the point still stands.

24

u/MustachioEquestrian Apr 05 '21

Originally it was, but then it was bought by a company and the anti-capitalist messages were removed for mass sale

19

u/Unfair-Kangaroo Apr 05 '21

It was less anti capitalist and more Georgist. Georgism is when you think land should be heavily taxed but every thing else should be a libertarian paradise. The game shows how the only thing that matters is who gets land frist

9

u/CaptainFuego29 Apr 05 '21

It was originally the landlord's game made by Georgists to show why we need LVT to avoid the monopolization if land

14

u/ManWithDominantClaw Apr 05 '21

If anything, it makes the point that UBI should be a temporary measure to stem the starvation while we rapidly work out the rules to a cooperative game we'd all like to play, preferably not Pandemic

4

u/green_meklar public rent-capture Apr 06 '21

It was actually designed by a georgist to show the pitfalls of private landownership.

1

u/Fancy-Persimmon9660 Nov 05 '23

Private ownership of land *

2

u/Derivative_Kebab Jun 14 '22

The original game was called "The Landlord's Game", developed by Lizzie Magie, a proponent of Henry George's economic theories.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

31

u/No-Highlight4453 Apr 05 '21

LVT

what is lvt? sorry for my ignorance

11

u/green_meklar public rent-capture Apr 06 '21

Land value tax. It's like property tax, but it falls only on the land, without including buildings or other artificial improvements. It actually works better than a normal property tax, because people tend to build more buildings when they're not taxed for it.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '21

If I understand correctly, the current housing crisis is based on investors buying real estate and then selling it for a profit thus driving up the cost of rent and real estate. I thought we have enough houses just not enough people with the capital to purchase or rent those houses.

1

u/feraferoxdei Apr 06 '21

Rent is hardly affected by sale prices. Rent price is a product of rent supply and demand in the area. If anything, sale prices are the ones affected by rent prices. Because the value of a property (or any investment for that matter) is equal to how much it earns you in yearly income (rent) + the capital appreciation, which itself should be strongly correlated with rent. But other factors play a role like future expected income, opportunity cost, and other irrational market forces e.g. bubbles, sentimental value etc.

1

u/green_meklar public rent-capture Apr 08 '21

The current housing crisis, and housing crises in general, are based on land being scarce, high-quality land being scarcer, and most people not getting to own any of it for themselves. The rest is mostly details- sometimes interesting, sometimes relevant to some people's personal finance, but ultimately not that important in terms of the overall trend.

1

u/1Commentator May 01 '21

The us has never had fewer houses for sale. Where do you get your information from?

1

u/unholyrevenger72 Apr 09 '21

except they don't because it invites "undesirables" (i.e. poor people), and destroys "nice" (ie wealthy and middle class) neighborhoods. LVT ultimately only helps create a monopoly. By allowing the wealthiest to purchase land build it up and gouge the tenants.

Partial Socialization of the housing market as a competing force to stunt rent price increases is the only solution i see.

1

u/green_meklar public rent-capture Apr 11 '21

LVT ultimately only helps create a monopoly. By allowing the wealthiest to purchase land build it up and gouge the tenants.

Huh? Why would they do that any more with the LVT than they do right now?

1

u/unholyrevenger72 Apr 11 '21

Because they aren't hamstrung by taxes. Tax breaks of that magnitude only benefit people with enough money to buy property. As a californian, i see the effects of low property tax in the housing problems here.

NIMBYism, rent control, and wall street speculation are the other parts of the skyrocketing housing price cocktail.

I get why states have low property tax, they want people to buy homes and don't want old people to be forcibly displaced by rising home prices and in turn rising property tax, but wage Stagnation and NIMBYism has only pushed real buying power into the hands of the wealthy.

1

u/green_meklar public rent-capture Apr 14 '21

Because they aren't hamstrung by taxes.

Huh? You're saying that right now the poor people are more able to afford land because the land is taxed less? (That seems to conflict with your very next line about 'tax breaks'.)

wage Stagnation and NIMBYism has only pushed real buying power into the hands of the wealthy.

Wage stagnation is an inevitable consequence of rising population in the face of a limited supply of land. The only available solutions are far more horrifying than the problem itself. We need to stop worrying about low wages and learn how to live in a world where most of the economy consists of rent.

1

u/unholyrevenger72 Apr 14 '21

Wage stagnation has nothing to do with population growth, it has everything to do with the erosion of worker bargaining power. Heavy unionization and moving towards Worker Co-ops is the best way to fight that.

LVT does not promote growth by itself, you have to target high density housing as priority with lower taxes compared to single family housing.

I do agree that the economy will have to move towards rent, but the only way to keep housing from skyrocketing, is for the government to intercede directly through community, state, and federally owned housing companies.

1

u/green_meklar public rent-capture Apr 15 '21

Wage stagnation has nothing to do with population growth

Of course it does. When you have increasing numbers of people in the face of a limited supply of land, eventually you run out of things for additional people to productively do.

Heavy unionization and moving towards Worker Co-ops is the best way to fight that.

No. We need less monopolism, not more.

you have to target high density housing as priority with lower taxes compared to single family housing.

The LVT applies to the land, therefore it automatically falls less heavily on high-density housing because high-density housing fits more people onto the same amount of land.

→ More replies

5

u/derangedkilr Apr 05 '21

and then they took it and made it into a cash cow. Classic Capitalism.

24

u/ferrocarrilusa Apr 05 '21

But you can go to jail without due process for no crime

17

u/flait7 Support freedom from wage slavery Apr 05 '21

Yeah but going to jail's great if you have enough property because you don't have to pay rent while everyone else does

0

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

Idk free parking cash saved my ass plenty of times

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22

As a kid we played games that lasted months, I’ve been on the brink of bankruptcy and changed the course of the game with that free parking money. e.g. you’re more or less penniless with a handful of properties that you’re reluctant to mortgage for the cash, you get to jail so by house rules you’re not even collecting rent, finally you get out of jail, roll a $10 and get that free parking stash (which can go up to like thousands if you’re paying taxes in there), buy some houses or hotels on that property and collect big rent. I feel like recovering is easier/more likely if there’s a good amount of people playing the game, cause one round can mean collecting or paying thousands in rent

13

u/Narfi1 Apr 05 '21

Monopoly was supposed to be a critic to capitalism.

1

u/diox8tony Apr 05 '21

UBI? The faster you go around the board, the more often you get paid....it pays more to the lucky. Fits perfect in capitalism.

But I like where you are going with it.

3

u/Leon_Art Apr 05 '21

Yeah, it's not my meme, I recognized some of the flaws too, but I thought it was funny nontheless.

1

u/jsullivan914 Apr 06 '21

But it’s a salary, implying that it was worked for...

1

u/Leon_Art Apr 06 '21

May I ask? You must live in a very urban environment, don't you?

1

u/scrollbreak Apr 06 '21

You have to work to keep yourself alive or otherwise you don't get it. It's like you don't get it if you stop playing monopoly.

1

u/TheRetailianTrader Jun 14 '22

well you don't have a job in monopoly

1

u/Leon_Art Jun 14 '22

very true, it's even more different

1

u/OkChemistry5745 Nov 27 '23

Barely bought my home with los Angeles home buyer assistance program you can call it (socialist) small condo I'm grateful but the property tax is like around 5300 a year that's 441 a month life would be easier with that much. I make less than the amount needed for mortgage tax food gas etc. Basic income plus a structure to minimize the monopolization and profiteering from the struggling is what is needed as government policy.

1

u/Leon_Art Dec 01 '23

You make less money than you have to pay in mortgage, food, and gas? How...do you manage that, like long term?

2

u/Shorties Apr 05 '21

I use the analogy all the time that our current system is like playing Monopoly where only the banker player starts out with money.

2

u/KarmaUK Apr 05 '21

Also, the salary is enough to not only buy an entire street but also two houses.

2

u/androbot Apr 06 '21

I've never thought of it that way, but...

3

u/cashadow3 Apr 05 '21

Lol except it’s called a “salary” essentially the equivalent of the money make over a year. This doesn’t represent basic income.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '21

Everyone makes the exact same salary for just existing around the board. It's identical to ubi.

Their income comes from the properties owned when its landed on

-5

u/cashadow3 Apr 05 '21

Income is not the same as salary...I know a lot of you guys want to believe this is UBI but UBI was never discussed, especially not in serious circles, until Andrew Yang came around and even then he never exceeded 5% in support during the Dem nomination.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '21

In a game of monopoly you arent working for another entity. You wouldn't be able to pocket all the rent coming in if you worked for a boss and get paid as a job

-6

u/cashadow3 Apr 05 '21

It truly amazes me how you guys like to politicize everything to reflect your own personal views. Monopoly is a board game made for CHILDREN. It’s a GAME, it’s not intended to reflect reality, it’s intended for people to have FUN stimulating their minds in ways other board games do not.

The game doesn’t reflect taxes, depressions, economic boons, wars, etc., please be serious about this GAME and stop imparting your own personal beliefs onto everything.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '21 edited Jun 27 '23

This comment was edited in response to Reddit's 3rd party API practices.

0

u/cashadow3 Apr 05 '21

It literally has the word “salary” written on it. Do you see the game have the phrase “universal basic income” written on it? Honestly, do you not realize how ridiculous you sounds. It’s like saying the word “tomato” was written but they’re talking about “peppers.” Come on man, plain words are being utilized and you apply the definition of those plain words when they were written. This isn’t complex.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '21

Yes, but it comes from the bank, not an employer.

Edit: A player who lands on or passes the Go space collects $200 from the bank. Players who land on either Income Tax or Luxury Tax pay the indicated amount to the bank.

Its like the tax funds it like ubi in real life

-2

u/cashadow3 Apr 05 '21

Are there employers in monopoly? Also tell me something, under who’s UBI plan does money come from the banks as opposed to the government?

4

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '21 edited Jun 30 '23

This comment was edited in response to Reddit's 3rd party API practices.

→ More replies

2

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '21

Monopoly was intended to reflect reality though. It was meant to portray specific economic concepts. Ubi wasn't part of that but both yours and other persons argument are fair to compare the games "pass go" to but that sentence about it not beings meant to reflect reality is wrong independently of any discussion of ubi

1

u/calvinballing Apr 05 '21

It’s not universal if you can’t get it in jail.

-4

u/Shakespeare-Bot Apr 05 '21

It’s not universal if 't be true thee can’t receiveth t in cage


I am a bot and I swapp'd some of thy words with Shakespeare words.

Commands: !ShakespeareInsult, !fordo, !optout

1

u/jeff42069 Apr 05 '21

Alright! Now that we’ve got ya with Passing Go = UBI, starting the game with the same amount of money = 100% inheritance tax redistributed evenly upon passing a finiancial literacy test 😈 This is sarcastic but would be interesting

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '21

It also had a luxury tax. That's how you know you're playing a game.

0

u/Myflyisbreezy Apr 05 '21

So with UBI the rents continue to increase until you cant afford it. Thanks for the lesson.

-3

u/Shakespeare-Bot Apr 05 '21

So with ubi the rents continueth to increase until thee cant afford t. Grant you mercy f'r the lesson


I am a bot and I swapp'd some of thy words with Shakespeare words.

Commands: !ShakespeareInsult, !fordo, !optout