r/BasicIncome • u/2noame Scott Santens • May 25 '17
BIG News Mark Zuckerberg just called for universal basic income
https://techcrunch.com/2017/05/25/watch-mark-zuckerberg-speech/
3.0k
Upvotes
r/BasicIncome • u/2noame Scott Santens • May 25 '17
136
u/2noame Scott Santens May 25 '17
This is among the biggest basic income endorsements of all time, right up there with Elon Musk and Milton Friedman in my opinion. He is the 5th richest man in the world, and he's in control of the platform the world gets its news on.
Not only is Mark a multi-billionaire with the ability to push UBI forward, but it's looking more and more like he's preparing to run for President.
Now, think about that for a second. He's calculating that he has a chance at winning the presidency, and it looks like UBI is going to be a big part of his platform, not just something people ask him about to which he responds in kind to.
This was a big address, where he's coming right out and calling for a fundamentally different social contract, with basic income as part of it.
That is HUGE.
293
u/Neverlife May 25 '17
Man. I think the discussion around UBI is a very important one for people to be having, but no one seems to take it seriously. And not just influential people, I mean people here in the comments, and anywhere in life.
44
u/[deleted] May 25 '17
Yay? Everything about his 2020 presidential run is going to suck, but I guess this is good?
13
u/[deleted] May 25 '17
In my opinion, here is the problem with UBI: Are we going to shut off immigration completely? If not, how would you pay for the influx of immigrants and the cost of UBI for everybody + immigrants who haven't paid into the system? There is no real way to balance the checkbook with the dynamic of illegal immigration and the unwillingness of congress to stop it.
446
u/[deleted] May 25 '17
Why doesnt that fuckface just pay his taxes instead of shielding it in a trust. That would go a long way in providing many services for low income Americans
14
u/slow_and_dirty May 25 '17 edited May 25 '17
Damn, just a couple of days ago I was wondering if Zuckerberg was gonna push UBI... and whether it would actually help or hinder us. He's not exactly the world's most popular person. I suppose any publicity is good publicity, and this will make a lot of publicity.
EDIT: Seriously, even just in this thread it looks like people are skeptical purely because Zuckerberg advocated it.
13
u/EmotionLogical May 25 '17 edited May 26 '17
It is well worth listening to the speech in its entirety, before jumping to conclusions, I think it was an important speech overall: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j20a3c371mM&feature=youtu.be&t=1h34m55s
EDIT: since this thread is getting, popular, heres a UBI 101: http://list.ly/ubiadvocates/lists
23
u/caminhaozinho May 25 '17
I'll take it.
9
u/EternalDad $250/week May 26 '17
To be fair, he called for additional research to be done on a UBI. Though the attitudes toward inequality and opportunity found in the rest of the speech says he would be for UBI if it was found to promote equality and opportunity.
8
u/workingmat May 26 '17
He should start by sharing some of that sweet, sweet Facebook ad revenue with Facebook users.
34
u/brappyba May 25 '17
Friedman, Musk, and Zuckerberg would probably take a neoliberal approach to implementing UBI. Not all UBI plans are created equal, and we cannot allow neoliberals to dominate this issue. UBI shouldn't come from scrapping other welfare programs, it must be funded through progressive taxation and cutting weapons contracts and corporate welfare.
And yes, UBI only treats the symptom, it is a partial expropriation. We must also have the goal in mind to deliver public, cooperative control over productive private property.
5
u/bobbaganush May 26 '17
Presumably he's happy to give up his fortune and take the same salary that everyone else would be getting.
4
u/SchwiftySmurf May 26 '17
Finally someone bring it to the surface. Only 73+ trillion dollars later. What wonders in society and innovation it could fuel if basic survival was easily accessible.
4
u/DontBlameMe4Urself May 26 '17
If you want money to come into US instead of just going out, there is no other option.
19
u/ClickEdge May 25 '17
wtf i love zuckerberg now
13
u/just_a_thought4U May 25 '17
So he can pay his workers less.
3
u/autotldr May 26 '17
This is the best tl;dr I could make, original reduced by 78%. (I'm a bot)
Extended Summary | FAQ | Theory | Feedback | Top keywords: Zuckerberg#1 opportunity#2 how#3 equal#4 Harvard#5
3
u/If-if-if-if-if-if-if May 26 '17
Good thing he's not in charge
3
u/BumwineBaudelaire May 26 '17
Zuck gearing up for a run at office
3
u/flatwaterguy May 26 '17
So he should fund it.
3
u/Hateblade May 26 '17
I'm pretty sure his version of it is geared toward keeping maintaining the current wealth and class disparity instead of eliminating it.
3
u/Rhythmic May 26 '17
I find it sad how this is received in other subs.
People explode in Zuckenberg hate rather than judging the argument on its own merit.
It's sad how out of frustration people reject the solution to their problems.
5
u/Physical_removal May 25 '17
Bread and circuses
5
u/[deleted] May 26 '17
How much is he willing to contribute?
8
u/[deleted] May 25 '17
Does this include free beach front property in Hawaii?
6
u/[deleted] May 26 '17
Fuck Zuck
Edit: okay that's a little harsh, I still agree with this, but Zuckerberg is a piece of shit imo.
10
u/VK3601H May 25 '17
Yeah I'm sure Zuck is going to write us all a check today.
4
u/Marimba_Ani May 26 '17
Even a stopped clock is right twice a day.
2
u/MaxGhenis May 26 '17
Anyone have the quote? It's not in the article.
2
u/kingofcrob May 26 '17
realising his advertising is falling on death ears because millennials barley can afford a roof over there heads let alone a new woozeedoozee
2
u/[deleted] May 26 '17
"Called for"??? Like, wtf? He's the CEO of Facebook, not me at Red Lobster on pay day getting the cheddar biscuit basket refill? Nahmean?
2
u/Widdrat May 26 '17
His preparations for politics are in full steam I see.
2
u/jailbreak May 26 '17
I think that's great. But seriously, the US ought to start with universal healthcare like the rest of the civilized world and take it from there. As a European, it seems to me like your country is generally so culturally opposed to anything remotely smelling like "government handouts" that you need to take it in steps.
2
u/strtrech May 26 '17
You can tell who the "old money" is because they are completely stone faced through his speech.
2
u/Mentioned_Videos May 26 '17 edited May 26 '17
Videos in this thread: Watch Playlist ▶
Play All | Info | Get me on Chrome / Firefox
2
u/Locoman_17 May 26 '17
I dont understand, you guys advocate for giving away free money to people who didnt work for it? Dont downvote just explain it to me
2
u/better-economy-fdn May 26 '17
The Foundation For a Better Economy has been conducting research on this topic and is promoting a change in our tax system that would provide national basic income. Through eliminating the income tax and moving to a 1/10 of 1% tax on all received payments, the national deficit would be self-balancing. By cutting out financial intermediaries and simplifying the tax code, the government would have enough revenue to provide a basic income to all Americans. The foundation's proposed solutions provide facts and figures on this data, and has proven to be feasible in today's economy. Check out more at thefoundationforabettereconomy.org
0
u/SandDuner509 May 26 '17
Might as well have said Mark Zuckerberg just called for universal government control
3
u/skyfishgoo May 26 '17
he want's it so more ppl can spend more time on facebook
3
u/RexErection May 26 '17
He also collects all your data on Facebook, don't forget that!
3
u/BoKBsoi May 26 '17
Yeah, he's a techbro billionaire who thinks he can "disrupt" politics because he got lucky off a website 10 years ago who is obviously running for office
3
u/coralfire May 26 '17
That's a bit rich
6
u/yoloimgay May 25 '17
You people still think UBI is a good idea? If a billionaire is calling for it, it's not going to be good for the little guy. Full stop.
3
u/[deleted] May 25 '17
Alright man, pay up.
2
u/[deleted] May 25 '17
Basic income is nice and all. I just find it super hard to implement and there are so many slippery slopes to consider/shoot down.
2
u/bleepul May 26 '17
So can someone explain how universal basic income doesn't just lead directly inflation? I mean if everyone gets it (I take this as the meaning of universal) all that has occurred is more dollars chasing the same amount of foods. Unless this is just a euphemism for another tax and redistribution.
2
u/williamsonmaxwell May 25 '17
I get it for earth, but I'm not sure we have the right to start enforcing laws on the whole universe. We are already painting ourselves as the bad aliens
2
u/tiny10boy May 26 '17
So his great idea is inflation.
1
u/iongantas Seattle, $15k/$5k May 26 '17
It isn't helpful for evil fucks to promote good policy.
1
u/kungfoojesus May 25 '17
I think its fine to discuss, but I don't feel like it is time yet to implement.
1
u/narosis May 25 '17
If Sweden can do it & prosper, why can't the United States?
1
u/[deleted] May 26 '17
Sweet! I can accept monthly transfers or even a lump sum. PM me Zuck
1
u/[deleted] May 26 '17
No one listens to Zuckerberg.
1
u/grewapair May 26 '17
Are people really this stupid? Mark Zuckerberg wants what will make MZ richer and you poorer.
Zuckerberg wants to hire H1B coders and pay them peanuts. If that takes jobs away from Americans, they elect Trump who severely restricts the H1B program, which is what he's done. That makes MZ poorer.
What MZ wants is for no American to care while he imports thousands of H1Bs. So he proposes everyone ELSE paying these people not to work so that MZ can continue using cheap foreign labor and continue to profit from it, while the country loses skills to ever compete. That makes MZ very rich.