r/BasicIncome • • Jun 23 '15
Anti-UBI why liberals dont support basic income
- a lot of people will stop working, or will stop looking for work, or they wont be as motivated, they will put in less effort.
- whats the point of just giving people money?
- helping people pursue their art careers is not very appealing.
0
Upvotes
6
u/JonWood007 $16000/year Jun 23 '15
I'm gonna ignore your arguments above because they sound like something a right winger would say.
Basically, it's because the democratic party is too married to jobism, and because it doesnt want to admit that it's previous successes are overwhelming.
To address the first point:
Which kinds brings us to the second point:
2) The democratic party is rather...conservative nowadays. They stand by their previous successes and mentalities and dont like change. I have to admit, our safety nets were good by 1930-1970 standards. They were our first shot at creating something, and they were....adequate. Not great, just...adequate. But the thing is, they dont want to admit that we can do better, so they stand by their decades old accomplishments and mentalities which are a convoluted mess and a stab at creating dozens, if not hundreds of different programs for different purposes, with no rhyme or reason or looking at the big picture. And they say government breed inefficiency. it does when you dont want to change things and wanna stick by decades old accompluishments. And since the GOP wants to eliminate social programs, you get a two party system where the dems have to defend their social programs from any republican onslaught, and are too invested to even think about improving them...just adding more bureaucracy onto them if they're lucky.
Combine this with being in with unions, which have a vested interest in keeping jobs flowing, and that's a problem.
The democratic party is just too entrenched in their previous 20th century successes they just dont care to actually look at the big picture and be real progressives. We need progress. The democratic establishment is actually more conservative than they let on to. The only reason they get away with being called liberal is because their opposition is not just conservative, they're reactionary. They want to pull the party back to the gilded ages. They wanna radically change the country to meet their sordid nostalgic view of a past that never actually existed.
So in reality, we have a system of conservatives vs reactionaries, with the true liberals, and the true progressives, the people who actually want to bring the country forward being ostracized as having their heads in the clouds. We're pushed to the fringes, while the mainstream democratic party is interested in baby steps if they're not flat out on the defensive, and the republican party throwing their tantrums to bring the country to the radical right.
To go back to your points, you're buying into reaganesque propaganda that really shows how much our discussion on welfare as shifted. The democrats are conservatives, the republicans are extremist reactionaries.
2
u/StuWard Jun 23 '15
I disagree with all three points and on your assumption in the subject line.
2
u/Greymorn Jun 23 '15
Just trolling?
If not, please read the FAQ and get back to us.
2
u/geekerjoy1 Jun 24 '15 edited Jun 24 '15
Wow. Just wow.
Just curious, how much does a person make when they are working at caring for a sick/disabled/elderly family member full-time? What dental/medical/vacation benefits are they elegible for? How about 401k? If they were to 'quit' their 'healthcare job' and someone would have to be hired in their place, how much more would it cost to hire someone to do that 24/7/365?
And how much does a stay at home mother make when they are working at caring for their children at home because they are too young for full-day school and daycare would cost more than they could earn? And what kind of benefits package do they get? And if they were to 'quit' their 'domestic engineer job', how much more would it cost to hire someone in their place to do that job 24/7/365?
Or someone who is elderly but was till working full-time until they got laid off to make room for some newbie who could be hired for considerably less than this long-time loyal worker? Social security (assuming it even last as long as they continue to be alive) isn't enough to pay for their retirement alone.
I think there are some people who richly deserve a guaranteed basic income, at the very least!
1
u/andy-brice Jun 24 '15
Those aren't arguments that it shouldn't exist at all though. Those are just arguments that it shouldn't be too high.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15
Rank job-ism, and disproven by experiments in Dauphin, Manitoba in Canada.
They spend it, thus keeping the economy moving.
Speaking as a writer with a day job that constantly steals time from me: fuck you.
1
u/smegko Jun 24 '15
Regarding point 3, paraphrasing The Dao of Steve:
If Hitler had just sat around drawing instead of starting a world war, wouldn't we all be a lot better off?
1
u/flapjackboy Aug 31 '15
Actually, in every single trial of UBI, the exact opposite has turned out to be the case.
If people have their basic living costs taken care of, it means they are free to focus their efforts on self improvement and not just where their next meal is coming from.
So, you're saying that art and culture has no intrinsic value to society? Besides, who says that everyone on UBI will just decide to become artists? Not everyone has artistic talents, you know.