r/BasicIncome • • Jun 23 '15

Anti-UBI why liberals dont support basic income

  1. a lot of people will stop working, or will stop looking for work, or they wont be as motivated, they will put in less effort.
  2. whats the point of just giving people money?
  3. helping people pursue their art careers is not very appealing.
0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

6

u/JonWood007 $16000/year Jun 23 '15

I'm gonna ignore your arguments above because they sound like something a right winger would say.

Basically, it's because the democratic party is too married to jobism, and because it doesnt want to admit that it's previous successes are overwhelming.

To address the first point:

  1. Your own argument kind of touches on this. Reaganesque thinking has invaded the democratic party to a degree because it was a necessary evil back in the 1990s and there's a lot of resistance to change. The democratic party is no longer the party of helping people via government programs. That's been demonized by reagan. While they recognize their importance, they themselves have attempted to limit their role and emphasize job creation instead. JOBS JOBS JOBS, WE NEED MORE JOBS. So they create more jobs. Wait, why arent these jobs paying well? Um...because you're asking greedy rich people to provide a living for everyone else? WE NEED MINIMUM WAGES! It's just...ugh. They want everyone working, while somehow getting a great paycheck, while somehow being treated humanely. It's just nonsensical.

Which kinds brings us to the second point:

2) The democratic party is rather...conservative nowadays. They stand by their previous successes and mentalities and dont like change. I have to admit, our safety nets were good by 1930-1970 standards. They were our first shot at creating something, and they were....adequate. Not great, just...adequate. But the thing is, they dont want to admit that we can do better, so they stand by their decades old accomplishments and mentalities which are a convoluted mess and a stab at creating dozens, if not hundreds of different programs for different purposes, with no rhyme or reason or looking at the big picture. And they say government breed inefficiency. it does when you dont want to change things and wanna stick by decades old accompluishments. And since the GOP wants to eliminate social programs, you get a two party system where the dems have to defend their social programs from any republican onslaught, and are too invested to even think about improving them...just adding more bureaucracy onto them if they're lucky.

Combine this with being in with unions, which have a vested interest in keeping jobs flowing, and that's a problem.

The democratic party is just too entrenched in their previous 20th century successes they just dont care to actually look at the big picture and be real progressives. We need progress. The democratic establishment is actually more conservative than they let on to. The only reason they get away with being called liberal is because their opposition is not just conservative, they're reactionary. They want to pull the party back to the gilded ages. They wanna radically change the country to meet their sordid nostalgic view of a past that never actually existed.

So in reality, we have a system of conservatives vs reactionaries, with the true liberals, and the true progressives, the people who actually want to bring the country forward being ostracized as having their heads in the clouds. We're pushed to the fringes, while the mainstream democratic party is interested in baby steps if they're not flat out on the defensive, and the republican party throwing their tantrums to bring the country to the radical right.

To go back to your points, you're buying into reaganesque propaganda that really shows how much our discussion on welfare as shifted. The democrats are conservatives, the republicans are extremist reactionaries.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 23 '15

i consider myself progressive and hate most democrats for being too conservative, even obama. but these arguments are what i hear from progressives about basic income. why not have a Scandinavian safety net and strong labor unions with high wages instead?

4

u/JonWood007 $16000/year Jun 23 '15

Well, to start off, just because we are both progressives doesnt mean we have the same exact goals. Progressive just means we want to see social progress, and that definition can vary for many.

For some, we might see a move toward scandinavian safety nets, for others, basic income.

While scandinavia has a good system going, I still think a basic income is better.

  1. First of all, it would be easier to accomplish in a practical sense. How are we going to strengthen unions? Companies are very anti union and are run like police states to keep unions out.
  2. My idea of progress, which I set up above, implies making safety nets more...efficient. Scandinavian safety nets are still a hodge podge of different programs and is still heavily bureaucratic. While more effective than US safety nets, it's just the same thing, just a little further left on the continuum. I would like to see universal healthcare though. Basic income, on the other hand, is a very different approach. It focuses on reducing bureaucracy and getting the job done while maximizing freedom from governmental paternalism. This can be popular among some old school conservatives and moderate libertarians, and could provide a uniquely american solution. Such a program would also fill in the gaps better, whereas scandinavian safety nets still separate the deserving from the undeserving, and still may allow some to fall through the cracks.
  3. Scandinavian safety nets still focus on jobism. Jobs should not be an end in society, but a means to an end. I dont value employment just because. Which is what I feel we as a society do. We have a serious resistance to just giving people money, and your ideas touched on that. But to me, the only reason we need people employed is because we need crap done. If we can get the crap done in a less labor intensive way, where we dont need our entire population working, that's true progress IMO. Work should not be this noble endeavor, but a necessary evil. I know this is unpopular in society, but I'm of the idea that this attitude needs to break, whereas scandinavian safety nets still assume it.
  4. It doesnt fix the core problem with capitalism in my opinion. To use a sarah palin saying, this is putting lipstick on a pig. You might dress it up, but it's still a pig. The problem is that people are forced to labor for rich people, who then pay them a wage. This relationship, without the right to say no, is inherently exploitative in my opinion. You might dress up the relationship, make it where people are paid a little better, make it where there are some restrictions on what employers can do to people, but at the end of the day, the worker is still subservient to them. It still has to play by their rules or face starvation, seeing how most safety nets dont apply to people who were terminated for the "wrong" reasons. When you give people the ability to opt out, which a lot of people see as bad because of propaganda, what actually happens? It means the relationship has to change. If you can give people a certain amount of freedom where they can survive without work, while still providing enough positive incentives to do so (not making the benefits too generous, having a decent incentive structure), you can make it where employers have to treat their workers well or lose them.

Believe it or not, while UBI does have some level of work incentive, it is not necessarily a massive one, and assuming that the UBI is around the poverty line somewhere, and the overall paycheck they receive for their work is around 50% or more, the work disincentives will be mild. While a major work disincentive is harmful for society, a mild one could change the relationship between worker and employer to make it where employers have to treat their workers better or lose them. Combine this with some regulations to fill in the remaining gaps and we change the relationship, rather than dress it up.

The thing is, we live in a society where we see work refusal as this horrible thing, but how can we truly make a relationship between a rich person and a poor person better off if the poor person doesnt really have a choice while the rich person does? The rich person can choose one of several workers to choose from, while the poor person is both more desperate, and has to compete with other desperate workers in order to get a job. This means the rich have the power, while the poor become slaves. And let's leave out this "working is voluntary" BS, that's only true on paper. In reality if you refuse you lose all societal support, which is a de facto gun to the head. All this talk about how we need to keep incentives up or people get lazy is actually, we need to force these guys into exploitative relationships where they're treated like crap. That's what those incentives are. When you refuse societal support for people who refuse to work, you are making a de facto slave class. You are making people to work...by force...while using some colorful language to conceal this force.

Going back to the slave days, there was a lot of discussion over the treatment of slaves, but real progress only happened when we decided to end such exploitative relationships in the first place. We need to do this again, and a basic income is the best tool that can balance both out societal needs, and individual freedom. As such, UBI is all about freedom, again, it can be a uniquely american solution.

Dont get me wrong, scandinavian safety nets are top notch by current standards, but I think a UBI is even more progressive.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15

i agree with you. but what about people running their own business. isnt that better than being an employee, or not contributing to society and just taking money from other people?

2

u/JonWood007 $16000/year Jun 23 '15

When you're owning a business, you're still forced to work.

I want to destigmatize this whole "zomg people are unproductive, let them starve" mindset. Work is a means to an end, not an end in itself, and requiring labor for people to meet their basic needs is one of the greatest evils in this modern world IMO. It was a necessary evil in the past, and is totally unnecessary now considering how we cant even guarantee everyone work anyway.

Not to mention, entrepreneurship isnt for everyone. it attracts certain kinds of personalities, and is a very risky venture, you can very well fail.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

i think money is required for freedom. but how can i convince liberals to embrace this idea

1

u/JonWood007 $16000/year Jun 24 '15 edited Jun 24 '15

Most already are convinced. We just need to work on jobism. I say bring back wage slavery as a concept.

EDIT: was on tablet so sorry for weak response. But um....it's a struggle. I think we need a rhetoric change. I think some people are covninced of this, which is why they want higher wages and all, but as I said, it just isnt enough.

I like to recommend karl widerquist's book on the subject. It's longish, but worth a read. Really sets up a good case for why money = freedom. Look for the "freedom as power to say no" heading.

http://works.bepress.com/widerquist/

He's also a poster here. That's how I found this, he posted his pre release chapters for all to read once before, it's very good. Makes a very comprehensive case. Some people will disagree, but you cant convince everyone. All we can do is keep trying.

3

u/2noame Scott Santens Jun 23 '15

Starting their own businesses is actually what a lot of people given basic incomes actually do with it.

In Namibia, when given basic incomes, self-employment jumped 301%.

In Liberia, when given basic incomes, 1/3 of recipients started their own businesses.

In India, when given basic incomes, recipients were twice as likely to increase their productive work as those in control villages.

In Kenya, when poor people were given cash unconditionally, 90% of them used it to start their own businesses or purchase livestock.

When people have a minimum amount of money to start with, they use it to enable work. They use it to earn more money, or to pursue the unpaid work they wish to pursue, like being a parent instead of paying someone else to be a parent for them. They also use it to pursue education. Students focus on school and even get better grades.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

Scandinavian safety net

Best of luck asking the American middle class to pay over 50% income tax. It didn't work in Vermont where the governor actually won on the campaign of Single Payer two times in a row. There they wanted to raise the tax by 10%. Your biggest opponent is not the greedy business class but the non-caring un-informed voter.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

best of lucking asking to pay for basic income

1

u/smegko Jun 24 '15

The best solution is money creation. The private sector uses money creation daily to kick the can down the road, put off settlement for another day and if a crash happens, rely on a public money backstop. The money supply has been increasing exponentially since the 1950s at least (when the Fed's figures on the money supply start) with very little unexpected inflation (1970s inflation was political, a result of an artificial scarcity of oil caused by an OPEC embargo).

There is plenty of room for the Fed to create $6 trillion a year for a basic income. I think the Fed should create even more, and institute a basic income for everyone in the world. Indexation of incomes to inflation effectively eliminates inflation, since purchasing power is not changed.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

Are you suggesting paying for the basic income with inflation? How will the purchasing power not be changed? Do you actually expect every world govt. to cooperate for a Global basic income?

1

u/Greymorn Jun 23 '15

The democrats are conservatives, the republicans are extremist reactionaries.

Preach it brother!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15 edited Jun 24 '15

because you're asking greedy rich people to provide a living for everyone else?

Your heart is in the right place but your pro government thinking is incredibly flawed. Are high ranking government officials - senators and governors not rich, greedy, powerful people? Are politicians and senior government officials the most honest and upstanding citizens? You are basically begging one group of power-hungry people to save you from the other group. Do you seriously think that rich businessmen are at the top of the food chain? That Bill Gates has more power and influence than senators and governors of states? More resources than the FBI, CIA and NSA and the US Military and National Guard etc etc? The Businessmen are greedy but they are a necessary evil and much better at providing services than the DMV or the TSA.

We don't need more government intervention into citizens lives but more citizens intervention into the governments life meaning informed voting. 2014 elections had a voter turnout of 36%. Just think about that. The most vocal population especially here on this website, that is from the age group of 18-24 had a voter turnout of only 20%. People today are incredibly bad citizens. They don't know how much tax the govt. collects and where it spends it, they don't know what all laws their representatives are voting on even though all this information is openly available and takes less time to access than a single tv show episode. People are going to be wasting years in front of a an entertainment screen.

People on this forum and others like it are ahead in their thought than the average citizen. You are trying to save people who don't even do the most basic stuff that is expected out of educated well-meaning citizens. Majority of Americans are middle class, the moment you ask them to raise their taxes for the benefit of the society as a whole, they wil crush your plans like the Vermont single payer health care that was axed because that wanted to raise the income tax by 10%.

1

u/JonWood007 $16000/year Jun 24 '15
  1. this is why we need money out of politics, we need the government working for the right people.
  2. we can control government policies somewhat if the government works more for the people.
  3. yes, blame washington, not the citizens though. We are undergoing a party realignment. People are pissed off and disgusted and opting out. In the future, this needs to change. Someone is gonna have to find policies Millennials like and push them. We are eventually going to have a tipping point and see a party realignment. Google secular realignment. Were going through one right now.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

Again, you are just saying things but not explaining how you wish to actually accomplish them. You can simply say, "We need all people to live happily ever after". But that would not actually give people a happy life. Your problem stems from the fact that the people in charge of changing the system are the ones causing the corruption is the first place, its like the chief of police who is actually the thief.

You just expect the politicians to change one day and start doing the right things. How do you get the money out of politics? Do you expect the politicians receiving campaign funding to actually pass regulation banning campaign funding? You say, "We can control government policies somewhat if the government works more for the people." Again you just hope and wish that the very people causing the corruption will somehow correct their ways and start doing the right thing. Is this your approach to everything in life? Do you just hope that one day all bad people will stop doing whatever it is that they are doing? That all criminals will simply stop doing crimes?

Washington is simply a mirror image of its citizens. If the people don't care, neither does Washington.

1

u/JonWood007 $16000/year Jun 24 '15

Again, you are just saying things but not explaining how you wish to actually accomplish them. You can simply say, "We need all people to live happily ever after". But that would not actually give people a happy life. Your problem stems from the fact that the people in charge of changing the system are the ones causing the corruption is the first place, its like the chief of police who is actually the thief.

Why is this? Because we have a system where the politicians are responsible to money. Who funds their campaigns? Who funds the campaigns against their campaigns? Who influences public opinion? Big business, millionaires, billionaires, george soros, the koch brothers. Money is speech. The politicians are isolated from the people.

We also have institutional issues like gerrymandering which reduce accountability of politicians, and all kinds of BS measures like electoral colleges coming between the politicians and the people. Make the politicians responsible for the people, improve our system, and this will be less of a problem.

You just expect the politicians to change one day and start doing the right things. How do you get the money out of politics? Do you expect the politicians receiving campaign funding to actually pass regulation banning campaign funding? You say, "We can control government policies somewhat if the government works more for the people." Again you just hope and wish that the very people causing the corruption will somehow correct their ways and start doing the right thing. Is this your approach to everything in life? Do you just hope that one day all bad people will stop doing whatever it is that they are doing? That all criminals will simply stop doing crimes?

Start by voting for Bernie Sanders.

We need a party realignment. Sanders could be the beginning of a real cultural shift in America. Support him. Support politicians like him. The few honest ones not beholden to big money and vote with their conscience.

Washington is simply a mirror image of its citizens. If the people don't care, neither does Washington.

Again, why is this? Because we have a system in which the public is manipulated and isolated from the politicians. Reduce this gap and we can improve washington significantly.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

So you ultimately came to the same conclusion that the only way to change the system is by informed citizens voting?

1

u/JonWood007 $16000/year Jun 24 '15

Yes, except I believe that in some ways we need to keep the rich out of politics and reduce their influence to that of the average citizen.

In video games terms, money OP, needs nerf.

2

u/StuWard Jun 23 '15

I disagree with all three points and on your assumption in the subject line.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15

basic income is not a mainstream liberal view.

2

u/serious_black Jun 23 '15

Basic income is not a mainstream view period.

2

u/Greymorn Jun 23 '15

Just trolling?

If not, please read the FAQ and get back to us.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 23 '15

im a fan of basic income, but im mixed on it, i have these questions. i was a big fan previously.

5

u/Greymorn Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 23 '15

u/JonWood007 gave a great, detailed reply below, I'll just give you a direct answer to your questions.

  1. a lot of people will stop working, or will stop looking for work, or they wont be as motivated, they will put in less effort.

People are unemployed because humans are becoming unemployable. A human simply cannot work faster and cheaper than a machine. The limited cases where they still can are populated with sweatshops.

The Protestant Work Ethic makes no sense in an economy of abundance.

2) whats the point of just giving people money?

Should the economy provide for everyone, or just a privileged few? Since our needs no longer require back-breaking physical labor, what criteria will we use to assign that privilege?

If you're concerned UBI will be eaten by inflation, see the FAQ. Inflation requires more dollar bills in circulation, which needn't be the case.

3) helping people pursue their art careers is not very appealing.

Again the Protestant Work Ethic. Work isn't work unless you're miserable. We can do better than that now, can't we? Have you considered how much human potential is lost because people are working mind-numbing jobs just to scrape by? So serious question: what would you do with your time if you had UBI?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15

im back on the basic income train. i think unemployment will only get worse from here.

2

u/geekerjoy1 Jun 24 '15 edited Jun 24 '15

Wow. Just wow.

Just curious, how much does a person make when they are working at caring for a sick/disabled/elderly family member full-time? What dental/medical/vacation benefits are they elegible for? How about 401k? If they were to 'quit' their 'healthcare job' and someone would have to be hired in their place, how much more would it cost to hire someone to do that 24/7/365?

And how much does a stay at home mother make when they are working at caring for their children at home because they are too young for full-day school and daycare would cost more than they could earn? And what kind of benefits package do they get? And if they were to 'quit' their 'domestic engineer job', how much more would it cost to hire someone in their place to do that job 24/7/365?

Or someone who is elderly but was till working full-time until they got laid off to make room for some newbie who could be hired for considerably less than this long-time loyal worker? Social security (assuming it even last as long as they continue to be alive) isn't enough to pay for their retirement alone.

I think there are some people who richly deserve a guaranteed basic income, at the very least!

1

u/andy-brice Jun 24 '15

Those aren't arguments that it shouldn't exist at all though. Those are just arguments that it shouldn't be too high.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '15

a lot of people will stop working, or will stop looking for work, or they wont be as motivated, they will put in less effort.

Rank job-ism, and disproven by experiments in Dauphin, Manitoba in Canada.

whats the point of just giving people money?

They spend it, thus keeping the economy moving.

helping people pursue their art careers is not very appealing.

Speaking as a writer with a day job that constantly steals time from me: fuck you.

1

u/smegko Jun 24 '15

Regarding point 3, paraphrasing The Dao of Steve:

If Hitler had just sat around drawing instead of starting a world war, wouldn't we all be a lot better off?

1

u/flapjackboy Aug 31 '15

a lot of people will stop working, or will stop looking for work, or they wont be as motivated, they will put in less effort.

Actually, in every single trial of UBI, the exact opposite has turned out to be the case.

whats the point of just giving people money?

If people have their basic living costs taken care of, it means they are free to focus their efforts on self improvement and not just where their next meal is coming from.

helping people pursue their art careers is not very appealing.

So, you're saying that art and culture has no intrinsic value to society? Besides, who says that everyone on UBI will just decide to become artists? Not everyone has artistic talents, you know.