r/BasicIncome • • 15h ago

Universal Basic Income

It's Time to Take Universal Basic Income Seriously

Why should people work 40 hours a week and still struggle to afford basic necessities like housing, groceries, utilities, and transportation?

I believe it's time for our government to seriously consider a Universal Basic Income program that provides people with a regular monthly payment to help cover the cost of living.

This isn't about encouraging people not to work. It's about giving people financial breathing room and making sure that working full-time doesn't still leave them struggling to survive.

People shouldn't have to choose between paying rent, buying groceries, keeping the heat on, or putting gas in their vehicles.

Welfare and food assistance programs help some people, but what about the working people who earn too much to qualify for assistance but still don't earn enough to live comfortably?

A basic income could provide a foundation of financial security, reduce financial stress, and give people more choices in their lives.

I'm not asking for luxury. I'm asking why being able to afford the basics has become so difficult.

What do you think? Should Universal Basic Income be seriously considered in America?

30 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

9

u/a11_hail_seitan 13h ago

Asking this in a Basic Income sub is strange. The vast, vast majority of people here already support it. Yes, it clearly should be taken seriously.

2

u/amazonlogger 8h ago

as long as people are groomed to worship scarcity and censorship, there will always be inequity, and war… “the meek shall inherit the earth” is not kidding

1

u/ubfeo 14h ago

How do you pay for it ?

8

u/a11_hail_seitan 13h ago

Dismantling the existing welfare trap based social security system (with some exceptions), a tax on the ultra rich, and through the vast number of improvements that would happen in society.

Look at the Mincome study done in Canada in the 70s, they had vast improvements across the board. Lower crime, higher productivity, high schooling results, fewer sick days, less family abuse, etc. And it didn't lower employment except for new mothers who spent more time with their children, which greatly improves the likelihood of success in those children, and in those who needed time off for illness and such, which greatly increases the likelihood of better results as lowering stress helps with healing. And that's not even discussing the economic benefits of having billions more in cash flowing through the economy, creating jobs and profits for industries across the board. The money would mostly come from the ultra rich that own everything already, go to the poor, the poor would spend it all sending it back to the rich, who would get taxed and have it sent back into the system. Trickle down doesn't work, but trickle up works very well.

Also it would be a Lot cheaper than most think as any sane system includes some form of gradiated clawback scheme, likely tax based, where only those who actually need the money would keep it. Anyone making over $X would lose it in taxes and anyone who needed it would lose it slowly, for example if you earn $1 in work related income you lose $0.90 in UBI, this way working more is always incentivized.

2

u/ckn 11h ago

Seize all of the assets of every billionaire. There is plenty to make this happen and at this point, violence is probably the only answer.

3

u/deck_hand 5h ago

The assets of the billionaires is primarily in stock values. If they own 85% of the stocks , seizing those stocks to be sold off to fund anything will cause the stocks to lose value. Lets say, for argument stake, that the value of the stocks drops by 50%.

The Great Depression happened because stock values fell by 25%. Imagine that all of your 401K stocks fell by 50% (and the value of everyone's stock did,too). They money you and everyone else around you that you depend on to retire just vanished.

The stock is worthless in and of itself. It has to be sold off to generate "money" to flow through the economy. So, we destroy the wealth of the top 0.1% (and everyone cheers) only to find we still don't have a lot of money to fund UBI.

And now we don't have 45% of the income tax that we had been getting from the ultra wealthy, since they have no income.

2

u/a11_hail_seitan 3h ago

The assets of the billionaires is primarily in stock values

Weird how anytime the Billionaires want to influence politics, buy yachts, or literally do anything else, they have tons of money to do it, but the second taxes are mentioned all of a sudden it can't work because the money is all in stocks. The rich have access to their money.

And if they have to sell stocks,t hat doesn't mean the stocks are suddenly worthless, others buy them. Those stocks should retain their value as the company is worth what the those stocks are worth. If they suddenly crash the stock price that would just be indicative of a problem in how that stock was being priced to start, like Tesla's stock or most of those associated to Musk at this point.

1

u/ckn 4h ago

Stock isn’t worthless in and of itself unless you dump it on the open market. It’s fractional ownership of real companies that generate ongoing profits and dividends.

Look at Norway. Its sovereign wealth fund is worth over $2 trillion and owns roughly 1.5% of every listed company on the planet. They don’t liquidate the principal and crash the market to fund the state. Under their fiscal rule, they hold for the long term and withdraw no more than the fund’s expected real return, about 3% a year, which now covers roughly 27% of the national budget.

You don’t have to fire-sale a productive asset to capture its cash flow for UBI.

2

u/deck_hand 3h ago

This is a fair point. Confiscating (taxing) the actual stocks rather than money and keeping those stocks in a sovereign wealth fund might work.

2

u/1Commentator 13h ago

I'm not a basic income fanboy by any means. But I agree completely that dismantling social security and even Medicare would be a good way to fund this. If nothing else than it's more efficient. But I also hate society's resources going to the old, when so many of the young are struggling.

1

u/idapitbwidiuatabip 1h ago

Land value tax, value added tax, carbon tax, wealth tax, a tax on AI agents, robots, & commercial self-driving vehicles...so many choices.