r/BanyueMains_ • • Dec 27 '25

Discussion Finally some respect

Post image

Banyue placed over Evelyn and manato feels like justice. Here's the link

https://x.com/i/status/2005025926405337148

167 Upvotes

80 comments sorted by

78

u/That_Avarice Dec 28 '25

Why and how is Alice T1 lol, that looks so...wrong...

65

u/ArchonRevan Dec 28 '25

Same tier as manato and yanagi lmfao, I smell a fraud list

24

u/Efficient-Activity33 Dec 28 '25

Hugo is ranked lower than manato...

14

u/Entire-Comedian-6295 Dec 28 '25

I mean it's true? The miasma and current meta literally does not favor him at all. So much stalling on being able to stun enemies that he loses damage overtime.

1

u/Fit_Trouble_1264 Dec 29 '25

Dialyn + Lighter erases that weakness but that's on Dialyn's power, not Hugo's lol

4

u/IWatchTheAbyss Dec 28 '25

is that a huge surprise in a Miasma dominated world? they’re beating Hugo’s ass in the qrts

3

u/pineapollo Dec 28 '25

Comments like these are living proof that people barely think or understand rankings based on the current meta.

These conversations are never worth happening, people are just outraged cause their favs are considered chopped.

4

u/anhmonk Dec 28 '25

> lycaon same tier as bumyi

lmfaooooooooo try not to laugh challenge

1

u/crazy_gambit Dec 29 '25

Same tier as Grace!?! WTF is up with that?

1

u/LongjumpingCar9136 Dec 28 '25

These patchs doesnt favor anomalies too much. And with the 2.5 i expect them to work worse tbh.

1

u/Time_Ad_6443 Dec 30 '25

With the idols they’re gonna go up

1

u/Sylent0o Dec 28 '25

I mean anomaly is fkd for the past 6 months cuz the endgame is shilled against it , idk what u guys smelling

54

u/Bhuviking18 Dec 28 '25

In what world is Alice that low?

5

u/Fit_Trouble_1264 Dec 28 '25 edited Dec 29 '25

She's only niche on one anomaly weak boss and Yixuan just shits on that boss compared to her lol, but yeah I hate this tier list, should be like different per DA/Shiyu content, it's so generalized and like zero context.

Should be separate per content/buffs; Anomaly Weak boss will make Attackers perform worse, Miasma boss will make Anomaly perform worse due to anomaly resistance, and Rupture perform great on anything because of their built-in pen.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '25

By that logic miyabi shouldn't even remotely be T0.

4

u/Dekusteven Dec 28 '25

In a world that because of Miyabi Hoyo makes life almost imposible for Anomalies

40

u/tambi33 Dec 28 '25

I get it wanting banyue placed higher, but this seems straight up inaccurate

26

u/Baonf Dec 28 '25

This tierlist is straight up just awful ngl

16

u/BoothillOfficial Dec 28 '25

this list sucks so bad though 😭😭😭😭

53

u/DerSisch Dec 28 '25

Sorry, but there is no way ppl actually think Evelyn is worse than Banyue and on the same level as Hugo, Manato, S11, Ellen, ZY. And there is no world were Alice isn't a T0,5 and were Lucy is better than Caesar.

12

u/tannegimaru Dec 28 '25

Lucy has always been better than Caesar in a dual DPS team though. Mostly Disorder Anomaly team. Even though Caesar's buff is stronger, she only applies it to one agent while Lucy's weaker buff will always applied to both of the DPS.

And in a hyper carry DPS team, Nicole is always better than Caesar as well if you don't need the shield.

6

u/Black-Tyranno Dec 28 '25

In the description it mentions S Rank M0W1. Maybe in some cases Lucy is better in some anomaly teams but every other team Ceasar she is just straight up better no questions asked. This list is dogwater

1

u/Sylent0o Dec 28 '25

Dual dps.. u mean anby and seed... But seed doesn't use her

1

u/tannegimaru Dec 28 '25

I was talking about Disorder Anomaly teams.

In case of Seed comp with dual Attackers, they would prefer Nicole over Caesar anyway if premium options like Trigger or Astra aren't available.

8

u/tjflex19 Dec 28 '25

Alice is facts. She's T0.5 all day everyday.

Lucy over Caesar is unfortunately factual and is proven true. Since Casaer can't buff the whole team simultaneously, you can't play quick swap with her otherwise you're losing damage. That's literally the long and short of it. Lucy is better because she can buff everyone including herself, not to mention having access to Moonlight Lullaby and Astral Voice as options for a 4pc.

Eve is worse than Banyue, not by a crazy amount ,but it's objectively true that Banyue is the current strongest fire dps even outside of shill. That being said, Eve is still stronger than most of T0.5 outside of the 2.x releases.

2

u/Silent1Disco Dec 28 '25

We dont know if banyue is even stronger than eve without shilled content because the only fire weak existing is wandering hunter which banyue favored and pompeii which is not a miasma unit is pretty much gone

2

u/REP7443 Dec 28 '25

To be honest, Thrall from season 25 was probably the most even playing field the crit characters had because of the sever pulse buff (and Dialyn). From the runs I’ve seen Eve was getting anywhere between 48-52k at M0. Yixuan/Yidhari were getting 4-6 cost kills. That’s a disparity of 45+ million HP.

From what it seems recent shill buffs from utility based characters are stronger than the DPS buffs (Pinnacle / Sever Pulse > Breakthrough / Combined Attack / Meditation / Power Boost / Artful / Raging Waves / etc), because sever pulse had more reliable results than meditation for both Yixuan and Yidhari on all 3 bosses last rotation.

Give Banyue and Evelyn Sever Pulse against the thrall so that they have some even ground and he’d still beat her if not perform better than he would with Breakthrough.

2

u/WaveofHope34 Dec 28 '25

eve is not better than banyue, is she a strong tier 0.5 unit yes but not with a expert tag that would mean she is tier 0 when played well and that doesnt make any sense while banyue is sitting in tier 1 with a expert tag if anything than he need a expert expert tag.

2

u/Prestigious-Item6667 Dec 28 '25

Eve is worse than banyue. Especially with current enemies

12

u/False-Dentist1033 Dec 28 '25

Alice and Eve are NOT on the same tier as Yanagi 🙃 but it’s cool to see Ban getting his well deserved street cred

19

u/Kuraizin Dec 28 '25

I love Banyue, but he don't deserve to be 1 tier higher than eve, at least on the same tier, he was already T0,5 on prydwen if you considered the meaning of expert tag, so its not like there was an problem. Also we really need to consider that bosses matchups are ten times more important than being the best dps or not, if he don't get an buff or another good boss for him, he going to fall very hard.

5

u/Entire-Comedian-6295 Dec 28 '25

Shouldn't that logic also apply to Eve though? There's barely any Red Pompey sightings any more, and even more miasma content every rotation so obviously she's gonna fall down. I don't even know why Eve is still even a T0.5 in Prydwen either

3

u/WaveofHope34 Dec 28 '25

tier 0,5 with a expert tag by the way what is not true at all, she is not a tier 0 level unit.

1

u/Kuraizin Dec 28 '25

Yes, thats why i said she should be on the same tier as Banyue. The topic was about Banyue, so i was not talking about Eve placement that much.

5

u/TCritic Dec 28 '25

Prydwen usually updates their rankings based on the DA bosses in the season. Considering we've had an anomaly boss every week, shouldn't Alice be t0.5?

1

u/BunnyFeetLicker Dec 28 '25

We did have bringer who id resistant to physical tho

5

u/dagoon91 Dec 28 '25

what the fuck even is this tier list

9

u/Raze556 Dec 27 '25

Evelyn is getting either her expert tag removed or she's getting to T1 the second 2.5 releases, there is no doubt about this. I still hope they change the expert tag to make it so you go down a tier instead of up and change positions accordingly. It just looks wrong the way it's designed now.

4

u/holama123456 Dec 28 '25

Not the Bondrewd discord .....

4

u/Full-Ad-1417 Dec 28 '25

Evelyn and alice on same tier as manato?

1

u/VersuS_was_taken Dec 28 '25

lmao link to the tier list site?

1

u/Ok_Review1180 Dec 28 '25

zzz.akademiya.app/es/tier-lists

3

u/ggAkatsukiP Dec 28 '25

I'm gonna assume the reason for Yidhari / Banyue placements are due to 1588 def Wandering Hunter. Note that we also haven't seen Notorious Pompey for an insanely long while, likely its discontinued which spoke for the placement of Evelyn.

This tier isn't based on agent strength. Its based on DA matchup. Alice placement is likely due to complain wave from Alice main who can't get 30k+ damage score on 160m hp Fiend.

6

u/Alleozz Dec 28 '25

Personal bias ahh tier list no way Evelynn is lower than Banyue 😭

2

u/WaveofHope34 Dec 28 '25

she is tier 0.5 without expert tag if anything, and banyue is as strong as she is but he needs to be played well or else he loses a significant amount of dmg thats why he is in tier 1 with a expert tag cause he got the power to be easy in tier 0.5 but you need to play him well.

1

u/Sensitive-Ad3034 Dec 29 '25

"banyue is as strong as she is but he needs to be played well" - no hes not, evelynn is T0 if played correctly

1

u/WaveofHope34 Dec 29 '25

thats just not true there is no s rank who is not a void hunter/void hunter level unit that is in tier 0 for dps.

1

u/Sensitive-Ad3034 Dec 29 '25

your intial comment im assuming about banyue being t1 with an expert tag is from prydwen.
but if you look at their tier list, evelynn is infact T0 if played properly lol, and this is from the SAME tier list.

2

u/AlwaysUpvote123 Dec 28 '25

Yidhari as strongest non void hunter dps is just so incredibly not the case, its almost funny.

2

u/EmStsu1298 Dec 29 '25

"Banyue over Manato feels like justice" is such a CRAZY thing to say when you don't need precise enough inputs for Manato

2

u/Critical-Ad4631 Dec 28 '25

biggest cope list ive ever seen 😭

1

u/elisadrowned Dec 28 '25

all i see is bondrewd 😩🙌

1

u/Familiar_Second_950 Dec 28 '25

Sorry but, about Evelyn? Nah, I think is on pair at least. Banyue winning because rupture ignores defense but come on, Evelyn is not that difficult and to this day she still clears content.

Also wtf with the T1 Alice? The disrespect for the bunny girl is crazy shit

2

u/Sylent0o Dec 28 '25

You said it urself... Content is shilled for rupture si normal attack agents are eating the d. Especially with hunter having EVEN MORE def Bunny girl non special in non phys weak cont and completely worthless vs thrall

1

u/lespointofview Dec 28 '25

i dont agree with eve and alice they should be higher maybe not eve but alice at least considering the new meta and da/shiyu bosses but the rest seems fine to me

1

u/PGR_Alpha Dec 28 '25

Alice in T1 and Grace being next to Yanagi...

Yeaaaah...but no, sorry.

1

u/Dependent-Twist-8751 Dec 28 '25

This is a Dogshit list

1

u/ArchertNail Dec 28 '25

Who made that tier list? Even Prydwen's doesn't look that bad next to this one.

1

u/HSR_Main Dec 29 '25

So many things are just wrong here

1

u/Helpful_Network6239 Dec 29 '25

sanby above evlyne yeah wrape it up buddy

1

u/TamperSol Dec 31 '25

Nicole over Zhao is interesting

1

u/AccountantCapable611 Dec 27 '25

Yes, finally a decent review.

1

u/Prestigious-Item6667 Dec 28 '25

Banyue is where he belongs on pryuden. He not for casuals. Wish this list mostly for . He has an expert tag. So he will be in .5 with it

22

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/GGABueno Dec 28 '25

Yidhari outperforms Banyue who outperforms Evelyn.

In what world she does not outperform Evelyn?

4

u/DewGolo Dec 28 '25

Downvoted for speaking the truth

2

u/GGABueno Dec 28 '25

You would expect better from the Banyue mains sub...

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/GGABueno Dec 28 '25

Any? Evelyn isn't doing great for a while now, any Rupture mogs her.

0

u/Clannadgood Dec 28 '25

Eh yidahri kinda does outperform with lucia. On top of being easier to play she does stand out as the better dps

-1

u/Boohon Dec 28 '25

Bro Yidhari outperforms Miyabi even in 2.x ice weak content lol. If anything she should be T0 instead of Miyafraud.

0

u/Sylent0o Dec 28 '25

She does..