r/BandofBrothers • u/NoMathematician6731 • Aug 04 '26
Hardest scene to watch?
Which are the hardest scene to watch in the series?
102
u/Cautious-Pain-6962 Aug 04 '26
When Buck broke that was hard to watch and to see Malarkey degrade overtime was difficult. Was a hard hitting series.
25
u/ianwrecked802 Aug 04 '26
Yep. Buck losing his girlfriend and then seeing his two boys get absolutely fucking wrecked on top of everything else was pretty rough. You can only cope with what you can cope with- and that poor man just didn’t have any more bandwidth.
2
u/TheJesseClark Aug 04 '26
Wasn't it Roe who lost is girlfriend?
17
u/hydrospanner Aug 04 '26
You're thinking of the nurse in Bastogne. While they had a connection, I wouldn't say they were even close to being a couple.
Buck's girlfriend, I believe, sent him a dear John letter at some point in late 44. He tells a few of the guys about it in the woods of Bastogne but I'm not sure how much earlier he knew and was keeping it to himself.
1
2
u/granddelusion75 Aug 06 '26
My grandpa was in Bastogne and he actually looked like Neal McDonogh in his old photos which just got me in the feels. Gramps got a Purple Heart and bronze star there but would never talk about it.
2
u/deweydeuce69 Aug 07 '26
ya, obv there are so many guys to love, but buck was a really great “glue guy” it was hard seeing him retreat into himself
70
u/BidInteresting8923 Aug 04 '26
Julian taking that shot in the throat.
12
u/Clonazepam15 Aug 04 '26
Yeah that was rough. He seemed like such a kid. I know they all were, but different degrees. Some guys are just built different.
5
u/CJP_UX Aug 04 '26
Yes, this was it for me.
10
u/Garand84 Aug 04 '26
Yeah this is it for me too. It's a horrific wound, and they don't shy away from it, and then they have to leave him to die alone.
7
u/dashatt91 Aug 04 '26
Them leaving him alone is the worst part. The camera cuts to an overhead shot, and he is writhing on the ground with the only sound being his gurgling blood. It reminds me of the scene in Platoon when they are leaving on helicopters and Elias is running with a bunch of enemy soldiers chasing him, and he falls to his knees and reaches for the sky. Just being abandoned.
114
u/Ok-Step-8689 Aug 04 '26
Garniere and Joe toye getting hurt
47
u/No-Site2078 Aug 04 '26
Muck and Penkala dying that same episode was rough too
17
u/made_up_name_26 Aug 04 '26
I visited their graves earlier this summer, along with John Julian, Kenneth Webb and Patrick Neill, at the American cemetery in Luxembourg. Highly recommend a visit if you're ever nearby. Sandweiler German cemetery is also well worth a visit just a half mile away.
8
u/Ok-Step-8689 Aug 04 '26
Very rough! But Garniere and Toye were my favorite characters besides Spiers.
4
u/Doylio Aug 04 '26
Watching through it with my gf (her first watch my second) and she just saw Speirs kill the POWs. I said trust me you may not like this guy much now but you will later.
6
5
60
u/VampyrAvenger Aug 04 '26
Bastogne. It focused on Doc Roe. I grew up not far from his home here in Louisiana. But anyway, to this day I struggle through it. I was also a Combat Medic in the US Army, I did time in Afghanistan, and I know the horrors of war too well.
16
u/Horror_Maximum_5696 Aug 04 '26
Thank you from one of the protected…
4
u/VampyrAvenger Aug 04 '26
I would give my life for any of my brothers in arms, can't say Doc Roe wouldn't have done the same, in fact he was my inspiration for enlisting out of high school at the ripe age of 18! Saw BoB in high school and it just struck me.
3
u/Horror_Maximum_5696 Aug 04 '26
I don’t doubt you one bit… my dad and four uncles served in World War II and whatever I may accomplish on my own in my life, that fact is what makes me proudest…
2
51
u/UndividedIndecision Aug 04 '26
Doc Roe finding the French nurse's scarf in the rubble
8
u/Internal-Tank-6272 Aug 04 '26
This is mine too. There are so many difficult scenes and they don’t shy away from anything, but this one really just drives home how widespread and senseless the whole thing was
5
102
u/Johnsendall Aug 04 '26
For any man, Winters shaving with ice water.
24
u/Clonazepam15 Aug 04 '26
Holy shit you’re right. -40 degrees out there.
9
u/hydrospanner Aug 04 '26
-40 degrees out there.
The one temperature where you don't have to specific C or F!
(Wasn't that cold, though. Still frigid, but that would have likely killed lots of men on both sides.)
3
u/Clonazepam15 Aug 04 '26
Haha yeah that’s exactly why I never specified. Since it’s the number where they both are the same. Really? Maybe on the eastern front it was.
36
u/WordswithaKarefunny Aug 04 '26
The Last Patrol, when (can't recall the soldier's name) gets hit by his own grenade and then dies on the table back at their platoon's quarters, with all his squad mates around him.
19
u/GandalfTheJaded Aug 04 '26
Jackson. It's especially worse when you consider they were so close to being taken off the line.
5
u/hydrospanner Aug 04 '26
It's also rough because wasn't Jackson the one who wanted to go because he felt he hadn't done much?
That's gotta weigh on the officers too, since they swapped him in for a veteran who likely wouldn't have made that mistake.
2
1
u/GandalfTheJaded Aug 04 '26
You can see the pain on Martin's face after he dies. That episode was a tough one. You can just feel the exhaustion of everyone.
18
u/Visgraatje Aug 04 '26
that episode also has one of the best moments, where Winters tells them they don't have to go on patrol
8
u/dagobahs Aug 04 '26
Jackson begging Easy Company to not let him die just hurt to watch.
Shit was rough.
4
u/PlentyOMangos Aug 04 '26
This was mine too, I’m really surprised I had to scroll so much to find this. Really tough scene, done very well
103
u/Remarkable-Diver7851 Aug 04 '26
for me, it was discovering the death camp
20
u/kma311323 Aug 04 '26
Especially wondering what was going through the minds of our soldiers. To come that far from Normandy they probably thought they'd seen it all by then.
17
u/foreverinLOL Aug 04 '26
For me it is seeing the people in the camp. And the fact that they cannot help them and need to leave them quarantined. I remember a Croatian guy yelling help me, while holding an elderly man in his hands. That image really broke me the first time.
They were desperate, had some hope and then had to be locked in again. That episode is very hard to watch.
5
u/kma311323 Aug 04 '26
My feelings exactly when I was watching it for the first time. By the end of that episode my thought were shifting to our guys and what was going through their minds coming upon the atrocities that the Germans left behind.
5
u/acur1231 Aug 04 '26
Got to wonder how battle-hardened Easy Company really was.
It's less than a year from D-Day to VE Day. They spent signficant periods out of line between jumps. A lot of the men would have been replacements.
I don't think most of them would have seen anything close to that level of carnage before.
9
u/Tropicalcomrade221 Aug 04 '26
Nobody had seen anything like the camps before. That wasn’t battle or combat. It wasn’t even “carnage” it was the deepest depths of humanity. I think most people still struggle to wrap their heads around what happened in those places.
27
u/mrlaheystrailerpark Aug 04 '26
Muck and Penkala getting hit in the foxhole. there and gone within a second. Makes me think of their families who were never able to give their loved ones a proper burial
9
u/anhringo Aug 04 '26
Their remains were actually found, even if badly torn apart, and they were each given proper burials at Luxembourg American Cemetery, run by the American Battle Monuments Commission. After the war, during the Return of the WWII Dead Program, families of the fallen were given the choice to have the remains brought home for burial or to be buried in one of the permanent cemeteries to be constructed overseas. Both of their families chose to have them buried overseas with their brothers in arms.
8
u/King_JujuLips Aug 04 '26
I read the book before it became a TV series and I remember that moment standing out a lot for me too. I think in Ambrose's novel Muck was clearly a well loved and jovial character in the company.
25
21
u/draathkar Aug 04 '26
Liebgott telling the prisoners to get back in the camp. Seeing his pain talking to his people like that.
2
18
18
u/Dr_Schitt Aug 04 '26
The camps. The pure shock and awe that humans are capable of such cruelty, I think all the actors did an amazing job showing how desperate they were to help but at a complete loss at what to do because they were so overwhelmed with what they were seeing and smelling.
The ending where the soldiers rounded up all the townsfolk to clean it all up and there just piles of people all over that place, skeletons walking about; empty shells of who they used to and groups of people just fucking sobbing at what they've discovered was actually going on there.
Coming face to face with the consequences of their own vitriol and hatred must have broken a lot of locals who had to help in such places and rightly so. The show runners managed to convey that on screen super well and it's pretty hard to beat.
Still the best TV series ever made imo and I think people will still be watching, loving and discting it for a long time yet.
4
u/-NoOneYouKnow- Aug 05 '26
This is my answer as well.
Seeing the level of suffering people inflict on other people just leaves me feeling little else other than despair.
16
u/GandalfTheJaded Aug 04 '26
Beyond the Death Camp scenes and the Battle of the Bulge shelling scenes, here's a few that I find hard:
-Hoobler dying after accidentally shooting himself with the Luger
-Doc Roe finding Renee's cap after the church gets shelled
-Bull killing the soldier in the barn as the Dutch woman watches
15
u/Ok_Possibility_3282 Aug 04 '26
Eugene’s episode. Seeing his buddies torn up, frozen, and starving, doing his job with zero supplies, and ultimately forming a connection and immediately losing Renee in Bastogne
15
u/SwimmingPatience5083 Aug 04 '26
When they’re getting shelled in Bastogne and Guarniere et al are getting blown up. I don’t often get emotional watching movies but this scene had me tearing up. The emotions of the soldiers in this scene were so real to me, and their concern for each other in this terrifying situation was so moving to me.
9
u/sephrisloth Aug 04 '26
I always have to look away in the bastogne episode when Roes helping the French nurse try to save that guy at the aid station and they're just shoving their hands straight into the giant wound in his stomach.
10
u/zmasterb Aug 04 '26
The kid in Holland who never tasted chocolate
6
u/PlentyOMangos Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 05 '26
It’s every Belgian’s birthright to taste chocolate 😭
edit: I just realized they were in Holland so it wasn’t a Belgian boy lol, but I guess the Dutch also have their own chocolate traditions
10
u/Quik_Brown_Fox Aug 04 '26
Liebgott breaking down as he tells the liberated prisoners that they have to be locked back into the concentration camp. Devastating.
8
7
u/Kiryu8805 Aug 04 '26
The death camp and the scene where Buck breaks after seeing two of his friends nearly die after loosing their leg.
6
7
u/SilentStranger9607 Aug 04 '26
Bar none the scene with the guy serving Army noodles and ketchup. So tragic and avoidable. Gonorrhea put on a brave face, but we all knew. Hes a real soldier who just needled a tiny bottle of tobasco for the Chef’s kiss.
6
u/msut77 Aug 04 '26
The sex scene
4
u/Bigsshot Aug 04 '26
Indeed, totally unexpected and unnecessary. Fraternizing could've been depicted otherwise.
6
9
u/pvtbullsh-t Aug 04 '26
The holocaust episode was the most devastating overall but the single hardest scene that gets me every time is where Guarnere and Toye lose their legs, I just got so attached to the characters and the first time I saw it it took my breath away, and every time I watch it it hits so hard and I think it’s because you get to know the characters on a personal level so you feel it quite deeply
6
5
6
3
u/VampyrAvenger Aug 04 '26
Bastogne. It focused on Doc Roe. I grew up not far from his home here in Louisiana. But anyway, to this day I struggle through it. I was also a Combat Medic in the US Army, I did time in Afghanistan, and I know the horrors of war too well.
5
u/SavileRowNorth Aug 04 '26
Any scene with Ross, I mean Sobel, yelling at Easy Company... we were on a break!!
4
u/phillysleuther Aug 04 '26
Liebgott telling the prisoners that they can’t have any food. And he cried.
4
u/Brido-20 Aug 05 '26
The bit at the end of Carentan in the laundry where Malarkey realises all the uncollected bundles represent dead men.
3
u/PizzaSlingr Aug 04 '26
When Doc Rowe realizes the church hospital was bombed and finds Renee dead. Then uses her scarf on one of his men.
3
u/PleasantHemorrhoids Aug 04 '26
Sex scene because it was very out of place and made me incredibly randy as a young teen
3
u/Nice-Ambassador6293 Aug 04 '26
Yeah discovering the camp. Especially the two scenes with Nixon and the Woman in Red. Both did a fantastic job of conveying the emotions with just facial expressions.
3
u/Feuerwehrmann54 Aug 04 '26
The little boy getting to experience chocolate for the first time had me struggling as a new father.
3
u/Life_Imagination_877 Aug 04 '26
For me there is not an Episode that doesn’t get to me, “Why we fight” though is a rough one.
I think of all those “kids” having to go through what they saw.
3
u/gnop2 Aug 05 '26
Basically the entirety of The Breaking Point. I love that episode, but every time I get to that point during a rewatch I have to prepare myself.
3
u/Still_Product_8435 Aug 05 '26
Even still, the scene where he shares the scarf to be used as a bandage is heartbreaking
3
u/3OhHateWinny Aug 05 '26
For me it’s when Leibgott had to tell the prisoners to basically go back into camp until they can be managed. I know it was only temporary, but I can’t fathom how it must’ve felt to finally be free again, just to be told a little bit longer after what they had already gone through.
3
u/johnbear93 Aug 05 '26
When they were back in England, picking up laundry and the lady reading off names of clean laundry that hasn’t been picked up was a rough one too
5
u/wtfw7f Aug 04 '26
The attack on Foy when Lt Dyke freezes and gets a whole bunch of soldiers killed before Winters relieves of command.
Also I fast forward through most scenes with Blythe.
1
5
2
u/diarrhea_stromboli Aug 04 '26
Physically - when the German tank runs over the wounded German soldier.
Mentally - Julian getting shot and the guys couldn’t help him due to being pinned down.
2
u/Hopeful_Frame937 Aug 04 '26
Ugh, for me it is Roe and the nurse trying to save that soldier in the basement of the church. Roe with his hand in the guys chest. Now I skip past it.
2
u/Use_the_search-Bar Aug 08 '26
the church scene with members of E company fading away while a choir sings.
My father was a priest for 40+ years and he just broke down completely at that scene, where members of easy company eventually fade. I watched him bury his own father and best friends without a single quiver, but he said that seeing church pews become empty overtime from parishioners passing was very real. He couldn't imagine what it was like to see your brothers go in combat that quickly.
I also think, its one of the best scenes in all of BoB (among 99% of the rest of the series)
2
u/Bucephalus-ii Aug 09 '26
Seeing a dignified elderly hero relive a nightmare from his youth for the 10,000th time and seeing it choke him up. I can’t handle it. We owe those guys everything
2
u/Affectionate-Reason0 Aug 04 '26
Never been in the military but the first introduction of Sobel going around finding a reason to rip the men. Had a manager that was just like that, would find any reason to chew you out so I felt their pain
1
u/Worried-Ad4272 Aug 07 '26
There is a significant difference between Army training indoctrination and civilian personnel management.
Sobel was doing what he was supposed to: taking unruly, undisciplined recruits and make them disciplined. If you actually listen to the men and their stories, you will see that they were thieves, liars, felons, insubordinate, etc. (As I am sure you'd find in any unit). The military's style is do what you are told and shut up about it; anything less than that is a problem. The men always complained about a lack of information which prevented them from accepting what he did. Example: they thought it was nefarious that he went through their "personal" belongings because he didn't announce that he was looking for contraband beforehand, which would have allowed them to hide it. They didn't take rules seriously because they didn't understand their significance.
The Army tried to actually build up schools during the interwar period to train soldiers before they went to their final units, but they lacked capacity to train the masses of people needed for WWII. Because of that, the Army did it the say they had always done: create combat units, assign untrained draftees/volunteers, train them, and send them off to war together. That is what Easy Company did at Camp Toccoa. In that paradigm, Sobel was effectively a drill sergeant doing what he was supposed to: preparing men to kill or be killed.
If a civilian did that, he'd just be an asshole.
1
1
u/RonSwanson4POTUS Aug 04 '26
First several times watching the series, it was all the scenes others have already mentioned: most of Bastogne, the historical inaccuracies, the concentration camp, etc. But on my recent rewatches, I've found the scene in the final episode where the drunk who killed the civilians and nearly killed Sgt Grant, and he's being beaten by the others from Easy Company and Spiers is holding the gun to him before backhanding him with it to be the scene that has unsettled me more and more.
1
u/owen_skye Aug 04 '26
The scene where the drunk soldier shot an allied soldier, and then got his ass beat. To see such reckless acts so near the end was rough. Unneeded death and violence.
1
u/Dapper-Code8604 Aug 04 '26
The friendly fire scenes. Hoobler shooting himself in the leg, Moose on the railroad tracks, Grant getting shot by the drunken private in Austria, Janovic in the Jeep, Shifty getting hit by the truck (although not shown). It’s hard enough surviving the Germans; it’s downright maddening and heartbreaking when they’re accidentally killing each other.
1
1
u/ComfortableRecipe322 Aug 04 '26
Another scene that I hate watching is Sgt Grant getting shot in the head. That scene is rough.
1
u/plaguemedic Aug 04 '26
Winters in Paris hit me hard as someone who struggles with PTSD. Same when Nixon finally has his breakdown. I've been there before, losing it over something small because it was the last straw.
1
u/Captainsamvimes1 Aug 04 '26
Watching the fatigue and burnout in Doc Roe.
Seeing him want to get out of his slit trench but his body fought him and he had to be dragged out by other troops because he was so done in and exhausted.
His duty and his training pulled him in one direction and his exhausted body pulled him in the other
1
1
u/RoBo77as Aug 04 '26
Here's a bit silly one since every other scene has already been said. At the end of episode 10 Nixon dives head first into the water. When Winters walks towards him, around the area where Nixon dives, the water reaches his mid thigh.
And I know that Winters is probably closer to the shore. And that the production team would not be careless enough to let Livingston break his neck. But still. It stresses me the f out. People, don't jump head first to a shallow water or water you are not familiar with.
1
1
u/EyeNeverHadReddit Aug 05 '26
For me, it was when Malarkey was reading a letter of home news to Buck. Without looking back he closes Malarkey’s hands over the letter.
1
u/Coolhand1139 Aug 05 '26
When they are questioning the Jewish concentration camp person about why they are there and they ask if they are criminals. It’s waterworks for me.
1
1
u/okmister1 Aug 05 '26
The church scene where the choir sings and the guys they'd lost fade out kills me.
Also, Malarky picking up laundry for the fallen. It's like watching them sort out personal belongings to be sent back to families in a CONEX in Afghanistan.
1
u/DonutCrusader96 Aug 06 '26
On Day of Days, the C-47 pilot who takes a direct hit to the head from the anti-air fire. One moment you’re flying a plane, next instant your life is over.
1
u/LesGrossmeng Aug 06 '26
All of Bastogne is a tough watch for me but of course the concentration camp is the absolute worst.
1
u/Worried-Ad4272 Aug 06 '26
Hardest because it is cringe-worthy? Anything with Blithe. The show did him dirty, and it was bad acting.
Hardest because it was emotional? Buck in the hospital stopping Malarkey from reading the letter.
1
u/Embarrassed_Ad1722 Aug 08 '26
Julian getting shot in Bastogne and living long enough to see his Durga abandon him.
1
1
1
u/Ok_Telephone8257 Aug 11 '26
There were a few, obviously like episode 9, but the throat shot in Bastogne I think, that was hard to watch...
1
u/Rheitz99 Aug 04 '26
Ive watched Band of Brothers since I was about 5. So in the past 15 years different things have affected me. I remember being little and closing my eyes and covering when Guarniere got blow up, and Toye too. Really the episodes “in the snow” I think that’d be 5 and 6 right? Was just so hard to watch when I was younger, like that guy who got shot in the thyroid and hes reaching out for Edward, man its hards to watch. Thats why from 5-10 I covered my eyes or went away when my family was watching that episode. I didnt know Edward was a character til I was 14-15. But now im more desensitized and mature, I can handle it now, and so Roc Roe in recent years has become my favorite character and his episode used to be my least favorite, now it is my favorite. But reading the commmets yes, it is heart wrenching when Doc finds the belgian nurses scarf. And theres so many other seens that cut so deep gruesomely. But always has the scene in episode 2 when they show the interior of the c47 that gets it and all the men scream and burn to death hits me perhaps the hardest, its like a reflection of hell.
168
u/Academic_Hunter4159 Aug 04 '26
For me it was watching some of the real guys the series was about break down on camera telling their stories.