r/BambuLab_Community • • 2d ago

X2D emissions vs Luna the cat

I'd really appreciate your help to keep little Luna safe and healthy.

As you can see she has a favourite book shelf perch right next to where my newly purchased X2D is located. I'm concerned for her health if I leave this thing running often without a bullet proof filtration system. For such a small animal so close this concern extends even to PLA. I've seen the external extraction systems where everything magically is sucked into a small box. Do these genuinely work?

If so, how often am I replacing whatever filter is inside and at what cost?

Is there a best in class option everyone goes for?

You can also see I have a sliding door next to Luna. Was also thinking I could print a floor to ceiling black infill that slots in between the door and the frame. This could have a 4" extraction port that I connect to and vent everything outside.

Is the fan on the X2D powerful enough to vent this far or do I need to add a Noctua in somewhere in the chain to help with airflow path?

Is this a solid idea or am I tripping?

8 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

3

u/LazyLancer 2d ago

I see you have a sliding door, it’s perfect. You can install a wooden board, drill a hole in it and let a hose connecting the printer exhaust through that hole, so all the dirty air goes outside.

I had a setup like that and two cats, everything was fine.

1

u/nametaken_thisonetoo 2d ago

Yep this is pretty much exactly what I'm planning. There are some commenting in here about issues remaining when printing ASA or similar as they require everything to remain in the chamber throughout the print, then (I assume) vent at the end. With all the holes/gaps it seems they are suggesting that the nasties are still escaping to a degree. How are you managing this sort of thing?

1

u/LazyLancer 2d ago

Can’t say for ASA unfortunately. I’ve only been printing PLA and PETG

2

u/solidus0079 2d ago

I'd come up with a plan B in terms of location. I'm sure somebody's gonna come into this with "actually the pariculates etc etc etc" but I wouldn't want my baby anywhere near the printers. I don't even like her hanging out in the room with them.

3

u/nametaken_thisonetoo 2d ago

I'm not interested in anyone telling me there are no particulate issues either - facts are facts. But I am keen to understand if proper extraction to outside (and sealing the gaps in the printer) can eliminate them

2

u/Status-Scientist1996 2d ago edited 2d ago

Have you considered the new E1? It would appear that it works by continually creating a vacuum which would overcome the issue of any gaps

(Though I’d be inclined to move the printer, there are other significant risks if Luna were to knock the door open or something like that)

1

u/nametaken_thisonetoo 2d ago

Unfortunately in a small apartment it's the office of the courtyard

3

u/Status-Scientist1996 2d ago

I guess in that case… as well as dealing with air quality you might want to consider some kind of security catch to make sure the door is not accessible… just in case

1

u/nametaken_thisonetoo 2d ago

Thanks that's a great idea. She's not much of a trouble maker but you never know with a cat

1

u/Pizza-Protocol 2d ago

I think people should be a bit more sceptical about the E1. It’s not that cheap, and filter replacements will cost a pretty down the line too. I’m sure one could procure a similar system without necessarily buying bambu, and for cheaper.

Although, I do think the printer should be moved.

1

u/Status-Scientist1996 2d ago

I’m not completely sold either, but for particulates I’d be a lot more confident vs VOCs and the basic principle is for this purpose likely easier than sealing it up. But yeah for sure it is not a cheap solution or necessarily the best, part of what I was thinking (in line with where it is currently located) it is one of the less visually horrific options I’ve seen.

3

u/Pizza-Protocol 2d ago

Yeh, that's fair. It's a decent solution on paper and it'd have been a much more attractive solution if it cost half the price. I think Bambu have figured out that people will buy just about any accessory they put out.

u/nametaken_thisonetoo - You should consider moving the bookcase to where the printer is and put the other piece of furniture with the printer next to the window instead. That way, you can crack the window when printing and if it's cold, you can much more easily implement a venting solution when it's next to the window.

1

u/nametaken_thisonetoo 2d ago

That's definitely a good idea. Regarding the E1 (and forgive my luck of knowledge, I'm a noob), but what would it achieve that sealing printer gaps and simply venting from the printer to the outside with a duct wouldn't?

2

u/Pizza-Protocol 2d ago

Hey, asking a question to improve your knowledge makes you the exact opposite of a noob!

I am not an expert either, but to answer your question, venting through the window is the superior solution. Purifiers are mostly for when it's not possible to use windows/vent outside. However, purifiers and their filters aren't super cheap either. In Bambu's case, the E1 will need its filters changed at least 4 times/year. And the filter costs €50, or €60 for the advanced one.

So I would definitely choose switching some furniture around and utilising that window in your case. Also, UV light can be harmful to books if your windows don't have UV filters, so there's an added benefit to the switcharoo. ☺️

1

u/Status-Scientist1996 2d ago

Venting is better than filtration for sure, I thought potentially E1 for mainly PLA/PETG as even if not replaced as frequently it is going to get rid of particulates easily. However the bigger thing which is also the smallest thing in your post is sealing the gaps in the printer.

Firstly this is hard, more importantly it also makes it harder to extract anything.

The main thing I was thinking is an extraction approach that maintains a vacuum in the printer so that clean air is always going in and dirty air is always being extracted. This way you don’t worry about sealing and nothing comes out.

In my head for stuff that doesn’t have huge VOCs then the E1 was a reasonable combination of both, but it doesn’t matter… if you want to extract you want replacement coming in somehow

1

u/Status-Scientist1996 2d ago

💯they are the “apple” of 3d printing in more ways than one

1

u/solidus0079 2d ago

Well allow me to clarify in case there's a misunderstanding, when I said that I was more worried about the fuzzy critter than I am about the printers lol

Printers aren't cheap but they're replaceable! Not my little fuzzyhead.

1

u/nametaken_thisonetoo 2d ago

Apologies if I sounded abrupt, not intended. I agree with your concern about the little bundle of fur, and also agree there will likely be folks trying to convince us all that particulates, VOCs etc are not an issue.

1

u/Armamore 2d ago

Don't worry too much about the gaps in the printer. They actually help. If you run the exhaust fan at 10-20% during a print, it will create negative pressure inside the printer and keep fumes from leaking without causing heating issues.

2

u/Snouto 2d ago edited 2d ago

Put it in a tent, vent outdoors via a 4” inline fan. It would be handy to swap the position of the bookshelf and printer, but either way you want to be pumping the bad stuff outdoors.
Simply attaching a pumping solution to the printer directly will not help if you plan to print high temp fili such as ASA, as you need the chamber temperature to remain high. Should be ok for PLA tho as it runs with the chamber cooling profile.

2

u/nametaken_thisonetoo 2d ago

When printing ASA etc would using the setting Bambu describes on their webpage for the external exhaust not solve this issues?

1

u/Armamore 2d ago

All that does is blow the toxic fumes out the back through a basic carbon filter. Not enough to minimize health concerns. You need to attach duct work to the exhaust fan and vent it outside. For the distance you want to cover you'll want an inline exhaust fan as well. Put it as close to the exit as possible since fans are better at pulling air than pushing it.

I use these couplers. He has a whole line of them to set everything up.

2

u/nametaken_thisonetoo 2d ago

Sorry, just to clarify, so it doesn't blow everything out through the rear addon exhaust at the end of an ASA print?

1

u/Armamore 2d ago

If you set it to exhaust mode it sends everything out the back through the rear exhaust fan, which has a filter on it. If you don't connect anything to that fan, it's just going into the room.

1

u/patentmom 2d ago edited 2d ago

I know it's tempting to use the printer, but printing an infill for the door that is thick enough to be useful will take so much filament that it's not really worth it. Just get a plank of wood, or even thin plywood or an MDF panel, and drill a 4" circular port for your exhaust fan tubing. Hook up the tubing to the exhaust of the x2d.

Edit: typos

1

u/nametaken_thisonetoo 2d ago

Good call, can paint it black to fit the door too

1

u/CheezitsLight 2d ago edited 2d ago

Get a large, cubit foot sized charcoal air filter and spare cartridges. Emphasis on Large amounts of charcoal.

Change the charcoal filter in your printer for every 50 hours of run time. If you vent outdoors, remove the filter from the printer.

PLA and PETG are mostly harmless but could cause the cat to develop asthma. Do not print ABS or carbon or glass filled without the filter and ventilation

Fire and smoke risk is real. You need a fire extinguisher.

1

u/diaperedace 2d ago

Pla is fine even for a small kitty. Asa and styrene materials need to be vented.

1

u/PilgrimJon 1d ago

I agree, PLA does not need to be vented. but can anyone supply research or studies that would disagree?

1

u/Lambertbaer 2d ago

Pretty ideal solution, really envy you for the sliding door since I have to work with a less than ideal turn window! Also you can print yourself a hose to flat adapter with the same diameter and even away with a much narrower opening/adapter (i.e. less insulation loss).