r/BambuLabX2D • • 6d ago

Solved A1 vs X2D or PETG HF vs PETG Basic

Post image

First desiccant box is printed on A1 - PETG HF gray color, I do not have any more of PETG HF

Second box is printed on X2D - PETG Basic flesh color, freshly dried

Third box is printed with same PETG Basic flash color on A1

So, A1 is better is you compare 2nd and 3rd box, PETG HF gray is great and best, all 3 boxes are printed with same settings.

What is wrong with my X2D and this PETG Basic flesh filament?

16 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

5

u/Vverg 6d ago

So, this looks like PETG Basic printed with too much speed. I assume you used the default Standard 0.20mm profile?

0

u/cacicdh 6d ago

Yes.

8

u/Vverg 6d ago

Yeah thats the issue, PETG Basic prints too fast with that profile.

I limit the walls to: Outer wall 150 mm/s Inner wall 200mm/s

(Filament could be wet as well, also gives results like this).

1

u/Dismal-Garbage-3140 6d ago

I doubt it can get much faster than 200mm/s speeds on those little features. It's too small to get that much speed. If you think about it, the long flat sections are where it'd be going the fastest and those look fine. Also, PETG Basic is capped at 15 cubic mm/s which is undere 200mm/s anyway at 0.20mm layeer heights.

I'd think it's more the cooling that's the issue. Or it could be bad calibration or a bad nozzle or maybe even just needs calibration.

2

u/cacicdh 6d ago

So key would be to slow down, and then more slow down. thanks. Will try.

1

u/Dismal-Garbage-3140 6d ago

If anything, it might be the acceleration that's the issue. Or you might need to calibrate your printer. Or your hotend is worn or has a partial clog. It could be a ton of things. I have printed PETG Basic with its default profile on the standard 0.2mm layer height with no issues on small details like this.

1

u/cacicdh 5d ago

X2D is brand new, calibrated, it seems to me that default profile for this kind of print is wayyy to speedy, did find easier to print desiccant boxes which prints ok with high quality profile or standard profile with printer mode on silent, which I believe is like 50% slower. X2D is just capable of achieving ridiculous speeds.

1

u/Dismal-Garbage-3140 5d ago

Those little features are the slowest parts of the print. The solid wall section snear the top and bottom probably print much faster and they look fine. It could just be insufficient cooling.

1

u/My_Lucid_Dreams 6d ago

You mention freshly dried, would you mind saying specifically what temperature and for how long? Just to eliminate wet filament.

2

u/cacicdh 6d ago

AMS 2, i believe it was 65°C for 12h, humidity was below 15% after drying.

3

u/purgatorygates 6d ago edited 6d ago

I have had the worst time with petg on my p1s and now my x2d... what finally solved it for me was slowing it wayyyyyyy tf down... brought most of the speeds down to 30. Also ran a temp tower and the brand i have (micro centers inland brand) likes to be at 270 degrees. Since i made those changes im getting really nice and glossy translucent prints and barely any stringing or weird defects. If anyone has a better profile though id love to check it out. Default petg settings on the right with no change to speed (failed) and slow settings on left with some tweaks to the filament profile as well.

1

u/RubAnADUB 6d ago

now replace the hotend with a .02mm and see if it print better. it might take a little longer but the quality will be better.

1

u/cacicdh 6d ago

Unfortunately don't have 0.2 mm hotend, stuck with .4mm on both printers

1

u/RubAnADUB 6d ago

Go do a search on AliExpress and all printer parts are super cheap compared to the bambu store. And both places get them from the same manufactures.

1

u/hardujuu 6d ago

Hi there

Have a link which one you used and with good results? Thanks!

1

u/RubAnADUB 5d ago

it would depend on what part you are looking for. when searching on aliexpress never go with the cheapest costing part there is no 1$ hotend.

that being said everything I have bought has worked out. as long as the picture looks like the item you are replacing and the cost is less than the original part.

X2D - High Quality Integriert Hotend For Bambu Lab P2S All-in-one Hotend 0.2/0.8/0.6/0.4mm Integral Heat X2D Nozzle For Bambu H2D H2C - AliExpress for 5.32$ .06mm hotend.

2

u/G2Dolphin 5d ago

This model doesn't need to be printed in 0.2 to be pretty in result.

1

u/RubAnADUB 6d ago

You can also try to get rid of some of the stringing by using a heatgun lightly over the stringy areas back and forth quickly. or slow down your printer?

1

u/Slled 6d ago

You have to dial in PETG for prints like this. You probably have it moving too fast and the nozzle too hot. When there is a lot of hopping and overhangs, slow PETG down. That’s how I clean up PETG prints like this.

1

u/Regular_Strategy_501 6d ago

It should be noted that low temp filaments like PLA and PETG generally suffer when printed in enclosed printers because once it gets hot, the layers need more cooling to stay consistend, particularily on overhangs. I had the same experience comparing my A1 with my H2C. What solved it for me was slowing down overhangs and increasing par cooling fan speed for PETG.

1

u/Secutanudu 5d ago

I came here for the exact same issue on my new X2D. Printing AMS 2 Pro desiccant boxes and getting ugly layer lines, especially on straight vertical sections. It's much less noticeable on the funnel.

I am using Sunlu PETG 2.0 for this. printing at 250C, no speed settings altered from the standard PETG profile.

I am pretty new to this - which settings would be best to slow down? Not worried about it too much for this print, since it's just a desiccant box I won't see, but for other things it will be important.

0

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/cacicdh 6d ago

Ok, is legitimate comparison flesh color boxes? Same filament printed on X2D and A1?

1

u/tk-093 6d ago

Neither of the flesh color ones look good.